Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Popular Diets

What's the Best Popular Diet?

If you're looking to lose weight, feel healthier, or make eating well a little easier, you're not alone. With so many popular diets available today, it can be tough to know where to start. Whether you want to shed a few pounds, maintain your current weight, or manage a health condition, a diet program can offer the structure and support you need to reach your goals.

If you're tired of guessing what to eat, struggling with portion sizes, or just need extra motivation, the right plan can make a world of difference. Popular diets come in many forms, and the best one for you depends on your lifestyle and how much effort you want to put in. Some services deliver fully-prepared meals straight to your door - just heat and enjoy. Others provide fresh ingredients and easy-to-follow recipes, taking the guesswork out of meal planning.

Thursday, April 17th

2025 Popular Diet Reviews

Weight Watchers Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Weight Watchers

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Weight Watchers stands out as the most flexible, science-backed option for sustainable weight loss. You'll love how their SmartPoints system lets you eat any food you want while gently steering you toward healthier choices - no more feeling guilty about enjoying pizza or ice cream in moderation. Their proven four-pillar approach helps you build lasting habits around food, activity, mindset, and sleep, with new features like dietitian support and camera-based meal tracking making the journey even easier. We especially recommend Weight Watchers if you're tired of restrictive diets and want a practical, personalized approach that fits your real life while delivering real results.

Mayo Clinic Diet Review 4.5 Star Rating

Mayo Clinic Diet

4.5 Star Rating

The Mayo Clinic Diet stands out as one of the most scientifically-backed weight loss programs you'll find, offering a refreshing focus on sustainable habits rather than strict calorie counting. You'll get access to eight different meal plans (including Mediterranean, Higher Protein, and Healthy Keto options), along with helpful tools like a food tracking app, barcode scanner, and grocery lists to make healthy eating more manageable. What really sets this program apart is the included access to Mayo Clinic experts through group coaching sessions, plus a supportive community to keep you motivated. This program is ideal for anyone looking for a doctor-approved, flexible approach to weight loss that teaches lasting healthy habits - especially if you appreciate having expert guidance without strict rules or required product purchases.

Noom Review 4 Star Rating

Noom

4 Star Rating

Don't know how to lose weight? Noom guides you through it by teaching you the psychology behind your eating habits. You'll get daily lessons, food tracking tools, and some basic coaching to help you build better habits that actually stick. Their color-coded food system makes it super easy to make good nutrition choices (though if you're already a nutrition pro, you might find it a bit too basic). Yes, $70 a month is pretty pricey, and the basic coaching isn't anything special, but if you're just starting your weight loss journey and want someone to guide you through the process, Noom's educational content and flexible eating guidelines might be exactly what you need. Bottom line: it's great for beginners who want structure and support, but maybe look elsewhere if you're already savvy about nutrition or want to track detailed macros.

Atkins Review 4 Star Rating

Atkins

4 Star Rating

If you're looking for a science-backed approach to weight loss that doesn't involve counting calories, Atkins might be your answer. You'll learn to manage carbs strategically while enjoying plenty of satisfying proteins and healthy fats, with the flexibility to choose from three different plans based on your goals. Their comprehensive free tools, including meal plans and a highly-rated iOS app, make it easy to track your progress and stay motivated. We give Atkins a high rating and especially recommend it for people who struggle with carb cravings or blood sugar management, as well as those who prefer clear, structured guidelines for their weight loss journey.

Whole 30 Review 4 Star Rating

Whole 30

4 Star Rating

If you're looking to identify foods that might be triggering health issues like inflammation or digestive problems, Real Plans' Whole30 meal planning app takes the guesswork out of this strict 30-day elimination diet. Through the app, you'll get expert-designed meal plans, smart shopping lists with Instacart integration, and detailed prep timelines - all customizable to your dietary needs and family size. $20 a month is a very reasonable price for an app that can actually save you money by preventing food waste and helping you stick to your shopping list. However, this isn't a weight loss program - it's a highly restrictive diet that requires completely avoiding restaurants and processed foods, which may be too challenging for some people. Given its excellent execution of a very specific purpose, we still rate it with a high score.

Keto Diet Review 3.5 Star Rating

Keto Diet

3.5 Star Rating

If you're looking to start your keto diet with pre-made meals, Sunbasket offers a solid but pricey option with their carb-conscious menu. You'll get fresh, ethically-sourced ingredients and flexible meal prep options ranging from 4-minute microwaveable dishes to 30-minute DIY meal kits, though you'll need to plan your own breakfasts and track macros separately. While the service might be too expensive for long-term use (up to $12 per serving after initial discounts), it's an excellent way to learn keto cooking and jumpstart your low-carb journey.

Mediterranean Diet Review 3.5 Star Rating

Mediterranean Diet

3.5 Star Rating

Looking to lose weight while enjoying delicious Mediterranean cuisine? Sunbasket 's meal delivery service brings restaurant-quality, Mediterranean-inspired dishes right to your door. You'll get to choose from 7-9 health-conscious options weekly, featuring organic produce and responsibly-sourced proteins in perfectly portioned meals ranging from 400-800 calories. Whether you prefer to cook from their pre-portioned ingredients or heat up their ready-made meals, you'll enjoy the convenience of having nutritious, Mediterranean staples like fresh vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins delivered to your doorstep. This service is ideal for busy health-conscious individuals who want to lose weight naturally through portion-controlled, nutrient-dense meals without sacrificing flavor or spending hours in the kitchen.

Gluten-Free Diet Review 3 Star Rating

Gluten-Free Diet

3 Star Rating

Looking to explore gluten-free eating without the hassle of meal planning? Sunbasket offers a convenient solution with their flexible meal delivery service, featuring organic ingredients and diverse menu options. You'll get to choose between ready-to-heat meals and cooking kits that cater to various skill levels and time constraints. While the service comes at a premium price point, it could be a solid introduction to gluten-free cooking and eating. For weight loss specifically, we give it a middle-of-the-road rating - it's not designed as a weight loss program, but you can make it work by carefully selecting lower-calorie options and monitoring your portions.

Paleo Diet Review 3 Star Rating

Paleo Diet

3 Star Rating

If you're looking to embrace a clean eating lifestyle that focuses on whole, unprocessed foods, Sunbasket's Paleo meal delivery service might be your answer. You'll receive restaurant-quality dinners that align perfectly with paleo principles - meaning lots of meat, seafood, vegetables, and healthy fats, but no grains, legumes, or dairy. This service is best suited for paleo devotees and active individuals who need nutrient-dense meals and aren't primarily focused on weight loss. If you're looking to shed pounds, Paleo probably isn't the best choice.

Nutrisystem Review 2.5 Star Rating

Nutrisystem

2.5 Star Rating

If you're looking for a hands-off approach to weight loss and don't mind eating pre-packaged meals, Nutrisystem might seem appealing at first glance. The program handles all your meal planning and portion control, delivering shelf-stable and frozen meals right to your door. However, with poor food quality, confusing pricing tiers, and questionable business practices like hidden fees and strict cancellation policies, this service is hard to recommend to anyone - even those who prioritize convenience over taste. You'll likely find better value and satisfaction from buying frozen diet meals at your local grocery store or trying a more transparent meal delivery service.

Jenny Craig Review 2 Star Rating

Jenny Craig

2 Star Rating

You might remember Jenny Craig from their glory days of in-person weight loss centers, but the company's 2023 bankruptcy led to a complete overhaul that hasn't done them any favors. Now operating as an online-only service under Nutrisystem's parent company, they offer virtual coaching paired with frozen meal delivery - but the food quality is consistently rated as poor, and their pricing structure is intentionally confusing. You'd be better off avoiding Jenny Craig if you care about taste, transparency, or reliable customer service. With numerous complaints about undelivered orders, zero refund flexibility, and sub-par food quality, we give this service a low score and recommend looking elsewhere for your weight loss journey.

Lumen Review 2 Star Rating

Lumen

2 Star Rating

Lumen is a pricey breath analysis device that claims to measure your metabolism and tell you whether you're burning fat or carbs, but the science behind it is questionable at best. You'll need to shell out hundreds for the device plus a monthly subscription fee, and the company's "money-back guarantee" is essentially worthless since you can't return an opened device. While it might appeal to data-obsessed fitness enthusiasts who already track their nutrition religiously, it's definitely not suitable if you have asthma, diabetes, or various other health conditions. Save your money (and your breath) - this expensive gadget is more likely to collect dust than help you reach your health goals, earning it a "not recommended" rating from us.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Do you prefer a more flexible approach? There are app-based programs that help you track your food, offer personalized coaching, and focus on building long-term healthy habits. And if you find motivation in a community, some plans include virtual or in-person support groups to keep you accountable. Each type of diet has its own perks, so the key is finding the one that fits your needs and lifestyle.

Gluten-free diets are essential for people with celiac disease or gluten sensitivities and focus on eliminating wheat, barley, and rye. Keto diets emphasize high fat, moderate protein, and very low carbs, aiming to put your body into a fat-burning state called ketosis. Paleo diets encourage eating whole, unprocessed foods - like our ancient ancestors - including meats, fish, vegetables, and nuts, while avoiding grains, legumes, and dairy.

The Mediterranean diet, on the other hand, is rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and healthy fats like olive oil, with moderate amounts of fish and poultry. Each of these diets has unique health benefits, but if you also want to lose weight, you can combine any one of these popular diets with an app that includes calorie and macro-counting tools.

The variety of popular diets can feel overwhelming, but focusing on a few essential factors can make your decision easier. Here are some things to keep in mind when choosing a diet program:

  • Convenience. How much time do you want to spend on food? If you're always on the go, fully-prepared meals might be your best bet. If you enjoy cooking but need a little help, ingredient delivery kits offer a middle ground.
  • Flexibility. Do you prefer a structured plan or something more adaptable? Some popular diets follow strict guidelines, while others allow room for indulgences. If you have specific dietary needs, look for a program that offers customization.
  • Support system. Do you work better with a little encouragement? Some diets offer one-on-one coaching or community support, while others focus on self-guided tools. Choose the level of support that works best for you.
  • Cost. Popular diets range from budget-friendly apps to premium meal delivery services. Be sure to choose a program that fits your financial comfort zone while still offering the tools you need to succeed.
  • Sustainability. Can you stick with this plan for the long haul? While rapid weight loss might be tempting, the best results come from programs you can maintain over time. Look for diets that promote balanced, sustainable eating habits.

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best popular diets available today. With so many options to choose from, finding the right one can be confusing - but our reviews are here to help you make an informed decision. We hope our insights guide you to the best diet for your lifestyle, goals, and budget.

The Best Popular Diets Compare Popular Diets Compare Popular Diet Reviews What are the best Popular Diets Best Popular Diet Reviews

Popular Diet FAQ

Some of the most popular diet plans have been around for a while, including WW (formerly known as Weight Watchers), Nutrisystem and Atkins. Others are newer to the industry, like Noom and keto.
The best place to start is by being completely honest with yourself. What has worked in the past, and what hasn't? Do you need to have everything spelled out for you meal-by-meal, or would you find that stifling and likely to make you quit? Whichever diet you choose, the "best” one will always be the one you can stick to!
Absolutely! Many people feel the same way and want everything to be done for them, more or less. Nothing wrong with that! You'll probably want to look for a diet like Nutrisystem, South Beach Diet, or Medifast: you will buy ready-made meals and snacks and use them as the foundation of your nutrition, at least for the first few stages of your progress.
Not at all. There are many popular diets that teach you how and what to eat, but you get to do the shopping, preparing and cooking yourself. Being on a diet doesn't mean you have to eat ready-made, heavily processed foods!
Paleo and keto are two very popular diets right now. Paleo is sometimes known as "the caveman diet” and prioritizes eating the kinds of foods that hunter-gatherers did: meat and fish, eggs, nuts and seeds, fruits and vegetables (except for corn), some fats and oils, and natural sweeteners. Keto aims to help your body burn primarily fat as its energy source and usually allows for less than 5% of your daily calories to come from carbohydrates. Both diets place strong emphasis on whole foods and healthy fats, eliminate legumes and grains, and they don't allow refined sugars. The big difference: keto allows dairy and soy but cuts out most carbs, while paleo encourages fruits and vegetables but doesn't include soy or most dairy products.
That depends on which diet you choose. Most experts say that tracking what you eat is the best way to make sure you know how much you're eating; people tend to overeat by a lot and not realize it. But, if you don't want to track your food, consider following one of the popular diets that uses ready-made meals: all the work is done for you!
Many popular diets will have a quick initial drop in weight: if you're drastically changing your eating habits, reducing your caloric intake, and exercising more, you could see a fast drop of 5-10 pounds in the first week. But, before you get too excited, understand that much of that weight loss will be water, not fat. If you want to lose weight and, more importantly, keep it off, slow and steady really does win the race. A healthy rate of weight loss after the initial "whoosh” downward is usually considered to be 1-2 pounds per week.
Not necessarily. If you choose a diet plan that doesn't include the food - in other words, you're getting a nutritional plan, coaching or other support, and maybe an app for tracking your food, water, and exercise - expect your costs to be $50-$100 per month. If you opt for a diet that includes the food, like South Beach or Nutrisystem, you'll pay around $300 for 4 weeks of food. (But remember how much you WON'T be spending at the grocery store or bringing home takeout!)

Compare Popular Diets

Select any 2 Popular Diets to compare them head to head

best-popular-diets
  • Weight Watchers
  • Mayo Clinic Diet
  • Noom
  • Atkins
  • Whole 30
  • Keto Diet
  • Mediterranean Diet
  • Gluten-Free Diet
  • Paleo Diet
  • Nutrisystem
  • Jenny Craig
  • Lumen
Weight Watchers vs Mayo Clinic Diet Weight Watchers vs Noom Weight Watchers vs Atkins Weight Watchers vs Whole 30 Weight Watchers vs Keto Diet Weight Watchers vs Mediterranean Diet Weight Watchers vs Gluten-Free Diet Weight Watchers vs Paleo Diet Weight Watchers vs Nutrisystem Weight Watchers vs Jenny Craig Weight Watchers vs Lumen Mayo Clinic Diet vs Noom Mayo Clinic Diet vs Atkins Mayo Clinic Diet vs Whole 30 Mayo Clinic Diet vs Keto Diet Mayo Clinic Diet vs Mediterranean Diet Mayo Clinic Diet vs Gluten-Free Diet Mayo Clinic Diet vs Paleo Diet Mayo Clinic Diet vs Nutrisystem Mayo Clinic Diet vs Jenny Craig Mayo Clinic Diet vs Lumen Noom vs Atkins Noom vs Whole 30 Noom vs Keto Diet Noom vs Mediterranean Diet Noom vs Gluten-Free Diet Noom vs Paleo Diet Noom vs Nutrisystem Noom vs Jenny Craig Noom vs Lumen Atkins vs Whole 30 Atkins vs Keto Diet Atkins vs Mediterranean Diet Atkins vs Gluten-Free Diet Atkins vs Paleo Diet Atkins vs Nutrisystem Atkins vs Jenny Craig Atkins vs Lumen Whole 30 vs Keto Diet Whole 30 vs Mediterranean Diet Whole 30 vs Gluten-Free Diet Whole 30 vs Paleo Diet Whole 30 vs Nutrisystem Whole 30 vs Jenny Craig Whole 30 vs Lumen Keto Diet vs Mediterranean Diet Keto Diet vs Gluten-Free Diet Keto Diet vs Paleo Diet Keto Diet vs Nutrisystem Keto Diet vs Jenny Craig Keto Diet vs Lumen Mediterranean Diet vs Gluten-Free Diet Mediterranean Diet vs Paleo Diet Mediterranean Diet vs Nutrisystem Mediterranean Diet vs Jenny Craig Mediterranean Diet vs Lumen Gluten-Free Diet vs Paleo Diet Gluten-Free Diet vs Nutrisystem Gluten-Free Diet vs Jenny Craig Gluten-Free Diet vs Lumen Paleo Diet vs Nutrisystem Paleo Diet vs Jenny Craig Paleo Diet vs Lumen Nutrisystem vs Jenny Craig Nutrisystem vs Lumen Jenny Craig vs Lumen
Compare the Best Popular Diets
- VS -
Review the Best Popular Diets
See the Best Popular Diet
The Best Reviews of Popular Diets