Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Maytag Review

Thursday, December 5th

2024 Refrigerator Reviews

Maytag Review 3 Star Rating

Maytag

3 Star Rating
  • Prices from $714 to $2,699
  • 9 refrigerators
  • 18 Cu Ft.-27 Cu Ft.
  • Side-by-side, top freezer, french door
  • 1-year warranty, 10 years for parts
  • Free delivery
  • 15-day returns for free
  • "A+” rating from the BBB

As a long-established brand with over 100 years of experience, Maytag prioritizes dependability in all its products. When you bring home a Maytag appliance, you're getting a reliable companion that works hard for you. The company guarantees that its appliances, including refrigerators, dishwashers, ovens, and refrigerators, will match your efforts with their own durability. If you're seeking a straightforward, budget-friendly refrigerator option, Maytag might be a suitable choice, with most models priced under $2400. However, you might be disappointed if you're expecting a wide range of choices to select from.

Appliance Overview

  • Price range: $714 to $2,699
  • Types: Side-by-side, top freezer, french door
  • Different models: 9
  • Capacity: 18 Cu Ft.-27 Cu Ft.
  • Colors: 5
  • Energy Efficient: Some models
  • Return policy: 15 days
  • Warranty: 1-year full warranty and 10-year limited parts
  • Additional protection plans: Yes
  • Financing: Yes
  • Shipping: Free delivery

Basic model: Top Freezer Refrigerator with PowerCold

While there isn't a lot going on with the base model from Maytag, there are still a few features that set The Top Freezer Refrigerator apart. For instance, the PowerCold feature, BrightSeries LED Lighting, and Bottom-Mounted FreshLock Crispers with Humidity Controls are notable highlights of this particular model. Maytag also offers a 10-year limited parts warranty on the compressor for peace of mind. However, this model isn't ENERGY STAR certified. The price tag for this refrigerator is $714, which is competitive for a complete fridge-freezer combo, but may not tick many boxes for features.

Best Refrigerators

Top-tier model: 36-inch Wide French Door Refrigerator

The top model offered by Maytag is still pretty basic, but it has a lot more features than the base model. It also has an impressive increase in space (and an included freezer). This particular model comes equipped with the PowerCold feature, metal slide-out shelf, Store-N-Door ice dispensing system, and BrightSeries LED lighting. The temperature-controlled Wide-N-Fresh deli drawer is designed to accommodate large party platters and deli trays and is ideal for storing food at the perfect temperature. Furthermore, the Everydrop water filter reduces contaminants and filters both hard and soft water. This model meets ENERGY STAR standards and is priced at $2,699.

Free in-home delivery

Maytag stands out with continuing low costs by offering free shipping. As part of this service, you can expect in-home delivery with floor protection. This means that whether you live on the first or second floor, the delivery team will take care of your floors. While installation is not included in the free shipping, you can add it on for an additional $30. If you also want your old appliances removed, it will be an extra $20.

Free 15-day returns

Maytag offers a 15-day return window with no return fees. You can initiate a return at any time within 15 days of delivery. To qualify for a return, the refrigerator must be in new and unused condition. However, you're allowed to let the delivery team complete any initial testing on your appliance, and it will still be considered "new" for return purposes.

Best Refrigerators

Some questions about reliability

Maytag is part of the Whirlpool family, which has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, this doesn't necessarily translate to excellent reliability for Maytag's refrigerators. Some models receive high ratings, but others tend to last around 10 years on average, which is below the industry standard of 15 years or more. Common issues include condenser coil failure, malfunctioning ice maker assemblies, weak door seals, and excess moisture. Customers often complain about noise from Maytag appliances, and some have even received defective products that didn't work at all. On the other hand, some customers praise the space and design of Maytag refrigerators, indicating that there are positive experiences to be had.

Needs to work on reliability

Maytag doesn't stand out among refrigerator brands due to its limited selection, mediocre performance, and lackluster features. If you're looking for a reliable and high-performing refrigerator, we recommend exploring other brands first. Considering that many customers have issues with reliability over time, this doesn't seem like a great place to put your money. If you're looking for a more reliable refrigerator, you can check out our higher-rated options instead.

Where Can You Find the Best Refrigerator?

When purchasing a new refrigerator, choosing your new appliance can be a daunting decision that requires careful research and consideration. You're not just investing in a household appliance; you're making a choice that will impact your daily life for years to come. Whether you're moving into a new home and need a reliable appliance to keep your food fresh, or you're replacing an old fridge that's been giving you trouble for years, you want to make sure you get a model that meets your needs and fits your budget.

Refrigerators have come a long way in recent years, offering a range of features and designs to suit different lifestyles and preferences. From basic side-by-side models to cutting-edge designs with touchscreens and Wi-Fi capabilities, there's a refrigerator on the market to suit every taste and budget. Some models offer advanced features like smart sensors that can detect when food is spoiling and alert you to its presence, while others offer sleek designs that blend into your kitchen decor.

The Best Refrigerators Compare Refrigerators Compare Refrigerator Reviews What are the best Refrigerators Best Refrigerator Reviews

Refrigerator FAQ

In the past, the only option was the freezer-on-top, fridge-on-bottom style, and then customers got the option for side-by-side styles. Today's refrigerators also offer the French door design, usually with two doors on the top and a pull-out freezer drawer (or two) on the bottom. Even more modern features include see-through doors, doors with touchscreens that can display calendars or stream music, and ice makers for cocktail-sized cubes!
Prices vary widely: by brand, features, size, and so forth. You could buy a mini-fridge for a dorm room for under $100, or a top-of-the-line professional model for almost $15,000! Fortunately, most refrigerators for average home use cost somewhere between $7,000 and $4,000.
Yes. Maybe you want a fridge in the house and a freezer in the garage. You can indeed buy refrigerators with no freezer, but be ready for a much more limited selection.
Yes. Not everyone wants to give up the space in their fridge that's taken up by the components of a water dispenser. You can find a decent range of options for refrigerators with no water dispenser in the door.
Most refrigerators will take anywhere from 3 to 24 hours to reach the FDA-recommended temperature of 40 degrees. Keep that in mind as you're planning the logistics of clearing out your old fridge and getting the new one set up: you'll want a way to keep food cold while you're waiting for your new appliance to cool down.
Refrigerators have the longest lifespan of most home appliances: about 13 years, according to the National Association of Home Builders. Your fridge also comes with a manufacturer's warranty, usually about a year. You can buy extended protection if you like, which generally extends that coverage for up to 5 years.
Buying your refrigerator online makes it much easier to narrow down all of the possibilities and zero in on the appliance that best fits your needs. In an appliance store, you could easily wander back and forth between several models, trying to keep all of the features and differences straight in your head. Shopping online, you can easily compare two models side-by-side (pun intended) and keep track of your favorites. Plus, most stores near you will have a very limited floor selection, as opposed to the vast inventory featured online.
That will depend on the store where you get your refrigerator. You could get free delivery or pay a small fee to have it brought to your home and installed. If you need your old fridge hauled off, that's usually included at an extra cost as well.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

No matter which style you want, with a new refrigerator you're definitely in for an upgrade in quality or reliability. While you might be a bit worried about cost, don't worry, we've got your back. With refrigerators ranging from under $500 to over $5,000, there are new refrigerators out there for any budget. The top model on the market might be pricey, but you can find tons of comparable options for reasonable prices as well.

As long as you know what you're looking for in terms of features, size, and other key elements, you can easily stay within your budget without compromising on the tech side. Not everyone wants an in-door water/ice dispenser or Wi-Fi connectivity, so figuring out your refrigerator priorities can help you find the best deals for your new appliance.

Once you've determined what kind of refrigerator will best suit your needs, it's time to research different brands and models. Some manufacturers have a reputation for producing reliable appliances with excellent customer service, while others may be more prone to issues or recalls. All manufacturers are known for something different, with some focusing on more high-end options and others concentrating on the essentials. Make sure you find a brand that aligns with your refrigerator checklist.

However, with so many different brands out there, it can be difficult to know where to begin. If you need a starting point, here are several factors you might want to consider to help you find the perfect brand, model, or style of refrigerator:

  • Style. Do you want a traditional side-by-side refrigerator or do you want something that changes up how you use your space, like a top freezer or bottom freezer? Knowing how you like to pack your perishables can help you easily narrow down which brands to shop with. Some have more options than others in a particular style.
  • Features. Check the features and options available on different refrigerators. Do you want food sensors and specialty drawers to keep food fresh? Do you want Wi-Fi connectivity?
  • Reputation. Invest in a high-quality refrigerator from a reputable manufacturer. This way, you'll know you can get years of reliability out of your new appliance. Look for models with impressive warranties and solid reputations to make sure you're getting the most for your money.
  • Price. Set a budget for your refrigerator and compare options in your range across different brands. Not all brands are made the same and you might find high-end features for low-end prices, depending on where you shop. While it's important to stay within your budget, remember that quality can last for years to come, so investing in a more expensive refrigerator can pay off over time.

To help you find the best refrigerators for your home and style, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the top refrigerator brands and models on the market. We hope our research will help you find a top-notch addition to your kitchen appliances.

The Best Reviews of Refrigerators