Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Sunday, February 16th
If you're thinking you've heard of Milk Bar on a Netflix show, you're right. Christina Tosi, the mastermind behind this trendy dessert brand, was featured on "Chef's Table”, and her mission is all about turning nostalgic home-baked flavors into iconic treats. Milk Bar has been serving up goodies since 2008, and they deliver pies and other desserts nationwide.
Only 3 flavors of pie
If you're here for pie, Milk Bar keeps it simple with just three options: Chocolate Milk Bar, Milk Bar Pie, and Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch. Unfortunately, at the time of our review, the last one was sold out - leaving you with even fewer choices. While these pies are undeniably unique and playful, the limited selection might leave pie lovers wanting more.
Pies are definitely tasty-sounding
But, just so you have an idea of Milk Bar's take on pies, let's dig in and see what these treats are like. We personally love the idea of the Chocolate Milk Bar Pie: it's got a chocolate chip cookie crust, a fudgy chocolate filling, and it's dusted with chocolatey powdered sugar. They do describe it as being "limited number” and "holiday”, but we spotted it on the menu at various times of the year - so don't lose hope if you're trying to order in that no-holiday stretch of August and September. This pie is the cocoa-based version of the classic Milk Bar Pie, which has an oat cookie crust and a "sticky, buttery, salty-sweet filling”.
Some discounts are available
Both pies sell for $53 (and we can't tell you how much the Chocolate PB version would cost when it's back in stock, because it only displayed "sold out” in the pricing area). Want to save a little? You might get a discount if you order enough. We noticed a $15 off $80+ deal if you enter your email, and shipping is free when you spend $100 or more. Otherwise, standard shipping costs $15, and express options range from $30 to $65. That means it might make sense to stock up on pies or mix in some cookies and cake truffles to hit that free shipping threshold.
Important details can be hard to find
When you order a pie from Milk Bar, you can place your order up to 30 days ahead of time - but you can't specify an exact delivery date. They recommend that you order at least 2-3 days in advance of when you'd like your pie to arrive. Oddly, that information was in the "Product & Storage Details” section of the pie page…where, at least on the chocolate version, there weren't any actual details about how the pie arrives (frozen? fresh?), whether you need to bake it, or if you can pop it in the freezer for longer-term storage. We had to jump over to the classic Milk Bar Pie to learn that it arrives fresh, should be refrigerated immediately or frozen, and can be enjoyed at any temperature. Your pie should keep in the fridge for a week, or up to a month in the freezer.
An "F” from the BBB and other reputation problems
How about reputation? Here's where things get a little less sweet. Milk Bar has a rocky reputation with customer service. Their Better Business Bureau rating is an "F”, mostly because they haven't responded to a few complaints. More troubling are the reviews on Google, where over 30% of customers have rated the company with just 1 or 2 stars. The main gripes? Long delivery times, no response from customer support, and desserts that didn't arrive in great condition. Imagine opening up a box of pie that you paid express shipping for, only to find it dried out or crumbled - that's been the experience for more than a few people.
Pick a different pie delivery company
Our conclusion? With just three pies to choose from (two if one continues to be sold out), high shipping fees unless you spend over $100, and a spotty track record for customer satisfaction, Milk Bar isn't your best bet for pie delivery. While their pie flavors are certainly unique, the overall experience is likely to leave you feeling less than impressed. This is the lowest-ranked option among the pie shops on our list.
Let's talk about convenience. Ordering pies online has made it easier than ever to enjoy a fresh-baked treat without stepping foot in the kitchen. Whether you're planning a celebration, gifting a pie to a loved one, or just satisfying a personal craving, online bakeries offer the ideal solution.
Many vendors ship pies nationwide, carefully packing them so that they arrive fresh and ready to enjoy. You'll find specialty pies from artisan bakeries, classic favorites from heritage brands, and even customizable add-ons to make your order truly unique.
Pies hold a special place in culinary history, dating back thousands of years. Ancient Egyptians are credited with the earliest pie-like recipes, typically made with oats, honey, and dates. (Bake like an Egyptian?) The concept evolved as it traveled through Greece and Rome, where meat-filled pies became a staple.
By the time pies reached medieval Europe, they had transformed into a versatile dish with sweet and savory options wrapped in sturdy crusts. Today, pies are a beloved dessert and comfort food in many cultures, with flavors that range from classic to cutting-edge.
Speaking of flavors, traditional favorites like apple, pumpkin, and pecan remain at the top of the list, especially during the holidays. But adventurous bakers have introduced novel creations to delight the foodie in all of us. Imagine a tangy-sweet key lime pie infused with coconut, a decadent chocolate-bourbon pecan pie, or a savory dinnertime pie like tomato-basil ricotta. Pies continue to adapt to modern tastes, making them a perennial crowd-pleaser.
Ready to order pies online? We are too! As you browse all of your options, here are some key factors to consider when choosing a website:
Ordering pies online is a deliciously easy way to enjoy this timeless treat, and the pie fans at Top Consumer Reviews have evaluated and ranked some of today's most popular pie purveyors (say THAT ten times fast). With so many options at your fingertips, you're sure to find the perfect slice for any occasion - and have it conveniently delivered right to your doorstep!
Select any 2 Pie Delivery to compare them head to head