Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Popcorn Clubs

Where Can You Find the Best Popcorn Clubs?

If you - or someone you love - is a fan of the white, fluffy goodness that is popcorn, what better than to have it delivered right to the home or office on the regular? Because really, the stuff you get at the theater is usually way too salty, dripping with fake butter, and definitely doesn't taste good after a day of sitting in the bucket. And, what you can buy at your local supermarket has probably been sitting on a shelf for so long, there's no way that it's going to be fresh. Right?

Popcorn Clubs take this treat to a whole other level of deliciousness. Did you know that cheddar and caramel are not the only two flavor options out there? Start shopping around and comparing monthly subscription plans, and soon you'll discover that there are artisans crafting crazy flavors like Dill Pickle, Mango Habanero, and holiday-specific tastes like Cranberry and Winter Spice.

Thursday, February 9th

2023 Popcorn Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Amazing Clubs never disappoints when it comes to monthly gift subscriptions, and their Popcorn Club is our hands-down favorite. Each package comes with a 2-gallon container of three different flavors of popcorn, in unique flavors like Honey Butter Sea Salt and Key Lime. Affordably priced and with free shipping on every delivery, this club offers plenty of payment and schedule options to fit every budget. And, everything Amazing Clubs offers is backed by an unparalleled satisfaction guarantee. This is our highest-rated Popcorn Club.

Shirley's Review 4.5 Star Rating


4.5 Star Rating

Shirley's gives you hand-crafted, fresh popcorn made in their Bluffton, Ohio shop. With two delicious flavors included in every delivery, this Popcorn Club lets your lucky recipient try combinations like Birthday Cake and Caramel Nut Cluster from month to month. Shipping is included at no extra charge, and Shirley's guarantees that you'll love every delivery - or they'll send you a replacement, no questions asked. If you like supporting small businesses without compromising on quality or flavor, Shirley's is an excellent choice among Popcorn Clubs.

Moose Munch Review 4 Star Rating

Moose Munch

4 Star Rating

Who doesn't love chocolate AND popcorn? Moose Munch is well-known for its delectable blend of sweet-and-salty popcorn, dark or milk chocolate, and often pecans, macadamias, or other nuts. The three plans available from Harry & David, makers of Moose Munch, include two 10-oz. bags per shipment, and you decide if you prefer a 3-, 6-, or 12-month subscription. All plans are under $25/month, making this one of the more affordable options. Just keep in mind that you're not getting a huge bucket of popcorn like other Popcorn Clubs.

Popcorn Factory Review 3.5 Star Rating

Popcorn Factory

3.5 Star Rating

The Popcorn Factory is practically a household name when it comes to gift-giving occasions. Their Popcorn Club comes in two sizes and you're billed month-to-month with no long-term commitment required. This is one of the spendier clubs in our review when looking at how much you get vs. how much you pay for it, and you'll only get a single flavor of popcorn in each package. The company has a great satisfaction guarantee, but because of the higher prices and fewer flavors, this Popcorn Club isn't at the top of our rankings.

Snacktime Express Review 3 Star Rating

Snacktime Express

3 Star Rating

If you're looking for the least expensive Popcorn Club on the market, Snacktime Express fits the bill. This month-to-month club gives you the choice between a 5- and 8-cup plan, priced affordably at under $11/month. There's no long-term commitment or hefty upfront cost: simply subscribe and keep paying per delivery. However, there's virtually no buzz to be found online about how well Snacktime Express is doing when it comes to fresh, tasty popcorn or keeping customers happy, so bear that in mind if you decide to go with this economical option among Popcorn Clubs.

Gourmet Gift Baskets Review 2.5 Star Rating

Gourmet Gift Baskets

2.5 Star Rating

Gourmet Gift Baskets offers a wide variety of gift-giving options for foodies of every type. But, compared with rival retailers, their Popcorn Club doesn't quite measure up. It's the most expensive, and you'll only get a 1-gallon container of a single flavor with each delivery. Plus, the store doesn't have a clearly-stated satisfaction guarantee, leaving us wondering what happens if a flavor falls flat for your gift recipient. We recommend considering the higher-ranked Popcorn Clubs we reviewed.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

As a gift-giving option, Popcorn Clubs make it easy to really "wow" your lucky recipient. Most plans let you choose how many deliveries you'd like to buy, usually ranging from a single month to once a month for a full year. Some even let you stagger the shipments, bringing freshly-crafted popcorn once per season. The best clubs let your recipient preview what will be coming in their upcoming deliveries, so that they can skip a month if a flavor isn't their favorite or if they're going to be out of town.

Of course, no two Popcorn Clubs are alike, so it's worth doing a little bit of research before you select the one for your next monthly subscription. Want the inside scoop on picking the right one for you? Here's a helpful list of criteria that can help you find the perfect one for you or the person you're gifting:

  • Amount. How much popcorn will you get in each delivery? Some Popcorn Clubs include a whopping two gallons of product, while others are just enough for a few handfuls.
  • Variety. Do you want more than one flavor in each package? Do you prefer more run-of-the-mill flavors, really wild ones, or maybe a little of both? Does the company let you specify a taste preference, or swap flavors if one isn't quite your favorite?
  • Cost. What will you pay for your subscription? Are shipping costs included in the monthly price? Do you get a good value for your money?
  • Customer Service. What do people say about the Popcorn Club? Is there a good refund policy or satisfaction guarantee if your popcorn doesn't arrive in great condition or even if you just don't like something you receive?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Popcorn Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the perfect tasty treat for your next gift-giving occasion - or just for your upcoming movie nights at home!

The Best Popcorn Clubs Compare Popcorn Clubs Compare Popcorn Club Reviews What are the best Popcorn Clubs Best Popcorn Club Reviews

Popcorn Club FAQ

This will differ with each service but is completely up to you! Most subscriptions are offered on a 3, 6, or 12 month basis. Some offer a month-to-month or seasonal subscription as well. Your subscription will just depend on what you choose.
Is popcorn delicious? Yes, these services send fresh popcorn in each shipment. The packages are sent through food-safe mail deliveries to ensure you're getting top-quality popcorn. The only thing to worry about is what to do when you run out!
The cost of a popcorn subscription will depend on a lot of factors. The first factor in cost is the length of your subscription. You also need to consider the size of the package, different services allow you to choose how much popcorn is sent. The least expensive starts at $9.99, with prices going up from there.
They make great gifts! A popcorn club offers exciting new things to try every month! The only thing to worry about with a Popcorn Club gift, is if the person has allergies.
Chocolate is a great year-round gift, and the best chocolate clubs take care to package each shipment with the weather and destination in mind. Ice packs and insulation may be included, to help keep the chocolate in perfect condition while en route.
This is something very important to consider with any food membership. Make sure you read the ingredients of every package before you eat anything. You can also message the subscription service you choose, and ask them if they offer any special packages.
There is a lot of variety in these subscriptions! Each month offers at least one new flavor to try, while some offer even more. With subscriptions that have many options, you'll have a choice of which flavors you want for that month. Other services have a flavor pre-picked for each month, so you can choose when to start.
Each subscription length is different. Most Popcorn Club subscriptions have a definitive end, most being 3, 6, or 12 months. A few offer month-to-month subscriptions that you can just stop when you want. There are also seasonal subscriptions, where you get one package every 3 months.
The Best Reviews of Popcorn Clubs