Thursday, March 27th
2025 Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
Pacific Pickle Works
- $80/year for Gherkin Club (8 jars) or $160/year for Big Dill Club (16 jars) - $10 per jar for both plans
- Quarterly deliveries of artisanal pickled vegetables
- Creative flavor combinations like gin-brined pickles and spicy pickled beets
- Sources vegetables from Santa Barbara farmers' market
- Featured in restaurants and specialty cocktails
- Nationally recognized brand with appearances on Today Show
- Earned "A+" rating from Better Business Bureau
- Positive customer feedback on service and complaint resolution
- Glass jar packaging
Known as "the pickle people," with Bradley Bennett as their "Principal Pickle" (which we surmise is pickle-ese for "CEO”), this company started with Bennett's proprietary spicy pickle recipe in 2001 before expanding into e-commerce due to growing demand. They source their vegetables from the Santa Barbara farmers' market, and their pickled products are featured in restaurants and specialty cocktails. This small business has gained national recognition, appearing on the Today Show and in publications like Spoonful and Gourmet News.
Plans offer 4 or 16 jars per year, priced $80 and $160 respectively
If you're a pickle enthusiast, Pacific Pickle Works offers two exciting quarterly subscription options that'll keep your pantry stocked with unique pickled creations. You can join the Gherkin Club for 2 jars per quarter at $80 (receiving 8 jars annually) or go big with the Big Dill Club for 4 jars per quarter at $160 (getting 16 jars annually).
Pricing more than fair for specialty pickled veggies
The variety is what makes this pickle of the month club special - you won't just get regular pickles. Your deliveries might include creative options like their "Pickles Under the Ginfluence” brined in gin with rosemary and jalapeño, spicy pickled asparagus ("Asparagusto"), "Cauliflower Power," or "Unbeetables" (their heat-packed pickled beets). At $10 per jar for both subscription levels, these pickles fall right in the sweet spot of the pickle subscription market, which typically ranges from $9 to $19 per jar.
Shipping is costly, but you only pay it once
The bad news is that those prices will only be available if you're able to pick up your pickles locally. If you're having them shipped to CA, NV, AZ, NM, OR, or WA, expect to pay $40 for shipping (one-time, not for every delivery) for a Gherkin Club subscription. If you're shipping to any other US state, it'll be $60. A banner across the top of their website advertises "free shipping always on orders over $60 (US Mainland)”, but we don't think this applies to their pickle of the month club.
Website is missing important information
Pacific Pickle Works' website doesn't list any information about their shipping practices or best practices for storing or refrigerating your pickles. You might not be surprised to learn that we also didn't find an FAQ page, a return policy, or a satisfaction guarantee. That's unfortunate, because they ship their pickles in glass jars, which are nicer but more prone to breaking than plastic containers - so it would be nice to know what recourse you have if your pickle package turns up soaked in vinegar.
Testimonials indicate the company handles complaints fairly
Their individual products don't appear to be listed with customer reviews, either. However, the website has a testimonials page, where one customer writes, "PPW has delicious pickles and excellent customer service. After a little mix up with my order, the company fixed it immediately and made me feel like my satisfaction with their products truly mattered.” Not having their official policies available in writing is definitely an oversight, but it appears PPW's regular customers are happy with their business practices, and we didn't find any angry rants elsewhere on the internet. PPW has earned an "A+” from the Better Business Bureau, too.
Products are exciting, but subscription plan leaves room for doubt
While Pacific Pickle Works offers some truly exciting and creative pickled treats, you'll want to think carefully before subscribing. If you're an adventurous eater who loves trying unique flavor combinations and different pickled vegetables, you might really enjoy the surprise element of their quarterly deliveries. However, if you're mainly interested in traditional cucumber pickles or prefer knowing exactly what you're getting, this might not be the club for you. Granted, they have limited pickle of the month club information available and have a somewhat risky nature of the surprise format. They've got great potential, but there's definitely room for improvement in terms of transparency and customer communication.
More Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
The 6 Best Pickle of the Month Clubs
Which Pickle of the Month Club is the Best?
Are you tired of grocery store pickles that lack that perfect crunch and authentic flavor? Whether you're a casual snacker or a passionate pickle connoisseur, pickle of the month clubs offer an exciting way to explore artisanal varieties delivered right to your doorstep.
From traditional kosher dills to innovative flavors like gin-brined spears or honey mustard chips, these clubs provide access to unique, small-batch creations you won't find in stores. But just like the wide variety of pickles themselves, pickle of the month clubs can vary greatly in the pickles they deliver and the options they offer.
Pickle of the Month Club FAQ
Continued from above...
Some pickle of the month clubs take a "surprise and delight" approach, curating unique selections each month from gourmet producers across the country. Others put you in control, letting you handpick your favorites from their available varieties - perfect for those who know exactly what they like or have specific dietary preferences. Options can range from traditional cucumber pickles to fermented vegetables like kimchi, asparagus, or beets.
Monthly pickle subscriptions typically range from $10 to $19 per jar, with most offering free (or reasonable) shipping. Some focus on traditional fermentation methods that promote gut health, while others specialize in creative flavor combinations and variety. Subscriptions usually include 2-4 jars per delivery, with jar sizes ranging from 16 to 32 ounces.
When shopping for a pickle of the month club, several factors deserve your consideration:
- Delivery frequency and flexibility. Most clubs offer monthly deliveries, though some provide bi-monthly or quarterly options. Look for services that allow you to pause or modify your subscription.
- Storage and shelf life. Most artisanal pickles require refrigeration and can last 2-6 months when properly stored. Check whether your subscription includes temperature-controlled shipping.
- Shipping and packaging. Some pickle of the month clubs include shipping in their subscription price, while others charge separately. Look for secure packaging to prevent breakage and consider whether temperature control is provided.
- Reputation and reviews. Check customer reviews and ratings from independent sources. Look for companies with good standing on review sites and with organizations like the Better Business Bureau.
Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated the best pickle clubs available online, comparing factors like price, variety, shipping policies, and customer satisfaction. Whether you're treating yourself or searching for a unique gift, we'll help you find the perfect pickle of the month club to satisfy your craving for crispy, flavorful pickles delivered right to your door.
Compare Pickle of the Month Clubs
Select any 2 Pickle of the Month Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Pickles News
Related Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Pickle of the Month Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
