Pie Clubs Reviews

Who's better?

Grand Traverse Pie Company vs CRUST

We've analyzed the best Pie Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Pie Club Reviews

Here you can see how Grand Traverse Pie Company and CRUST match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Pie Clubs in 2026.

Winner

Grand Traverse Pie Company

  • Starting at $176.91 for 3 months
  • Shipping included in cost
  • 3, 6, or 12-month subscriptions

Grand Traverse Pie Company specializes in gourmet pies. Their flavors take on classic pies we all love, adding their own gourmet flair. Customers can choose a 3, 6, or 12-month subscription to these pies and either select their own flavors for the whole duration of the club or have Grand Traverse Pie Company choose flavors for them. The cost of a subscription is comparable to what we've discovered from other places and we like that these pies arrive ready to eat or can be frozen for later. Grand Traverse Pie Company receives major compliments from their customers and an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, so we've given them a high rating as well.

CRUST

  • Starting at $112
  • 3 or 6-month deliveries
  • 6 pie flavors

CRUST has a wide array of pastries and other baked goods that can be purchased from their online store. Their pie-of-the-month club, otherwise known as "Cutie Pie Club", comes in either a 3- or 6-month subscription. Customers will receive a 6" pie delivered each month. Pies arrive slightly thawed from a frozen state and need to be enjoyed within 3 days. Shipping is free here, but pricing still seems a little high considering you're only getting one small pie each month. Their flavors are pretty common, so this company has only earned an average rating here.

Pie has become the dessert we return to again and again throughout the year - blueberry on the Fourth of July, pumpkin at Thanksgiving, apple come Christmas. It's practically the unofficial mascot of our holidays, but there's no rule that says you have to wait for a special occasion to slice into one. In fact, a warm pie on an ordinary weeknight can turn the simplest dinner into something worth lingering over.

Join a pie club and get pies delivered on a regular schedule - enjoy them right away or pop them in the freezer for later. You choose how long the plan lasts and how often boxes arrive, and in some cases you can even pick the flavor each month. Most subscriptions run 3, 6, 9, or 12 months, while others keep going indefinitely until you cancel. It also makes a thoughtful gift for anyone who loves dessert.

Some bakeries publish their flavor lineup for the year, while others keep things mysterious and surprise you with each order. If you'd rather sample before committing, many will also sell single pies so you can try a one-off flavor or grab extra for a big event. Many rotate seasonal offerings as ingredients come into peak - so timing your order can make all the difference.

Few things are as comforting as a good pie, whether it's capping a Sunday dinner or baked on a whim. It's a crowd-pleaser that rarely disappoints, but have you ever tried making one yourself? Eating a slice is easy; tackling a from-scratch pie is another story - pie-making takes patience, lots of steps, and more time than you'd expect. Still, the buttery smell of a crust browning in the oven can make the effort feel completely worth it.

From mixing and chilling the crust to rolling it out, making the filling, assembling everything neatly, and finally baking, a homemade pie takes real effort. It can be a joyful ritual, but most of us just don't have the hours it demands. Thankfully, plenty of bakeries now handle the whole process for you - they bake fresh pies and ship them straight to your doorstep, so you can plate dessert without the mess or the stress. Whether you're hosting a holiday dinner or craving a weeknight treat, it's never been easier to serve pie that tastes homemade.

Many pie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients, so you don't need to worry that you'll receive a lesser quality product than what you could make yourself. You'll be able to try far more flavors than you've ever experienced that will delight your family, guests, or whoever you might consider gifting a pie subscription to. When deciding which pie company to sign up with, take the following things into consideration:

The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best pie clubs available for you to sign up for online. Our in-depth look at these subscriptions will help you choose a company that offers convenient, mouth-watering pies that you can indulge in all year round!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Pie Club FAQ

What should I look for in a pie club?
Since there are a lot of pie clubs competing for your business, it's important to pay attention to some key things. The most obvious one is their menu. See if they list all their flavors so you can get an idea of whether or not they make a wide variety of unique pies and if their ingredients are something that excites you. You don't want to get bored with pies you have already tried a million times or get too many repeat flavors in your deliveries over time. Next, look at their pricing and see if they offer discounts for subscribers and how much it will be over the duration of your subscription. Is shipping free? Or is it a pricey addition to your pies? Lastly, pay attention to the Better Business Bureau rating for the company and the reviews from their buyers. This will let you know more about the quality of the pies, how reliable delivery is, and if their customer service is swift in taking care of issues. Among these three main things, you should be able to pick a pie club that you'll be happy with.
What pie flavors can I expect in my subscription?
There are some staple pie flavors we've all come to know and love like apple, pumpkin, strawberry rhubarb, blueberry, and even chocolate. But this is just scratching the surface of how many amazing options are out there to be explored. Pie clubs have created a delectable selection of pies you've likely never even tried before that can be delivered straight to your door on a regular schedule. You're in for fun flavors like cherry lattice, berry crumb, salted caramel, and ginger pear.
Why should I subscribe to a pie club?
When you can avoid going to a store or running from place to place to find what you're looking for, shopping online is always more convenient. You can quickly browse all pie flavors in a company's inventory from home and compare pricing among other brands too. It's the best way to get the lowest prices and keep an eye on sales. Plus, when it comes to food items like pies, it saves a significant amount of time and mess if someone else does all the work for you. It may also be your only option if you want to try the unique variety of flavors out there or don't feel entirely confident in your culinary skills. Brick-and-mortar gourmet pie stores are really hard to find, so there's also a high chance that you won't even be able to get the pies you're looking for unless you buy them online.
How do I know if the pies from a club contain something I'm allergic to?
If you're concerned about potential allergens in your pies, be sure to buy from a company that lists all their ingredients and nutrition facts on their website. Often they'll list them out by flavor so you know ahead of time if everything is safe for you. Companies that are dairy-, soy-, egg-, or nut-free will often promote this as a selling point for people who are looking to avoid these ingredients. If you can't find the ingredient information you're looking for, always reach out to the company directly and they'll be sure to give you all the details you need to know about their recipes.
How often will I need to order my pies?
The great thing about a subscription is that you set it up once and won't have to give it a second thought afterwards. Once you place an initial order that specifies the duration of your deliveries, the quantity, and flavors (if you get to choose), you won't have to do anything afterwards. Pies will be delivered based on the schedule you set and the only thing you do from there is anticipate your delivery and enjoy your pies upon arrival.
What if I don't like the kind of pie that comes in my shipment?
If you're subscribing to a company that surprises you with flavors in each delivery, it's possible that you'll get a shipment of something you aren't a big fan of. Look for a company that offers a satisfaction guarantee in case your pie isn't fresh or something else is wrong with it. Usually they'll refund your money or offer you a store credit in this case. Otherwise, hopefully the people you are sharing your pie with will be excited about the flavor even if it isn't your favorite.
How long will my pies stay fresh?
Since every company uses different ingredients, they may vary a bit in how long they are shelf-stable for. Most of the time, the company will send you information with your delivery about how soon you need to enjoy your pie or how to freeze it if you plan to save it for a later date. The companies we prefer typically use high-quality ingredients without preservatives, so it's a good rule of thumb to just eat your pie within a day or two of it being delivered.
Do pie clubs make a good gift?
One reason pies make a fantastic gift is because a single person can enjoy it for days or it can feed a group. Everyone loves a good pie, so you can't go wrong. We love it when we find a company that offers packaging that revolves around a holiday or special event because then not only are you giving a delicious gift, but it also comes with a beautiful presentation. You can usually add a personalized gift message for whoever is receiving the subscription as well.

Compare Any 2 Products

Amazing Clubs
Southern Baked Pie Company
Grand Traverse Pie Company
Piedaho
Chocolate Maven Bakery
Butter & Crumb Pie Company
Goldbelly
CRUST
Three Babes Bakeshop
vs
Amazing Clubs vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyAmazing Clubs vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyAmazing Clubs vs PiedahoAmazing Clubs vs Chocolate Maven BakeryAmazing Clubs vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyAmazing Clubs vs GoldbellyAmazing Clubs vs CRUSTAmazing Clubs vs Three Babes BakeshopSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanySouthern Baked Pie Company vs PiedahoSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Chocolate Maven BakerySouthern Baked Pie Company vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanySouthern Baked Pie Company vs GoldbellySouthern Baked Pie Company vs CRUSTSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Three Babes BakeshopGrand Traverse Pie Company vs PiedahoGrand Traverse Pie Company vs Chocolate Maven BakeryGrand Traverse Pie Company vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyGrand Traverse Pie Company vs GoldbellyGrand Traverse Pie Company vs CRUSTGrand Traverse Pie Company vs Three Babes BakeshopPiedaho vs Chocolate Maven BakeryPiedaho vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyPiedaho vs GoldbellyPiedaho vs CRUSTPiedaho vs Three Babes BakeshopChocolate Maven Bakery vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyChocolate Maven Bakery vs GoldbellyChocolate Maven Bakery vs CRUSTChocolate Maven Bakery vs Three Babes BakeshopButter & Crumb Pie Company vs GoldbellyButter & Crumb Pie Company vs CRUSTButter & Crumb Pie Company vs Three Babes BakeshopGoldbelly vs CRUSTGoldbelly vs Three Babes BakeshopCRUST vs Three Babes Bakeshop Three Babes Bakeshop vs CRUSTThree Babes Bakeshop vs GoldbellyThree Babes Bakeshop vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyThree Babes Bakeshop vs Chocolate Maven BakeryThree Babes Bakeshop vs PiedahoThree Babes Bakeshop vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyThree Babes Bakeshop vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyThree Babes Bakeshop vs Amazing ClubsCRUST vs GoldbellyCRUST vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyCRUST vs Chocolate Maven BakeryCRUST vs PiedahoCRUST vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyCRUST vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyCRUST vs Amazing ClubsGoldbelly vs Butter & Crumb Pie CompanyGoldbelly vs Chocolate Maven BakeryGoldbelly vs PiedahoGoldbelly vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyGoldbelly vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyGoldbelly vs Amazing ClubsButter & Crumb Pie Company vs Chocolate Maven BakeryButter & Crumb Pie Company vs PiedahoButter & Crumb Pie Company vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyButter & Crumb Pie Company vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyButter & Crumb Pie Company vs Amazing ClubsChocolate Maven Bakery vs PiedahoChocolate Maven Bakery vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyChocolate Maven Bakery vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyChocolate Maven Bakery vs Amazing ClubsPiedaho vs Grand Traverse Pie CompanyPiedaho vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyPiedaho vs Amazing ClubsGrand Traverse Pie Company vs Southern Baked Pie CompanyGrand Traverse Pie Company vs Amazing ClubsSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Amazing Clubs
See the Best Pie Clubs in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Old Fashioned Custard Pie Reci

Old Fashioned Custard Pie Recipe | Ree Drummond | Food Network

Everyone loves a pie for their Thanksgiving dessert, and this year Ree is going custard, rather than pecan, apple or pumpkin.

Tue, 13 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Blueberry Speculoos Slab Pie R

Blueberry Speculoos Slab Pie Recipe | Molly Yeh | Food Network

Molly is more of a cake person, but this pie is an exception because it’s heavy on crust, her favorite part of any pie. This recipe has a blueberry jam-like filling with a barrier of speculoos ...

Mon, 12 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Apple Pie Filling - Food Netwo

Apple Pie Filling - Food Network Kitchen

With our simple apple pie filling recipe, you’ll learn the best apple varieties to use for a sweet-tart flavor and how to achieve a gooey yet firm texture, plus what to make with all those apple ...

Wed, 14 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Fresh Peach Pie Recipe | Food

Fresh Peach Pie Recipe | Food Network

Spread a layer of the brown sugar pudding in the bottom of the pie crust. Spread a layer of the peach filling over the pudding layer. Top generously with the whipped cream and smooth the top.

Mon, 12 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

The Best Lemon Meringue Pie -

The Best Lemon Meringue Pie - Food Network Kitchen

This lemon meringue pie recipe from Food Network Kitchen is the stuff of dreams: A classic sweet and tart dessert with a foolproof meringue topping that won't weep!

Thu, 15 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Perfect Pie Crust Recipe | Ina

Perfect Pie Crust Recipe | Ina Garten - Food Network

Try this recipe for Perfect Pie Crust from Food Network's Ina Garten.

Wed, 14 Jan 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.