What is the Best Popcorn of the Month Club?
Have you ever found yourself craving the perfect snack that combines comfort, nostalgia, and gourmet flavors? Popcorn of the month clubs offer a delightful solution for snack enthusiasts, movie buffs, and anyone looking to explore unique popcorn varieties from the comfort of their home. These subscription services can solve several common dilemmas: the challenge of finding interesting snacks for family movie nights, the quest for thoughtful recurring gifts, or simply the desire to discover popcorn flavors beyond what's available at local stores.
When exploring popcorn subscription options, you'll find quite a range of services. Some clubs are run by multi-generation family businesses that have been perfecting their recipes for decades - imagine receiving monthly deliveries of caramel corn made from a cherished 1940s recipe that made a small-town shop famous. Others are part of larger subscription box companies that offer everything from coffee to cookies, with popcorn being just one of their many offerings (but often sourced from cute little mom-and-pop shops too).
Monday, June 16th
2025 Popcorn Club Reviews
Amazing Clubs
Amazing Clubs' Popcorn of the Month Club delivers three unique, handcrafted flavors right to your door each month, ranging from indulgent dessert varieties to bold savory combinations. You'll get a generous 2-gallon portion of fresh popcorn with every delivery, plus their flexible subscription options let you customize everything from payment plans to delivery schedules. With exceptional customer service, free shipping included, and consistently rave reviews from customers, this club is our top recommendation for popcorn enthusiasts who want to explore new flavors without sacrificing quality or convenience.
Shirley's
If you're craving gourmet popcorn with small-town charm and big flavors, Shirley's Popcorn of the Month Club delivers both. Each month, you'll receive two generous bags of freshly-made popcorn featuring creative seasonal flavors alongside classic favorites, all crafted in their Bluffton, Ohio shop with the same care that made their movie theater popcorn famous. The personal touches - like handwritten notes with each delivery and exceptional customer service - make you feel like part of Shirley's family. We think this subscription is perfect for popcorn enthusiasts who appreciate artisanal quality, unique flavor combinations, and supporting a family-owned business that truly cares about its customers.
Fisher's Popcorn
If you're seeking classic popcorn perfection delivered to your door, Fisher's monthly subscription brings the nostalgic taste of beach boardwalk treats right to your home. Their family-owned operation has spent over 80 years perfecting traditional flavors like caramel and white cheddar, maintaining the same hand-crafted quality that made them famous. With generous portions starting at half-gallon tubs and flexible delivery scheduling, Fisher's makes treating yourself (or someone special) to premium popcorn a breeze. This service is perfect for popcorn purists who appreciate time-tested flavors and family-recipe quality over trendy, experimental combinations.
Dell Cove Spices
Looking to elevate your popcorn game? Dell Cove Spices delivers a unique DIY popcorn experience by sending you non-GMO kernels from Indiana family farms paired with all-natural, gluten-free seasonings. You'll receive enough kernels for 7 bowls plus a full-size seasoning pouch each month, letting you control your portions and ingredients while experimenting with exciting flavors like Buttery Garlic, Chocolate Caramel, and Dill Pickle. The subscription includes thoughtful touches like handwritten gift notes and eco-friendly packaging, making it perfect for health-conscious snackers who enjoy getting hands-on in the kitchen. While it requires a bit more effort than pre-popped options, this service offers excellent value at $22.50 per monthly box for those who appreciate fresh-popped, customizable popcorn.
Poppington's
If you're looking for variety in your popcorn of the month club, Poppington's offers four creative flavors in each monthly box from their family-owned shop in Greenville, SC. While their recent price reductions are exciting at first (now starting at $36 for a one-time box), they appear to have doubled shipping costs to make up the difference. You'll get about 12 cups of popcorn per shipment, with tasty seasonal options like Havarti Dill and Christmas Tree Cake, though you can't pick specific flavors. Despite higher prices than some competitors and limited delivery date options, Poppington's still earns a good rating for their quality products and innovative flavor combinations.
Popped Artisan
If you're a vegan snack enthusiast who appreciates artisanal treats and unique flavor combinations, Popped Artisan's subscription service might be your perfect match. At around $10 per 6-ounce bag, this woman-owned company crafts small-batch, desert-inspired vegan popcorn with exciting flavors like Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel and Prickly Pear Caramel, all while maintaining high quality standards (gluten-free, nut-free, no preservatives). The portions here are modest and the price point is premium - this popcorn of the month club isn't for budget-conscious snackers or those seeking traditional butter-and-salt varieties. Given the quality, unique flavors, and excellent customer service but considering the portion size and premium pricing, Popped Artisan is still an appealing choice for adventurous snackers or as a thoughtful gift.
Great American Popcorn Company
If you're craving artisanal popcorn delivered to your door, Great American Popcorn Company's subscription service offers two bags of gourmet popcorn monthly for $21.95 (plus $9 shipping). You'll get access to their impressive rotation of over 70 unique flavors, all made with non-GMO kernels from American family farms, though you can't choose which flavors you receive each month. While the lack of flavor customization and shipping costs might give you pause, the consistently rave reviews about both product quality and customer service make this worth considering. Based on our evaluation, it's a solid choice for adventurous snackers who don't mind being surprised by their monthly flavors.
Gourmet Gift Baskets
If you're seeking a popcorn of the month club, Gourmet Gift Baskets might leave you wanting more. While they offer flexible scheduling options for deliveries, their conventional flavor lineup and concerning customer service issues make this a less-than-stellar choice for gifting. This service would work better for someone shopping for her- or himself and who doesn't mind playing it safe with flavors, but if you're looking to wow a popcorn enthusiast or need reliable gift delivery, you should explore other options. With delivery hiccups, quality concerns, and uninspiring flavors, Gourmet Gift Baskets is not terrible, but you can definitely do better.
The Popcorn Factory
If you're in the market for a monthly popcorn club, The Popcorn Factory probably isn't your best bet. While their creative flavors like Strawberry Sparkling Wine and Avocado Sea Salt sound intriguing, you'll likely be frustrated by the tiny portions (sometimes as little as 2.5 ounces), high shipping costs ($9.99 per delivery), and spotty customer service. Most popcorn enthusiasts will find better value and reliability elsewhere. Given the numerous issues with delivery, quality, and customer support, we can't recommend this subscription service.
Moose Munch
If you're tempted by having Moose Munch delivered to your door monthly, you might want to think twice. While Harry & David's popcorn subscription promises convenience and variety with two 10-oz bags of premium popcorn each month, the steep price tag and concerning quality issues make this a tough sell. Since being acquired by 1-800-Flowers, Harry & David's customer service has plummeted, and many customers report receiving stale or rancid popcorn with no resolution. Given the quality concerns, poor customer service, and high cost per ounce, we can't recommend this popcorn club.
Continued from above...
If you like surprises, many popcorn of the month clubs keep things fun by not telling you which flavors are coming. That way, each box feels like a little gift to yourself-or to someone else if you're giving it as a present. One month you might get a spicy cheddar blend, and the next, a sweet popcorn drizzled with white chocolate and raspberry. It's a great way to keep snack time interesting.
These clubs also give you the chance to support small, local businesses. Many popcorn subscriptions feature family-owned shops that make their popcorn in small batches using high-quality, non-GMO corn. This means the popcorn is fresher and often tastier than what you'd find at the store. Plus, it lets you try fun and unique flavors you wouldn't normally find in big-name brands.
The format of these clubs varies significantly as well. While most send ready-to-eat popcorn in sealed bags to maintain freshness, some focus on providing premium kernels and seasoning kits for home popping adventures. Some services specialize in classic flavors done perfectly, while others push the envelope with innovative combinations like "Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel” or the extremely spicy "Hellfire & Damnation”.
With so many great options out there, it can be hard to know which popcorn of the month club to choose. Here are a few things to keep in mind when deciding on your perfect match:
- Customer reviews and company history. How long has the company been operating? What do recent customers say about their experiences? Are there any concerning patterns in negative reviews? What level of transparency does the company maintain about their operations? Look for companies with 3+ years in business and consistently positive reviews across multiple platforms.
- Value and quantity. What's the true cost per serving? How do premium flavors impact the pricing? Is there enough popcorn to be shared with your household, or will you have to hide it away to keep for yourself? You might want to look for a service that deals in gallons of popcorn rather than ounces.
- Gift-giving flexibility. Can you personalize the gift experience? Can you pick the shipping date? How much control does the recipient have over their subscription? Choose popcorn subscription services offering gift messages, customizable delivery schedules, and recipient preference controls.
- Customization options. How flexible is the subscription? What happens if you need to pause deliveries? Can you skip any flavors you know you won't like? If you're a picky eater, choose a service that will allow you to see what flavors are coming up next.
Ready to find your perfect popcorn subscription? Top Consumer Reviews has carefully researched and analyzed the best popcorn of the month clubs available today, looking at everything from company history and customer feedback to serving sizes and shipping policies. Whether you're planning movie nights with the family or searching for a unique gift that keeps on giving, our detailed guide will help you choose a subscription that fits your snacking preferences and your wallet.
Popcorn Club FAQ
Compare Popcorn Clubs
Select any 2 Popcorn Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Popcorn Club News
Related Popcorn Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Popcorn Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
