Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Martha & Marley Spoon Review

Sunday, May 16th

2021 Prepared Meal Company Reviews

Martha & Marley Spoon Review 2.5 Star Rating

Martha & Marley Spoon

2.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Per-serving cost of $8.20 to $12
  • Free shipping

Award-winning recipes and fresh ingredients equal a delicious meal, according to Martha & Marley Spoon. This Prepared Meals service also says that they can help you do that for less than you'd usually pay at the supermarket. But, is that actually the case?

Starting with a database of more than 18,000 Martha Stewart recipes, they're off to a good start. All of their plans include pre-portioned ingredients, including fresh herbs and vegetables, and recipes that can be completed 6 steps at the most.

For your plan, you'll have some choices to make. First, are you serving dinner to 2 people or 3-4? Next, would you like to receive 2, 3, or 4 recipes and ingredients each week? Finally, do you prefer to receive meals that are prepared with strictly vegetarian options?

Once you've made those selections, you'll choose from 10 options in the weekly menu, with entrees like Chili-Lime Shrimp, Warm Tortelloni and Bean Salad, or Steak and Almond Romesco. And, if you like to plan in advance, Martha & Marley Spoon makes their 10-recipe weekly menus available as far out as four weeks ahead of time.

Best Prepared Meal Companies

Your Prepared Meals will be delivered according to your geographic area;, in our region, we could choose between Monday and Tuesday. The company promises that your shipments will be usable for a minimum of 4 days after the delivery date; fish is the sole exception and should be cooked within 48 hours of delivery. You'll also need to have some pantry staples on hand, like sugar, salt, oil and eggs.

The moment of truth: does Martha & Marley spoon deliver what they advertise, especially in comparison with competitor providers of Prepared Meals? The answer is "not so much". We encountered so many complaints from customers who said that their orders came days after the promised delivery date - including ice packs that were completely melted, air temperature meats, and damaged shipping containers. The ideal response on the part of the business would be to offer a refund or replacement, or at minimum a store credit.

Unfortunately for them - and for you - there is no satisfaction guarantee or return policy to be found on the Martha & Marley Spoon site. Some customers said that they were offered a discount on a future order, but who'd order again from a company that dropped the ball so significantly the first time? It's good that their representatives were responsive to the complaints we found, but they'd do better to provide a solid, customer-friendly guarantee and return policy - like most of the competition already offer.

As much as we liked the idea of being able to cook like Martha Stewart, this Prepared Meals service just doesn't deliver. With few options to customize plans for dietary needs, late deliveries, and poor customer service policies, Martha & Marley Spoon will probably have you heading to the grocery store - or to a higher-ranked business in our review - for your meals.

Who Has the Best Prepared Meals?

How many times have you come home after a long day and stared blankly at your refrigerator or pantry, trying to figure out what to eat? Or stopped at the drive-thru for fast food because the thought of coming up with something for dinner was just too much?

You're not alone. For people who'd like the convenience of fast food with the benefits of home cooking, Prepared Meals are the answer. For every imaginable palate and preference, there's a prepared meal service that can help. Several of today's most popular services send you high-quality, often organic ingredients - including fresh produce like shallots and herbs - saving you the hassle of planning your meals and going to the store.

The Best Prepared Meal Companies Compare Prepared Meal Companies Compare Prepared Meal Company Reviews What are the best Prepared Meal Companies Best Prepared Meal Company Reviews

Prepared Meal Company FAQ

Prepared meal subscriptions are popular for the same reason your favorite fast food joint has a long line at the drive-through at dinnertime: they're convenient! Imagine never having to go grocery shopping again! However, most people who subscribe to a prepared meals plan use it to supplement their regular cooking rather than replacing every single meal (e.g. just for a few dinners a week, for all weekend meals, etc.).
That depends on the service you select. Some specialize in reheat-and-eat meals similar to a traditional TV dinner, while others deliver all of the ingredients you need to prepare the recipes they provide. There are also options for holiday meals, special occasion dinners, plus sides and desserts if you want to impress the crowd at your next office potluck - without having to do the work yourself!
You might be surprised. Most prepared meal services let you see customer comments on each dish - while some might not have been a huge favorite, most have hundreds (if not thousands) of rave reviews. And, if you're not known for being terribly creative or skilled in the kitchen, prepared meals can help you get out of your comfort zone and expand your taste horizons.
It will definitely cost more than if you bought all of the ingredients and prepared them yourself. But, the per-meal cost is typically less than what you'd spend in a restaurant. Expect a cost-per-serving somewhere between $8 and $12, depending on the plan you select.
Most services offering prepared meals have several options to choose from, either as an overall plan (like vegan or gluten-free) or on a meal-by-meal basis where you choose from a menu of meals for the month and can avoid any ingredients that you prefer not to have.
Two words: convenience and taste. Would you rather come home to another dinner of ramen or PB&J, or to a box of fresh ingredients that you can pull together into a restaurant-quality meal in just a few minutes? Subscribing to a prepared meals service can help you get out of your fast food rut, spare you the agony of yet another week of meal planning and grocery shopping, or just add some welcome variety to your eating habits.
Unfortunately, most prepared meal plans aren't going to be affordable if you're feeding a crowd every night. There are a few that cater to larger families (or that have more portions per delivery so that you can have leftovers, feed houseguests, etc.). These services even have some menus that are designed to be more kid-friendly.
That depends on the service. If your meals arrive in bad condition - rotten ingredients, thawed meals that were supposed to be frozen at the time of delivery, and so forth - you'll usually get a refund or a replacement. A few providers of prepared meals offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee with a refund or store credit, regardless of the reason.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

If you have a loved one that needs to start eating a special diet for diabetes or other medical issues, you can choose a prepared meals company that offers ready-to-reheat meals packaged similarly to a TV dinner and that have been carefully created by nutritionists specifically for that condition.

On the other hand, maybe you've been tasked with bringing a mind-blowing main course to an important company function, but your skills in the kitchen are limited to boiling water and burning toast. No problem: just choose a Prepared Meals service that focuses on gourmet-level, special occasion entrees like chicken cordon bleu or even surf-and-turf.

When deciding which company is a good fit for your delivery of Prepared Meals, you'll soon notice that there's a wide variety to choose from. How do you select the one that's best for you? Here are some things to consider as you look at each service:

  • Menu. What does the provider offer? Can you choose from many different plans, like Vegetarian or Mediterranean? If you're trying to meet a special dietary need, like gluten-free or keto-friendly, will there be options for you? Does the type of Prepared Meals they send - reheat-and-eat vs. some cooking required - work for your situation?
  • Price. What will it cost to get your Prepared Meals? Can you choose to buy specific entrees a la carte, or do you have to buy a package?
  • Amount of Food. If you have a large family, is there a plan that will satisfy everyone? Are the serving sizes enough to fill you up?
  • Customer Service and Reputation. What have other people said about the experience of buying Prepared Meals from this business? Are packages delivered on time, with ingredients that are still fresh and properly refrigerated? If not, does the company's customer service department respond appropriately with a refund or credit?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Prepared Meals Delivery Companies available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right company to deliver the kind of meals you want, directly to your doorstep!

Compare Prepared Meal Companies

Select any 2 Prepared Meal Companies to compare them head to head

best-prepared-meal-companies
  • Freshly
  • Bistro MD
  • Veestro
  • Home Chef
  • Sunbasket
  • Hello Fresh
  • Blue Apron
  • Diet To Go
  • Harry & David
  • Magic Kitchen
  • Personal Chef To Go
  • Martha & Marley Spoon
  • Plated
  • Home Bistro
Freshly vs Bistro MD Freshly vs Veestro Freshly vs Home Chef Freshly vs Sunbasket Freshly vs Hello Fresh Freshly vs Blue Apron Freshly vs Diet To Go Freshly vs Harry & David Freshly vs Magic Kitchen Freshly vs Personal Chef To Go Freshly vs Martha & Marley Spoon Freshly vs Plated Freshly vs Home Bistro Bistro MD vs Veestro Bistro MD vs Home Chef Bistro MD vs Sunbasket Bistro MD vs Hello Fresh Bistro MD vs Blue Apron Bistro MD vs Diet To Go Bistro MD vs Harry & David Bistro MD vs Magic Kitchen Bistro MD vs Personal Chef To Go Bistro MD vs Martha & Marley Spoon Bistro MD vs Plated Bistro MD vs Home Bistro Veestro vs Home Chef Veestro vs Sunbasket Veestro vs Hello Fresh Veestro vs Blue Apron Veestro vs Diet To Go Veestro vs Harry & David Veestro vs Magic Kitchen Veestro vs Personal Chef To Go Veestro vs Martha & Marley Spoon Veestro vs Plated Veestro vs Home Bistro Home Chef vs Sunbasket Home Chef vs Hello Fresh Home Chef vs Blue Apron Home Chef vs Diet To Go Home Chef vs Harry & David Home Chef vs Magic Kitchen Home Chef vs Personal Chef To Go Home Chef vs Martha & Marley Spoon Home Chef vs Plated Home Chef vs Home Bistro Sunbasket vs Hello Fresh Sunbasket vs Blue Apron Sunbasket vs Diet To Go Sunbasket vs Harry & David Sunbasket vs Magic Kitchen Sunbasket vs Personal Chef To Go Sunbasket vs Martha & Marley Spoon Sunbasket vs Plated Sunbasket vs Home Bistro Hello Fresh vs Blue Apron Hello Fresh vs Diet To Go Hello Fresh vs Harry & David Hello Fresh vs Magic Kitchen Hello Fresh vs Personal Chef To Go Hello Fresh vs Martha & Marley Spoon Hello Fresh vs Plated Hello Fresh vs Home Bistro Blue Apron vs Diet To Go Blue Apron vs Harry & David Blue Apron vs Magic Kitchen Blue Apron vs Personal Chef To Go Blue Apron vs Martha & Marley Spoon Blue Apron vs Plated Blue Apron vs Home Bistro Diet To Go vs Harry & David Diet To Go vs Magic Kitchen Diet To Go vs Personal Chef To Go Diet To Go vs Martha & Marley Spoon Diet To Go vs Plated Diet To Go vs Home Bistro Harry & David vs Magic Kitchen Harry & David vs Personal Chef To Go Harry & David vs Martha & Marley Spoon Harry & David vs Plated Harry & David vs Home Bistro Magic Kitchen vs Personal Chef To Go Magic Kitchen vs Martha & Marley Spoon Magic Kitchen vs Plated Magic Kitchen vs Home Bistro Personal Chef To Go vs Martha & Marley Spoon Personal Chef To Go vs Plated Personal Chef To Go vs Home Bistro Martha & Marley Spoon vs Plated Martha & Marley Spoon vs Home Bistro Plated vs Home Bistro
Compare the Best Prepared Meal Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Prepared Meal Companies
See the Best Prepared Meal Company
The Best Reviews of Prepared Meal Companies