What is the Best Popcorn of the Month Club? Have you ever found yourself craving the perfect snack that combines comfort, nostalgia, and gourmet flavors? Popcorn of the month clubs offer a delightful solution for snack enthusiasts, movie buffs, and anyone looking to explore unique popcorn varieties from the comfort of their home. These subscription services can solve several common dilemmas: the challenge of finding interesting snacks for family movie nights, the quest for thoughtful recurring gifts, or simply the desire to discover popcorn flavors beyond what's available at local stores.
Best Option
What makes Amazing Clubs' Popcorn of the Month Club worth your time and money? Well, you're getting premium gourmet popcorn delivered right to your door each month - and we're not talking about your average movie theater popcorn here. Each month brings you three new mouth-watering flavors (think white chocolate, sea-salt cheddar, and crunchy almond mocha) that you won't find at your local store. Amazing Clubs' works with small businesses across the country to bring you the best of the best, plus they include free shipping with every delivery. Their customer satisfaction policy is so good it's almost unbelievable - but trust us, it's real. It's no wonder they consistently rank at the top of popcorn club rankings.
Most flexible subscription options among competitors
Amazing Clubs' subscriptions are unmatched when it comes to flexibility. You can choose from subscription lengths of 3, 4 (seasonal), 6, or 12 months, with the ability to customize delivery frequency to either monthly or every other month. When it comes to payment, you've got options to pay in full or per shipment, and you can even plan ahead by selecting a start date up to 11 months in advance. Want to give popcorn as a gift? You can personalize the announcement through mail, email, or print it yourself.
Shipping is included in $36.95/month price
While $36.95 per month could sound steep for popcorn, each monthly delivery includes a generous 2 gallons of gourmet popcorn - plenty to share with friends and family - and shipping is already included in that price. Plus, Amazing Clubs regularly offers deals, with discounts ranging from $5 off a 3-month subscription to $30 off a 12-month club membership. In fact, they're so consistent with their promotions that it's worth clicking around on the website while you wait for a discount code before subscribing, since you're practically guaranteed to be offered one.
Wide variety of flavors accompanied by popcorn newsletter
You'll receive three unique, handmade gourmet popcorn varieties each month, and here's the fun part - you'll never see the same flavor twice in a calendar year. Along with your popcorn, you'll get the "What's Poppin'" newsletter which includes interesting popcorn facts, serving suggestions, and details about your monthly selections. To find out what flavors you might receive, you can check out the "Past Selections" tab on the product listing to get a general idea of the popcorn flavors Amazing Clubs provides. After subscribing, you can preview upcoming flavors and skip months that don't appeal to you, which is perfect if you have dietary restrictions or are just particular about your popcorn. Some mouth-watering flavors you might receive include:
Satisfaction guarantee is robust
You'll be happy to know that Amazing Clubs stands firmly behind their popcorn with their "They'll Love It!" Guarantee, which is refreshingly straightforward (and thankfully free of legal jargon). If you're ever unhappy with your popcorn delivery, they'll do whatever it takes to make things right - and if you're still not satisfied, you can cancel anytime and get a full credit for any unshipped orders. For instance, while most subscribers love discovering new taste sensations (from sweet treats to savory surprises), one reviewer found the flavored options a bit too adventurous and would have preferred plain buttered popcorn. When that customer expressed their concern, Amazing Clubs immediately jumped in to offer alternatives and promised dedicated support to make things right. To get help with any issues, you can reach their customer service team seven days a week from 7 AM to 10 PM Central time (with extended holiday hours) by phone or by email.
You're almost guaranteed to be a repeat customer
Based on customer reviews, this popcorn of the month club is quite the crowd-pleaser. Amazing Clubs has earned an impressive 4.8-star average from over 2,000 reviews, and it's easy to see why - customers consistently rave about the generous portions, fresh quality, and exciting variety of flavors. Gift-givers seem particularly pleased, with many reporting that their recipients loved it so much they ended up extending their subscriptions or even ordering it for other family members. Multiple customers mentioned being pleasantly surprised by the larger-than-expected deliveries, and the consistent freshness and on-time delivery have earned the service quite a few repeat customers.
Our top choice for popcorn clubs
You're going to love Amazing Clubs' Popcorn Club - it's truly in a league of its own. Between the three unique flavors you'll get each month, flexible subscription options that work with your schedule and budget, and a customer service team that genuinely wants you to be happy with every kernel, this popcorn club has earned our highest recommendation.
Great
If you order from Shirley's, you'll be getting a taste of small-town charm straight from Bluffton, Ohio, where Shirley's Gourmet Popcorn got its start at the local Shannon Theatre. What began as their famously delicious movie popcorn (that customers kept bringing tubs back for) has grown into a beloved brand, named after their warmest, friendliest employee - Shirley herself, who spent 25 years making moviegoers feel like family. Today, you'll get that same hometown feeling delivered right to your door, with two unique, freshly-made flavors in every box.
How the subscription works and what you'll get
You're in for a treat with Shirley's Popcorn of the Month Club. Each month, you'll receive two bags of gourmet popcorn, containing 10-12 cups each, delivered right to your door. You'll always get one seasonal flavor of the month plus one of Shirley's signature classics - and they never repeat the same combination twice. Plus, each shipment comes with a personal touch: a handwritten note that makes every delivery feel like a gift from Shirley herself.
Flavors that'll make your taste buds dance
Looking through Shirley's flavor calendar is like browsing a gourmet food magazine. You might find yourself savoring Cheddar Pretzel Ale in January, cooling off with Frosted Raspberry Lemonade in July, or getting festive with White & Dark Chocolate Peppermint in December. They've got quite a range too - from indulgent sweet treats like Birthday Cake to savory adventures like Everything Bagel and Spiked Garlic Parmesan. Some other flavors you might encounter include:
Free shipping
While a few other popcorn subscriptions have raised their prices over the years, Shirley's have remained the same. You can start with a 3-month subscription at $120 (breaks down to $40/month, or $20 per bag), upgrade to 6 months for $230, or go all-in with a full year at $400. Shipping is completely free, too.
Gifting customization is limited
You'll want to place your order by the 8th of the month to get your popcorn around the 10th. Planning to give it as a gift? Your options are fairly basic, but it appears that you can check a box during checkout to add a personalized message. Just remember that all orders get packaged on the 10th, so if you miss that 8th of the month cutoff, your first delivery will roll over to the following month. If you need a specific delivery date, there's a good chance the helpful customer service team can work with you - just mention it in your special instructions or reach out directly.
Generous 30-day refund policy
If you're not happy with your popcorn (though we doubt that'll happen), you have 30 days to return it in its original packaging, along with your receipt. For returns, just send your items back to Shirley's shop in Bluffton, Ohio - but keep in mind you'll need to cover the shipping costs. Missing something from your order? No worries. Just give them a call or send an email with your order details. And if anything arrives damaged or isn't quite right, they've got your back with their 100% satisfaction guarantee - Shirley's will replace your popcorn free of charge.
Rave reviews
You can order with confidence knowing that Shirley's has earned an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau. Their customers rave about both the popcorn and service - from UK visitors making special trips just for their birthday cake flavor, to couples playfully debating whether spicy cheese or polar pop mix is better. What really stands out is their exceptional customer service. When one customer had some hiccups with multiple orders, the team went above and beyond - Pete quickly fixed billing issues, Amy made personal calls to sort out shipping concerns, and Jen jumped in to help with rewards questions. Shirley's truly treats you like family, making sure every detail is perfect.
Highly recommended
If you want to support a family business and get amazing popcorn delivered to your door, or if you enjoy trying bold and unique flavors without breaking the bank, we think you'll love what Shirley's Popcorn Club has to offer. Their outstanding customer service makes you feel like part of the family, which is why we think you should definitely check them out for your popcorn of the month subscription.
Very Good
From humble beginnings as a boardwalk stand in 1937, Fisher's has grown into a beloved Delaware beach institution. It all started with Everett Fisher and his secret caramel recipe, which his son Donald helped perfect (even running things while Dad served in WWII). Today, you'll find Fisher's Popcorn in three beach locations and thousands of East Coast grocery stores. Still family-owned, they make every batch by hand with the same care Everett insisted on. (And they've been gluten-free since before it was cool.)
Receive a half-gallon tub for $20/month
Fisher's Popcorn Club offers four subscription lengths with tiered pricing: a 3-month plan for $60, all the way up to a yearlong subscription for $240 (with 6 and 9-month options in between). These prices are for half-gallon tubs, but you can size up to 3.5 gallons if you're feeling extra snacky - and the bigger the container, the more you'll save per serving. You can also snag 10% off your first order just by joining their mailing list. The pricing is quite competitive, especially since shipping is included, and you're getting generous portions starting at a half-gallon.
Schedule deliveries in advance
Need your popcorn by a specific date? You can schedule deliveries up to 12 weeks out, which isn't as far in advance as some rivals allow, but better than those that don't offer scheduling at all.
Choose your flavors, or let them pick for you
You've got options when it comes to the flavors you receive in your popcorn of the month subscription here - either let Fisher's surprise you with a mystery flavor each month or stick with your favorite for every delivery. Here's their complete flavor lineup:
Some flavors aren't always available
At the time of our visit, their 3-way split of Caramel/Butter/Cheddar was marked as unavailable, with no restock date announced. We also saw mentions of a Pumpkin Spice Caramel flavor, but couldn't add it to our cart, so we assume that means it's seasonal. Fisher's selection is a bit limited compared to other popcorn clubs - you won't find any "out-there" flavor profiles here.
Customers rave about Fisher's Popcorn Club
You'll be joining quite the fan club when you subscribe to Fisher's Popcorn - they've earned a near-perfect 4.9-star rating from their subscription customers. Whether you're shopping for that person who "has everything" or continuing a cherished family tradition, their popcorn club brings the boardwalk right to your doorstep.
Your satisfaction is always their top priority
While Fisher's Popcorn doesn't accept returns on correctly-filled orders, you can rest easy knowing they'll make things right if something's not quite perfect. Notice an issue with your order? Just let them know within a week, and they'll fix it up. Not completely in love with your popcorn? (It happens, though rarely.) Their customer service team has been standing behind their products for over 80 years, and they're ready to help - just give them a call or send an email. While some competitors offer more formal guarantees, there's something reassuring about Fisher's family-business approach that puts us at ease. And, when you've got thousands of happy customers and a near-perfect rating, sometimes a simple "trust us, we've got you covered" is all you need.
Best pick for tried-n-true popcorn flavors
Want your popcorn to be delicious but not too outlandish? Fisher's Popcorn Club is the right place to be. They focus on perfecting classic flavors like caramel and white cheddar rather than going wild with unusual combinations (which could be a relief in a world of "birthday cake buffalo wing" popcorn flavors). This family-owned Delaware popcorn of the month club earns a very good score.
Very Good
Looking for a healthier twist on your popcorn of the month club? Dell Cove Spices stands out from other popcorn clubs by sending you unpopped non-GMO kernels grown on family farms in Indiana, paired with all-natural seasonings that are gluten-free, nut-free, and often sugar-free and vegan-friendly. You'll become your own popcorn chef - popping fresh kernels and seasoning them to taste (which means more control over ingredients and portions than pre-popped competitors). The company caters to health-conscious foodies who value clean labels and eco-friendly practices.
A monthly adventure in DIY popcorn making
Dell Cove's popcorn subscription starts at $67.50 for three months, which breaks down to $22.50 per box. Each month, you'll receive a unique popcorn adventure in an elegant black box with a red satin ribbon. Inside, you'll find a half-pound of unpopped kernels (enough for 7 big bowls) and a full-size pouch of seasoning. You'll need to pop the kernels yourself, which makes this club unique among its competitors, and keep in mind that you'll need to add some moisture to your popped kernels (like butter, oil, or ghee) to help the seasonings stick properly. (Some customers have noted this can be a bit tricky at first).
Level up your popcorn game with optional add-ons
Not sure if you have all the right popcorn-making equipment? Dell Cove has you covered with some handy accessories. You can add a microwave popper for $25 - it's collapsible, eco-friendly, and doesn't even require oil to use. There's also a fancy glass spice jar for $9.95, laser-etched with "POPCORN SEASONING" so it's easy to spot in your cabinet. (These additions are especially thoughtful if you're gifting the subscription to someone who might not have all the popcorn-making essentials.)
Try new kernel varieties
Want to know what's in store for your popcorn adventure? Each month, you'll get to experiment with different kernel varieties and flavor combinations as you pop your own gourmet snacks. Dell Cove has carefully curated a year-long schedule of tasty pairings that'll keep your popcorn game fresh and exciting. Here's their flavor schedule:
Ships immediately after order
When you order Dell Cove's Popcorn of the Month Club, you'll get your first shipment right after purchase, with subsequent boxes arriving at the beginning of each month. Want to make it extra special? They'll include a handwritten gift note in your first box at no extra charge (which adds a lovely personal touch). As for shipping costs, you'll see the exact amount during checkout - and when we tested it, shipping was free on our 3-month subscription.
Customer support is responsive
Dell Cove Spices' customer service really shines. While they don't have a huge number of reviews, the ones they do have are consistently positive. One buyer shared how the company went "above and beyond" when they needed to cancel an order due to an address mistake - they found the service team incredibly kind and easy to work with (and they loved the quality of their popcorn of the month subscription so much they'd order again in a heartbeat). Another happy customer bought it as a gift for their husband and was thrilled with the first shipment, eagerly anticipating the next month's delivery.
A solid service for a specific kind of customer
While this popcorn of the month club is a bit off-beat in terms of having to pop the kernels yourself, Dell Cove Spices is perfect if you want control over your ingredients and portions. Plus, who doesn't love the smell of freshly popped corn wafting through their kitchen? If the flavors they offer sound good to you, there's no reason not to give them a try.
Good
You know that warm, fuzzy feeling you get when you're sharing a treat with friends and family? That's exactly what inspired Poppington's Gourmet Popcorn club. When the founders noticed there wasn't a single popcorn shop in downtown Greenville, SC, they decided to change that - and since opening in 2012, their gourmet popcorn shop has been delighting local customers. In 2023, new owners Skyler and Brittanie Burkett took over, bringing fresh energy and creative new flavors that have helped transform this local favorite into a destination for popcorn lovers everywhere.
Popcorn subscription prices have gone down...
We were excited to discover that Poppington's has substantially lowered their prices since the last time we reviewed them. The 3-month subscription is $85 (down from $114), and the 6-month option is $167 (previously $228). You can also choose a one-time purchase for $36.
...but shipping fees have doubled
Unfortunately, Poppington's may be recouping the cost with higher shipping fees. Where shipping used to be calculated around $12 at checkout, it's almost doubled at $23.12 for UPS Ground.
Try four flavors per shipment
One more thing has changed since the last time we took a look at Poppington's. Where their popcorn subscription boxes used to contain three distinct flavors, they've since added chocolate varieties to their offerings, bringing each box's contents up to a whopping four gourmet popcorn flavors each month. Poppington's is perfect if you're someone who loves trying new flavors rather than getting stuck with large quantities of the same thing. Each variety comes in a 4-cup bag and follows a carefully-curated calendar of flavors that balances classic favorites with adventurous combinations.
Sweet, savory, and everything in between
Poppington's flavor lineup includes everything from comforting classics to bold innovations. Here's a taste of what you can expect throughout the year:
Leans toward sweeter popcorns
There are a couple of drawbacks to keep in mind with this popcorn of the month club. For instance, you can't choose specific flavors, and Poppington's does reserve the right to make substitutions if needed. Also, some subscribers have mentioned feeling like the boxes contain too many sweet popcorn flavors and that they'd love to see more savory selections. That said, these things are not out of the ordinary when it comes to popcorn of the month clubs, and might not be of concern to you at all.
Gift-giving details for Poppington's popcorn club
Sending Poppington's popcorn of the month club as a gift? You can add a personalized touch with a handwritten message on their custom notecards - just look for the gift message box under the payment section when ordering. Keep in mind that if you're planning to start someone's subscription, timing matters: orders placed after the 15th of any month will begin with the following month's shipment. You also can't select a specific delivery date.
No returns for perishables
Poppington's return policy is pretty typical for a company selling perishables. You can't return food items unless they're clearly defective (for example, the bag is torn), and if you receive an incorrect item, don't open it - reach out to their customer service team directly for resolution. During warmer months, don't panic if your chocolate-covered popcorn arrives a bit melted - just pop it in the fridge for about an hour. Also worth noting: once your order is prepared, they can't cancel it or issue store credit if you change your mind.
Not as many online reviews as some rivals
While Poppington's has earned an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau, it's difficult to find reviews specifically about their popcorn club subscription. That makes it hard to evaluate how reliable their shipping and customer service are, which could be a reason to choose another popcorn club if you're purchasing a monthly subscription as a gift for someone else. However, there are plenty of positive reviews for their Greenville, SC location on Yelp. Customers who've tried their popcorn love their diverse flavor selection. One enthusiastic reviewer raved about their spicy dill and Chicago mix varieties. Another called the Birthday Cake flavor "insanely delicious".
Pricier than some, but great quality
Poppington's popcorn club is pricier than some alternatives with its moderate monthly portions (about 12 cups), and it may not be the perfect pick for gift-giving due to limited shipping date customizability. However, you're still getting something special here - the chance to explore four unique flavors in each shipment, all while supporting an enthusiastic small business that really knows their kernels. Poppington's club could be an excellent choice if you're treating yourself or someone you love to a gourmet popcorn subscription.
Good
Popped Artisan, a woman-owned popcorn company in the Sonoran Desert, has been crafting small-batch vegan popcorn with regionally-inspired flavors since 2014. Their commitment to quality means you're getting gluten-free, nut-free snacks without any preservatives or artificial ingredients. Whether you're interested in their popcorn club for yourself or as a thoughtful gift, you can feel good knowing each bag is made with real ingredients and ethical practices that result in a truly gourmet popcorn experience.
Subscriptions start at $109 for 3 months
Popped Artisan's popcorn is a bit pricey at roughly $10 per 6-ounce bag. However, if you're a repeat customer who can't get enough, the subscription pricing works out to be a couple bucks cheaper than making several one-time purchases. You can choose from three subscription lengths for your popcorn club subscription: 3 months at $109, 6 months at $209, or 12 months at $399. Each month brings four 6-ounce bags of different flavors.
Customers rave about the unique flavors and quality
If you're hesitant about these unique flavor profiles, you don't need to be - customers rave about them, especially the "magical" Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel and the del Bac Whiskey Infused varieties. The popcorn's quality comes from being small-batch and carefully crafted - while it may be on the pricier side, customers agree it's worth it for the exceptional taste and quality. People say the flavors are "definitely not subtle" - and they mean it as a compliment.
A rotating roster of desert-inspired flavors
No two months of a Popped Artisan popcorn subscription will be the same. From desert-inspired creations like Prickly Pear Caramel and Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel to classics with a twist like Rosemary Salted Caramel and Bourbon Espresso Caramel, subscribers can expect an exciting variety. You might receive savory options like Truffle, Green Chile, or Mesquite Smoked Cheddar alongside sweeter selections like Churro or Lemon Poppyseed.
Free shipping with thoughtful touches for gift-giving
Standard shipping with first-week-of-the-month delivery is included in the cost for customers in the continental US, but if you need a last-minute popcorn gift for a vegan friend or client, you have the option to pay extra for express shipping. You also have the option to include a personal note with your gift. Customers frequently mention giving this popcorn club as gifts, noting how the beautiful Sonoran desert packaging makes it perfect for sending to clients and family.
Excellent customer service keeps subscribers coming back
When you join the Popped Artisan popcorn of the month club, you're signing up for more than just great snacks - you're getting stellar customer service too. While there aren't as many reviews for this popcorn of the month club as some of their rivals enjoy, we're reassured by those we did find that if any issues arise, you'll be taken care of.
Overall very appealing, but room for improvement
With their truly original flavors and proactive customer service, Popped Artisan makes for a great gift option or as a way to treat yourself. While the quality is excellent, this popcorn company would need a stronger customer presence and more quantity per shipment to rank higher than some of their rivals.
Good
Great American Popcorn Company started in 1994 when David and Catherine Lewis left their corporate jobs in Chicago to open a popcorn shop in Galena, Illinois. Today, their kids Victoria and Zachary run the show, making small-batch gourmet popcorn with non-GMO kernels from American family farms- and they've grown from a single storefront to having both a prime downtown location and a dedicated production facility for their booming online business.
A delightful monthly treat delivered to your doorstep
With Great American Popcorn Company's "Flavor of the Month" popcorn club, you'll receive two bags each containing 8-10 cups of gourmet popcorn each month for just $21.95. Your subscription includes flexible delivery options - you can choose monthly, bi-monthly, quarterly, semi-annual, or annual deliveries. (The price per month stays consistent regardless of frequency, though - no discounts for loyalty here.)
Shipping costs $9/delivery
You'll also need to factor in shipping costs of $9 per delivery, bringing your popcorn subscription up to $30/month. But here's a nice surprise: when we went to check out, they had thrown in a free Scratch-Off Ticket as a gift with our order.
Over 70 popcorn varieties, but not much control over what you get
Want to know just how many popcorn flavors you might get in your subscription box? While Great American Popcorn Company offers over 70 unique flavors that could show up at your door, you won't have much control over which ones you receive. From classic comfort flavors like Butter Glazed and Cheddar Cheese to adventurous options like Kentucky Salted Bourbon and Hellfire & Damnation, there's something for every palate - but unlike some competitors, you can't specify preferences for sweet vs. savory, preview upcoming flavors, or skip months when flavors don't appeal to you. The product description for the "Flavor of the Month" club only includes a preview of that month's flavors, but you can check out their "Popcorn" page to find the full list of possibilities.
Designed with gifting in mind
Giving a popcorn club subscription as a gift? When checking out, simply enter your lucky recipient's shipping information, and they'll get their first delivery the following month. You can even add a personal gift message to make it extra special. Better yet, if you'd like something physical to hand over (because let's face it, unwrapping an email isn't quite as fun), just check the "Are you sending popcorn as a gift?" box during checkout, and they'll email you a printable gift certificate along with your order confirmation. You can also check out Great American Popcorn's FAQ articles for a peek at what the gift boxes look like.
100% satisfaction guaranteed
Great American Popcorn Company promises 100% satisfaction with every purchase - if you're not completely happy with your popcorn of the month subscription, you can contact their customer service for a replacement or refund. If you receive damaged goods, you'll need to contact the shipping carrier directly and hang onto all packaging materials for your claim.
Fantastic reviews
We loved reading what customers have to say about this popcorn company - their enthusiasm is downright contagious. When you order from them, you can expect lightning-fast delivery and popcorn so irresistibly fresh that you might find yourself in a love-hate relationship with your snack stash (just like the customer who hilariously documented their internal struggle: "First handful... 'I love you guys!' Finish the bag... 'I hate you guys!'"). The online ordering experience gets consistently high marks, with one loyal customer raving about how they order "all the time" despite only being able to visit the physical store annually. The consensus seems crystal clear - customers are blown away by both the phenomenal service and the exceptional quality, with one reviewer declaring that it's "ridiculous how good it is".
High-quality popcorn
You'll find a lot to love about this popcorn club, even though it doesn't let you customize your monthly flavors (which might be a deal-breaker if you're a picky eater) - but if you enjoy trying new and interesting snacks, you're in for a treat. With over 70 creative flavors in their rotation, Great American Popcorn Company delivers high-quality, handcrafted popcorn, backed by stellar reviews from their customers. If you like to go with the flow, we think you should give this monthly subscription a try.
Fair
While Gourmet Gift Baskets didn't start with popcorn - they actually began in a New Hampshire flower shop back in 2002 - they've grown into a multi-million dollar gift basket company that now offers a popcorn subscription among their many gifting options.
3, 6, 9, and 12-month subscription options from $89.99
You can get a monthly 1-gallon popcorn subscription that ranges from 3 to 12 months, with pricing that gets more cost-effective the longer you commit. The 3-month option at $89.99 comes to about $30 per gallon, while the 12-month "Best Offer" at $229.99 brings it down to roughly $19.17 per gallon - a significantly better deal if you're in it for the long haul. You can choose between monthly or every other month deliveries, and one particularly nice feature is the ability to schedule your first shipment up to 18 months in advance (perfect for planning ahead for birthdays or special occasions, and more flexible than competitors who ship immediately or on a fixed schedule).
Flavors play it safer than some family-owned popcorn companies
Want to know what popcorn flavors you'll get each month? Gourmet Gift Baskets lays it out for you on the product page. You can't skip or swap flavors, but that's pretty standard for popcorn clubs. Here's what you'll get:
Gourmet Gift Baskets' popcorn flavor selection is relatively conventional compared to some family-owned competitors who offer more adventurous varieties. If you're looking for more interesting flavor combinations, you should check out some other options on our list.
No specifics on subscription-related concerns in return policy
You have 15 days from delivery to return any unopened popcorn for store credit (minus shipping costs). Have an issue with damaged or missing items? Just let them know within 15 days for a replacement. Gourmet Gift Baskets sells a wide range of products, and popcorn subscriptions aren't their main focus. That means their satisfaction guarantee lacks a bit of detail that popcorn-focused rivals provide - for example, what recourse do you have regarding heat-damaged popcorn during shipping? They don't say.
Customer reviews reveal issues with delivery and perishable quality
While Gourmet Gift Baskets has an "A+" Better Business Bureau rating, we uncovered a number of customer reviews elsewhere that would make us think twice about gifting their popcorn of the month subscription. There are reports of significant delivery issues that could ruin a special occasion. For example, when someone ordered a Valentine's Day gift a week in advance with guaranteed delivery and paid extra for shipping, their gift got stuck in transit and didn't arrive days after the holiday. Another customer who paid for expedited August delivery faced similar frustrations when their package didn't show up for days, with zero updates and unresponsive customer service (and if there's anything worse than a late gift, it's being unable to get answers about where it is). And while there are no reviews about the popcorn subscription itself, we did come across several complaints about the quality of other food items included in gift baskets from this company.
Not highly recommended
We can't enthusiastically recommend Gourmet Gift Baskets' popcorn of the month club. The flavors are pretty standard (nothing here made us say "wow!"), and you'll find better options elsewhere - especially if you're thinking about giving this as a gift. That all adds up to a below-average rating from us.
Subpar
Looking to try a popcorn subscription? You'll find The Popcorn Factory (a branch of 1-800-Flowers) offering two monthly club options. There's a regular and a larger "Popcorn Lovers" size - but before you get too excited, we should mention that our previous ratings of their parent company's customer service have been less than stellar.
You might only receive 2.5 ounces of popcorn some months
You've got two subscription choices from The Popcorn Factory, and the main difference comes down to size. The premium option runs $19.99 for a 1-gallon tin, while the standard option costs $12.99 for a smaller canister. Interestingly, the amount of popcorn you receive varies dramatically - the premium tin contains anywhere from 7 to 33 ounces, while the smaller canister ranges from 2.5 to 9.5 ounces. This wide range in quantity seems unusual since you're paying the same price regardless of how much popcorn you receive that month. Add in the $9.99 shipping fee per delivery, and this subscription ends up being pricier than the majority of rival popcorn clubs. (The 20% off your first order you can redeem by giving The Popcorn Factory your email address barely makes a dent in the difference.)
How the monthly flavor rotation works
The Popcorn Factory's popcorn of the month club follows a fixed calendar schedule. You'll start the year with Cracked Pepper & Sea Salt in January, move on to romantic Strawberry Sparkling Wine in February, and continue through interesting combinations like Avocado Sea Salt in April and Habanero in June. While the flavors are creative, there's one catch - you can't skip months if a particular flavor doesn't appeal to you. Though you can cancel anytime, you'd need to completely cancel and resubscribe to avoid a specific flavor, which isn't exactly convenient.
A concerning pattern of customer service issues
Based on multiple customer reports, your experience with The Popcorn Factory might be quite frustrating. People have faced serious delivery issues, with orders never arriving despite paying for expedited shipping. When customers try to resolve these problems, they're met with unresponsive email support and lengthy phone wait times. When we tried to reach out via their live chat to ask about popcorn portion sizes, we got an automated response telling us to try their phone number instead.
Product quality and subscription flexibility leave much to be desired
If you do receive your popcorn, you might find the quality disappointing. Customers mention receiving gummy, sticky popcorn, and some flavors like the January Cracked Pepper & Sea Salt are described as overwhelmingly spicy. Many customers find it's not worth the price. To make matters worse, people report having a very difficult time canceling their memberships.
Not recommended
We'll be direct: we can't recommend The Popcorn Factory's popcorn of the month club. Between the additional shipping costs ($10 per delivery), wildly varying portion sizes, and concerning patterns of customer service issues, you're likely to end up frustrated rather than delighted. When you could be paying $30 total for what might be just 3 ounces of popcorn - and that's assuming it arrives at all - there are simply better ways to satisfy your gourmet popcorn cravings. You'll find better value, more flexible options, and more reliable service with other popcorn subscriptions in our review.
Poor
If you've ever enjoyed a bag of Moose Munch popcorn, you might be intrigued by Harry & David's popcorn of the month club that promises to deliver this premium snack right to your door. The Moose Munch Premium Popcorn Club sends you two 10-oz bags monthly - but before you get too excited about never having to track down your favorite treat in stores again, there are some serious quality and service issues you should know about.
3 plans from $18.33/month
You've got three flexible subscription lengths to choose from with the Moose Munch Popcorn Club. The 3-month plan runs $59.99 ($20/month), the 6-month option is $109.99 ($18.33/month), and the year-long subscription costs $199.99 ($16.67/month). Each monthly delivery includes two 10-oz bags of Moose Munch. (For reference, you can buy it in grocery stores for about $19.84 per 10-oz bag.)
Flavors to satisfy every craving
While the flavors you receive are subject to change at Harry & David's discretion, generally, you can expect to receive a selection of both classic favorites and innovative limited-edition flavors on the following rotation:
Some flavors repeat two months in a row
You may have noticed that there are some repeat flavors in the list. If constant variety is what you're looking for in a popcorn of the month subscription, you'll want to check out one of Harry & David's rivals (but they won't have Moose Munch).
$20 for 20 ounces of popcorn isn't the best deal
While the convenience of having Moose Munch delivered to your door might draw you in, you should be aware that you won't get as much bang for your buck here in terms of quantity. With an additional $6.99 shipping fee per delivery, when you break it down, your monthly cost will be over $20 for about 20 ounces of popcorn. Compared to other popcorn clubs that deliver gallon-sized portions for similar prices, the Moose Munch Popcorn Club portions are a bit modest. That said, Moose Munch isn't just popcorn. What keeps people reaching for another handful is their premium mix-ins: each bag comes loaded with decadent chocolate, candied nuts, and other gourmet additions that transform plain popcorn into an indulgent treat.
Concerning customer service record
If you're still considering the Moose Munch Popcorn Club, you should know about some serious red flags in Harry & David's customer service. Their return policy is suspiciously vague, promising only that "you must be delighted, or we'll make it right" with no further details on how they plan to keep their word. While Harry & David used to enjoy a flawless reputation, the company has earned a dismal 1.2-star average rating from over 1,200 customer reviews, since being acquired by 1-800-Flowers.
Recent quality issues plague this once-beloved company
The problems with Harry & David's Moose Munch popcorn club go beyond customer service. Long-time customers report that the recipe here is different from what you used to receive from H&D - and from what you'll still find in stores. On top of that, multiple customers have reported receiving rancid Moose Munch and getting nowhere with support. Reaching a representative has become nearly impossible through their outsourced customer service system - you might even lose your chance to connect if you miss your moment in their queue-less chat system.
Stay away
We wouldn't recommend Harry & David's Moose Munch popcorn subscription at this time. It appears that their acquisition by 1-800-Flowers is part of a bait-and-switch business model: they use a trusted name to draw you in, while cutting corners on quality to rake in higher profits. They're counting on you not doing your research ahead of time - so you can congratulate yourself for visiting TopConsumerReviews.com before purchasing this subscription for yourself or someone you love.
Continued from above...
Have you ever found yourself craving the perfect snack that combines comfort, nostalgia, and gourmet flavors? Popcorn of the month clubs offer a delightful solution for snack enthusiasts, movie buffs, and anyone looking to explore unique popcorn varieties from the comfort of their home. These subscription services can solve several common dilemmas: the challenge of finding interesting snacks for family movie nights, the quest for thoughtful recurring gifts, or simply the desire to discover popcorn flavors beyond what's available at local stores.
When exploring popcorn subscription options, you'll find quite a range of services. Some clubs are run by multi-generation family businesses that have been perfecting their recipes for decades - imagine receiving monthly deliveries of caramel corn made from a cherished 1940s recipe that made a small-town shop famous. Others are part of larger subscription box companies that offer everything from coffee to cookies, with popcorn being just one of their many offerings (but often sourced from cute little mom-and-pop shops too).
If you like surprises, many popcorn of the month clubs keep things fun by not telling you which flavors are coming. That way, each box feels like a little gift to yourself-or to someone else if you're giving it as a present. One month you might get a spicy cheddar blend, and the next, a sweet popcorn drizzled with white chocolate and raspberry. It's a great way to keep snack time interesting.
These clubs also give you the chance to support small, local businesses. Many popcorn subscriptions feature family-owned shops that make their popcorn in small batches using high-quality, non-GMO corn. This means the popcorn is fresher and often tastier than what you'd find at the store. Plus, it lets you try fun and unique flavors you wouldn't normally find in big-name brands.
The format of these clubs varies significantly as well. While most send ready-to-eat popcorn in sealed bags to maintain freshness, some focus on providing premium kernels and seasoning kits for home popping adventures. Some services specialize in classic flavors done perfectly, while others push the envelope with innovative combinations like "Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel" or the extremely spicy "Hellfire & Damnation".
With so many great options out there, it can be hard to know which popcorn of the month club to choose. Here are a few things to keep in mind when deciding on your perfect match:
Ready to find your perfect popcorn subscription? Top Consumer Reviews has carefully researched and analyzed the best popcorn of the month clubs available today, looking at everything from company history and customer feedback to serving sizes and shipping policies. Whether you're planning movie nights with the family or searching for a unique gift that keeps on giving, our detailed guide will help you choose a subscription that fits your snacking preferences and your wallet.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
