Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Maytag Review

Thursday, October 6th

2022 Refrigerator Reviews

Maytag Review 2.5 Star Rating

Maytag

2.5 Star Rating
  • About a dozen models to choose from
  • Prices range from $790 to $2,399
  • 1-year full warranty, 10 years limited parts warranty

Maytag has been a recognized brand in home appliances for over 100 years, personified by "The Maytag Man" . You won't find any overly-fancy fridges here, just basic and budget-friendly options under $2400.

Very narrow selection

There are only about a dozen refrigerators currently offered by Maytag. These include top freezer, side-by-side, bottom freezer and French door styles in black, white and stainless steel finishes. With such a small selection, you're less likely to get the exact configuration you're hoping for. For example, the French door style without an in-door water dispenser was out of stock, and none of the bottom freezer models had water dispenser options at all. But, if you're easily overwhelmed by having dozens of models to browse, Maytag can eliminate some of that hassle.

Features that don't really impress

cYou won't find too many advanced features with a Maytag fridge. We didn't spot any that had smart features like Wi-Fi connectivity or touchscreen doors. The only capability that popped out at us is the PowerCold option on some models: push a button to cool your fridge down quickly, even if the doors have been open for a while as you loaded groceries (or because someone forgot to close them). Maytag also promotes a Beverage Chiller compartment with some fridge styles, but it doesn't seem like much more than an in-door place to store juice or milk.

Watch out for the deli drawer

And, one feature we don't love (usually on the French door styles) is the deli drawer. In our experience, those drawers get crammed with food and then the sliding cover pops out of place, or the plastic see-through cover gets cracked when people drop food on it. That's a feature we actively avoid when shopping for a new fridge, but you'll have a hard time avoiding it at Maytag if you're specifically looking for French door models.

Best Refrigerators

Might not last very long

Maytag is one of several refrigerator brands in our review that are part of the Whirlpool family, and so it shares Whirlpool's "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. Unfortunately, that doesn't mean that Maytag has refrigerators that are just as reliable. While some models average a 4-star rating or higher, a few score much lower. On average, Maytag refrigerators seem to last 10 years at the most, which is below average compared with many rival brands that go 15+ years before needing to be replaced. Frequent issues include condenser coil failure (that will lead to a fridge full of spoiled food), malfunctioning ice maker assemblies, weak door seals and excess moisture. You've only got a one-year full warranty on any Maytag fridge, plus 10 years limited parts coverage (where the fine print says it only includes the compressor).

A history of recalls

And, although it was over a decade ago, there was a huge recall of Maytag refrigerators back in 2009: originally, over 1 million units were recalled (across several Maytag-affiliated brands) and an extra 40,000+ of just Maytag-branded models were included later. Why? Electrical failures caused overheating and even fires. We're sure that Maytag has taken care of that in subsequent designs - after all, there haven't been any big recalls since - but you'll still see that mentioned as you do your research.

Low ranking among refrigerator brands

Maytag doesn't have a lot going for it among refrigerator brands. Small selection, lackluster performance and less-than-impressive features keep it from ranking very high among the companies in our evaluation. Is it the worst brand you could buy? Maybe not, but we suggest checking out the higher-rated options first.

Which Brand of Refrigerators is the Best?

Whether you're equipping the kitchen in your brand-new home or replacing the trusty appliance you've had for years that finally gave up the ghost, you're making a major purchase that needs to be reliable and give you a good value for your money.

Today's refrigerators range from your basic side-by-side (or even a more old-fashioned freezer-on-top, fridge-on-bottom style) all the way up to cutting-edge designs that have a touchscreen in the door - for displaying recipes, checking the weather, or even listening to your favorite Spotify playlist.

The Best Refrigerators Compare Refrigerators Compare Refrigerator Reviews What are the best Refrigerators Best Refrigerator Reviews

Refrigerator FAQ

In the past, the only option was the freezer-on-top, fridge-on-bottom style, and then customers got the option for side-by-side styles. Today's refrigerators also offer the French door design, usually with two doors on the top and a pull-out freezer drawer (or two) on the bottom. Even more modern features include see-through doors, doors with touchscreens that can display calendars or stream music, and ice makers for cocktail-sized cubes!
Prices vary widely: by brand, features, size, and so forth. You could buy a mini-fridge for a dorm room for under $100, or a top-of-the-line professional model for almost $15,000! Fortunately, most refrigerators for average home use cost somewhere between $7,000 and $4,000.
Yes. Maybe you want a fridge in the house and a freezer in the garage. You can indeed buy refrigerators with no freezer, but be ready for a much more limited selection.
Yes. Not everyone wants to give up the space in their fridge that's taken up by the components of a water dispenser. You can find a decent range of options for refrigerators with no water dispenser in the door.
Most refrigerators will take anywhere from 3 to 24 hours to reach the FDA-recommended temperature of 40 degrees. Keep that in mind as you're planning the logistics of clearing out your old fridge and getting the new one set up: you'll want a way to keep food cold while you're waiting for your new appliance to cool down.
Refrigerators have the longest lifespan of most home appliances: about 13 years, according to the National Association of Home Builders. Your fridge also comes with a manufacturer's warranty, usually about a year. You can buy extended protection if you like, which generally extends that coverage for up to 5 years.
Buying your refrigerator online makes it much easier to narrow down all of the possibilities and zero in on the appliance that best fits your needs. In an appliance store, you could easily wander back and forth between several models, trying to keep all of the features and differences straight in your head. Shopping online, you can easily compare two models side-by-side (pun intended) and keep track of your favorites. Plus, most stores near you will have a very limited floor selection, as opposed to the vast inventory featured online.
That will depend on the store where you get your refrigerator. You could get free delivery or pay a small fee to have it brought to your home and installed. If you need your old fridge hauled off, that's usually included at an extra cost as well.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Choosing the right fridge requires taking several factors into account. First, what's your budget? Believe it or not, you can find models for less than $500 and for more than $5,000, so having an idea of what you want to spend can help you narrow down the possibilities.

Next, how much room do you have? Taking accurate measurements is a must, otherwise your fridge may not fit on installation day - and don't forget to account for the room needed to open the doors. Also, how much room do you need inside? A good rule of thumb is four to six cubic feet of interior space for every adult in the household. Finally, what features are must-haves (or must-avoids)? Not everyone wants an in-door water/ice dispenser or a Wi-Fi capable appliance.

Once you've come up with a general overview of the refrigerator that will best suit your needs, it's time to see which brands fit the bill. Some manufacturers are more reliable than others: a few makers have a reputation for dropping the ball when it comes to customer service after the sale, and at least one has experienced major recalls due to fire hazards. No matter which brand and model you eventually decide, it's a smart idea to see what extended warranty coverage is available to help mitigate any costly problems you might experience down the road.

To recap, here are the criteria you should have in mind as you shop for a new refrigerator:

  • Budget. How much can you afford to spend? Are you willing to go above that limit for a must-have feature or top-notch warranty coverage?
  • Size. How much space do you have where the fridge will be installed: height, width, and depth? How much room does it need to have inside to accommodate your household (and remember that your small kids now will be adult-sized in the not-so-distant future).
  • Features. What features are absolutely essential, nice to have but not required, or an absolute "no way" ? What color will complement your current decor - or will your fridge pave the way for a whole new look? Energy-saving vs. bells and whistles (or both)?
  • Reliability. What do current owners of the brand and model you like have to say about the longevity of the refrigerator? How long will it be under warranty? How easy is it to get repairs completed while under warranty?

TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the most popular brands of refrigerators on the market today. We hope this information helps you choose the right model for your next major appliance purchase!

The Best Reviews of Refrigerators