Where is the best place to sell diamonds? Looking for a way to secure some extra money, but aren't sure where to get it? Maybe you have some old jewelry lying around that could get a new lease on life with someone else. Or perhaps you have diamonds that have fallen out of settings you can't find anymore. Whether you want to get rid of a diamond ring from a past relationship or a family heirloom you never really wear, selling diamonds can be a great way to get some more cash quickly (seriously, many diamonds are worth $2,000+).
Best Option
Read Full Review
Express Gold Cash is a diamond buying service that stands out in almost every category. This family-owned site has some of the best reviews we've seen during our research, with an outstanding 4.9-star average out of 5 on Trustpilot. With consistent praise for generous offers, high appraisal professionalism, and fast payouts, Express Gold Cash is a top spot to sell diamonds without worrying about missing out on value. For these reasons, and the incredible reputation of this diamond buyer from third-party review sites, it earns the top spot with 5 stars in our review.
Great
Read Full Review
Cash for Gold USA is a highly-rated online service where you can get cash for selling your diamonds, as well as precious metal jewelry and other valuables, all with one easy mail-in kit. Cash for Gold USA has no fees for sending in your items, and the kits include competitive insurance, too. With high ratings from the BBB and Trustpilot, most customers agree that Cash for Gold USA has great offers and solid service you can trust to be secure, whether you agree to their offer or not.
Great
Read Full Review
Worthy is an online auction platform that connects you (and your diamonds) with professional buyers. This site promises high value for your jewels because Worthy only makes money on commission, so they get paid when you get paid, motivating them to help your diamonds reach top dollar. Worthy also holds an excellent rating from the BBB and high praise on third-party reviews like Trustpilot as a trustworthy and stress-free location to sell diamonds.
Very Good
Read Full Review
Diamond Buyers International is a competitive service that promises higher offers due to cutting out middleman costs when you sell diamonds there. All offers come from GIA-trained appraisers, and you can get the money in your account within 24 hours if you accept. With competitive insured shipping and top marks from the BBB and Trustpilot, Diamond Buyers International is a great site to consider if you want to sell your diamonds. Only its slightly lower customer base than its closest competitors keeps it from a higher rating, but it still earns a competitive score overall.
Diamonds USA is an established online and physical retailer for buying and selling diamonds. However, with some drawbacks like limitations on diamond types or a lack of transparency on the insurance amounts, it doesn't quite make the top picks for places to sell diamonds. While we liked the best price guarantee and 10% bonus offer we spotted, there were some mixed reviews on the value of the offers, given the stone quality.
Average
Read Full Review
My Gemma is a luxury resale company where you can buy, sell, or consign authenticated items, including diamonds and fine jewelry. Whether you want to sell your diamond directly to My Gemma or consign your diamonds through its sales platform, the process starts with a description of your diamond and GIA certification details (if you have them). While the site receives high praise overall, it isn't often used by those who specifically want to sell diamonds, earning it a more balanced score in our review.
Average
Read Full Review
GoldFellow is a site that specializes in gold, silver, and platinum, as well as allowing you to sell diamonds. While you can sell diamonds over.25 carat, this option focuses more on precious metals. GoldFellow has an outstanding reputation with a 4.9-star average on Trustpilot; however, the lack of reviews for selling diamonds specifically keeps it from being as competitive as it could be. For now, GoldFellow receives a high recommendation if you want to sell gold, but an average rating when it comes to selling diamonds.
Fair
Read Full Review
Gemesti is a site to sell diamonds that has a more unique process than other sites in our review. You start your estimate online with photos and certificates, and don't move on to a professional appraisal until you accept the estimate. The company is a little slower than its competitors, though, and it currently doesn't have many reviews to support it. So, for now, it's a bit of an unknown. For these reasons, Gemesti scores slightly below average overall.
Subpar
Read Full Review
Sell Your Gold is an online buyer that purchases gold, silver, platinum, and diamonds. With a promise for same-day offers, and transparency for its evaluation methods, Sell Your Gold seems to stand out from the pack. However, before you sell diamonds here, keep in mind that customers reported frustrating practices like haggling or lowball offers. Since Sell Your Gold seems to be bringing back the same frustrations as getting jewelry evaluated in person, it ranks much lower in our review than it could.
Poor
Read Full Review
The Diamond Valet is an online service that offers you the opportunity to sell diamonds, luxury watches, and engagement rings you don't want anymore. However, with no estimate calculator, long waits for quotes, and no reviews with the BBB or Trustpilot, The Diamond Valet falls behind the pack. It just doesn't stand out as a site you can trust for selling your diamonds.
Continued from above...
Looking for a way to secure some extra money, but aren't sure where to get it? Maybe you have some old jewelry lying around that could get a new lease on life with someone else. Or perhaps you have diamonds that have fallen out of settings you can't find anymore. Whether you want to get rid of a diamond ring from a past relationship or a family heirloom you never really wear, selling diamonds can be a great way to get some more cash quickly (seriously, many diamonds are worth $2,000+).
Plus, you can sometimes keep the settings if you want them for another gem (or sell the gold, too, if you want). When a diamond is just collecting dust, you can get something more out of it by finding a top-tier jeweler or consignment shop to sell diamonds and score a boost to your finances at the same time.
If the hassle of going into a jewelry store and having your diamond piece appraised is keeping you from selling your diamonds, don't worry. These days, selling diamonds online is easier than ever. You can find buyers and marketplaces without ever leaving the comfort of your home. The best websites to sell diamonds offer clear instructions to ship diamonds for appraisals and keep you updated throughout the entire process, and with so many services, you can choose the best one for your jewels with more convenience than ever before.
So, how does a modern diamond appraisal work? If you're working with an online store to sell diamonds, you'll want to make sure you're getting a fair evaluation of your gems. The best diamond buyers have trained gemologists who can carefully examine and grade stones even if you don't have the original purchase information. The best stores will clearly explain their appraisal and understand the features that they'll use to judge your diamond. Will they use heat? Light? What tests will be run on your gem to ensure its quality? You can also expect insurance on shipping, so your diamond is safe to and from the store if you decide not to take an offer. For extra confidence, look for companies that use GIA-certified appraisals.
When it comes to getting your cash for your diamond sales, your final value will depend on some important factors. Gem appraisals will look at the size, clarity, cut, and color of a diamond. How the market looks can also affect how much you're offered when you want to sell diamonds. So, even if you've had a diamond appraised before, you might want to try again because pricing can change from year to year. Most diamonds will sell for less than the original retail price, but you can expect anywhere from hundreds to thousands of dollars - for a gemstone you rarely wear.
If you're ready to get some diamonds to their new buyers and a bit of extra cash in your pocket, we totally understand. But, it can be hard to decide where to ship your precious stones. So, to give you confidence that you're choosing the right jeweler, here are a few factors to consider so you can get the best deal for your diamonds:
Now that you've got some options, it's time to get some appraisals and sell your diamonds. Finding the right partner is crucial to make sure you get the top value for your diamond, so Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the best options on the market today. This way, you can get rid of your extra jewelry clutter and put a little extra cash in your account at the same time!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
