We evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Amazing Clubs vs The Popcorn Factory

Sunday, June 22nd

2025 Popcorn Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating
  • $36.95/month includes 2 gallons of gourmet popcorn and free shipping
  • Discounts available from $5-$30 off based on subscription length
  • Three unique hand-crafted flavors in each monthly delivery, never repeating within the same calendar year
  • Flexible subscription options: 3, 4, 6, or 12 months with monthly or bi-monthly delivery
  • Start date can be scheduled up to 11 months in advance
  • Choice of payment methods: pay in full or per shipment
  • Monthly "What's Poppin'" newsletter with popcorn facts and serving suggestions
  • Ability to preview and skip upcoming flavors
  • "They'll Love It!" guarantee with full credit for unshipped orders
  • Customer service available 7 days a week
  • 4.8-star average from over 2,000 customer reviews
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Amazing Clubs' Popcorn of the Month Club delivers three unique, handcrafted flavors right to your door each month, ranging from indulgent dessert varieties to bold savory combinations. You'll get a generous 2-gallon portion of fresh popcorn with every delivery, plus their flexible subscription options let you customize everything from payment plans to delivery schedules. With exceptional customer service, free shipping included, and consistently rave reviews from customers, this club is our top recommendation for popcorn enthusiasts who want to explore new flavors without sacrificing quality or convenience.

The Popcorn Factory Review 2 Star Rating

The Popcorn Factory

2 Star Rating
  • Two subscription options: Standard ($12.99/month) and Premium ($19.99/month), both with $9.99 shipping per delivery
  • Fixed monthly flavor rotation with creative seasonal combinations
  • Premium subscription includes 1-gallon decorative tin
  • Unique flavors like Strawberry Sparkling Wine and Avocado Sea Salt
  • Flexible cancellation policy - can cancel anytime
  • OU-D certified kosher products
  • Monthly deliveries ship first week of each month

If you're in the market for a monthly popcorn club, The Popcorn Factory probably isn't your best bet. While their creative flavors like Strawberry Sparkling Wine and Avocado Sea Salt sound intriguing, you'll likely be frustrated by the tiny portions (sometimes as little as 2.5 ounces), high shipping costs ($9.99 per delivery), and spotty customer service. Most popcorn enthusiasts will find better value and reliability elsewhere. Given the numerous issues with delivery, quality, and customer support, we can't recommend this subscription service.

What is the Best Popcorn of the Month Club?

Have you ever found yourself craving the perfect snack that combines comfort, nostalgia, and gourmet flavors? Popcorn of the month clubs offer a delightful solution for snack enthusiasts, movie buffs, and anyone looking to explore unique popcorn varieties from the comfort of their home. These subscription services can solve several common dilemmas: the challenge of finding interesting snacks for family movie nights, the quest for thoughtful recurring gifts, or simply the desire to discover popcorn flavors beyond what's available at local stores.

When exploring popcorn subscription options, you'll find quite a range of services. Some clubs are run by multi-generation family businesses that have been perfecting their recipes for decades - imagine receiving monthly deliveries of caramel corn made from a cherished 1940s recipe that made a small-town shop famous. Others are part of larger subscription box companies that offer everything from coffee to cookies, with popcorn being just one of their many offerings (but often sourced from cute little mom-and-pop shops too).

The Best Popcorn Clubs Compare Popcorn Clubs Compare Popcorn Club Reviews What are the best Popcorn Clubs Best Popcorn Club Reviews

Popcorn Club FAQ

This will differ with each service but is completely up to you! Most subscriptions are offered on a 3, 6, or 12 month basis. Some offer a month-to-month or seasonal subscription as well. Your subscription will just depend on what you choose.
Is popcorn delicious? Yes, these services send fresh popcorn in each shipment. The packages are sent through food-safe mail deliveries to ensure you're getting top-quality popcorn. The only thing to worry about is what to do when you run out!
The cost of a popcorn subscription will depend on a lot of factors. The first factor in cost is the length of your subscription. You also need to consider the size of the package, different services allow you to choose how much popcorn is sent. The least expensive starts at $9.99, with prices going up from there.
They make great gifts! A popcorn club offers exciting new things to try every month! The only thing to worry about with a Popcorn Club gift, is if the person has allergies.
Chocolate is a great year-round gift, and the best chocolate clubs take care to package each shipment with the weather and destination in mind. Ice packs and insulation may be included, to help keep the chocolate in perfect condition while en route.
This is something very important to consider with any food membership. Make sure you read the ingredients of every package before you eat anything. You can also message the subscription service you choose, and ask them if they offer any special packages.
There is a lot of variety in these subscriptions! Each month offers at least one new flavor to try, while some offer even more. With subscriptions that have many options, you'll have a choice of which flavors you want for that month. Other services have a flavor pre-picked for each month, so you can choose when to start.
Each subscription length is different. Most Popcorn Club subscriptions have a definitive end, most being 3, 6, or 12 months. A few offer month-to-month subscriptions that you can just stop when you want. There are also seasonal subscriptions, where you get one package every 3 months.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

If you like surprises, many popcorn of the month clubs keep things fun by not telling you which flavors are coming. That way, each box feels like a little gift to yourself-or to someone else if you're giving it as a present. One month you might get a spicy cheddar blend, and the next, a sweet popcorn drizzled with white chocolate and raspberry. It's a great way to keep snack time interesting.

These clubs also give you the chance to support small, local businesses. Many popcorn subscriptions feature family-owned shops that make their popcorn in small batches using high-quality, non-GMO corn. This means the popcorn is fresher and often tastier than what you'd find at the store. Plus, it lets you try fun and unique flavors you wouldn't normally find in big-name brands.

The format of these clubs varies significantly as well. While most send ready-to-eat popcorn in sealed bags to maintain freshness, some focus on providing premium kernels and seasoning kits for home popping adventures. Some services specialize in classic flavors done perfectly, while others push the envelope with innovative combinations like "Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel” or the extremely spicy "Hellfire & Damnation”.

With so many great options out there, it can be hard to know which popcorn of the month club to choose. Here are a few things to keep in mind when deciding on your perfect match:

  • Customer reviews and company history. How long has the company been operating? What do recent customers say about their experiences? Are there any concerning patterns in negative reviews? What level of transparency does the company maintain about their operations? Look for companies with 3+ years in business and consistently positive reviews across multiple platforms.
  • Value and quantity. What's the true cost per serving? How do premium flavors impact the pricing? Is there enough popcorn to be shared with your household, or will you have to hide it away to keep for yourself? You might want to look for a service that deals in gallons of popcorn rather than ounces.
  • Gift-giving flexibility. Can you personalize the gift experience? Can you pick the shipping date? How much control does the recipient have over their subscription? Choose popcorn subscription services offering gift messages, customizable delivery schedules, and recipient preference controls.
  • Customization options. How flexible is the subscription? What happens if you need to pause deliveries? Can you skip any flavors you know you won't like? If you're a picky eater, choose a service that will allow you to see what flavors are coming up next.

Ready to find your perfect popcorn subscription? Top Consumer Reviews has carefully researched and analyzed the best popcorn of the month clubs available today, looking at everything from company history and customer feedback to serving sizes and shipping policies. Whether you're planning movie nights with the family or searching for a unique gift that keeps on giving, our detailed guide will help you choose a subscription that fits your snacking preferences and your wallet.

Compare Popcorn Clubs

Select any 2 Popcorn Clubs to compare them head to head

best-popcorn-clubs
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Shirley's
  • Fisher's Popcorn
  • Dell Cove Spices
  • Poppington's
  • Popped Artisan
  • Great American Popcorn Company
  • Gourmet Gift Baskets
  • The Popcorn Factory
  • Moose Munch
Amazing Clubs vs Shirley's Amazing Clubs vs Fisher's Popcorn Amazing Clubs vs Dell Cove Spices Amazing Clubs vs Poppington's Amazing Clubs vs Popped Artisan Amazing Clubs vs Great American Popcorn Company Amazing Clubs vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Amazing Clubs vs The Popcorn Factory Amazing Clubs vs Moose Munch Shirley's vs Fisher's Popcorn Shirley's vs Dell Cove Spices Shirley's vs Poppington's Shirley's vs Popped Artisan Shirley's vs Great American Popcorn Company Shirley's vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Shirley's vs The Popcorn Factory Shirley's vs Moose Munch Fisher's Popcorn vs Dell Cove Spices Fisher's Popcorn vs Poppington's Fisher's Popcorn vs Popped Artisan Fisher's Popcorn vs Great American Popcorn Company Fisher's Popcorn vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Fisher's Popcorn vs The Popcorn Factory Fisher's Popcorn vs Moose Munch Dell Cove Spices vs Poppington's Dell Cove Spices vs Popped Artisan Dell Cove Spices vs Great American Popcorn Company Dell Cove Spices vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Dell Cove Spices vs The Popcorn Factory Dell Cove Spices vs Moose Munch Poppington's vs Popped Artisan Poppington's vs Great American Popcorn Company Poppington's vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Poppington's vs The Popcorn Factory Poppington's vs Moose Munch Popped Artisan vs Great American Popcorn Company Popped Artisan vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Popped Artisan vs The Popcorn Factory Popped Artisan vs Moose Munch Great American Popcorn Company vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Great American Popcorn Company vs The Popcorn Factory Great American Popcorn Company vs Moose Munch Gourmet Gift Baskets vs The Popcorn Factory Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Moose Munch The Popcorn Factory vs Moose Munch
Compare the Best Popcorn Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Popcorn Clubs
The Best Reviews of Popcorn Clubs