Southern Baked Pie Company Review

Sunday, February 16th

2025 Pie Delivery Reviews

Southern Baked Pie Company

• About 22 dessert pies to choose from
• Prices range from $39.95 to $124.95
• Gluten-free pies available
• "Dinner” pies available (such as chicken pot pie)
• Can order up to a year in advance
• Shipping fees of $24.95 to $49.95
• Pies delivered within 1-2 days
• Most pies have dozens of 5-star reviews (or more)

Founded in 2012 in Gainesville, Georgia, Southern Baked Pie Company brings classic Southern charm and family recipes to life with its signature all-butter pie dough and a mouthwatering variety of sweet and savory pies. Launched by Amanda Wilbanks, a University of Georgia graduate with a passion for baking, the company uses fresh, seasonal ingredients sourced from local Georgia farmers. From whole pies to minis, Southern Baked Pie offers something for every occasion, delivering a taste of the South to customers across the country.

Best selection of pies online

The selection at Southern Baked Pie Company is extraordinary, with both traditional dessert flavors as well as savory options suitable for dinner. Here's what we found on the menu during our most recent visit (and keep in mind that you'll have to click on "Dessert Pies” or "Dinner Pies”; they're not all listed on the same section of the online store):

• Dessert Pies
• Buttermilk ($39.95)
• Caramel Pecan ($39.95)
• Chocolate Chess ($39.95)
• French Coconut Custard ($39.95)
• Cherry ($39.95)
• Apple ($39.95)
• Sugar Cream Celebration ($39.95)
• Salted Caramel Turtle ($44.95)
• Cranberry Apple Pecan ($44.95)
• Pumpkin ($44.95)
• Gluten-Free Apple, Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, or French Coconut ($44.95)
• Gluten-Free Pumpkin ($49.95)
• 4-pack of sweet pies: Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, French Coconut, Buttermilk ($49.95)
• Pie Sampler: 3 full-size pies in your choice of flavors ($119.95)
• Dinner Pies
• Chicken Pot Pie ($44.95)
• Pot Roast Pie ($44.95)
• Southwestern Taco Pie ($44.95)
• Chicken Ranchero Pie ($44.95)
• Tomato Pie ($44.95)
• Vegetable Pot Pie ($44.95)
• Quiche Lorraine ($44.95)
• Spinach & Mushroom Quiche ($44.95)
• Sausage & Onion Quiche ($44.95)
• Gluten-Free Quiche Lorraine, Tomato Pie, or Spinach & Mushroom Quiche ($49.95)
• 4-pack of savory pies: one each of Chicken Pot Pie, Southwestern Taco,
• Tomato, Pot Roast; or just Chicken ($49.95)
• Pie Sampler: 3 full-size pies in your choice of flavors ($119.95)

Try a little of everything with a combo

Where we really started getting excited to dig in was with the combo sets. Who wouldn't like a Dinner & Dessert Box (choose 1 sweet pie and 1 savory pie for $85), a Breakfast Box (1 Quiche Lorraine, 1 Spinach & Mushroom Quiche, and 1 pan of 8 cinnamon rolls for $114.95), or a Southern Supper Box (your choice of 3 savory pies for $124.95)? With any of these combo kits or even the individual pies, it's easy to keep ‘em coming if you click on the "Subscribe & Save” option - and you'll get a discount of up to 10%, depending on your order.

Pies shipped frozen, arriving in 1-2 days

How does Southern Baked Pie Company ensure that their desserts and dinners arrive in terrific condition? Not counting major holiday weeks, they deliver Tuesday through Saturday using UPS and FedEx - taking 1 or 2 days to arrive once shipped. All pies are shipped frozen, with 5 lb. of dry ice. Regardless of the type of pie you pick, it should arrive cool to the touch and ready for you to enjoy, bake, or freeze.

Shipping isn't cheap

And, speaking of shipping, don't expect it to be cheap. On the $39.95 Buttermilk Pie we went to order, the options were $24.95 for flat-rate shipping (sounds risky), $39.95 for 2nd Day Air, and $49.95 for overnight. We also had a $1.95 fee for "Shipping Protection by Route” tacked on - and we're seeing that more frequently as smaller businesses like Southern Baked Pie Company try to cover the cost of refunds and replacements, especially on perishable items like pies that are so easily damaged if the carrier isn't mindful of how they throw boxes on the truck or plop them upside-down on the doorstep.

People (including celebs) love these pies

There's no doubt that these pies are popular. While Southern Baked Pie Company doesn't come right out and brag as you browse their menu, click on any flavor that gets your attention and you'll see plenty of customer reviews. (We did like the little bit of horn-tooting done by the ribbons on the thumbnail images: the French Coconut Custard pie was featured by Hoda & Jenna, the Chocolate Chess was featured in Forbes, you get the idea.) Those ratings are verified by Yotpo, so you can trust that the company isn't filtering out negative reviews - there just aren't many, if any. We did spot one negative review that somehow had 5 stars (even though the title was literally "Don't order”), but we're not worried about Southern Baked Pie Company's overall reputation.

Great score for this pie delivery company

There's really nothing not to love about this pie shop. The selection of pies, both savory and sweet, is sure to offer something for literally everyone on your gift-giving list - or to have you coming back for more yourself. Prices are comparable with competitors', and we're thrilled to see so many positive reviews from happy customers. Although Southern Baked Pie Company was slightly edged out by the rival in our #1 spot - mostly because their pies have thousands of reviews - we're beyond excited to give them one of our highest ratings.