What is the best rowing machine for your home gym? If you're looking for a full-body workout that's gentle on your joints but tough on calories, a rowing machine might be exactly what you need. These versatile fitness devices have surged in popularity recently, and for good reason - rowing machines offer one of the most efficient workouts available, engaging over 85% of your muscles while providing both cardiovascular and strength benefits. The rhythmic motion also promotes better posture and core strength, which can alleviate back pain for many users. (Your spine will thank you).
Best Option
Founded in 1976 by brothers Peter and Dick Dreissigacker, Concept2 started with a vision to create innovative rowing products from their humble Vermont headquarters. What began as a small operation crafting rowing oars has evolved into the undisputed king of rowing machines worldwide. Their air-resistance flywheel technology has become so universally respected that Concept2 rowing machines are now the official standard for indoor rowing competitions globally. As you'll discover in our comprehensive review, there's a reason why every serious athlete, CrossFit box, and Olympic training facility chooses Concept2 rowing machines above all others.
The RowErg is Concept2's flagship rowing machine
Concept2's primary offering, the RowErg, is priced at just $990 and represents the perfect blend of durability, performance, and value. This aluminum and steel workhorse uses air resistance through Concept2's flywheel technology, allowing users to control workout intensity simply by rowing harder or adjusting the damper setting. The machine comes equipped with the highly regarded PM5 Performance Monitor that tracks distance, speed, pace, calories, and watts with unparalleled accuracy. Available with standard legs (14" seat height) or tall legs (20" seat height), the RowErg can be easily separated into two pieces for storage without tools and includes built-in caster wheels for easy movement.
Concept2's specialized ergometer family extends beyond rowing
Beyond their flagship RowErg, Concept2 offers a complete lineup of specialized air-resistance machines. Their product family includes the SkiErg ($850), which simulates Nordic skiing for a full-body workout while being easier on the knees, and the impressive StrengthErg ($1,500), a compact multi-functional strength training machine that uses the same air-resistance technology to deliver safe, effective resistance training without traditional weights. All Concept2 machines feature the same robust PM5 monitor system, aircraft-grade aluminum frames, and exceptional build quality. Each model connects with Concept2's ErgData app, allowing users to track progress across different workout types. While rowing machines remain Concept2's bread and butter, these specialized ergometers showcase the Vermont-based company's commitment to creating versatile fitness equipment that delivers measurable, comparable results for athletes at all levels.
Concept2 keeps it simple: no subscription required, just pure rowing
Unlike some predatory rowing machine companies that lock essential features of their rowers behind pricey subscriptions, Concept2 offers its ErgData app completely free of charge for both iOS and Android users. This companion to your rowing machine connects via Bluetooth to the PM5 monitor and offers workout tracking, detailed post-workout analysis with stroke graphs and heart rate zones, customizable displays, and even social features like the Real Time Loop where you can row alongside others virtually. Concept2's rowing machines work perfectly fine without the app, with no limitations whatsoever, as the built-in PM5 monitor already provides all essential metrics. Your workout data can be automatically synced to the free Concept2 Online Logbook and exported to other fitness platforms like Strava, Apple Health, and Garmin Connect. While Concept2 doesn't offer instructor-led classes or scenic rows like subscription-based competitors, their approach emphasizes pure athletic performance and community connection through challenges and leaderboards - exactly what serious rowers prioritize in their rowing machines.
Shipping from Concept2 is straightforward but not free
When ordering a Concept2 rowing machine directly, expect to pay for shipping, with costs varying by model and location. Standard RowErg models ship for $55 within the lower 48 states, while taller models that come in two boxes cost $85. Shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, or Puerto Rico jumps significantly to $175 for standard models. Canadian customers pay $100 for standard models and $140 for taller versions. Most Concept2 rowing machines ship within 1-3 business days, and express shipping options are available for those willing to call their customer service line.
A no-nonsense 30-day return policy backs your purchase
If your Concept2 rowing machine doesn't meet expectations, you have 30 days from the shipping date to return it for a refund of the purchase price. While Concept2 doesn't mention any restocking fees in their policy (a refreshing stance in today's market), they do require you to cover all shipping costs associated with returns. Before sending anything back, you'll need to call Concept2's customer service to initiate the return process.
Industry-leading warranty protection comes standard
Concept2 RowErgs come with a two-year limited warranty on all parts, while the frame itself is protected for five years from your purchase date. However, you'll likely never need to use it - these machines are legendarily durable. As one owner noted, "They last forever. I bought mine at 50 and I expect it to outlive me."
Concept2 earns an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau, confirming its reputation
When it comes to industry credibility, Concept2 delivers impressive credentials with an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, though they haven't sought official BBB accreditation. While their Trustpilot presence is modest (just a handful of reviews averaging 3. 9 stars), where Concept2 rowing machines truly shine is in specialized rowing communities and forums. The consensus among serious rowers is crystal clear: these machines are "bombproof and accurate" and widely considered "the standard" against which all other rowing machines are measured.
Real rowers swear by Concept2's legendary durability and accuracy
Customer testimonials for Concept2 rowing machines read like love letters to reliability. The machines earn particular praise for withstanding institutional use: "Durable enough to be abused by high school athletes for 10 years" and "my club keeps them outside and absolutely abuses them and they keep on keeping on." Concept2's customer service also earns compliments, with one customer reporting their monitor issue was "resolved very quickly" with "brilliant service." The rare criticisms tend to focus on noise levels compared to water rowers, with some retired professional rowers preferring the aesthetics and quieter operation of alternatives - though they acknowledge the unmatched accuracy of Concept2's performance metrics.
Concept2 takes the crown as the undisputed champion of rowing machines
After extensive research, Concept2 rowing machines earn our highest possible recommendation with a perfect 5-star rating. These rowing machines combine industrial-grade durability with competition-level accuracy at a price point that represents genuine value. Whether you're a seasoned athlete tracking splits to the millisecond or a fitness enthusiast looking for decades of reliable workouts, Concept2 delivers what matters most. The company's stellar reputation among professional rowers isn't just marketing hype - it's well-earned through consistent quality and performance that other rowing machines simply can't match. If you're serious about rowing, there's no better investment for your home gym than a Concept2.
Great
Invented by Yale engineer and US National Rowing Team candidate John Duke, WaterRower set out to bring the authentic on-water rowing experience into your living room. Their handcrafted wooden rowing machines, produced in the USA and Germany, aren't just fitness equipment but "fitness furniture" designed with Shaker-inspired elegance. While not quite claiming our top spot, WaterRower's water resistance system and furniture-quality construction earn them a strong second place in our rankings - offering a compelling blend of performance and aesthetics that might just make you forget you're not gliding across an actual lake.
Over 30 models from $799
When you land on WaterRower's website, you can browse by collection categories including WaterRower originals, Performance models, Metallic models, and other fitness equipment from their NOHRD line of cardio, wellness, and strength products. All WaterRower machines (of which there are around 30) utilize their patented WaterFlywheel technology to replicate actual rowing resistance, creating both the physical sensation and peaceful sound of rowing on water. Their products are handcrafted in the USA and Germany with meticulous attention to materials - whether wood that absorbs sound and vibration or sleek stainless steel. Most models feature the S4 Performance Monitor for tracking workout metrics and come with impressive 700-pound weight capacities, plus optional Bluetooth connectivity through the ComMod upgrade for connecting to fitness apps like WATERROWER CONNECT and CITYROW. Let's take a look at a few exemplary models:
WaterRower offers rowing without subscription strings attached
Unlike some competitors, WaterRower doesn't require you to subscribe to a fitness app to use their rowing machines. You can row offline, or use their free WATERROWER Connect app (with 70,000+ users) that provides all the essentials: technique guidance, heart rate monitoring, and performance tracking that syncs with popular fitness apps. For those wanting more, premium features unlock additional classes, scenic rowing videos, and advanced analytics, though WaterRower doesn't disclose pricing on their website. The social aspect is nicely integrated too, with optional leaderboards and achievement sharing that adds a competitive edge to your rowing sessions.
Shipping charges and timeframes vary by location
WaterRower rowing machines don't come with free shipping, but their pricing is straightforward: $99 for wooden models and $150 for metal models, with CityRow models shipping at $100 per machine. Your rowing machine should arrive within 5-7 business days after ordering, which is relatively quick for large fitness equipment.
Warranty protection ranges from 1-5 years
WaterRower stands behind their products with a tiered warranty system: a standard 1-year limited warranty that you can upgrade to 3 years on components and 5 years on the structural frame simply by registering your purchase within the first year. Touchscreen electronics get 1 year of protection regardless.
Return policy information is mysteriously absent
Curiously, WaterRower doesn't publicize their return policy on their website, so you'll want to be absolutely certain before purchasing your rowing machine. However, their service and maintenance support is exceptional. If your WaterRower needs repair under warranty, they'll cover shipping costs for ground/economy return shipping (premium shipping options cost extra). The company earns points for their maintenance philosophy too - WaterRower rowing machines require minimal upkeep beyond adding a purification tablet to the water tank every 3-6 months, which they'll send you for free for the first three years of ownership. (Don't skip this maintenance step or your water will turn green).
WaterRower earns stellar trustworthiness scores across the board
When it comes to reputation, WaterRower stands tall with an impressive "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and a stellar 4.2-star average on Trustpilot from over 2,200 reviews. Customers consistently praise the rowing machine's aesthetics, with one longtime user noting, "The quiet swishing of the water makes using it a pleasure" while another appreciated the "best packaging and easiest setup seen in a long time." Even when issues arise, WaterRower's service team earns high marks, with one customer sharing how they immediately replaced a rail with a small dent. While the company's rowing machines don't generate much negative feedback, some users mention maintenance requirements like quarterly water treatment and occasional bolt adjustments as minor drawbacks.
Choose WaterRower for aesthetics, meditation, and a more natural rowing experience
Why pick a WaterRower over the ubiquitous Concept2? It ultimately comes down to what you value in a rowing machine. WaterRower excels for home users seeking a beautiful piece of fitness equipment that doesn't clash with their furniture. The wooden craftsmanship and soothing water sounds create what many describe as a "therapeutic" rowing experience - "It's done wonders for my mental and emotional health," one user shares. While competitive rowers might prefer the Concept2 for its standardized metrics and durability, WaterRower offers a more natural-feeling resistance that mimics actual rowing. For steady-state workouts and those who row primarily for fitness rather than competition, WaterRower provides an engaging, enjoyable alternative that's as much a statement piece as it is exercise equipment.
Very Good
Founded in 2002 by John Sun during the early days of e-commerce, Sunny Health & Fitness has transformed from a modest online retailer into a premier fitness equipment brand over its double-decade journey. If you're searching for an affordable entry point into rowing without sacrificing quality, Sunny's diverse lineup of rowing machines deserves your attention. While these budget-friendly rowers likely won't deliver the premium experience of high-end competitors, Sunny Health & Fitness offers surprising value that might make you question whether spending more is truly necessary - but we'll get to that as we go through the details.
All models are budget-friendly fitness without compromising on quality
Across their 14 different models (6 magnetic, 3 water, 2 hydraulic, and 3 air), Sunny offers consistent features that make them perfect starter machines: sturdy steel construction, digital monitors that track essential workout metrics, and compatibility with their free SunnyFit App that provides thousands of workouts without subscription fees. Most Sunny rowers feature comfortable padded seats, anti-slip foot pedals with adjustable straps, and transport wheels for easy storage. With weight capacities ranging from 250-350 lbs, these rowing machines from Sunny Health & Fitness strike an impressive balance between affordability and functionality - perfect for those entering the rowing world without committing to high-end prices. Let's take a look at one rower from each resistance type category:
No subscription needed
Unlike some fitness brands that trap you in recurring payment cycles, Sunny offers their SunnyFit App completely free of charge - no subscriptions, no hidden fees, and no tiered membership plans to navigate. Your Sunny rowing machine works perfectly fine straight out of the box, and connecting to the app only enhances the experience without limiting functionality. The app itself is surprisingly robust for a free offering, featuring thousands of workouts across 16 different categories (from beginner to advanced), immersive world tour sessions that simulate outdoor environments, and compatibility with over 200 Smart Devices. Available on Apple App Store, Google Play, Apple TV, and Google TV, the SunnyFit App lets the whole family connect to track their progress in real-time, join the global Sunny community, and even compete on leaderboards.
Shipping is free, returns come with strings attached
Sunny Health & Fitness makes ordering easier by including free shipping on all their rowing machine models we examined. However, if you need to return your rower, you'll need to navigate their somewhat rigid 30-day return policy. Returns due to "buyer's remorse" require you to pay shipping costs and incur a 15% restocking fee. Fair warning: you'll need to keep that original packaging in pristine condition, as items returned in non-original packaging void your refund entirely. Sunny insists on proper return packaging, with severely damaged returns potentially resulting in no refund whatsoever.
Sunny protects your investment (to a point)
Your Sunny rowing machine comes with a tiered warranty that provides decent but not exceptional coverage. The structural frame is protected for 3 years, which matches industry standards for budget to mid-range rowers, while other parts and components are covered for just 180 days. This short component coverage is definitely something to consider when weighing Sunny against competitors. If problems arise, Sunny Health & Fitness doesn't send technicians to your home, but their customer service team can provide replacement parts and repair guidance during the warranty period.
A rare clean bill of health from reviewers and the BBB
In a world of amplified complaints and inflated reviews, Sunny Health & Fitness stands out with a legitimately impressive reputation. They've achieved the rowing machine industry equivalent of a unicorn: an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and official BBB accreditation - a combination rarely seen in fitness equipment manufacturers. On Trustpilot, Sunny rowing machines maintain a respectable 3.4-star average, but what's truly remarkable is the complete absence of negative reviews specifically about their rowers. One satisfied customer praised Sunny's support team for helping revive a secondhand rower: "Customer support was very effective and friendly in helping me to bring a used rower from Craigslist back to usable condition." Another rowing enthusiast who purchased the SF-RW5515 model acknowledged it as an excellent "starter machine" despite its basic features, explaining: "It counts time, strokes, estimated calories burned, and total strokes over the machine's life. But for like 200 dollars, it's fine."
Impressive value that will serve most home rowers well
When the dust settles, Sunny Health & Fitness delivers exactly what they promise: affordable rowing machines that provide reliable workouts without breaking the bank. These rowers occupy a sweet spot where value meets functionality. Are they Concept2 or WaterRower alternatives? Not quite - serious rowing enthusiasts and competitive athletes will still gravitate toward premium brands with more advanced features and longer component warranties. But for the average fitness enthusiast looking to add a solid cardio option to their home gym, Sunny's rowing machines absolutely get the job done. The company's stellar reputation, budget-friendly pricing, and decent frame warranty make these rowers an easy recommendation for casual users who want effective workouts without the premium price tag. Sunny Health & Fitness proves that you don't always need to spend more to row more.
Average
Founded by Bruce Smith, a former U.S. National Team coach and championship rower with a fascinating family history in boat building, Hydrow aims to bring the authentic rowing experience into your home. This Boston-based company, which has developed two sleek, high-tech rowing machines with immersive "on-the-water" displays, certainly looks impressive at first glance. But beneath the polished exterior and compelling origin story, our research revealed some concerning design issues and customer support limitations that potential buyers should consider before investing in a Hydrow rowing machine.
Two rowers from $1,545
Hydrow blends sleek design with magnetic resistance technology across their two-model lineup, where aluminum and steel frames provide durability while keeping weight manageable. Both rowing machines share Hydrow's signature immersive experience through HD touchscreens that stream live and on-demand workouts from waterways around the world. Every Hydrow rower connects with Bluetooth devices for heart rate monitoring and workout tracking, plus features integration with fitness apps like Strava and Apple Health. Here's what you can expect:
Membership is practically mandatory for optimal rowing experience
While Hydrow technically offers a basic "Just Row" mode without a subscription, you'll be rowing in digital darkness without one. For $44/month (that's $528 annually), Hydrow's membership unlocks what you're actually paying for: over 5,000 on-demand rowing workouts filmed on waterways worldwide, live sessions led by Olympic-caliber athletes, plus off-machine yoga, Pilates, and strength training. One membership covers unlimited household profiles, making Hydrow's rowing machines significantly more economical for families. The mobile app integration extends your Hydrow experience beyond the machine itself and comes included with the standard membership, though non-rower owners can purchase app-only access separately. Without the membership, your $1,500+ Hydrow essentially becomes an expensive mechanical rowing simulator with basic metrics but none of the immersive content that makes these rowing machines special in the first place.
Free shipping, but return fees may apply
When you order a Hydrow rowing machine directly from their website, shipping appears to be included in the purchase price, saving you from unexpected fees at checkout. While they'll try to upsell you on bundles with machine mats and memberships, the delivery itself won't cost you extra. That said, if you decide Hydrow's sleek rowing machines aren't right for you, the return process gets pretty strict - returns requested within 30 days will be hit with a substantial $250 return shipping fee that's deducted from your refund. And, be aware that Hydrow won't refund any original shipping, delivery, or installation charges you might have paid.
Hydrow's warranty offers decent protection
Every Hydrow rowing machine comes with a tiered warranty structure that provides varying levels of coverage. The structural frame is protected for a generous five years, while components (including the handle, strap, and seat assembly), the screen, and other electronics get twelve months of coverage. Labor is also covered for the first year. For those wanting extended protection for their Hydrow investment, an optional Extended Limited Warranty and Accidental Damage Protection plan is available within 60 days of purchase - which you may want to spring for, because some customers report frustration with recurring component failures that require expensive repairs once the standard warranty expires.
Hydrow enjoys strong customer satisfaction despite some support concerns
On the Better Business Bureau, Hydrow maintains a respectable "B+" rating, though it does have 12 filed complaints on record. Meanwhile, Hydrow rowing machines have collected an impressive 4.3-star average from over 10,000 reviews on Trustpilot - a strong indication that most customers are genuinely pleased with their purchase. Satisfied rowers frequently praise the machine's beautiful design and the quality of the guided workouts: "I love the training videos that have helped correct my posture, breathing, use of legs - well everything," gushes one enthusiastic reviewer who called their Hydrow "the best decision I have made in a long time."
Not all rowing experiences with Hydrow are smooth sailing
However, Hydrow's reputation isn't without its choppy waters. Negative reviews consistently highlight three major issues with these premium rowing machines: recurring mechanical problems (particularly with the handle spool assembly), customer service frustrations, and complaints about the mandatory subscription model. One disgruntled customer reported having to pay $200 twice in less than eight months to repair the same design defect, while another bluntly stated the software "forces you to listen to an intro on how to use it every time even if you've used it 1,000 times." Perhaps most concerning, some users describe potential safety issues, with one reviewer reporting their screen shattered during normal use, leaving "[their] home gym covered in glass shards" - certainly not what you'd expect when investing in Hydrow's high-end rowing experience.
Hydrow delivers solid rowing performance, but lacks reliability
Taking into account Hydrow's premium pricing alongside recurring mechanical issues and frustrating customer service experiences, we award Hydrow rowing machines a middle-of-the-road rating. While Hydrow offers beautiful design and engaging workout content, we cannot recommend Hydrow rowing machines to budget-conscious shoppers, those seeking hassle-free maintenance, or rowers who prefer equipment that works independently of subscription services. If you're someone who wants the peace of mind that comes with proven durability - or simply can't justify spending $2,000 on a machine that might require costly repairs within its first year - you'd be better served exploring alternatives like the bulletproof Concept2 rowers that dominate professional training facilities.
Fair
You've likely spotted Life Fitness rowing machines at your local gym - those fancy, water-resistance rowers that have caught your eye during cardio day. While Life Fitness rowing machines aren't the most budget-friendly options on the market, their commercial-grade construction and fluid technology resistance systems warrant consideration - though whether they're worth the investment for home use is something we'll explore in this review.
Two models from $1,849
Life Fitness brings commercial-grade quality to their rowing machines, with two distinct models sharing robust construction and impressive weight capacities of 330 pounds. Whether you prefer the natural feel of water resistance or the precision of air-magnetic combination, Life Fitness offers rowing machines with ergonomic handles, adjustable footboards with secure straps, and digital consoles that track essential metrics like time, distance, and calories burned. Take a look:
No membership required, just Bluetooth convenience
Life Fitness rowing machines offer Bluetooth connectivity that lets you track workouts through your preferred fitness apps. The Row HX connects to third-party fitness apps, while the Heat Row's Performance model features more advanced workout metrics through its TFT 2.0 console. You won't find any pushy subscription upsells or locked features here.
Shipping doesn't come free
Life Fitness charges for shipping on their rowing machines, with the Row HX Trainer incurring around $176 in delivery fees in our test case. While this might feel like an unwelcome addition to the already premium price tag, it's reasonable for heavy fitness equipment.
Return policies that might make you think twice
Life Fitness allows returns within 30 days of delivery, but be prepared for a significant 20% restocking fee on all rowing machines. That means returning your $1,849 Row HX Trainer could cost you nearly $370 in restocking fees alone, not counting the non-refundable original shipping and installation charges. If you're on the fence about a Life Fitness rowing machine, this policy might push you toward competitors with more generous return terms.
Warranty coverage reflects commercial-grade confidence
Life Fitness does back their rowing machines with included warranties, however. The Row HX Trainer comes with a robust 5-year frame warranty, 3 years on tank and seals, 2 years on mechanical components, and 1 year each for the console and labor. Similarly, the Heat Row offers 3 years on the frame, 2 years on mechanical parts, and 1 year on electrical components and labor.
Life Fitness holds a solid "B" grade with the BBB, but customer voices are scarce
Life Fitness maintains a "B" rating with the Better Business Bureau, with the downgrade from an "A" or "A+" resulting from a single unanswered complaint. On Trustpilot, though, Life Fitness rowing machines barely make a splash with just two reviews averaging 2.9 stars - and neither review specifically mentions their rowing machines. The real story comes from product listing reviews, where Life Fitness rowing machines receive mixed feedback. One satisfied Heat Row owner praises the "excellent machines", while others report frustrations ranging from "foot straps that come loose" to connectivity issues with the "pointless Bluetooth capability" - apparently, at that time, the rowers didn't work with Life Fitness' own app. Several reviewers express disappointment with technical support, with one noting they "tried over and over" to contact the company about returning their Life Fitness rowing machine without success.
Most home users will find better options elsewhere
Life Fitness delivers rowing machines with the same commercial-grade construction that has made their treadmills and ellipticals gym favorites for decades. But at $1,849+ with significant shipping costs, restocking fees, and mixed customer experiences, these rowing machines should give home users pause. After all, our top-rated rowing machines are available for half the price, are nearly indestructible, and come strongly recommended by most serious rowers. If you're determined to recreate the gym experience at home and budget isn't a concern, Life Fitness rowing machines will do alright - but you'll likely find the experience is more akin to being a gym owner than a patron, complete with all the behind-the-scenes maintenance costs.
Fair
Founded in 2018, this rowing machine company claims its founder Eric Zeng abandoned his law career to design fitness equipment for his chronically ill wife. While that's a touching narrative of love-driven innovation, the generic website riddled with grammatical errors and suspiciously perfect 5-star reviews tells a different story. Yosuda's rowing machines are budget-friendly, but we'll discuss whether this newcomer delivers substance behind its sentimental marketing in this review.
Yosuda keeps it simple with a focused lineup
At the time of our review, Yosuda offered just three rowing machine models, with one sold out. The two available models both sit on the budget end of the rowing machine market, with one entry-level option and one mid-range offering that provides more features while still remaining more affordable than premium brands. Both Yosuda rowing machines promise quiet operation and space-efficient design, but let's take a closer look at each in-stock model:
Shipping is free but returns might cost you
While Yosuda doesn't explicitly advertise free shipping, we found they didn't charge for delivery when we tested the checkout with our address. Their return policy, however, is where you need to pay attention. You'll have 30 days to return unopened, unused products in original packaging, but be prepared for a 10% restocking fee if the return is your fault (which covers everything from buyer's remorse to ordering mistakes). If you want to return because of a company error like defective parts or wrong items, Yosuda will cover return shipping.
Yosuda's reputation is suspiciously pristine on-site but questionable elsewhere
Yosuda doesn't appear to have a Better Business Bureau listing, which isn't uncommon for smaller fitness equipment manufacturers but does limit your recourse options. Their Trustpilot presence is concerning - with only 4 reviews total, and most seeming potentially manufactured. The one authentic-sounding review paints a troubling picture of customer service: "Product is great! Customer service response is less than 1 star. I emailed, called, texted. No reply in 20 hours. Why buy from them?" Meanwhile, Yosuda's own website shows perfect 5-star averages across all their rowing machines, which should raise eyebrows. Even the most reputable rowing machine brands receive occasional complaints - perfect scores across the board suggests either heavy moderation or fabricated reviews (or both).
Yosuda is a budget gamble that might pay off if you're lucky
Yosuda rowing machines represent the classic budget dilemma you'll likely encounter during Cyber Monday deal hunting. While scattered reviews from satisfied customers suggest these rowing machines can deliver basic functionality at rock-bottom prices, they're definitely not the right choice if you value reliable customer support or quick repairs. The price points are low enough that you're not risking a small fortune on Yosuda equipment, but purchase with the clear understanding that you're essentially on your own if something goes wrong. Think of the warranty as a lottery ticket rather than a guarantee - if you do manage to get support when needed, consider it a pleasant surprise rather than an expected service. For beginners testing the waters of rowing without a major investment, Yosuda might suffice, but serious fitness enthusiasts or those who want peace of mind should invest in a more reputable rowing machine brand.
Subpar
Founded in 1975 and headquartered in Logan, Utah, NordicTrack has evolved from its origins making Nordic ski machines to become a powerhouse in the home fitness equipment space. NordicTrack's rowing machines represent just one facet of their extensive fitness lineup - but how do these rowers stack up against dedicated rowing specialists? While their smart features and sleek displays certainly catch the eye, you'll want to read on to discover if NordicTrack's rowing machines deliver the authentic rowing experience and durability that serious fitness enthusiasts demand.
Magnetic resistance rowers from $899
All NordicTrack rowing machine models utilize Silent Magnetic Resistance (SMR) technology, offering a smooth, quiet rowing experience with 26 digital resistance levels to accommodate various fitness goals. Each NordicTrack rower comes equipped with an HD touchscreen display and integration with iFIT, their interactive fitness platform that provides global rowing experiences and trainer-led workouts. The iFIT SmartAdjust technology is standard across all models, automatically adjusting resistance to match your fitness level during workouts. NordicTrack keeps the construction consistent with durable materials built to withstand intensive training, while also incorporating user comfort features like adjustable foot straps and ergonomic seating. The primary distinction between NordicTrack models lies in their display screen sizes:
iFIT subscription is optional, but the rowing experience isn't equal without it
While NordicTrack rowers work perfectly fine in manual mode without a subscription, you'll miss out on what makes these machines special. The free version of iFIT offers basic functionality and some built-in workouts, but upgrading to a paid membership (Train tier at $15/month or $144/year, or Pro tier at $39/month or $396/year) unlocks the full NordicTrack rowing experience with trainer-controlled resistance, global scenic rows, and on-demand classes. You'll still see your workout stats and control resistance without a subscription, but the interactive elements that distinguish NordicTrack from basic rowing machines remain locked behind the paywall.
Shipping is free, but return policies come with some fine print
All NordicTrack rowing machines ship free to your door, which is a nice perk when you're investing in fitness equipment that weighs as much as a small rhinoceros. When it comes to returns, however, NordicTrack isn't quite as generous. If your rowing romance doesn't work out, you'll need to request a return within 30 days of delivery and brace yourself for a hefty $250 return shipping charge plus a 10% restocking fee. The company also requires a signature upon delivery, with three attempts made before your rowing machine gets shipped back to the warehouse - potentially triggering those same return fees.
NordicTrack's warranty is decent but won't cover everything forever
NordicTrack backs their rowing machines with a multi-tiered warranty package that includes 10 years on the frame, 2 years on parts, and 1 year each for the tablet and labor. Each NordicTrack rowing machine comes with specific warranty details in the user manual, which you'll find in the box or online. While this coverage is fairly standard for premium rowing equipment, it's worth noting that some customers report difficulties and expenses when seeking repairs after the warranty period.
NordicTrack earns an "A+" from the BBB...
While NordicTrack boasts an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau (though without accreditation), the rowing machine manufacturer's reputation seems to exist in two parallel universes. The positive reviews - many suspiciously noting they received "a reduced price in exchange for [their] honest and unbiased opinion" - praise everything from the "smooth rowing stroke" to how the machines are "quiet and sturdy with a great display." But peek at feedback from customers who've owned their NordicTrack rowers for six months or longer, and you'll discover a very different narrative.
...but long-term owners tell the other side of the story
The honeymoon period with NordicTrack rowing machines appears to end abruptly for many users. "I purchased a Nordic Track RW9,000 rowing machine in 2021... despite light usage, it has required repairs 3 times," laments one customer, describing how the rowing belt repeatedly wears through and breaks. Another owner found themselves facing a $500 console replacement - nearly a quarter of the machine's original price - after just two years of light use. Perhaps most troubling is the consistent theme of expensive repairs and difficult customer service interactions, with one owner reporting that local repair shops "will not deal with NordicTrack due to their poor customer service." When investing in home fitness equipment that should last for years, these long-term reliability concerns raise serious questions about NordicTrack's value proposition.
NordicTrack rowing machines earn a disappointing score from us
When you spend over $1,000 on a NordicTrack rowing machine, you're essentially placing a bet on its longevity - and based on user experiences, it's a gamble you're likely to lose. While the initial rowing experience might impress, the parade of broken belts, failed consoles, and astronomical repair costs ($200 just to get a technician through the door, by the way!) makes these machines a dubious long-term investment. Compare this to a gym membership where that broken rowing machine is someone else's problem, and suddenly paying NordicTrack's premium prices to own one yourself seems even less wise. If you're determined to bring a rowing machine home, we strongly recommend exploring alternatives that won't leave you stranded with a 200-pound paperweight and a depleted bank account after the warranty expires.
Subpar
Xterra Fitness is somewhat enigmatic in the rowing machine market. The brand operates as a sister company to Sole and Spirit Fitness, yet finding credible information about Xterra specifically feels like rowing upstream without oars. A conspicuous lack of online presence and third-party reviews never inspires confidence when you're investing in fitness equipment. While Xterra offers both water and magnetic rowing machines at typical price points, the question remains: can this shadowy brand deliver quality rowing experiences when there's so little transparency? Let's dive deeper before you commit your hard-earned dollars to an Xterra rowing machine.
6 models from $399
Xterra's rowing machines share several features across their lineup of 6 models (3 magnetic and 3 water resistance options). Many Xterra rowers feature aluminum seat slide rails, LED displays with workout metrics, Bluetooth FTMS connectivity for third-party apps like Kinomap, and space-saving vertical storage designs with transport wheels. Most models include heart rate monitoring capability (though chest straps are sold separately), contoured comfort seats, and pivoting foot pedals with adjustable straps. Xterra rowing machines emphasize quiet operation, though the water rowers will naturally produce more sound than their magnetic counterparts. Let's take a look at their highest priced and their lowest priced offerings:
Xterra's subscription service is affordable but lacks live classes
Xterra Fitness doesn't require a subscription to use their rowing machines (which, shockingly, isn't always the case with rival retailers), but they do offer an optional XTERRA+ app experience that costs $9.99 monthly or $99 annually (saving you $20). While owners of qualifying Xterra rowing machines receive this membership for free with their serial number, everyone gets access to the same content: over 3,000 on-demand workout classes across 10 categories including rowing, cycling, boxing, yoga, and meditation. The XTERRA+ app lets you sort workouts by trainer, category, intensity, and duration while tracking your progress and goals, but don't expect live classes or scenic rows like some competitors offer.
Xterra's policies are a mixed bag, with several extra fees to watch for
Xterra Fitness provides a 30-day return window for their rowing machines, but you'll be responsible for return shipping costs plus a 10% restocking fee in most cases. While some Xterra rowing machines come with free shipping, it varies by model. Warranties also vary by model, with premium options like the ERG800W Torpedo receiving extended warranties (3 years on the frame) compared to budget models like the ERG180 (just 1 year). When service is needed, Xterra offers phone support where representatives will attempt troubleshooting or connect you with local service options, though out-of-warranty customers must purchase replacement parts directly through email.
Nearly zero online reviews, which is concerning for a fitness equipment maker
Xterra Fitness operates in a worrying review vacuum, with no Better Business Bureau listing, no Trustpilot presence, and virtually no customer feedback on independent websites or forums. This lack of public accountability should raise red flags for anyone considering one of their rowing machines. The only "reviews" we could find were on Xterra's own product listings, including suspiciously polished testimonials for models like the ERG180 that displayed tell-tale signs of manufactured feedback. While this doesn't automatically mean Xterra's rowing machines are problematic, it does mean you'd be purchasing one without the safety net of verified customer experiences that typically guide smart buying decisions in the fitness equipment market.
Xterra's online anonymity makes their rowing machines a risky proposition
We simply can't recommend Xterra Fitness highly when they maintain such a ghost-like presence online. Their rowing machines might be perfectly functional (or even exceptional), but with virtually zero independent customer reviews, we're left in the dark about how these machines actually perform in real homes over time. Will the seat still glide smoothly after six months? Does Xterra actually honor their warranty claims? The absence of this crucial feedback forces us to assign Xterra a lower rating. While their budget-friendly models like the ERG180 don't represent a massive financial gamble, we'd suggest looking at alternatives from more established rowing machine manufacturers before taking a chance on Xterra's mysteriously review-free equipment.
Weak
Part of the ICON Health & Fitness family (alongside brands like NordicTrack and iFIT), ProForm positions itself as the rowing machine solution for "life pros" who need efficient workouts that fit into busy schedules. Their focus on space-saving designs and integrated technology through iFIT connectivity shows promise, but as we'll explore, ProForm's rowing machines come with some notable limitations that might make you think twice before committing to their ecosystem. Will their streamlined lineup of just two rowing machines deliver the quality and value you're looking for? Let's find out.
Magnetic resistance rowers from $599
Both ProForm rowers utilize silent magnetic resistance technology that ensures your workouts won't disturb the household, while offering space-saving folding designs that address the practical concerns many home users face. Each model integrates with iFIT's subscription service, providing access to trainer-led workouts where resistance adjusts automatically to match the program. Let's take a closer look:
iFIT membership is unavoidable at checkout but optional for basic use
ProForm rowing machines technically function without a subscription in "manual mode," but there's a catch: you're forced to select an iFIT membership option during checkout ($39/month, $396/year, or $699/two years). ProForm clearly pushes you toward their ecosystem by automatically adding extras to your cart (like a $99 heart rate monitor you'll need to manually remove during checkout). ProForm's refusal to let customers avoid the iFIT universe is just one example of the growing problem with subscription models across all industries. Companies are pushing consumers to pay monthly fees for things we used to buy once and own forever - from software to fitness equipment to cars. This shift puts more money in corporate pockets while leaving consumers stuck paying endless fees for basic functionality. We're definitely not happy about this trend, nor ProForm's participation in it.
The iFIT subscription includes workouts of all kinds
Since you're going to be strong-armed into it anyway, you might be asking what you get with a paid iFIT membership. Your ProForm rower becomes significantly more capable, offering trainer-led workouts where resistance adjusts automatically to match the program, streaming options for entertainment during exercise, and a variety of workout types beyond just rowing (strength, pilates, yoga, HIIT, and meditation). The mobile app integration allows for workout scheduling through their AI Coach, custom workout creation, and syncing with third-party fitness platforms like Strava and Apple Health.
Free shipping, but buyer beware when it comes to returns
ProForm makes shipping your rowing machine easy on the wallet with $0 standard delivery (a nice touch when you're already spending upwards of $599). But their return policy? That's where things get complicated. If your ProForm rower doesn't meet expectations, you've got 30 days from delivery to request a return - but brace yourself for a hefty $250 return shipping charge plus a 10% restocking fee. Once your rowing machine ships, these fees are unavoidable. ProForm also warns that any assembly service you've paid for is non-refundable, and returned products must include all parts and accessories or you'll face an additional 10% charge. They're clearly hoping you'll just keep the rower rather than navigate this return obstacle course.
Warranty coverage that reflects your investment level
ProForm rowing machines come with warranty protection that varies by model but generally includes a 5-year frame warranty backed by 1-year coverage on parts and labor. For ProForm owners, this means your investment is reasonably protected against manufacturing defects, but as with most fitness equipment warranties, normal wear and tear isn't covered.
Buyer beware: ProForm's machines are high-maintenance
ProForm's rowing machines might look elegant in product photos, but the company's customer feedback tells a more troubling story. Recurring complaints focus on hardware failures ("the bungee cord popped" after just 8 months), synchronization problems ("rower would not sync with console at 11 months"), and frustrating customer service experiences. One disappointed owner summarized their experience: "We purchased a rower through Costco and out of the box the display didn't work... They wanted me to get a brand new piece of equipment FIXED to get it working?" Another ProForm rowing machine owner was shocked when replacement parts cost nearly as much as their entire machine: "I purchased a rower proform 220R 8 months ago and the bungee cord popped. I called and the part itself is over $200. I purchased this rower for $250." Even when ProForm's customer service does respond, resolution can be painfully slow - as one reviewer noted after multiple technician visits and over six months of waiting for repairs.
ProForm rowing machines can't row away from fundamental flaws
ProForm represents everything frustrating about today's fitness equipment landscape: flashy machines that strong-arm you into recurring subscriptions while falling apart faster than your New Year's resolution. Their rowing machines join the subscription-model bandwagon with mandatory iFIT membership selection at checkout, yet can't seem to master the basics of durability - with bungee cords snapping, consoles failing, and replacement parts sometimes costing nearly as much as the original machine. (Planned obsolescence, anyone?) When your ProForm rowing machine inevitably requires service, prepare for a nightmare of a customer support experience and a hefty bill. While ProForm's rowers might look sleek in promotional photos, the combination of aggressive subscription tactics, questionable build quality, and painful return policies means most rowing enthusiasts would be better served looking elsewhere. (Unless, of course, you enjoy the workout that comes from repeatedly reaching for your wallet).
Poor
Founded on the principle of "echelon" formation - where cyclists work together to go farther and faster - Echelon Fitness positions itself as a community-focused alternative in the connected rowing machine market. Their two budget-friendly rowing machines might catch your eye with their sub to $1,000 price tags, but as you'll discover in our review, Echelon's approach to fitness equipment comes with some significant asterisks.
Two machines under $1,000
Echelon offers just two rowing machine models, with minimal customization options and a narrow price range:
Beware the subscription bait-and-switch
While Echelon rowing machines tempt with their sub to $1,000 price tags, there's a costly asterisk attached. Unlike competitors that offer functional standalone equipment, Echelon's rowing machines are essentially expensive paperweights without their Premier membership ($39. 99/month or $399. 99 annually). Even basic "free row" functionality requires an active internet connection and app login. This subscription-dependent model has sparked widespread customer frustration, with numerous reviewers reporting that after software updates, their machines became unusable without maintaining the subscription. When evaluating Echelon's seemingly budget-friendly rowing machines, remember to factor in this ongoing cost - over just three years, you'll spend more on subscriptions than on the actual hardware.
Free shipping isn't really free
Echelon's shipping policy feels like a rowing machine workout itself: full of resistance. While they advertise "Free Shipping" with their rowing machines, the fine print reveals this only applies when you purchase an annual Premier Membership. Expect delivery within 2-3 business days for smaller items (under 150 lbs), but rowing machines may take 10-14 days through FedEx Freight, which only delivers to ground level - so hope you don't live in a walk-up apartment or you'll be lugging your new Echelon machine up the stairs yourself.
30-day returns that come with hoops to jump through
Echelon allows returns within 30 days of delivery, but your rowing machine must be returned in "brand new, re-sellable condition" with all original packaging, manuals, and accessories. While they provide a prepaid shipping label, Echelon reserves the right to deduct fees or deny returns if they determine the product shows any signs of use or damage. After 30 days? You're completely out of luck, as Echelon flatly states that "return requests after 30 days from delivery date will not be accepted."
Warranty protection that costs extra
In perhaps the most questionable policy among rowing machine manufacturers, Echelon doesn't appear to include a warranty with their machines unless you pay extra. Extended warranty packages range from $60 (1 year) to $240 (4 years). This reflects Echelon's subscription-and-upcharge-focused business model where the initial purchase price is just the beginning of your financial relationship.
Customers don't mince words about their Echelon disappointment
With a dismal 1.4-star average rating from 176 reviews on Trustpilot, Echelon's rowing machines have rowed their way into troubled waters. "Absolutely the worst company to deal with. Do not buy anything from them. The equipment is such poor quality and their customer service department is not helpful whatsoever," writes one frustrated customer. The recurring theme in negative reviews isn't just about hardware issues - it's about Echelon's business practices. Another customer explains their predicament: "I bought an Echelon product to own it, not to rent it. But after a recent forced software update, the bike I paid for now requires an internet connection just to function, even in basic mode." Even positive reviews come with asterisks, like one user who loves their EX5s bike but laments, "YOU HAVE TO PAY just to see your personal statistics which is really ridiculous when you buy an expensive, connected piece of exercise equipment." When it comes to Echelon rowing machines, the stream of customer experiences suggests you're better off pulling in a different direction.
Echelon's nickel-and-dime business model leaves rowers high and dry
Echelon has perfected the art of the upsell, turning what should be a straightforward rowing machine purchase into a labyrinth of additional charges. From the misleading "free shipping" that's only free with an annual membership, to the paid warranties that should come standard, to the forced internet connectivity that renders your machine useless without a subscription - Echelon treats its rowing machines as mere gateways to your wallet rather than fitness solutions. This is a business model built on extracting maximum revenue after the initial purchase, not on customer satisfaction. We cannot recommend Echelon rowing machines to anyone seeking a reliable, hassle-free rowing experience. We especially urge fitness enthusiasts who value ownership rights, offline workout capabilities, or transparent pricing to avoid Echelon's rowing machines entirely - unless you enjoy paying subscription fees just to access basic functions on equipment you thought you owned.
Poor
Originally engineered for hotel fitness centers, Sole Fitness brings decades of commercial-grade durability to home rowing machines. While the North American company has built its reputation primarily on treadmills (their website is even called SoleTreadmills, which doesn't exactly inspire confidence in their rowing expertise), their single rowing machine offering - the SR550 - attempts to merge air and magnetic resistance systems for a premium experience. But can a company known for helping hotel guests get their cardio in successfully translate that expertise to the specialized world of rowing?
One model to rule them all, but does it succeed?
Sole Fitness offers just a single rowing machine in their product line - the SR550 ($1,499) - which combines both air and magnetic resistance systems for a supposed "on the water" feeling. Built around a long aluminum rail that accommodates users of various heights (with an impressive 400-pound weight capacity), this Sole rowing machine attempts to stand out with its 10.1-inch touchscreen display and smart features. You'll find 10 pre-programmed workouts plus 12 user-defined options, all controllable via both the console and conveniently placed handlebar adjustments. Sole highlights Bluetooth connectivity, integrated speakers, and compatibility with their free Sole+ app for workout tracking. The folding design with transport wheels adds practical functionality.
No subscription required, but Sole's free app isn't winning any races
Sole Fitness offers their SR550 rower with completely free access to their Sole+ app. This app delivers hundreds of workout videos spanning from beginner to advanced routines, ranging from quick 10-minute sessions to hour-long endurance challenges. While Sole emphasizes their "professional fitness trainers" and heart rate metric integration, user reviews paint a different picture of the experience. The app has been criticized for being difficult to navigate and severely limited in its ability to export workout data to other fitness platforms. One particularly frustrated user noted that when you finally figure out how to share your rowing machine data, it only communicates workout duration - no calories, distance, or heart rate information follows. Even worse, some users discovered concerning language in the terms of service about Sole "globally transmitting" personal data. (We suppose they recoup what they lose in subscription fees by selling your personal information to the highest bidder).
Buyer beware: Sole's return policies will leave your wallet bare
If you're eyeing a Sole Fitness rowing machine, prepare to pay for shipping. You'll pay around $50 for basic curbside delivery, $250 for room-of-choice service, or $400 if you want delivery and assembly. And if you're not satisfied? Sole's 30-day return policy sounds generous until you read the fine print: returns come with a substantial $300 shipping fee plus a 10% restocking charge. Unlike some competitors, Sole at least doesn't require you to repackage the rowing machine yourself, but returns must be placed outside for pickup.
Sole's reputation is treading water, with serious warning signs
Before purchasing a Sole Fitness rowing machine, you should know their reputation is shaky. Sole has earned an abysmal "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau for failing to respond to multiple complaints, leaving several customer issues completely unresolved. While specific rowing machine reviews are scarce, the overall customer sentiment paints a concerning picture. Their positive reviews often appear suspiciously timed, with many glowing testimonials obviously being written immediately after sales calls, but before the rowing machine has arrived - not exactly a vote of confidence in their actual products. One satisfied rowing machine owner did praise Sole's responsiveness when their console broke: "JW and the team at Sole were fast, responsive, cool and easy to work with." However, the negative reviews are far more troubling, with customers describing Sole as a "scam company" with "awful customer service" where representatives are "rude, argumentative, and show zero respect." Some users even suggest the company might be using fake service representative names and pushing returned hotel equipment onto residential customers. For a fitness company, Sole certainly seems to be running from accountability.
Sole Fitness is on thin ice
When it comes to rowing machines, Sole Fitness falls dramatically short of the finish line. Despite offering decent warranties and subscription-free workouts, the company sinks under the weight of its predatory return policies, abysmal customer service, and questionable app functionality. The SR550 rower itself might perform adequately, but when backed by an "F"-rated BBB business with a reputation for arguing with customers rather than helping them, we simply cannot recommend Sole Fitness rowing machines to anyone who values their sanity or budget. Your fitness journey deserves better equipment from a company that will actually stand behind their products should issues arise. For a similar price point, you'll find rowing machines from competitors that won't leave you stranded mid-stroke when problems occur.
Continued from above...
If you're looking for a full-body workout that's gentle on your joints but tough on calories, a rowing machine might be exactly what you need. These versatile fitness devices have surged in popularity recently, and for good reason - rowing machines offer one of the most efficient workouts available, engaging over 85% of your muscles while providing both cardiovascular and strength benefits. The rhythmic motion also promotes better posture and core strength, which can alleviate back pain for many users. (Your spine will thank you).
Who benefits from rowing machines? Just about everyone, as it turns out. Fitness enthusiasts appreciate how rowing machines deliver high-intensity workouts with minimal impact on joints. Rehabilitation patients find rowing machines ideal for rebuilding strength without risking further injury. Even busy professionals gravitate toward rowing machines because they offer time-efficient workouts that burn significant calories in shorter sessions. And for those with limited space, many rowing machines can be folded away when not in use - perfect for apartment dwellers who don't want a treadmill dominating their living room.
However, not all rowing machines are created equal. The market offers distinct variations that cater to different preferences and training goals. Some use water resistance to create a smooth, natural feeling reminiscent of actual rowing on water. Others employ air resistance that responds dynamically to your effort - row harder and you'll feel greater resistance. Magnetic resistance models offer whisper-quiet operation ideal for apartment dwellers (your downstairs neighbors will never know you're working out at 5 AM), while hydraulic rowers typically provide the most compact footprint for those with space constraints.
When shopping for a rowing machine online, several factors should guide your decision:
Selecting the right rowing machine requires balancing these considerations against your budget and fitness goals. The good news is that the market now offers excellent options at various price points. Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best rowing machines available based on quality, performance, and value. We hope this review helps you find the best rowing machine for your home fitness journey - and puts you well on your way to achieving those fitness goals.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
