Olive My Pickle Review

Thursday, March 27th

2025 Pickle of the Month Club Reviews

Olive My Pickle

• 3-item subscription box starts at $41.82 with free shipping ($13.94 per item), up to 12 items for $117.11 ($10.84 per item)
• Raw, unpasteurized fermented pickles made through traditional lactofermentation process
• Rich in probiotics and beneficial for gut health
• Every batch pH tested for safety
• 6-month shelf life from packaging date
• Wide variety including pickles, olives, kimchi, sauerkraut, and fermented green beans
• Specialty LiveBrine probiotic drink options available
• Free shipping on all orders
• Certified Kosher products
• Over 9,000 customer reviews with photos and serving suggestions

Olive My Pickle was created by passionate small-batch fermenters who believe that eating fermented food is the path to better gut health and healing. Each pouch of pickles comes with a few olives, too, hence their name, and all of their products are Certified Kosher. A pop-up when we landed on the site offered us 20% cash back on our first order, plus an extra 10% off every order on a pickle of the month plan.

Fermented pickles are better for your gut

You might think all pickles are created equal, but Olive My Pickle's fermentation process is actually quite different from what you'll find at the grocery store. Instead of using vinegar and heat like traditional pickles, they use an ancient method called lactofermentation that only requires salt, water, and spices. This means your pickles stay raw and unpasteurized, creating a living food that's packed with beneficial probiotics for your gut health. Don't worry about food safety, though - they pH test every single batch to make sure it's perfectly safe to eat. Pretty cool, right?

Be prepared for a unique flavor profile

The fermentation process means these won't taste like a grocery store pickle, either. People say they like the complexities, that they're "crispy enough to break one in half with your hands”, and that the flavor packs a punch. You can expect a tartness from the lactic acid, less sweetness than you'd taste with a vinegar-brined pickle, and a more earthy flavor.

You should try a package before you subscribe

Olive My Pickle's monthly subscription club is popular for good reason - these pickles are expensive, and subscribing offers savings to pickle enthusiasts who can't justify spending $15 per jar. The company encourages customers to try their pickles first by purchasing one or two packages. This helps you discover your favorite flavors and determine your ideal consumption rate, since tolerance for fermented foods varies from person to person. It's also a practical approach that prevents customers from signing up for a subscription just to get the 20% discount and then canceling - something that's particularly challenging for a small business to manage financially.

$41.82 for 3 items, shipping included

Shipping is always free with Olive My Pickle. Their pickle of the month club boxes come in sizes of 3-12 items, with prices ranging from $41.82 to $117.11. The more items you order, the less you pay per item ($15.49 down to $10.84). Each pickle container is 32 ounces with 20 servings. You can find out the number of servings and product weight in each variety of pickle (or other product) right on the product listing.

More than just pickles

When you order from Olive My Pickle, you'll get to choose from four different fermented pickle varieties: Kosher Dill, Garlic, Spicy Kosher, and Horseradish Fermented. But that's just the beginning - they also offer ten different olive varieties (from buttery Castelvetrano to spicy mixes) and an impressive selection of other fermented goodies like kimchi, sauerkraut, and even fermented green beans. Each container holds 32 ounces and provides about 20 servings, giving you plenty of probiotic-rich snacks to enjoy.

Probiotic pickle juice for the brine drinkers out there

Those of us who are really crazy about pickles know the fun doesn't stop when the last pickle in the jar is eaten - the brine is just as good. Olive My Pickle gets it. They sell pouches of pickle juice called LiveBrine in several flavors (Classic Kosher Dill, Blue Spirulina & Lemon, Turmeric & Cracked Black Pepper, Pomegranate Beet & Tangerine, Aji Amarillo Pepper & Mango, and Dragon Fruit & Strawberry) for a healthy morning shot of probiotics… or maybe as a chaser after a shot of vodka. We don't judge.

Good for 6 months in the fridge

When you order from Olive My Pickle, your fermented goods will be shipped within 2-4 business days, packed in a compostable insulated mailer with ice packs for temperature control during transit. The company may hold weekend orders until Monday to avoid packages sitting in carrier facilities. While refrigeration during shipping isn't strictly necessary, and there's no risk of spoilage during normal shipping times, you'll want to refrigerate your products when they arrive. The good news is that these fermented foods have a generous 6-month shelf life from their packaging date, and you can extend their life by periodically rotating the package to redistribute the brine.

5 days to report damaged goods

Olive My Pickle's return policy is pretty strict, but that makes sense for food items. You can't return or exchange products just because you don't like them. They don't make any blanket promises about your satisfaction, but if they mess up and send you the wrong item, they'll make it right with a refund, store credit, or replacement. Got damaged goods? You have 5 days to let them know and send photos. Make sure you double-check your shipping address, because if your package is undeliverable or refused, you'll be stuck with the shipping costs both ways.

Thousands of reviews and recommendations from real customers

While Olive My Pickle doesn't have listings with the Better Business Bureau or Trustpilot, you can explore over 9,000 customer reviews on their website. You'll find authentic feedback complete with photos and creative serving suggestions - from classic egg sandwiches to elevated charcuterie boards and dirty martinis. Customers particularly praise how these pickles help curb general food cravings and capture that nostalgic, homemade taste reminiscent of their grandmother's kitchen.

One of our favorite pickle clubs

What we appreciate most about this brand is their transparency. They don't hide negative reviews from customers who weren't fans of fermented foods, which demonstrates honesty and passion about what they do. We give Olive My Pickle an excellent rating. They'd earn a perfect score if not for the fact that fermented foods are an acquired taste and you'll want to sample their products before committing to a subscription.