Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Great American Popcorn Company Review

Wednesday, July 17th

2024 Popcorn Club Reviews

Great American Popcorn Company Review 3.5 Star Rating

Great American Popcorn Company

3.5 Star Rating
  • Two bags (8-10 cups each) in two flavors each month
  • Priced at $21.95/month plus $7 in shipping per delivery
  • Family owned-and operated since 1994
  • "A+" rated by the BBB
  • 100% satisfaction guaranteed

The Great American Popcorn Company's story began in 1994 when David and Catherine Lewis decided to make Galena, Illinois their permanent home. Leaving behind their corporate careers in Chicago, they embraced a new way of life centered around family and exceptional customer service. Growing up in the store, their children witnessed firsthand the personalized treatment each customer received. Now, with their own children and a lifelong passion for popcorn, they continue to prioritize the same level of customer care that their parents instilled in their family business.

Popcorn artisans

Using the finest non-GMO popcorn sourced exclusively from American family farms, the Great American Popcorn Company creates simply delicious treats. Their gourmet popcorn is handcrafted in small batches daily, ensuring the highest quality. Whether visiting their storefront in scenic Galena or shopping online, customers can be confident that every batch is made with their satisfaction in mind. The Great American Popcorn Company takes pride in delivering a taste that sets them apart.

You'll get two flavors selected for you each month

So, how about their Flavor of the Month Club? You'll get two bags of their top flavors - pre-selected for all club members - in each delivery. While they don't show you a preview of what's to come or a list of what's been in earlier shipments, it's easy to see what's slated to ship for the current month right on the club page. You can also browse Great American Popcorn Company's popcorn flavors in their a la carte shop, to get an idea of what they typically have available in their profile of more than 80 different varieties. Some of the names are really funny, like the spicy Hellfire & Damnation, Texas Tornado, or Pickle Me Ranch.

Decent pricing

In setting up your popcorn club here, you can choose from several plans. Go monthly or every other month until you feel like canceling, or opt for a 3-, 6-, or 12-month package that won't renew at the end of the term. No matter which one you choose, you'll pay $21.95 per month (and they don't really disclose the additional per-delivery shipping fees of $7 until you add the plan to your online cart). That's not unreasonable pricing, given that you're getting two bags with 8-10 cups of popcorn in each one.

Best Popcorn Clubs

Reliable popcorn company

Reputation certainly isn't a problem for Great American Popcorn Company either. Though there aren't very many reviews specific to the monthly deliveries, everyone who tries this store's treats can't say enough about how good the popcorn is. And, since they offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee with a refund or replacement and zero hassle, there's nothing to worry about with this popcorn club. The Better Business Bureau agrees, giving the company a perfect "A+" rating.

Could give the customer a little more choice

Our biggest disappointment with the Great American Popcorn Company's club is that there's not as much control given to the customer. They don't let you specify sweet vs. savory, show you a calendar of previous or upcoming flavor combinations, or give you the opportunity to skip a month if they're sending something you know you're likely to dislike. None of that is a huge downside, but when compared with rival popcorn clubs, you'll often find some combination of those features that makes it easier to really love what you get.

Still a good choice

In spite of the lack of club options, we still think this is a good choice for popcorn lovers who are foodies too. The flavors here are delicious and unique, and you won't be disappointed in the quality of popcorn that you get.

Which Popcorn Club is the Best?

If you or someone dear to you is a fan of that delightful white and fluffy snack known as popcorn, what could be better than having it conveniently delivered to the house or office on a regular basis? Popcorn Clubs take this beloved treat to a whole new level of deliciousness, with cheddar and caramel as just the tip of the flavor iceberg.

By exploring different monthly subscription plans, you'll soon discover that skilled artisans are crafting extraordinary flavors such as Wild Onion, Sriracha, and even seasonal tastes like Sweet Summer Watermelon and Pumpkin Spice. Most plans allow you to choose the number of deliveries you'd like to purchase, ranging from a single month to a full year of monthly surprises. Some even offer the option to stagger the shipments, ensuring that freshly-crafted popcorn arrives once per season.

The Best Popcorn Clubs Compare Popcorn Clubs Compare Popcorn Club Reviews What are the best Popcorn Clubs Best Popcorn Club Reviews

Popcorn Club FAQ

This will differ with each service but is completely up to you! Most subscriptions are offered on a 3, 6, or 12 month basis. Some offer a month-to-month or seasonal subscription as well. Your subscription will just depend on what you choose.
Is popcorn delicious? Yes, these services send fresh popcorn in each shipment. The packages are sent through food-safe mail deliveries to ensure you're getting top-quality popcorn. The only thing to worry about is what to do when you run out!
The cost of a popcorn subscription will depend on a lot of factors. The first factor in cost is the length of your subscription. You also need to consider the size of the package, different services allow you to choose how much popcorn is sent. The least expensive starts at $9.99, with prices going up from there.
They make great gifts! A popcorn club offers exciting new things to try every month! The only thing to worry about with a Popcorn Club gift, is if the person has allergies.
Chocolate is a great year-round gift, and the best chocolate clubs take care to package each shipment with the weather and destination in mind. Ice packs and insulation may be included, to help keep the chocolate in perfect condition while en route.
This is something very important to consider with any food membership. Make sure you read the ingredients of every package before you eat anything. You can also message the subscription service you choose, and ask them if they offer any special packages.
There is a lot of variety in these subscriptions! Each month offers at least one new flavor to try, while some offer even more. With subscriptions that have many options, you'll have a choice of which flavors you want for that month. Other services have a flavor pre-picked for each month, so you can choose when to start.
Each subscription length is different. Most Popcorn Club subscriptions have a definitive end, most being 3, 6, or 12 months. A few offer month-to-month subscriptions that you can just stop when you want. There are also seasonal subscriptions, where you get one package every 3 months.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Let's face it, the popcorn you get at the movie theater is often overly salty, drowning in artificial butter, and loses its appeal after sitting in a bucket all day. And as for the options available at your local supermarket, chances are they have been languishing on the shelf for so long that they can hardly be considered fresh. Know what we mean?

Popcorn clubs, on the other hand, often prioritize sourcing high-quality ingredients and ensuring the freshness of their products. Subscribers can rely on receiving popcorn that is carefully prepared, maintaining its optimal taste and texture. The emphasis on quality assurance enhances the overall snacking enjoyment.

When it comes to gift-giving, Popcorn Clubs offer a fantastic opportunity to impress your lucky recipient. Opening each package from the monthly delivery brings an element of surprise and anticipation. Discovering new flavors or special edition popcorn adds a delightful sense of adventure to a snacking routine. The best clubs also allow recipients to preview what's in store for their upcoming deliveries, enabling them to skip a month if a particular flavor isn't to their liking or if they will be away.

Naturally, not all Popcorn Clubs are created equal, so it's wise to conduct a little research before committing to a monthly subscription. Want some guidance on selecting the right one for you? Here's a helpful list of criteria to consider in order to find the perfect Popcorn Club for yourself or the lucky person you're gifting it to:

  • Quantity. How much popcorn is included in each delivery? Are you satisfied with a few handfuls or do you prefer a generous three-gallon portion?
  • Flavor Variety. Are you looking for multiple flavors in each package? Are you more inclined towards conventional or adventurous flavors? Can you specify your taste preferences or swap flavors if you're not fond of a particular one?
  • Price. What is the cost of the popcorn club? Does it include shipping fees? Is the subscription offering good value for your money?
  • Reputation. What do people say about the club? Are there positive reviews regarding their customer service? Is there a reliable refund policy or satisfaction guarantee in case your popcorn arrives in poor condition or if you simply don't enjoy a certain flavor?

By reviewing and ranking today's most popular options, Top Consumer Reviews has made it easy to find a popcorn club that suits your preferences and offers a delightful experience. We wish you happy snacking once you've chosen a club to deliver popcorn goodness straight to your doorstep!

Compare Popcorn Clubs

Select any 2 Popcorn Clubs to compare them head to head

  • Amazing Clubs
  • Snacktime Express
  • Shirley's
  • Al's Popcorn
  • Fisher's Popcorn
  • Moose Munch
  • Great American Popcorn Company
  • Poppington's
  • Gourmet Gift Baskets
  • The Popcorn Factory
Amazing Clubs vs Snacktime Express Amazing Clubs vs Shirley's Amazing Clubs vs Al's Popcorn Amazing Clubs vs Fisher's Popcorn Amazing Clubs vs Moose Munch Amazing Clubs vs Great American Popcorn Company Amazing Clubs vs Poppington's Amazing Clubs vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Amazing Clubs vs The Popcorn Factory Snacktime Express vs Shirley's Snacktime Express vs Al's Popcorn Snacktime Express vs Fisher's Popcorn Snacktime Express vs Moose Munch Snacktime Express vs Great American Popcorn Company Snacktime Express vs Poppington's Snacktime Express vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Snacktime Express vs The Popcorn Factory Shirley's vs Al's Popcorn Shirley's vs Fisher's Popcorn Shirley's vs Moose Munch Shirley's vs Great American Popcorn Company Shirley's vs Poppington's Shirley's vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Shirley's vs The Popcorn Factory Al's Popcorn vs Fisher's Popcorn Al's Popcorn vs Moose Munch Al's Popcorn vs Great American Popcorn Company Al's Popcorn vs Poppington's Al's Popcorn vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Al's Popcorn vs The Popcorn Factory Fisher's Popcorn vs Moose Munch Fisher's Popcorn vs Great American Popcorn Company Fisher's Popcorn vs Poppington's Fisher's Popcorn vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Fisher's Popcorn vs The Popcorn Factory Moose Munch vs Great American Popcorn Company Moose Munch vs Poppington's Moose Munch vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Moose Munch vs The Popcorn Factory Great American Popcorn Company vs Poppington's Great American Popcorn Company vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Great American Popcorn Company vs The Popcorn Factory Poppington's vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Poppington's vs The Popcorn Factory Gourmet Gift Baskets vs The Popcorn Factory
Compare the Best Popcorn Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Popcorn Clubs
The Best Reviews of Popcorn Clubs