Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Renters Insurance

Where Can You Find the Best Renters Insurance Out There Today?

In a world where life's unexpected events can disrupt even the most carefully planned routines, ensuring the protection of your personal belongings and living space is a growing concern for individuals and families renting their apartments or homes. Fortunately, to address this pressing need, there are specialized services and trustworthy insurance specialists offering renters insurance.

So, why is renters insurance more essential than ever? First off, there are a ton more people renting these days. And renting a home or apartment brings its own set of responsibilities and potential risks that are completely different from owning a home. While your landlord's insurance may cover the building itself, it typically doesn't extend to your personal belongings.

Tuesday, March 5th

2024 Renters Insurance Reviews

Assurant Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating


5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Assurant is an insurance company with a global presence. Offering comprehensive renters insurance coverage tailored to individual needs, Assurant offers a customizable pricing model with tons of features and liability coverage. Prices can be higher but Assurant stands out with its high star ratings and stellar "A+" from the BBB. These things especially make them a top choice for renters insurance and prove that the higher cost is worth it to protect your home, belongings, and health, earning Assurant the #1 spot in this review.

Nationwide Review 4.5 Star Rating


4.5 Star Rating

Nationwide is an international company offering renters insurance in 43 states and Washington, D.C. Their comprehensive coverage includes personal property, loss of use, liability, and medical payments, with additional perks like credit card protection and more. Prices start at just $20 per month which is competitive in the industry. But the best part? Nationwide has a solid reputation and an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, standing out as a top choice for transparent, competitively priced renters insurance with comprehensive options and top-tier service. For this reason, it easily earns high marks in this review.

State Farm Review 4 Star Rating

State Farm

4 Star Rating

State Farm offers comprehensive renters insurance coverage in all states except California, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island. Their policies are customizable, including personal property, loss of use, liability, and medical payments coverage, along with valuable add-ons such as business property coverage and identity theft protection starting at $15 per month. Overall, State Farm is a competitive choice for renters insurance, offering a balance of affordability and coverage options, earning a 4-star rating in this review and ranking third overall.

Travelers Review 3.5 Star Rating


3.5 Star Rating

Travelers boasts over 165 years of experience in the insurance industry and offers a wide range of renters insurance coverage options. They provide comprehensive coverage, including personal property, loss of use, liability, and medical payments. While they excel in coverage, the downside is their lack of price transparency on their website, requiring customers to provide personal information for a quote. However, their user-friendly online platform and mobile app make managing policies and filing claims easy. With a solid reputation, an "A" rating from the BBB, and a 4.1-star average from customer reviews, Travelers is a good company for renters insurance, making it worth considering despite the initial quote process hassle.

Lemonade Review 3 Star Rating


3 Star Rating

Lemonade is a newer insurance option on the market that promises affordable renters insurance. The application process is speedy and simple, offering instant quotes based on basic details. What sets Lemonade apart is its user-friendly interface and dedication to making a positive social impact. However, its reputation and pricing receive moderate ratings. Plus, it may be harder for some customers to secure insurance through Lemonade as it is currently only available in 28 states plus Washington, D.C.

Allstate Review 2.5 Star Rating


2.5 Star Rating

Allstate is a well-known insurance provider that offers renters insurance with customization options, including personal property, loss of use, liability, and medical payments coverage, along with add-ons. Renters can expect an average monthly premium of around $16, but pricing can vary significantly by location, potentially making it less budget-friendly in higher-risk areas. While they offer discounts for bundling and safety measures, some customers have found their pricing higher and claim the discount opportunities are somewhat limited compared to other providers. With a mixed reputation and an average rating of 3.8 stars, it might be better to look at the more budget-friendly companies out there..

Liberty Mutual Review 2 Star Rating

Liberty Mutual

2 Star Rating

Liberty Mutual provides renters insurance that covers a range of customizable options, including earthquake coverage and identity theft protection. However, the lack of price transparency can be frustrating for customers. Despite competitive discounts, third-party reviews reveal some dissatisfaction, with an average rating of just 1.3 stars. This raises concerns about Liberty Mutual's customer service and commitment to policy promises. In general, we recommend exploring other providers on our list with higher customer ratings.

Geico Review 1.5 Star Rating


1.5 Star Rating

Geico offers renters insurance in partnership with over 20 insurance companies; however, this matching method means that Geico assigns customers to an insurance provider, limiting choices for customers in general. Unfortunately, Geico lacks pricing transparency, requiring customers to complete the quote process to get a price estimate. While Geico's website and app offer a clean and user-friendly experience, customer reviews suggest trustworthiness issues, with complaints about unmet promises and transparency concerns. Considering these factors, you may want to explore better options for renters insurance.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Imagine the loss and financial strain that could result from a fire, theft, or other unexpected incidents. Renters insurance steps in to protect your belongings, from furniture and electronics to clothing and jewelry, so that you're not left with the burden of replacing everything from scratch.

Renters insurance policies come in various forms to cater to your unique needs. Leading providers offer comprehensive coverage that goes beyond the basics, including liability protection and additional living expenses coverage. These services are designed to offer peace of mind, whether you're a student renting your first apartment or a family in a long-term lease.

Insurance experts often advise renters to consider the value of their possessions and the potential costs of replacing them as these costs can be added to your policy at the get-go. While no one wants to think about worst-case scenarios, renters insurance is a smart way to prepare for the unexpected.

Thankfully, obtaining renters insurance is a straightforward process; it's easily accessible for renters of all backgrounds. If you're unsure where to start, don't worry. Because your possessions and your financial security matter, we've taken the time to explore the top renters insurance services for you, so you can make an informed decision and protect what matters most.

Here are a few factors that can help you narrow down your choices:

  • Cost. Considering that renters insurance is a continuous expense, you'll want to check budgeting options in the long term. How much do you want to spend? Are you looking for a full package with all the bells and whistles? Or maybe budget and bundle options are best for you? Knowing what you want to spend will help you narrow down your options. Also, your landlord/property management company may have certain minimum coverage requirements, so start from there.
  • Transparency. On the note of price, some companies are more transparent than others regarding price points. Keep an eye out for those that give you upfront prices and easy access to quotes to feel more confident about what you want to spend.
  • User interface. With insurance that you need to check on or update or even (worst case) make a claim, you'll want to be comfortable with the user interface. Does the company have a mobile app? Is it easy to find what you need on the site? Are loading times quick and seamless? How easy is it to file a claim online? Keep these things in mind as you check out the options.
  • Reputation. Reputation is a big deal and trustworthiness is key. If customers aren't happy with the coverage or service they've gotten from a renters insurance provider, you'll want to stay away. Keep an eye on ratings from the Better Business Bureau and verified customer reviews can help you sift out the companies that aren't as trustworthy as the top choices.

Because we take your protection and peace of mind seriously, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best places to go for renters insurance today. We hope this helps you feel more secure about your home and belongings and stay stress-free about any future emergencies. With renters insurance, you'll be taken care of.

The Best Renters Insurance Compare Renters Insurance Compare Renters Insurance Reviews What are the best Renters Insurance Best Renters Insurance Reviews

Renters Insurance FAQ

Renters insurance is a policy that provides financial protection for your personal belongings, liability coverage, and additional living expenses in case of events like theft, fire, or accidents. It's essential and usually required by landlords because it helps safeguard your possessions and shields you from liability claims.
While roommates can share a rental, renters insurance policies are typically individual. Each roommate should consider getting their own renters insurance policy to protect their personal belongings and liability. Some insurers offer coverage for roommates living together under separate policies, and some also allow you to add a roommate to your existing plan.
Renters insurance is generally not required by law, but your landlord may require it as part of your lease agreement. Even if it's not mandatory, it's highly recommended to protect your interests.
While security measures can enhance safety, they don't replace the need for renters insurance. Renters insurance protects against a broader range of risks, including theft, fire, and liability, which security measures may not address fully. On the bright side, many insurance policies will offer discounts if you have extra security in your rental.
If your rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event, renters insurance can provide coverage for additional living expenses. This includes the cost of temporary accommodations like hotel stays, meals, and other essential expenses while your rental is being repaired or replaced. Not every plan covers this from the get-go, so make sure if you're concerned about it you pick an add-on or choose a plan that covers accommodations.
Renters insurance typically covers personal property, liability, and additional living expenses. Personal property coverage includes your belongings, while liability coverage protects you if you accidentally injure someone or damage their property. Additional living expenses coverage helps with temporary living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable. There are other add-ons with many policies, so you can get more or less coverage depending on what you need.
Yes, renters insurance often covers personal property even when it's outside of your rental. This coverage, known as "off-premises coverage," can protect your belongings worldwide, but it's essential to check your policy for specific limits and conditions. Some policies may have this included and others may require you to purchase it as an add-on.
Standard renters insurance typically doesn't cover damage caused by earthquakes or floods. However, many companies do offer earthquake or flood coverage as add-ons, but this does come at an extra cost. Many customers who live in an area prone to such events should consider purchasing separate earthquake or flood insurance for adequate protection.
The Best Reviews of Renters Insurance