Here you can see how Grand Traverse Pie Company and CRUST match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Pie Clubs in 2026.
Grand Traverse Pie Company specializes in gourmet pies. Their flavors take on classic pies we all love, adding their own gourmet flair. Customers can choose a 3, 6, or 12-month subscription to these pies and either select their own flavors for the whole duration of the club or have Grand Traverse Pie Company choose flavors for them. The cost of a subscription is comparable to what we've discovered from other places and we like that these pies arrive ready to eat or can be frozen for later. Grand Traverse Pie Company receives major compliments from their customers and an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, so we've given them a high rating as well.
CRUST has a wide array of pastries and other baked goods that can be purchased from their online store. Their pie-of-the-month club, otherwise known as "Cutie Pie Club", comes in either a 3- or 6-month subscription. Customers will receive a 6" pie delivered each month. Pies arrive slightly thawed from a frozen state and need to be enjoyed within 3 days. Shipping is free here, but pricing still seems a little high considering you're only getting one small pie each month. Their flavors are pretty common, so this company has only earned an average rating here.
Pie has become the dessert we return to again and again throughout the year - blueberry on the Fourth of July, pumpkin at Thanksgiving, apple come Christmas. It's practically the unofficial mascot of our holidays, but there's no rule that says you have to wait for a special occasion to slice into one. In fact, a warm pie on an ordinary weeknight can turn the simplest dinner into something worth lingering over.
Join a pie club and get pies delivered on a regular schedule - enjoy them right away or pop them in the freezer for later. You choose how long the plan lasts and how often boxes arrive, and in some cases you can even pick the flavor each month. Most subscriptions run 3, 6, 9, or 12 months, while others keep going indefinitely until you cancel. It also makes a thoughtful gift for anyone who loves dessert.
Some bakeries publish their flavor lineup for the year, while others keep things mysterious and surprise you with each order. If you'd rather sample before committing, many will also sell single pies so you can try a one-off flavor or grab extra for a big event. Many rotate seasonal offerings as ingredients come into peak - so timing your order can make all the difference.
Few things are as comforting as a good pie, whether it's capping a Sunday dinner or baked on a whim. It's a crowd-pleaser that rarely disappoints, but have you ever tried making one yourself? Eating a slice is easy; tackling a from-scratch pie is another story - pie-making takes patience, lots of steps, and more time than you'd expect. Still, the buttery smell of a crust browning in the oven can make the effort feel completely worth it.
From mixing and chilling the crust to rolling it out, making the filling, assembling everything neatly, and finally baking, a homemade pie takes real effort. It can be a joyful ritual, but most of us just don't have the hours it demands. Thankfully, plenty of bakeries now handle the whole process for you - they bake fresh pies and ship them straight to your doorstep, so you can plate dessert without the mess or the stress. Whether you're hosting a holiday dinner or craving a weeknight treat, it's never been easier to serve pie that tastes homemade.
Many pie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients, so you don't need to worry that you'll receive a lesser quality product than what you could make yourself. You'll be able to try far more flavors than you've ever experienced that will delight your family, guests, or whoever you might consider gifting a pie subscription to. When deciding which pie company to sign up with, take the following things into consideration:
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best pie clubs available for you to sign up for online. Our in-depth look at these subscriptions will help you choose a company that offers convenient, mouth-watering pies that you can indulge in all year round!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.