Which Pie Club Subscription is the Best?
As a society we've made pie a staple dessert for many holidays all throughout the year. Celebrating the 4th of July? Don't forget the blueberry pie. Thanksgiving? Bring on the pumpkin. Christmas? Apple pie all the way. But you don't need to wait for a holiday to eat pie.
With a pie club, you can get continual pie deliveries to be enjoyed right away or frozen for later when you want them. Customers choose the duration of deliveries, how often they come, and sometimes even the pie flavor shipped each month. A usual subscription of deliveries is around 3, 6, 9, or 12 months long, but some vendors have ongoing subscriptions that will continue indefinitely until you cancel.
Tuesday, January 21st
2025 Pie Club Reviews
Amazing Clubs
Amazing Clubs is always one of our top choices for subscriptions and gift-giving because they have something for everyone. When it comes to the pie club, their flavors change each month, are delivered carefully in order to keep them fresh, and are highly rated by customers. You can really make the delivery schedule your own here with plenty of choices regarding how often deliveries are made and for how long. Shipping is free with every order and you can cancel at any time. Amazing Clubs has an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, an incredible track record of customer satisfaction, and earns our top ranking among pie clubs.
Southern Baked Pie Company
Southern Baked Pie Company is a winner as far as flavor diversity goes. Their sweet and savory pies make a delicious treat or cozy dinner. They also have gluten-free options, which we've rarely found. Subscriptions include 1 pie per month for either 3, 6, or 12 months. Pies are highly rated, but the cost is more than some other places, plus you may spend around $40 on shipping alone. This was the major kicker for us with this company, but otherwise it's a perfect option for a pie club.
Grand Traverse Pie Company
Grand Traverse Pie Company specializes in gourmet pies. Their flavors take on classic pies we all love, adding their own gourmet flair. Customers can choose a 3, 6, or 12-month subscription to these pies and either select their own flavors for the whole duration of the club or have Grand Traverse Pie Company choose flavors for them. The cost of a subscription is comparable to what we've discovered from other places and we like that these pies arrive ready to eat or can be frozen for later. Grand Traverse Pie Company receives major compliments from their customers and an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, so we've given them a high rating as well.
Piedaho
Piedaho is a family-owned company that specializes in hand crafted pies that are sent to your door frozen and ready to enjoy (or freeze for longer storage). Customers really like the variety of flavors here and all agree that their pies are fresh and delicious. You can opt for 2, 4, or 12 large 10” pies per year with your subscription starting at $120. Shipping and a pie cutter is included with the cost of each order. Outside of the pie subscription, Piedaho offers gluten-free pies, which are really hard to come by, so surely this store will be a good fit for a lot of people. We're excited about Piedaho and have given them one of our top ratings.
Chocolate Maven Bakery
Chocolate Maven Bakery is a restaurant and online bakery. They are a local hot-spot for Santa Fe tourists and locals who love the quality and diversity of their food. Plus, they have a wide variety of pastries and baked goods that can be added to your monthly pie subscription to be delivered each month. Pies are delivered monthly, but you can easily pause, skip, or cancel your membership altogether so you aren't ever tied into anything. Pies are only $25 and subscriptions come with free shipping, so you'll get the most bang for your buck here. There aren't as many flavor rotations as we've found from other pie clubs, but the price alone here is worth some potential repeat pie flavors. Chocolate Maven Bakery is a pie club that's easy to recommend.
Butter & Crumb Pie Company
Butter & Crumb Pie Company has delectable pies in both sweet and savory flavors. Their pie memberships can be purchased for 3, 6, or 12-month durations starting at $170. This is a small company that uses high-quality ingredients and hand-makes all their products. We found shipping to be pretty expensive, which was one downside of a membership for us. They also don't offer any type of refund or customer satisfaction guarantee, so that was something we took into consideration when deciding to give this company a slightly-above-average rating.
Goldbelly
Goldbelly is an online food marketplace where restaurants can offer some of their most beloved dishes to loyal customers all throughout the country who want to have them shipped to them. There is so much to explore here, including their pie subscription. Surprise pie flavors are shipped once a month for either 3, 6, 9, or 12 months depending on what you choose. Each pie serves 8-10 people and is $64.95/month with free shipping. As far as where exactly the pies come from, how they are shipped, and how long they stay fresh, we aren't sure since Goldbelly doesn't list this information. The company has earned high ratings from customers, so it's a great place to shop for a lot of things, but we aren't entirely sold on it being the best or most affordable option for a pie subscription.
CRUST
CRUST has a wide array of pastries and other baked goods that can be purchased from their online store. Their pie-of-the-month club, otherwise known as "Cutie Pie Club”, comes in either a 3- or 6-month subscription. Customers will receive a 6” pie delivered each month. Pies arrive slightly thawed from a frozen state and need to be enjoyed within 3 days. Shipping is free here, but pricing still seems a little high considering you're only getting one small pie each month. Their flavors are pretty common, so this company has only earned an average rating here.
Three Babes Bakeshop
Three Babes Bakeshop is based out of San Francisco, California with options to pick up pies from their storefront, ship them locally, or send nut pies nationwide. If you do a subscription here, you'll only get nut pie varieties if you live outside of San Francisco. They do have gluten-free and vegan pies, but again, these are really only accessible to those who live close by. Three Babes Bakeshop uses fresh, organic ingredients, so it's a high-quality option, but we are disappointed that they aren't really available to everyone, so they've earned our lowest ranking among pie clubs.
Continued from above...
Some companies will display what their flavors for the year are going to be and others will surprise you with each order. In between, you can often do single pie purchases as well if you want to try a one-off flavor or need extra for a big event.
A good pie is a satisfying treat that can be enjoyed with Sunday night dinners or at any other time for no major reason at all. It's a crowd favorite that you can't go wrong with. But have you ever made pie? It's one thing to enjoy it, but a whole other level if you're making one from scratch. Pie-making can be quite the ordeal and takes a lot of steps and time to get it just right.
You've got to make the crust, chill it, roll it out, make the filling, piece it all together beautifully, and then bake it. Making pie can be a fun and satisfying tradition, but most of us don't regularly have time for that. Luckily there are companies dedicated to preparing fresh pies and delivering them straight to your door so you can serve them with no mess or hassle whatsoever.
Many pie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients, so you don't need to worry that you'll receive a lesser quality product than what you could make yourself. You'll be able to try far more flavors than you've ever experienced that will delight your family, guests, or whoever you might consider gifting a pie subscription to. When deciding which pie company to sign up with, take the following things into consideration:
- Variety. How many different flavors of pies are offered by the company? Do they have rotating seasonal flavors that are unique to the company and can't be found anywhere else? Can you select the quantity of pies you want in each delivery?
- Cost. The cost of your monthly subscription will vary based on the pie ingredients, flavor, and quantity you select. Take shipping costs into consideration when you're comparing prices between companies because this can make a significant difference in your overall cost. Some places offer free shipping and others will charge you for each shipment, so this might be a big factor in who you choose to go with.
- Reputation. What do customers say about the pie flavors offered by a company? Do pies taste fresh upon arrival and even after being frozen if you save it for later? Do orders arrive on a predictable schedule? Pay attention to comments about a company's customer service, satisfaction guarantee, and overall reliability to determine whether or not you want to trust them.
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best pie clubs available for you to sign up for online. Our in-depth look at these subscriptions will help you choose a company that offers convenient, mouth-watering pies that you can indulge in all year round!
Pie Club FAQ
Compare Pie Clubs
Select any 2 Pie Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Pie Club News
Related Pie Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Pie Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
