Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Monday, February 10th
Butter & Crumb Pie Company was started by Kelly Moreau, a woman who left a 25-year career in the corporate world to explore her passion for baking. She and her husband created new and original recipes for both sweet and savory pies with all natural ingredients, including local fruits and vegetables whenever available. All their pies are baked from scratch and pie dough rolled by hand. In addition to their Pie of the Month Club, they offer dinner and dessert boxes and 10” or 5” pies.
Sweet and savory
To give you an idea of what flavors of pies you can get here, we'll dive right into the ones that caught our attention. The chocolate brownie pie looked like something straight from heaven, the key lime pie is beautiful, and chocolate bourbon pecan, pumpkin praline, apple crumb, and blueberry crumb are just a few that we knew we could get behind. The fun thing about Butter & Crumb is that they also sell savory pies that could be used for a dinner, like french tomato pie, corn and cheddar, or mushroom and asparagus.
Dessert pies in subscriptions
If you want to try one of their savory pies, you'll have to order it separately from their Pie of the Month Club. All the flavors for the year that come in regular subscription deliveries are more of a sweet dessert. The company lists the whole year's worth of flavors so you know what you'll be getting in any given month. None of the flavors repeat, which we were excited to see.
3, 6, or 12-month memberships
You can sign up for either a 3, 6, or 12-month membership with the Pie of the Month Club. A 3-month membership is $170, 6 months is $364, and 12 months is $754, which breaks down to around $60 per order for a 10” pie that serves about 8-10 people. Customers will select the month they wish their deliveries to begin and they can expect them to ship on the last Monday of every month and arrive within 2-3 business days. The cost of shipping is calculated at checkout and depends on your zip code. For us, the cost was $39.95 per order, which was a hard pill to swallow.
Shipped frozen
All pies from Butter & Crumb are shipped frozen with ice packs in insulated coolers. They can be thawed on the counter or up to 2 days prior to cutting. Then they should be stored in the refrigerator. Specific instructions for thawing, reheating, and freezing each type of pie can be found on their website.
Thorough FAQ page
We really appreciate how thorough Butter & Crumb's FAQ page is on their website. It lists out just about any question you might have with answers, so they leave nothing to the imagination. If you have questions about ordering pies in bulk, local delivery, shipments to apartment, office, or residential buildings, or other unique requests, it's all laid out for you.
No refunds
If you are not satisfied with an order of pies, it's worth reaching out to Butter & Crumb, but keep in mind they do not offer refunds. The company says that depending on the circumstance they may replace your pie, but the cost of the shipment will be billed at the customer's expense.
Few ratings
There are a handful of customer reviews on Butter & Crumb's website if you look at a specific pie flavor. These reviews are generally really positive, which is great, but it's not a lot to go off of. There is no Better Business Bureau rating for the company and hardly any information on third-party sites relating to their subscription or anything else about the company.
Pricier option than others
We fully believe that any pie you order from Butter & Crumb will meet your expectations. This store is clearly a labor of love, as is the case with many small businesses. Surely the pies here are handcrafted with high-quality ingredients, so you might get better-tasting pies here than from a bigger, more well-established store. However, it comes at a price. The subscriptions here aren't cheap, especially when you factor in shipping. There is no mention of being able to cancel a membership and since refunds aren't available, we assume that once you pay for your membership upfront, you need to stick with it. If this isn't an issue for you, then by all means you should try out Butter & Crumb. However, they may be a pricier company than some are comfortable with, so they've earned a just above average rating from us.
As a society we've made pie a staple dessert for many holidays all throughout the year. Celebrating the 4th of July? Don't forget the blueberry pie. Thanksgiving? Bring on the pumpkin. Christmas? Apple pie all the way. But you don't need to wait for a holiday to eat pie.
With a pie club, you can get continual pie deliveries to be enjoyed right away or frozen for later when you want them. Customers choose the duration of deliveries, how often they come, and sometimes even the pie flavor shipped each month. A usual subscription of deliveries is around 3, 6, 9, or 12 months long, but some vendors have ongoing subscriptions that will continue indefinitely until you cancel.
Some companies will display what their flavors for the year are going to be and others will surprise you with each order. In between, you can often do single pie purchases as well if you want to try a one-off flavor or need extra for a big event.
A good pie is a satisfying treat that can be enjoyed with Sunday night dinners or at any other time for no major reason at all. It's a crowd favorite that you can't go wrong with. But have you ever made pie? It's one thing to enjoy it, but a whole other level if you're making one from scratch. Pie-making can be quite the ordeal and takes a lot of steps and time to get it just right.
You've got to make the crust, chill it, roll it out, make the filling, piece it all together beautifully, and then bake it. Making pie can be a fun and satisfying tradition, but most of us don't regularly have time for that. Luckily there are companies dedicated to preparing fresh pies and delivering them straight to your door so you can serve them with no mess or hassle whatsoever.
Many pie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients, so you don't need to worry that you'll receive a lesser quality product than what you could make yourself. You'll be able to try far more flavors than you've ever experienced that will delight your family, guests, or whoever you might consider gifting a pie subscription to. When deciding which pie company to sign up with, take the following things into consideration:
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best pie clubs available for you to sign up for online. Our in-depth look at these subscriptions will help you choose a company that offers convenient, mouth-watering pies that you can indulge in all year round!
Select any 2 Pie Clubs to compare them head to head