Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Good Sam vs Liberty Mutual

Monday, March 24th

2025 RV Insurance Reviews

Good Sam Review 2.5 Star Rating

Good Sam

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing: 6-month policy for $1,058 (reduced from $1,163 with discounts) for a 2022 Winnebago Travato
  • Multi-carrier agency offering potential for lower rates and wider coverage
  • Coverage available for full-time RVers and weekend campers
  • Storage Option allows premium reduction up to 53% during non-use periods
  • Comprehensive coverage options including liability, collision, and personal belongings
  • Multiple discount opportunities (Multi-Vehicle, Paid-in-Full, Multi-Policy)
  • Coverage for various RV types, including motorhomes and pull-behind trailers
  • Insurance protection for RV owners renting out their vehicles through Good Sam
  • Tiered roadside assistance packages available (sold separately)
  • "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau

Good Sam RV insurance looks pretty nice at first glance, offering coverage for DIY RV builds and touting numerous discounts. However, you may find that the reality doesn't quite match the hype. For one, their roadside assistance - while sounding great on paper - often fails to deliver when you need it most. And, because Good Sam is solely a broker working with multiple underwriters, it's hard to predict what your claims experience might be like. On top of that, they charge for 6 months what you'll spend in a year with other RV insurance providers. While we appreciate that they offer coverage for renters, Good Sam's RV insurance isn't our top choice. You'd be better off exploring other options that provide more reliable service at lower prices.

Liberty Mutual Review 2.5 Star Rating

Liberty Mutual

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing: Not specified; quotes available by phone
  • Strong financial ratings ("A” from A.M. Best, "A2” from Moody's, "A” from Standard & Poor's)
  • Comprehensive coverage available
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance offered
  • Agreed value for total loss replacement
  • Roadside assistance for RVs
  • Class B motorhomes covered under auto insurance policies
  • Other RV types covered through sister company Safeco
  • Potential auto discounts (multi-policy, claims-free, online purchase) may also apply to RV policies

Liberty Mutual offers RV insurance, but it shouldn't be your first choice unless you're already a policy-holder with them. While they have strong financial ratings, their RV insurance offerings seem like an afterthought. You'll find it challenging to get detailed information or an online quote for RV insurance, as their website is vague and you'll need to call for specifics. They don't cover full-time RVers or DIY builds and it's not clear what discounts apply. Given their lack of transparency and limited RV-specific coverage, we recommend exploring options with higher-ranked companies that specialize in RV insurance.

What is the Best RV Insurance Company?

If you're hitting the road in an RV, insurance is a must-have to protect your investment and your peace of mind. Whether you're a full-time traveler, weekend warrior, or using your RV seasonally, specialized RV insurance offers protection beyond standard auto policies. Unlike a car, an RV can function as both a vehicle and a living space, which means it faces unique risks.

RV insurance covers everything from accidents on the road to theft, damage, and liability while you're parked at a campsite. It ensures that both your transportation and your home-on-wheels are safeguarded. One of the biggest benefits of RV insurance is that it can protect you from unexpected costs.

The Best RV Insurance Compare RV Insurance Compare RV Insurance Reviews What are the best RV Insurance Best RV Insurance Reviews

RV Insurance FAQ

Before purchasing RV insurance, you'll need to gather all the necessary details about your RV, like its make, model, year, and mileage. You'll also need to know how much coverage you want for liability, collision, and personal belongings. You'll be asked questions about how often you use your RV and whether you'll be living in it full-time, as that can affect the type of coverage you need. You should always compare quotes from different companies to find the best rate for coverage that fits your lifestyle.
RV insurance covers not only driving risks, like auto insurance, but also living-related risks if you use your RV as a home. RV-specific policies can include protection for your personal belongings, liability coverage for injuries on your "property," and coverage for emergencies or roadside assistance. Regular auto insurance doesn't usually offer these kinds of protections, so it's essential to get a policy designed for RVs.
To find the best rates, compare quotes from multiple insurers and look for discounts like safe driver rewards or bundling with other insurance policies. Online tools make it easier to enter your RV's details once and get multiple quotes. Make sure to compare not just the price, but the coverage options, limits, and exclusions, as cheaper policies may not offer the protection you need.
Some RV insurance policies include coverage for full-time living, which is similar to homeowners insurance. It protects against personal liability, theft, and damage to your belongings while you're living in the RV. Be sure to let the insurance company know if you live in your RV year-round, as this might require special coverage that isn't included in part-time RV insurance.
When buying RV insurance, look for coverage that includes liability, collision, and comprehensive insurance, which protect you from damages to other people, your RV, and non-accident-related incidents like theft or weather damage. If you live in your RV full-time, look for personal liability and belongings coverage. You might also want roadside assistance and vacation liability coverage for times when your RV is parked and used as a living space.
Roadside assistance is not always included in standard RV insurance policies, but it can be added as an option. This coverage helps with services like towing, flat tire repairs, or battery jumpstarts if your RV breaks down. It's a valuable add-on, especially for RV owners who travel long distances or camp in remote locations. (What if you run out of gas on a long stretch of road? You'll be wishing you'd purchased roadside assistance if you do.)
Yes, if you rent out your RV, you may need additional coverage beyond a standard RV insurance policy. Some insurers offer policies designed for RV rentals, covering risks like damage from renters or liability issues. Be sure to inform your insurance company if you plan to rent out your RV, as not all policies allow it without an adjustment, and you could be liable for amounts in the 6 figures in case of an accident involving an unapproved driver.
Federally, if your RV weighs over 26,000 pounds, you may be required to hold a special Commercial Driver's License (CDL) or a non-commercial special license, depending on your state. Failing to have the proper license could result in denied insurance claims if you're involved in an accident, as you wouldn't be legally qualified to drive the vehicle. Be sure to check both federal and state requirements in your state and the ones you plan to drive through to be compliant and fully covered.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

For example, if you're in an accident and your RV is damaged, repair bills can quickly pile up. Similarly, if someone gets hurt in your RV, you could be liable for their medical expenses without the right coverage. Even less obvious risks, like damage from severe weather or theft of personal belongings inside the RV, can be covered under the right plan.

When you begin shopping for RV insurance, you'll quickly notice that different types of coverage exist. Basic policies include liability insurance, which covers the cost of damages or injuries you cause in an accident. However, comprehensive policies provide additional protection for events like theft, fire, or storm damage. Another option is collision coverage, which specifically pays for repairs or replacements if you crash your RV.

You might also hear about Total Loss Replacement and Actual Cash Value (ACV) coverage. Total Loss Replacement will pay for a brand-new RV if yours is totaled within the first few years of ownership, while ACV only gives you the depreciated value of your RV at the time of the accident. These types of policies can make a huge difference in your payout if something goes wrong.

You may notice that some services are direct insurance companies, while others are brokers. Insurance companies underwrite their own policies, meaning they manage claims and coverage in-house. Brokers, on the other hand, work with multiple insurance providers to find the best policy for you. There's value in choosing a broker because they can compare coverage and rates across various insurers, offering a wider selection and helping you find the most competitive prices. Brokers can also advocate for you if there's ever an issue with your policy and offer personalized service that insurance companies may not always provide.

Not every RV insurance provider covers all types of RVs or situations, which is important to keep in mind when shopping for coverage. Some insurers may not offer policies for DIY or custom-built RVs, while others might exclude full-time RVers, who live in their vehicles year-round. Full-timer coverage is often treated like homeowner's insurance, providing liability and personal property protection, but not every company offers it. Likewise, if you've built or heavily modified your own RV, it may be more challenging to find an insurer that will cover it, since factory-made vehicles are less risky.

To help you make an informed decision, here are a few key considerations when shopping for RV insurance online:

  • Liability coverage. Make sure your policy covers at least the minimum liability required by your state, but consider higher limits to protect against costly lawsuits or large accidents.
  • Comprehensive and collision coverage. Look for policies that offer coverage for events beyond collisions, such as fire, theft, and storm damage. This is crucial for RVs, which are often more vulnerable to these risks than regular cars.
  • Full-timer coverage. If your RV is your primary residence, make sure your insurance provides full-time living coverage, which acts like homeowner's insurance, protecting you from liability, property loss, and other residential risks.
  • Roadside assistance. Some insurers include roadside assistance in their policies, which can save you from expensive towing and emergency repair costs while traveling.
  • Personal belongings coverage. Check whether the policy covers your personal items inside the RV, especially if you travel with valuable electronics or other high-cost items.
  • Financial strength. Choose an insurer with a strong financial strength rating, such as an "A+” from AM Best. This indicates the company's ability to pay claims, which is critical in case you experience a major loss.

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the leading RV insurance providers available. We hope these reviews help you find the best service to suit your needs and keep your adventures on the road worry-free.

The Best Reviews of RV Insurance