What is the Best Popcorn of the Month Club? Have you ever found yourself craving the perfect snack that combines comfort, nostalgia, and gourmet flavors? Popcorn of the month clubs offer a delightful solution for snack enthusiasts, movie buffs, and anyone looking to explore unique popcorn varieties from the comfort of their home. These subscription services can solve several common dilemmas: the challenge of finding interesting snacks for family movie nights, the quest for thoughtful recurring gifts, or simply the desire to discover popcorn flavors beyond what's available at local stores.
Great
If you order from Shirley's, you'll be getting a taste of small-town charm straight from Bluffton, Ohio, where Shirley's Gourmet Popcorn got its start at the local Shannon Theatre. What began as their famously delicious movie popcorn (that customers kept bringing tubs back for) has grown into a beloved brand, named after their warmest, friendliest employee - Shirley herself, who spent 25 years making moviegoers feel like family. Today, you'll get that same hometown feeling delivered right to your door, with two unique, freshly-made flavors in every box.
How the subscription works and what you'll get
You're in for a treat with Shirley's Popcorn of the Month Club. Each month, you'll receive two bags of gourmet popcorn, containing 10-12 cups each, delivered right to your door. You'll always get one seasonal flavor of the month plus one of Shirley's signature classics - and they never repeat the same combination twice. Plus, each shipment comes with a personal touch: a handwritten note that makes every delivery feel like a gift from Shirley herself.
Flavors that'll make your taste buds dance
Looking through Shirley's flavor calendar is like browsing a gourmet food magazine. You might find yourself savoring Cheddar Pretzel Ale in January, cooling off with Frosted Raspberry Lemonade in July, or getting festive with White & Dark Chocolate Peppermint in December. They've got quite a range too - from indulgent sweet treats like Birthday Cake to savory adventures like Everything Bagel and Spiked Garlic Parmesan. Some other flavors you might encounter include:
Free shipping
While a few other popcorn subscriptions have raised their prices over the years, Shirley's have remained the same. You can start with a 3-month subscription at $120 (breaks down to $40/month, or $20 per bag), upgrade to 6 months for $230, or go all-in with a full year at $400. Shipping is completely free, too.
Gifting customization is limited
You'll want to place your order by the 8th of the month to get your popcorn around the 10th. Planning to give it as a gift? Your options are fairly basic, but it appears that you can check a box during checkout to add a personalized message. Just remember that all orders get packaged on the 10th, so if you miss that 8th of the month cutoff, your first delivery will roll over to the following month. If you need a specific delivery date, there's a good chance the helpful customer service team can work with you - just mention it in your special instructions or reach out directly.
Generous 30-day refund policy
If you're not happy with your popcorn (though we doubt that'll happen), you have 30 days to return it in its original packaging, along with your receipt. For returns, just send your items back to Shirley's shop in Bluffton, Ohio - but keep in mind you'll need to cover the shipping costs. Missing something from your order? No worries. Just give them a call or send an email with your order details. And if anything arrives damaged or isn't quite right, they've got your back with their 100% satisfaction guarantee - Shirley's will replace your popcorn free of charge.
Rave reviews
You can order with confidence knowing that Shirley's has earned an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau. Their customers rave about both the popcorn and service - from UK visitors making special trips just for their birthday cake flavor, to couples playfully debating whether spicy cheese or polar pop mix is better. What really stands out is their exceptional customer service. When one customer had some hiccups with multiple orders, the team went above and beyond - Pete quickly fixed billing issues, Amy made personal calls to sort out shipping concerns, and Jen jumped in to help with rewards questions. Shirley's truly treats you like family, making sure every detail is perfect.
Highly recommended
If you want to support a family business and get amazing popcorn delivered to your door, or if you enjoy trying bold and unique flavors without breaking the bank, we think you'll love what Shirley's Popcorn Club has to offer. Their outstanding customer service makes you feel like part of the family, which is why we think you should definitely check them out for your popcorn of the month subscription.
Continued from above...
Have you ever found yourself craving the perfect snack that combines comfort, nostalgia, and gourmet flavors? Popcorn of the month clubs offer a delightful solution for snack enthusiasts, movie buffs, and anyone looking to explore unique popcorn varieties from the comfort of their home. These subscription services can solve several common dilemmas: the challenge of finding interesting snacks for family movie nights, the quest for thoughtful recurring gifts, or simply the desire to discover popcorn flavors beyond what's available at local stores.
When exploring popcorn subscription options, you'll find quite a range of services. Some clubs are run by multi-generation family businesses that have been perfecting their recipes for decades - imagine receiving monthly deliveries of caramel corn made from a cherished 1940s recipe that made a small-town shop famous. Others are part of larger subscription box companies that offer everything from coffee to cookies, with popcorn being just one of their many offerings (but often sourced from cute little mom-and-pop shops too).
If you like surprises, many popcorn of the month clubs keep things fun by not telling you which flavors are coming. That way, each box feels like a little gift to yourself-or to someone else if you're giving it as a present. One month you might get a spicy cheddar blend, and the next, a sweet popcorn drizzled with white chocolate and raspberry. It's a great way to keep snack time interesting.
These clubs also give you the chance to support small, local businesses. Many popcorn subscriptions feature family-owned shops that make their popcorn in small batches using high-quality, non-GMO corn. This means the popcorn is fresher and often tastier than what you'd find at the store. Plus, it lets you try fun and unique flavors you wouldn't normally find in big-name brands.
The format of these clubs varies significantly as well. While most send ready-to-eat popcorn in sealed bags to maintain freshness, some focus on providing premium kernels and seasoning kits for home popping adventures. Some services specialize in classic flavors done perfectly, while others push the envelope with innovative combinations like "Mesquite Smoked Mezcal Caramel" or the extremely spicy "Hellfire & Damnation".
With so many great options out there, it can be hard to know which popcorn of the month club to choose. Here are a few things to keep in mind when deciding on your perfect match:
Ready to find your perfect popcorn subscription? Top Consumer Reviews has carefully researched and analyzed the best popcorn of the month clubs available today, looking at everything from company history and customer feedback to serving sizes and shipping policies. Whether you're planning movie nights with the family or searching for a unique gift that keeps on giving, our detailed guide will help you choose a subscription that fits your snacking preferences and your wallet.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
