Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Places to Sell Diamonds

Where is the Best Place to Sell Diamonds Online?

If you're one of those lucky people who have extra diamonds laying around and want to sell them for cash, it only takes a few clicks online to make it happen! Whether it's an old wedding ring, a family heirloom, a pendant, or any other type of jewelry that you're hoping to get a cash return for, it's never been easier.

Gone are the days of having to drive all over, taking your diamonds to a pawn shop or jewelry store to find the best deal. There are quite a few companies online who will buy your diamonds at competitive prices. Most provide step-by-step directions that make it easy to understand how to do business with their company.

Saturday, July 24th

2021 Places to Sell Diamond Reviews

Express Gold Cash Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Express Gold Cash

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Express Gold Cash primarily serves customers looking to turn in their gold for cash. However, they also accept diamonds, coins, silver, and other types of precious metals. Their process is as easy as requesting free packaging, sending in your diamonds, and getting an offer to accept or deny. Express Gold Cash has a price-match guarantee to keep them competitive. Customers have amazing things to say about working with this company, so they are a fantastic option when looking to sell your diamonds.

WP Diamonds Review 4.5 Star Rating

WP Diamonds

4.5 Star Rating

WP Diamonds is a reputable, honest, and highly-rated company that buys diamonds, watches, and luxury handbags. They are headquartered in New York with international offices as well. WP Diamonds has a smooth, easy-to-understand diamond buying procedure that protects customers' valuables and gives them a zero-risk experience. Hundreds of customers attest that WP Diamonds is a great company to work with, and we've given them one of our highest ratings.

Cash for Gold USA Review 4.5 Star Rating

Cash for Gold USA

4.5 Star Rating

Cash For Gold USA is one of a few precious metals buyers owned by CJ Environmental. In addition to gold, they also buy diamonds, silver, platinum, and palladium. You can quickly request a mailer on their website and send in your valuables to be appraised within 24 hours. They cover shipping and you don't have to commit to selling them your jewels if you change your mind. Cash For Gold USA has very good reviews from customers, so it's a solid option if you are looking to get appraisals on your diamonds from multiple companies.

Cash for Diamonds USA Review 4 Star Rating

Cash for Diamonds USA

4 Star Rating

Cash for Diamonds USA makes it simple to sell your diamonds, no matter the size or condition. You can send them in for free to be appraised and either choose to accept or reject the offer made by the company. They'll send your diamonds back at no cost if you choose not to sell, in the end. Customers will appreciate their price-match guarantee, which means they'll at least match all other offers made by competing companies. Cash for Diamonds USA is a low-risk option for selling your gold, silver, or diamonds.

GoldFellow Review 3.5 Star Rating

GoldFellow

3.5 Star Rating

GoldFellow is a well-liked and reputable company that buys diamonds, gold, silver, and platinum. Like other companies, their primary focus is on buying gold but do dabble in buying diamonds that are over ¼ carat. Their buying process is straightforward and they hold themselves extra accountable with video surveillance while unpacking your diamonds while evaluating them for an offer. GoldFellow is a solid option for those with diamonds of the right size.

Diamond Buyers International Review 3.5 Star Rating

Diamond Buyers International

3.5 Star Rating

Diamond Buyers International buys diamonds from customers and sells to a vast network of jewelers. There are no guidelines as to what types of diamonds they will accept, but they offer free online estimated appraisals as well as free appraisals on diamonds you ship to them. Diamond Buyers International has positive feedback from customers they've worked with and an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. We would like to see a detailed guarantee and more specifics on the types of gemstones they buy from customers, but this is a decent option for selling diamonds.

The Diamond Valet Review 3 Star Rating

The Diamond Valet

3 Star Rating

The Diamond Valet buys diamonds of .75 carat or larger. They initially seem to be a presentable, professional company, but quickly lose their steam by leaving off important information that customers need. The company does not have a Better Business Bureau rating or unfiltered customer reviews. They also do not provide a step-by-step process for selling your diamonds online. We recommend using a more straightforward diamond buyer.

Cash for Gold and Diamonds Review 2.5 Star Rating

Cash for Gold and Diamonds

2.5 Star Rating

Cash for Gold and Diamonds (aka Olympia Jewelry, Inc.) is a silver, gold, coin, and diamond buyer established in 2002. They are missing some key elements to stay competitive with other diamond buyers like a price match guarantee, clean website, and the ability for customers to decide if they want to accept a cash offer before being paid out. We are overwhelmed with how crowded and complicated the Cash for Gold and Diamonds website seems to make the process, so we recommend using a higher-rated service.

Sell Diamonds Review 1.5 Star Rating

Sell Diamonds

1.5 Star Rating

Sell Diamonds is located in the diamond district of New York City. They buy big or small diamonds, engagement rings, loose stones, and rare and exotic diamonds. They've been in the business of buying precious metals and jewels for over 25 years, but lack the customer reviews to prove their expertise. Customers will also have a hard time gathering pertinent information about how to go about selling their diamonds to Sell Diamonds because of their vague website, so we are uncomfortable recommending them for handling people's valuables. Sell Diamonds has earned our lowest ranking among diamond buyers.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

When selling your diamonds online, you'll want to make sure you get the best deal and work with a reputable company. You might want the option of a "draft offer" to compare different companies and make sure you get the most for your diamonds. When you're dealing with precious items, you don't want to make rushed decisions or feel taken advantage of. Luckily, there are quite a few reputable diamond-buyer options online for you to compare before ultimately making your selection.

When choosing an online site to sell your diamonds, we recommend you keep the following criteria in mind:

  • Requirements. What types of diamonds does the company buy? Do they have tight guidelines on what they will accept?
  • Process. Is the process for selling your diamonds simple and straightforward? Is customer service readily available to help you if you run into questions along the way? If you're getting the runaround and finding it complicated to understand the company policies and procedures, it might be best to sell your diamonds to a different company.
  • Reputation. What does the Better Business Bureau have to say about the diamond-for-cash company? If you're not using a professional or reliable platform, chances are there won't be as many buyers to purchase what is being sold. Finding a well-known, reputable company will provide the best return for your diamonds.

To help you identify the best site to sell your diamonds, TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked a variety of options. We hope this information helps you sell your diamonds quickly and for the best price!

The Best Places to Sell Diamonds Compare Places to Sell Diamonds Compare Places to Sell Diamond Reviews What are the best Places to Sell Diamonds Best Places to Sell Diamond Reviews

Places to Sell Diamond FAQ

If you have a diamond ring, watch with diamonds, loose diamonds, or a tennis bracelet that you want some fast cash for, you can sell them online. Most online diamond buyers list a minimum size that they will pay cash for, so as long as your diamonds meet that requirement, you can send them in no matter how big. Most jewelers also buy diamonds that are certified and non-certified.
Most jewelry buyers have a similar process for purchasing diamonds. Prospective sellers will fill out a form with all the information they have on their diamond, including a copy of its certification if they have it. They'll give information like the diamond color, cut, approximate size, weight, and more. Next, they'll receive a shipping label and instructions to send their diamonds in. They'll be inspected at the diamond buyer's facility and an offer will be made to the seller.
You can make between hundreds and thousands of dollars for selling your diamonds online. The amount depends on how many diamonds you have to sell, their quality, and how big they are. Although it would take a while, it isn't a bad idea to get offers from different diamond buyers and go with the one who offers you the most money.
There are 4 specific characteristics that determine the value of a diamond. They are referred to as "The 4 C's" : cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. These are globally accepted standards for evaluating a diamond. The cut refers to the shape of the diamond, the color refers to how yellowed the diamond is, clarity refers to the imperfections on the diamond, and the carat weight is essentially how large the diamond is. The better your diamond fares on all these scales, the more it is worth.
No problem! Once you've sent in your diamonds, you'll receive an offer on them. If it's lower than you'd hoped or you decide to keep your diamonds, you can get them back. Almost all diamond buyers will ship your diamonds back to you free of charge if you choose not to sell them.
Many diamond buyers have information on their website about how they evaluate a diamond. It might help to read reviews on the company and see if customers are happy with the offers they've received. You could also get offers from multiple diamond buyers to see how they compare and choose the company who offers you the most. If you know how much you purchased your diamond for, that is also a helpful reference point when selling it.
Yes. Diamond buyers offer insurance on your jewels when you send them in. You can get your diamonds insured for hundreds of thousands of dollars if necessary. This way you're covered in case something happens and the diamonds don't arrive like they were supposed to. Some diamond buyers inspect the packages they receive under video surveillance to keep them accountable and provide proof to sellers that they did not mishandle the diamonds.
Most of the time, yes. It's not uncommon for a diamond buyer to also purchase gold or other precious metals and stones. If you're selling a gold ring with a diamond, you could get an offer for both the gold and the diamond and have the chance to make more money that way. If you have more than just diamonds to sell, it's a good idea to find a buyer that can purchase everything you have to offer.

Compare Places to Sell Diamonds

Select any 2 Places to Sell Diamonds to compare them head to head

best-places-to-sell-diamonds
  • Express Gold Cash
  • WP Diamonds
  • Cash for Gold USA
  • Cash for Diamonds USA
  • GoldFellow
  • Diamond Buyers International
  • The Diamond Valet
  • Cash for Gold and Diamonds
  • Sell Diamonds
Express Gold Cash vs WP Diamonds Express Gold Cash vs Cash for Gold USA Express Gold Cash vs Cash for Diamonds USA Express Gold Cash vs GoldFellow Express Gold Cash vs Diamond Buyers International Express Gold Cash vs The Diamond Valet Express Gold Cash vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds Express Gold Cash vs Sell Diamonds WP Diamonds vs Cash for Gold USA WP Diamonds vs Cash for Diamonds USA WP Diamonds vs GoldFellow WP Diamonds vs Diamond Buyers International WP Diamonds vs The Diamond Valet WP Diamonds vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds WP Diamonds vs Sell Diamonds Cash for Gold USA vs Cash for Diamonds USA Cash for Gold USA vs GoldFellow Cash for Gold USA vs Diamond Buyers International Cash for Gold USA vs The Diamond Valet Cash for Gold USA vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds Cash for Gold USA vs Sell Diamonds Cash for Diamonds USA vs GoldFellow Cash for Diamonds USA vs Diamond Buyers International Cash for Diamonds USA vs The Diamond Valet Cash for Diamonds USA vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds Cash for Diamonds USA vs Sell Diamonds GoldFellow vs Diamond Buyers International GoldFellow vs The Diamond Valet GoldFellow vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds GoldFellow vs Sell Diamonds Diamond Buyers International vs The Diamond Valet Diamond Buyers International vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds Diamond Buyers International vs Sell Diamonds The Diamond Valet vs Cash for Gold and Diamonds The Diamond Valet vs Sell Diamonds Cash for Gold and Diamonds vs Sell Diamonds
Compare the Best Places to Sell Diamonds
- VS -
Review the Best Places to Sell Diamonds
The Best Reviews of Places to Sell Diamonds