Pie Delivery Reviews

Who's better?

Bake Me a Wish! vs House of Pies

We've analyzed the best Pie Delivery to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Pie Delivery Reviews

Here you can see how Bake Me a Wish! and House of Pies match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Pie Delivery in 2026.

Winner

Bake Me a Wish!

  • 9 pies to choose from
  • Prices range from $48 to $60
  • Shipping fees from $15.99 to $27.99

Bake Me a Wish! has been delivering pies to all 50 states since 2004 - and they've got the reputation to show for it. Look at any one of the pies on their menu and you'll find hundreds (if not thousands) of 5-star reviews, from the classic blueberry to the more novel sour cherry. This pie shop guarantees that your dessert will arrive fresh and on time or your money back, and there's a great rewards program to make it affordable to use Bake Me a Wish! for sending gifts year-round. There's a lot of competition in the pie delivery world, but this company has earned our top recommendation.

House of Pies

  • 9 pies to choose from
  • All pies are $44.95
  • Free shipping

They say that you can't get anything that is fast, good, and cheap, but House of Pies begs to differ when it comes to pie delivery. This Texas-based bakery offers 9 different pies, all priced at $44.95 and with free shipping (although you may want to pay for upgraded shipping and delivery protection for added peace of mind). People who've tried these pies - both in-person at one of the Houston area restaurants and via delivery - rave about the taste and texture. While we can't quite give House of Pies a perfect score due to a lack of gluten-free pies and some more adventurous flavors, this bakery comes pretty close to a perfect rating.

Convenience has never tasted better. With a few clicks, you can have a fresh-baked pie on the way - no oven mitts required. Whether you're planning a party, sending a sweet thank-you, or taming a sudden craving, online bakeries are the easiest way to make it happen. You can browse flavors, read reviews, choose delivery windows, and even track your box so that flaky crust arrives right when you want it.

Plenty of sellers ship pies across the country, packing them with care so they land on your doorstep fresh and ready to slice. The selection spans small-batch creations from artisan bakeries and beloved standbys from legacy brands, with options to add extras or personal touches that make the box feel like it was made just for you. Many even let you pick your delivery window - perfect for holidays or last-minute gifts.

Pies have held a cherished spot on the table for millennia, with roots in ancient Egypt, where cooks blended oats, honey, and dates into early pie-like creations - bake like an Egyptian, anyone? As the idea made its way through Greece and Rome, it shifted toward hearty, meat-filled dishes that became everyday staples. Over time, the concept kept adapting to local tastes, laying the groundwork for the wide range of sweet-and-savory pies we enjoy today.

By the medieval era in Europe, pies had evolved into sturdy-crusted vessels filled with both sweet and savory combinations. Today, they're comfort food and dessert across many cultures - their flavors range from time-honored classics to bold, experimental twists. Whether served at a holiday table or picked up from a corner bakery, pies keep reinventing themselves while staying deeply familiar.

Classic holiday pies - apple, pumpkin, and pecan - still lead the pack, but today's bakers aren't afraid to play. Think tangy-sweet key lime with coconut, a lush chocolate-bourbon pecan, or a savory supper pie like tomato-basil ricotta. You'll even spot gluten-free crusts and playful lattice designs as bakers remix traditions for new palates. Pies keep evolving with modern tastes, and that's why they remain a reliable crowd-pleaser.

Ready to order pies online? We are too! As you browse all of your options, here are some key factors to consider when choosing a website:

Ordering pies online is a deliciously easy way to enjoy this timeless treat, and the pie fans at Top Consumer Reviews have evaluated and ranked some of today's most popular pie purveyors (say THAT ten times fast). With so many options at your fingertips, you're sure to find the perfect slice for any occasion - and have it conveniently delivered right to your doorstep!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Pie Delivery FAQ

Can pies really be delivered fresh?
Absolutely! Most pie delivery services use advanced packaging techniques, like vacuum sealing and insulated containers with gel packs, to keep pies fresh during transit. Many also ship overnight or via expedited services for peak freshness.
Are pies shipped frozen or ready to eat?
It depends on the vendor. Most pies are flash-frozen to lock in flavor and need to be thawed before serving, but some companies offer pies that are shipped fresh and ready to enjoy right out of the box. Check the product details to know what to expect.
What types of pies can be ordered online?
You can find just about any pie you're craving! From classics like apple, pumpkin, and pecan to specialty flavors like lemon meringue, peanut butter chocolate, or even savory pot pies, there's something for everyone.
How do I store a delivered pie?
Storage instructions usually come with the pie. Fresh pies can often be kept at room temperature for 1-2 days or refrigerated for longer shelf life. Frozen pies should go straight into your freezer if not baked and eaten immediately.
Is it possible to order pies for a specific occasion?
Definitely! Many services let you schedule deliveries for special dates or holidays. Some even offer customization options, like adding a personal note or custom decorations for events like birthdays or anniversaries.
How much does pie delivery cost?
Prices vary depending on the pie, bakery, and shipping method. Expect to pay anywhere from $30 to $60 for the pie, with additional charges ranging from $7 to $50, depending on how quickly your order will arrive. Some sites offer free or discounted shipping on large orders or subscriptions.
What if my pie arrives damaged?
Most reputable vendors have a customer service team ready to help. They typically offer refunds, replacements, or discounts if your pie arrives damaged or not as expected. Be sure to document the issue with photos and contact them promptly.
Which pie delivery service should I pick?
When you're trying to pick a pie company, look for customer reviews, flavor variety, shipping options, and clear policies. Comparing a few services will help you find one that appeals to your taste (and budget). Don't forget to check for seasonal deals or sampler options to try multiple flavors.

Compare Any 2 Products

Bake Me a Wish!
Southern Baked Pie Company
Little Pie Company
House of Pies
Harry & David
Tiny Pies
Mackenzie Limited
David's Cookies
Williams Sonoma
Milk Bar
vs
Bake Me a Wish! vs Southern Baked Pie Company Bake Me a Wish! vs Little Pie Company Bake Me a Wish! vs House of PiesBake Me a Wish! vs Harry & DavidBake Me a Wish! vs Tiny PiesBake Me a Wish! vs Mackenzie LimitedBake Me a Wish! vs David's CookiesBake Me a Wish! vs Williams SonomaBake Me a Wish! vs Milk BarSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Little Pie Company Southern Baked Pie Company vs House of PiesSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Harry & DavidSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Tiny PiesSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Mackenzie LimitedSouthern Baked Pie Company vs David's CookiesSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Williams SonomaSouthern Baked Pie Company vs Milk BarLittle Pie Company vs House of PiesLittle Pie Company vs Harry & DavidLittle Pie Company vs Tiny PiesLittle Pie Company vs Mackenzie LimitedLittle Pie Company vs David's CookiesLittle Pie Company vs Williams SonomaLittle Pie Company vs Milk BarHouse of Pies vs Harry & DavidHouse of Pies vs Tiny PiesHouse of Pies vs Mackenzie LimitedHouse of Pies vs David's CookiesHouse of Pies vs Williams SonomaHouse of Pies vs Milk BarHarry & David vs Tiny PiesHarry & David vs Mackenzie LimitedHarry & David vs David's CookiesHarry & David vs Williams SonomaHarry & David vs Milk BarTiny Pies vs Mackenzie LimitedTiny Pies vs David's CookiesTiny Pies vs Williams SonomaTiny Pies vs Milk BarMackenzie Limited vs David's CookiesMackenzie Limited vs Williams SonomaMackenzie Limited vs Milk BarDavid's Cookies vs Williams SonomaDavid's Cookies vs Milk BarWilliams Sonoma vs Milk Bar Milk Bar vs Williams SonomaMilk Bar vs David's CookiesMilk Bar vs Mackenzie LimitedMilk Bar vs Tiny PiesMilk Bar vs Harry & DavidMilk Bar vs House of PiesMilk Bar vs Little Pie Company Milk Bar vs Southern Baked Pie Company Milk Bar vs Bake Me a Wish!Williams Sonoma vs David's CookiesWilliams Sonoma vs Mackenzie LimitedWilliams Sonoma vs Tiny PiesWilliams Sonoma vs Harry & DavidWilliams Sonoma vs House of PiesWilliams Sonoma vs Little Pie Company Williams Sonoma vs Southern Baked Pie Company Williams Sonoma vs Bake Me a Wish!David's Cookies vs Mackenzie LimitedDavid's Cookies vs Tiny PiesDavid's Cookies vs Harry & DavidDavid's Cookies vs House of PiesDavid's Cookies vs Little Pie Company David's Cookies vs Southern Baked Pie Company David's Cookies vs Bake Me a Wish!Mackenzie Limited vs Tiny PiesMackenzie Limited vs Harry & DavidMackenzie Limited vs House of PiesMackenzie Limited vs Little Pie Company Mackenzie Limited vs Southern Baked Pie Company Mackenzie Limited vs Bake Me a Wish!Tiny Pies vs Harry & DavidTiny Pies vs House of PiesTiny Pies vs Little Pie Company Tiny Pies vs Southern Baked Pie Company Tiny Pies vs Bake Me a Wish!Harry & David vs House of PiesHarry & David vs Little Pie Company Harry & David vs Southern Baked Pie Company Harry & David vs Bake Me a Wish!House of Pies vs Little Pie Company House of Pies vs Southern Baked Pie Company House of Pies vs Bake Me a Wish!Little Pie Company vs Southern Baked Pie Company Little Pie Company vs Bake Me a Wish!Southern Baked Pie Company vs Bake Me a Wish!
See the Best Pie Delivery in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Cream Pie Recipe | Kelsey Nixo

Cream Pie Recipe | Kelsey Nixon | Food Network

Get Cream Pie Recipe from Food Network Cook’s Note Banana Cream Pie: Make the basic filling and cool. Slice 3 to 4 bananas into the bottom of the prepared pie shell. Pour the cooled basic ...

Sat, 14 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Old Fashioned Custard Pie Reci

Old Fashioned Custard Pie Recipe | Ree Drummond | Food Network

Everyone loves a pie for their Thanksgiving dessert, and this year Ree is going custard, rather than pecan, apple or pumpkin.

Fri, 13 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

22 Best Chocolate Pie Recipes

22 Best Chocolate Pie Recipes & Ideas | Food Network

From classic favorites to innovative twists, discover a world of decadent chocolate pies that will satisfy your cravings and elevate your dessert game.

Wed, 11 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Gluten-Free Pie Crust - Food N

Gluten-Free Pie Crust - Food Network Kitchen

It seems like you should be able to make a go-to pie crust recipe gluten-free by swapping gluten-free flour for all-purpose flour. The recipe developers in the Food Network test kitchen tried ...

Sat, 14 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Blueberry Speculoos Slab Pie R

Blueberry Speculoos Slab Pie Recipe | Molly Yeh | Food Network

Molly is more of a cake person, but this pie is an exception because it’s heavy on crust, her favorite part of any pie. This recipe has a blueberry jam-like filling with a barrier of speculoos ...

Sat, 14 Feb 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Cottage Pie Recipe | Food Netw

Cottage Pie Recipe | Food Network

Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F (200 degrees C). For the filling: Melt the butter in a large oven-safe skillet over medium heat. Add the carrots, celery and onion and season with salt and pepper ...

Sat, 14 Feb 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.