Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Monday, February 10th
Lenore and Anna are two friends with a love of pie and produce who came together to create Three Babes Bakeshop (...we're not sure who the third babe would be...). Their store started out as a pop-up shop out of a shipping container and as it continued to grow, they launched an online store and have been in business over 11 years. Those in the San Francisco area can visit their commercial kitchen and buy a pie in-person; anyone else nationwide can have nut pies delivered to their door.
Vegan and gluten-free pies
When you look at the menu of pies available for purchase from Three Babes Bakeshop, there isn't a huge selection, but we did notice gluten-free and vegan options for those who need them. When we were shopping, the flavors we found included classic apple, blackberry crumble, bourbon pecan, bittersweet chocolate pecan (GF), salty honey walnut, classic pumpkin, classic pumpkin in a graham cracker crust (GF), blackberry crumble (GF), and vegan blackberry lattice.
Specify preferences
With the pie subscription service from Three Babes Bakeshop, they typically don't send the vegan or gluten-free pies, but they do encourage you to tell them what you do and don't like, so you might be able to make a special request for a vegan or gluten-free pie to be included. Otherwise, Three Babes Bakeshop says that your subscription will also likely include off-menu pies that aren't on their regular menu, so you can plan on more diversity than you see on their website.
Google doc order form
If you decide to commit to a subscription from Three Babes Bakeshop, you'll fill out your information on a Google doc. This includes your name, email address, phone number, who the subscription is for, frequency (weekly, twice per month, or once per month), subscription length (3, 6, 12 months or other), your fulfillment method, preferred fulfillment day, preferred fulfillment time, and what types of pie you or the person receiving the subscription likes the most. That's a little old-school compared with websites that have easy-breezy online order forms, but small businesses sometimes have to start, well, small.
Nut pies only
Something disappointing we realized when filling out the Google doc is that if you don't do an in-store pickup of your pies, it costs $15 per shipment, but they only ship nut pies nationwide. This really limits the selection you might receive, so it seems odd that they offer a subscription service at all.
Frequent deliveries
For those who do have access to the pies from Three Babes Bakeshop, it costs $37.50 per pie if you do a weekly order, $40 per pie for 2 pies per month, and $43 per pie if you just get one per month. The frequency of deliveries here is far more than what's offered from other companies, which may be overkill for some.
Enjoy within 1-2 weeks
It's not entirely clear how Three Babes Bakeshop ships their pies. Are they frozen? Do they thaw or stay frozen during transit? They don't say. However, they do give instructions for reheating fruit, nut pies, and quiches. Nut pies can be left unrefrigerated for 1-2 weeks or last weeks in the refrigerator, so it could be frozen or enjoyed slowly when left on the counter.
Reviews from the locals
The Better Business Bureau doesn't have a rating for Three Babes Bakeshop, so we referred to third-party sites where locals reported on their experience here. Mostly people really enjoy the pies, though some people felt like they were inconsistent as far as quality goes. For the most part, customers feel like the pies here are a real treat and they're excited about finding this local bakeshop, but no one mentioned their subscription or making lots of repeat purchases.
Limiting options
The fact that Three Babes Bakeshop only ships their nut pies nationwide makes this a really limiting place to sign up for a pie subscription. They have good gluten-free and vegan options for those who live locally, but outside of that not many people can fully enjoy the menu here. There is also nothing about a return policy or satisfaction guarantee, which we would prefer to see upfront, so Three Babes Bakeshop has earned our lowest ranking for pie clubs.
As a society we've made pie a staple dessert for many holidays all throughout the year. Celebrating the 4th of July? Don't forget the blueberry pie. Thanksgiving? Bring on the pumpkin. Christmas? Apple pie all the way. But you don't need to wait for a holiday to eat pie.
With a pie club, you can get continual pie deliveries to be enjoyed right away or frozen for later when you want them. Customers choose the duration of deliveries, how often they come, and sometimes even the pie flavor shipped each month. A usual subscription of deliveries is around 3, 6, 9, or 12 months long, but some vendors have ongoing subscriptions that will continue indefinitely until you cancel.
Some companies will display what their flavors for the year are going to be and others will surprise you with each order. In between, you can often do single pie purchases as well if you want to try a one-off flavor or need extra for a big event.
A good pie is a satisfying treat that can be enjoyed with Sunday night dinners or at any other time for no major reason at all. It's a crowd favorite that you can't go wrong with. But have you ever made pie? It's one thing to enjoy it, but a whole other level if you're making one from scratch. Pie-making can be quite the ordeal and takes a lot of steps and time to get it just right.
You've got to make the crust, chill it, roll it out, make the filling, piece it all together beautifully, and then bake it. Making pie can be a fun and satisfying tradition, but most of us don't regularly have time for that. Luckily there are companies dedicated to preparing fresh pies and delivering them straight to your door so you can serve them with no mess or hassle whatsoever.
Many pie clubs prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients, so you don't need to worry that you'll receive a lesser quality product than what you could make yourself. You'll be able to try far more flavors than you've ever experienced that will delight your family, guests, or whoever you might consider gifting a pie subscription to. When deciding which pie company to sign up with, take the following things into consideration:
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best pie clubs available for you to sign up for online. Our in-depth look at these subscriptions will help you choose a company that offers convenient, mouth-watering pies that you can indulge in all year round!
Select any 2 Pie Clubs to compare them head to head