Best Pizza of the Month Clubs for February 2025

Item: The Best Pizza of the Month Clubs - Summary Reviews
Rating: 5
Author: Top Consumer Reviews

The 5 Best Pizza of the Month Clubs

Tastes of Chicago

Goldbelly

Clubs of America

Giordano's Pizza

Which Pizza of the Month Club is the Best?

An unofficial poll said that nearly 1 in 4 people in the United States claim pizza as their favorite food. (Realistically this could be an exaggeration, but we're happy to run with it). For true pizza aficionados, a great level of enjoyment is a pizza club. Can you think of anything more indulgent than a pizza showing up on your doorstep at regular intervals?

Enjoying a pizza from a pizza club for lunch or dinner you can put absolutely no thought or effort into, yet it will be delicious. Plus, you'll get to try different flavors with each delivery. There's not an individual or family out there who wouldn't love and appreciate a pizza of the month club subscription. It's the ultimate gift that keeps on giving.

Continue reading below

Saturday, February 8th

2025 Pizza of the Month Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Tastes of Chicago

Tastes of Chicago sends out 2 or more (depending on your selection) 9” deep dish pizzas in each order for either a 3, 6, 9, or 12 month subscription. They have 6 flavors of pizza and you get to select the flavors you get with each delivery. Shipping is included in the cost, which starts at $196.99 for 3 months. There are thousands of customer reviews on Tastes of Chicago's website about the flavor and quality of these pizzas, and all of them are sky high. You won't go wrong by choosing Tastes of Chicago's pizza club, so they've earned our highest rating.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

BricknFire Pizza Company

BricknFire Pizza Company is based out of Baltimore and primarily serves customers from their food truck. They also have a pizza of the month club where customers nationwide (except for California) can receive monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly deliveries of 5-10 pizzas depending on their preference. We like that BricknFire Pizza Company offers gluten-free pizza subscription options for those who need it. Their pizzas are 15”x15”and you'll get a variety of popular flavors like pepperoni and margherita, as well as monthly specials. Although BricknFire Pizza Company doesn't give too many details about their pizza of the month club on their website and there aren't a lot of customer reviews, there are a lot of appealing things about this service. We'd definitely give them a try.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Goldbelly

Goldbelly allows people to receive popular dishes from famous restaurants around the country straight to their doorstep. When you sign up for their pizza club, you'll get flavors out of different states and pizzerias that you wouldn't otherwise have easy access to. You don't get to select your pizza ahead of time, but you'll know what's headed your way before it ships. Goldbelly is not a cheap option for pizzas, but they offer a unique variety that you won't get anywhere else and have good ratings from customers, so they're a great option for your pizza club.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Clubs of America

Clubs of America is a long-established subscription service offering beer, wine, chocolate, flowers, coffee, pizza, and more. With their pizza club, customers get three 9” pizzas prepared by their chef in Chicago for $61.95 per delivery with shipping included. Flavors are a surprise with each order, but they seem to have good diversity as far as what you might expect each month. Our hesitation with this company is their high prices for small pizzas and lack of customer reviews, so Clubs of America has earned a just-above-average rating from us for pizza clubs.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Giordano's Pizza

Giordano's Pizza has a simple and small menu of just 4 pizza flavors. Their deep dish pizzas come in either 6” or 10” sizes. Their Deep Dish Club sends out two 10” pizzas on the schedule you choose and you'll get to select the flavors you want. The cost is at least $73.49 per delivery with free shipping, which is quite expensive. Although customers really like the flavors here, there isn't a lot of diversity and we assume that those who are subscribing here are long-time fans of the company who have tried their pizzas before. For the price and small selection, this isn't the most exciting place to sign up for a pizza club.

Read Full Review

Visit Club

Continued from above...

Pizza is one of those foods that takes considerable effort to make (if you want something high-quality). You have to make the crust, let it rise, arrange all your toppings, and then bake it. Purchasing all the ingredients is a hassle alone, so it isn't a super quick dinner that you can whip up within minutes or sometimes even an hour. That's why pizza takeout and delivery services are so popular. Everyone loves a good pizza, but no one really wants to spend too much time making their own.

Signing up for your own pizza club or giving it as a gift is a great way to try all the different flavors of pizza that are out there. Some companies offer sourdough pizzas, which are bursting with flavor and others add unique ingredients into their dough to give your pizza a unique zest. Many places have a mix of toppings and sauces that you likely won't get at your local grocery store or even think of putting together yourself. Realistically, there's no way to enjoy the variety of pizzas that are out there by baking them from home.

The pizza of the month clubs we've found prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients, so that with every bite you'll want to exclaim, "This is the best pizza I've ever had!” They almost always include their nutrition facts and any allergens you should be aware of, so you know if the company will work for you or not. Here are a few other things to keep in mind when looking at different pizza clubs:

Variety. How many different flavors of pizza are offered by the company? Are you going to get repeats or always be able to try something completely new? Sometimes the company will post their upcoming list of pizza flavors for the year for you to view ahead of time, while others keep all of it a complete surprise.
Cost. The price of the pizza will likely depend on the ingredient quality, amount of toppings, and the size of the pizza. Pay attention to what you'll be paying for shipping with each delivery. Does it feel worth it? Or could you just as easily order something similar from your local pizza chain at a lower cost? You'll likely get much better variety and quality from a pizza club, but you do need to consider the total cost.
Reputation. What do customers say about the pizzas? Do they taste fresh and flavorful? Do orders arrive when they're expected? Are portions large enough to feed a family or last an individual a few days? Note the comments about a company's customer service, policies, and overall reliability to determine whether or not you want to buy from them.

The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the best pizza clubs available for you to sign up for online. We can't wait for you to start trying all the unique, bold pizza flavors that are crafted by gourmet shops around the country!

What are the best Pizza of the Month Clubs

Pizza of the Month Club FAQ

What makes gourmet pizzas unique?

The pizzas you can get from a gourmet pizza shop are often crafted with high-quality imported ingredients, unique sauce blends, and a combination of mouth-watering toppings that you've probably never tried before. Companies pride themselves on their unique recipes that make it so every pizza tastes completely different. It's far better than your typical, cheap, last-minute pizza you pick up on your way home from work, and you might get to try famous pizzas from around the country that you wouldn't otherwise have access to.

Why should I buy pizzas online?

In this day and age, shopping online is always far more convenient than going to a restaurant or store. With a pizza of the month club, you can avoid even having to leave the house, since your pie will be delivered straight to your doorstep. You'll avoid having to do any cooking, your kitchen can stay sparkling clean, and everyone at your house will be delighted by the vibrant flavor of the pizza you receive. Most of us only know a few recipes or ingredient combinations to make our own pizza at home, so it's fun to try something completely new that we wouldn't be able to make ourselves.

What if I have allergies?

Companies should be transparent about their ingredient list or at least spell out the possible common allergens like eggs, soy, wheat, or milk. We've seen quite a few companies that make gluten-free, dairy-free, or vegan pizzas, so if this is something you're interested in, you should prioritize the clubs offered by one of these pizza places. Plus, you could always reach out to a company directly to get a solid idea of what their pizzas contain and see if they'll work with you to deliver something safe for you and your family to eat.

How often will I need to order my pizzas?

The main perk of a pizza club is that you don't have to do any work past signing up for the initial subscription. You'll choose how often you want your deliveries to come, the quantity, and flavors (if the company lets you choose) - and then you never have to worry about it afterwards. If you love your pizza club and want to sign up for another year or few months of deliveries, you can easily go back to the company's website and set more up after your current ones expire.

What if I don't like the pizza flavor that comes in my shipment?

Look through the company's menu before signing up for their pizza of the month club. This will give you an idea of whether or not their usual flavors are something you'd typically enjoy or if they're too wild for your liking. Sometimes you'll find a pizza company that lists all their monthly flavors ahead of time, so you know exactly what you'll be getting each month, and some even let you pick which ones you want in your deliveries. If a company offers a satisfaction guarantee and your pizzas don't come fresh or you have delivery issues, they'll often give you your money back or send a replacement.

How long will my pizza stay fresh?

Most companies will ship your pizzas frozen. This means you can either keep them frozen for weeks or even months before enjoying them. Otherwise, you can bake your pizza and usually keep leftovers in the fridge for a day or two before finishing them off. You'll likely get an instruction card with your order that outlines exactly how to cook and store your pizza.

Do pizza clubs make a good gift?

Giving pizza as a gift is a unique and fun way to show love and appreciation. Food is emotional for us as a society, and being able to have a delicious meal without having to do any of the work is highly appreciated. Some people are extremely hard to give gifts to because they already seem to have everything, so pizza is a fun thing they can enjoy that they wouldn't already have on-hand.

What should I look for in a pizza club?

There are a few delectable pizza clubs out there, so you'll need to narrow down the perfect one for you. The most obvious thing to consider first is their menu. Do their flavors look unique? Or are you going to be spending your money on a basic pepperoni or cheese pizza that you can find somewhere else? Make sure there's enough variety to keep you interested throughout the duration of your subscription. Next, make sure pricing is within your budget. On top of the high quality pizza, you'll be paying for convenience and delivery, so make sure it feels worth it to you and is competitive with other companies. Lastly, read customer reviews when you can to see if the pizzas live up to people's expectations and arrive as expected and taste amazing. If you find a pizza club that checks all these boxes, you've found a winner.