Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Comp and Save Review

Saturday, October 16th

2021 Printer Ink Store Reviews

Comp and Save Review 4.5 Star Rating

Comp and Save

4.5 Star Rating

CompAndSave is the parent company behind our first-place Printer Ink company, Combo Ink. Unsurprisingly, you'll find the same low prices and great perks offered by both online stores.

In fact, at first glance on our comparison products, CompAndSave came in a little cheaper (list price) for one and the exact same for the other:

  • HP 902 XL: $38.80 for a combo set of high-yield replacement cartridges (1 black, 1 cyan, 1 magenta, 1 yellow). Individual cartridges are priced at $8.95 for color and $15.95 for black.
  • Samsung MLT-D115L: $44.99 for a compatible high-yield cartridge. 2-, 4-, and 10-packs available for extra savings.
Best Printer Ink Stores

However - when you factor in the coupons that were so easy to find on the Combo Ink site, CompAndSave comes in just a little behind: you'll have to dig to find any available discounts on this online store. (Hint: look at the Score Extra Savings banner at the top of the page; we found codes for 8% off orders of $45+ and a few others.) If you want to score similar savings to the Combo Ink page, look for a bar on the side of the page that says, "See More Savings" and you'll get the 15% off code when you sign up for their newsletter.

We also didn't find the "build your combo" feature on the CompAndSave store. You can still get discounts for ordering 3 or more products, though.

Other than those small details, almost everything is the same between the Combo Ink and CompAndSave stores. You can take advantage of a great return policy, free shipping on orders over $50, all from a store with a fantastic reputation: thousands of 4- and 5-star reviews and an "A+" from the BBB. Additionally, CompAndSave specifically references a Low Price Guarantee, so if you find your Printer Ink at a competitor site, chances are good that you can get it matched by this retailer.

Low prices, an extended return policy, and an ironclad reputation for customer service all make CompAndSave a worthy choice when buying Printer Ink for any brand of printer.

Where Can You Find the Best Printer Ink?

If you're looking for the best prices on toner and cartridges without sacrificing print quality, there are many online retailers that can deliver for your business or personal printing needs.

There are three main types of Printer Ink cartridges to consider: OEM, remanufactured, and compatible. OEM, or Original Equipment Manufacturer, cartridges are what you find in most office supply stores and big-box retailers. These products come directly from the brand, like HP or Canon, and are your most expensive option.

The Best Printer Ink Stores Compare Printer Ink Stores Compare Printer Ink Store Reviews What are the best Printer Ink Stores Best Printer Ink Store Reviews

Printer Ink Store FAQ

That's an easy one: do you like to save money? Who doesn't! Buying your printer ink through reputable online retailers will often save you quite a lot over what you'd pay at a local office supply store or even a big-box warehouse retailer.
The selection online is much broader than what you'll find at a brick-and-mortar store. Plus, you'll usually be able to choose among OEM, remanufactured and compatible options. So yes, chances are very good that you'll have no trouble finding the cartridges you need for your specific printer.
OEM stands for Original Equipment Manufacturer, which means that they are the ones made by the company itself (i.e. HP, Lexmark, etc.). Remanufactured cartridges are usually originals that have been refilled and refurbished: brand-new quality at discounted prices. Finally, compatible cartridges are off-brand but designed to work just as well as manufacturer-produced models.
That depends on your printer and which option you choose. Most often, you'll spend less if you buy compatible cartridges and more when buying OEM. Generally speaking, you can expect to save anywhere from 30-70% over the everyday retail price. Many online stores offer promotional discounts to save you even more.
Most online printer ink retailers have a satisfaction guarantee that will refund your money or replace your cartridges if they don't function as expected. You're more likely to encounter that with remanufactured and compatible options.
It's a good idea to check customer reviews when buying printer ink, to see how well others say a particular brand or option has worked under actual use. This is especially true if you're buying compatible cartridges: make sure plenty of other people have had good results and that they work consistently with the name-brand models they're replacing. Checking out a company's listing with the BBB is another smart way to make sure you're buying from a reputable business.
That usually depends on the amount of your order. Many retailers of printer ink will give you free shipping if you spend at least a certain amount (e.g. $50), but there are a few that deliver orders of any size at no extra cost.
In the past, it was common to find services that would refill used cartridges, at a fraction of the price to buy new ones. However, it has become increasingly difficult to locate providers who still offer the service. You may be able to buy ink kits to fill them on your own, but it's much more convenient to get inexpensive cartridges that are ready to use.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

But when you buy OEM Printer Ink from an online retailer, chances are very good that you'll save a lot of money over buying it from your local store. Remanufactured cartridges take the OEM products and refill them. That way, you know the cartridges will still be the right fit for your printer, and you pay less because you're essentially paying just for new ink.

While a few stores that sell Printer Ink will allow you to send in your used cartridges - or offer kits that let you refill your cartridges at home - most services that sell remanufactured ink and toner send you the cartridges pre-filled.

Compatible Printer Ink cartridges aren't made by your printer's manufacturer. Instead, they are made by third-party companies and typically go through rigorous testing to ensure that they deliver the same fit and print quality as the OEM cartridges. These are often the most economical option, since you're not paying for the brand-name reputation.

Depending on which type of Printer Ink cartridge you choose, you could save anywhere from 30-70% over the manufacturer's suggested retail price. Many online retailers offer promotional discounts, free shipping on orders that meet a minimum spend amount, and even deeper discounts when you buy in bulk. Also, the best online sellers of Printer Ink offer excellent satisfaction guarantee policies, giving you the confidence that your cartridge will work perfectly - or your money back.

When choosing an online store for your next Printer Ink order, how can you decide which company is right for you? Here are several criteria to keep in mind:

  • Selection. Does the business carry a wide range of products for your printer brand? Can you get the type of cartridge - OEM, remanufactured, or compatible - that you prefer?
  • Price. How competitive are the prices with respect to other stores? Are there any discounts that can save you more? Does the company offer free shipping?
  • Reputation. What do other customers have to say about their experience buying and using Printer Ink cartridges from this store? Is the customer service team responsive if there's a problem? Has the company been rated by the BBB?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Printer Ink stores available today. We hope this information helps you get your next ink or toner cartridges at the best price!

See the Best Printer Ink Store
The Best Reviews of Printer Ink Stores