Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Scar Creams

Which Scar Creams Are the Most Effective?

Scars are the visible reminders of our body's incredible ability to heal wounds. While some scars may hold sentimental value, most of us desire smooth, blemish-free skin. Whether the scars are from childhood mishaps, kitchen accidents, car crashes, or surgical procedures, finding ways to reduce their appearance is a common goal - especially when they're visible during our day-to-day activities or when we're wearing our favorite swimsuits.

When the deep layer of skin, known as the dermis, is damaged, our body initiates the healing process by producing new collagen fibers to close the wound. However, this healing area often appears different from the surrounding skin, resulting in a noticeable scar.

Wednesday, July 17th

2024 Scar Cream Reviews

Nuvadermis Advanced Scar Gel Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Nuvadermis Advanced Scar Gel

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Nuvadermis is a skincare brand that offers a range of products for moisturization, anti-aging, acne, and scars. Their scar treatments are formulated with high-quality ingredients and are cruelty-free. The flagship product, Advanced Scar Gel, is priced at $19.11 for 1.7 oz and contains ingredients like retinol, allantoin, vitamin E, betaine, and panthenol. It can be used on both new and old scars of all types, along with complementary products like silicone scar sheets and scar tape. With nearly 10,000 five-star customer reviews and an average rating of 4.2 stars, Nuvadermis' scar treatments are the most highly-regarded on our list.

Scar Control Review 4.5 Star Rating

Scar Control

4.5 Star Rating

Forces of Nature is a trusted brand that specializes in natural, organic medicine. Their Scar Control product is designed to address all types of scarring, including burns, hypertrophic, and acne scars. The formula consists of a blend of natural ingredients such as marigold, mustard seed, quartz, and essential oils like helichrysum and rosemary, with 2-3 drops applied directly to the scar three times a day. With over 1000 positive customer reviews and a 90-day money-back guarantee, Forces of Nature's Scar Control is a highly recommended option for scar treatment.

H Scars Formula Review 4.5 Star Rating

H Scars Formula

4.5 Star Rating

Healing Natural Oils offers their H-Scars Formula, a 100% natural and homeopathic remedy for various types of scars, including keloids and acne. The formula contains active ingredients such as Calendula Officinalis 12C and Silicea 12C, along with essential oils. Users can expect visible results within 6-8 weeks for old scars and 4-8 weeks for new scars. The product comes with a 90-day money-back guarantee, and customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from over 400 reviews. With its effective and gentle formula, along with the company's strong reputation, H-Scars Formula remains a top choice for treating scars.

NewGel+E Review 4 Star Rating


4 Star Rating

NewGel+E is a highly recommended silicone scar treatment that combines medical-grade silicone with Vitamin E to reduce and improve the appearance of scars. It is suitable for various types of scars, both new and old. Priced at $33.25 for 0.5 oz, it may seem expensive, but a small amount goes a long way. Many users have given it five-star reviews, praising its effectiveness for different types of scars. While it lacks additional ingredients found in other scar treatments, NewGel+E remains a popular choice for those seeking a silicone-based solution.

Zenmed Review 3.5 Star Rating


3.5 Star Rating

ZENMED specializes in cruelty-free skincare products formulated by doctors with natural ingredients. While their Skin Eraser Kit is not specifically focused on major scars, it effectively addresses scarring and skin discoloration resulting from acne, aging, and sun damage. The kit includes a microdermabrasion scrub and a dark spot corrector serum, featuring ingredients like clay, activated charcoal, walnut shells, aloe, rosehip oil, and marine algae extract. Priced at $69.99 for a two-month supply, the Skin Eraser Kit is backed by a 60-day money-back guarantee. Customer reviews are largely positive, but it's important to note that the kit is primarily designed for facial use and may not be suitable for all types of scarring.

Dermefface FX7 Review 3 Star Rating

Dermefface FX7

3 Star Rating

Dermefface FX7 is a scar cream developed by Dr. Dave David as part of the Skinception line. It claims to reduce the appearance of scars using a combination of active ingredients, antioxidants, and moisturizers, best used for at least 3-4 months (or longer for deeper/older scarring). The product offers a 67-day return policy, but the lack of customer feedback and higher price compared to competitors may make it a less attractive option. While Dermefface FX7 shows potential, there are other scar creams that should be considered first.

Enessa Review 2.5 Star Rating


2.5 Star Rating

Enessa specializes in organic skincare products, offering a wide range of options such as cleansers, toners, sun protection, serums, elixirs, and moisturizers. Among their offerings is the Diminish-Scar treatment elixir, priced at $62 for a 15mL bottle. This scar remedy is formulated with certified organic ingredients rich in vitamin E and essential fatty acids, and is best used on scars that are no more than six months old. Customer feedback for Diminish-Scar is limited, and unfortunately Enessa only provides a 30-day exchange policy without mentioning refunds. Considering the higher price and lack of extensive customer feedback, Diminish-Scar ranks as slightly below average compared with other scar treatments in our review.

Scar Rid Review 2 Star Rating

Scar Rid

2 Star Rating

Approved Science offers a range of nutritional health supplements, including Scar Rid, a two-step system designed to fade scars, balance skin tone, reduce inflammation, and promote healing. The system consists of a silicone-based gel and a rejuvenating repair cream. When used together three times a day, they aim to improve the appearance of scars. However, there are concerns about the company's reputation, including discrepancies in product images and potentially fake customer reviews. Given Scar Rid's high price point of $72 for a one-month supply (or less), we recommend that you prioritize scar creams with more verified customer feedback and lower costs.

ScarAway Review 2 Star Rating


2 Star Rating

ScarAway offers a silicone-based scar treatment that combines reusable silicone sheets and a scar gel for improved results. The sheets are applied directly to the scar and can be cut or used in combination for larger scars, while the gel is applied alternately with the sheets for up to 10 consecutive days. The treatment costs $24.99 for the package, but customer reviews are generally negative, citing issues with adhesion and limited product quantity. Plus, ScarAway does not offer a return policy or satisfaction guarantee. Try a scar cream or other treatment that shows more consistent results and skip ScarAway.

Scar Recovery Gel Review 1 Star Rating

Scar Recovery Gel

1 Star Rating

Dermstore carries a wide range of professional-strength skincare products, including SkinMedica's Scar Recovery Gel. Made with a powerful blend of alpha hydroxy acids, antioxidants, essential oils and more, most people who've used this scar treatment have seen solid results. Unfortunately, it costs over $100 for a 2-oz bottle - which might have still been worth considering if it weren't for the fact that it comes with no satisfaction guarantee. Plus, Dermstore's reputation has taken a nosedive with hundreds of complaints and an "F" from the BBB. All of that means that Scar Recovery Gel is our lowest-ranked option among scar creams and other treatments.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Although scars naturally improve over time, they never fully disappear. Understanding the size, color, and location of the scar is crucial in determining the best approach to minimize its appearance. Fortunately, there are numerous over-the-counter solutions that can expedite scar healing and help conceal them more effectively than simply waiting for years and hoping for the best.

There are a lot of products on the market today, making big promises about changing the appearance of your scar. Of course, some are more effective than others. Before investing in a scar cream, it is important to consider the following factors:

  • Cost. Price doesn't always reflect value. Some lower-priced treatments yield comparable or even superior results to their higher-priced counterparts. Comparing the cost of different scar creams is important, but don't forget to factor in free shipping or other perks that can make your purchase a better value for the money.
  • Effectiveness. Customer feedback and before-and-after pictures can serve as valuable indicators of a scar cream's success. If a particular product has garnered high customer satisfaction, there is a good chance you will see positive results as well. After all, your biggest question is probably "does it actually work?" Customer reviews are a great way to answer that question.
  • Application. How often do you have to use the scar cream? A bottle will get used up pretty quickly if you have to apply it several times a day. Do you have to apply it at a particular time of day? Is there anything you should avoid while using it (for example, will it make your skin sensitive to sunlight)?
  • Refund policy. Each individual's healing process varies based on factors such as scar size, location, and tissue damage. Check if the scar cream you choose offers a satisfaction guarantee in case it proves ineffective for your specific scar.

To identify the scar creams that are most effective at boosting your body's natural healing process, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated the best - and the worst! - on the market today. We're confident that this will help you make an informed decision and find just the right product to reduce the appearance of your scar in no time.

The Best Scar Creams Compare Scar Creams Compare Scar Cream Reviews What are the best Scar Creams Best Scar Cream Reviews

Scar Cream FAQ

Scar creams are formulated to smooth out skin that has been affected by scarring. This might be from acne, a burn, or some other type of accident. Scar creams tighten the skin and blend the blemishes so they are less noticeable. Instead of being like makeup that needs to be used daily, it works over time to create more permanent healing.
Yes! Most scar creams are actually made of homeopathic ingredients that are safe for all skin types and won't cause weird side effects. In essence, it's like a healing lotion for the skin. This is a good option before trying prescription medications that have potentially harmful and aggressive ingredients.
Luckily there are usually customer reviews you can read about scar creams available online. Highly-rated scar creams often have hundreds of customers who can attest to the effectiveness of the solution and sometimes post before-and-after pictures to prove their healing process. Skin that has been damaged often needs some extra moisturizing and vitamins to aid the healing process, so scar creams are a great solution.
Compared to using a prescription medication or seeing a doctor, scar creams are very affordable. Usually for $20-$50 you'll get visible results that are permanent. Paying a little money upfront to have your skin looking healthy and smooth again is worth every penny!
Many online retailers provide a money-back guarantee that allows customers to get a full refund if they don't get results from the scar cream. Some companies let customers use the product for a few weeks and then return the empty or used bottles and get their money back.
It shouldn't! A scar cream should feel refreshing to your skin, just like lotion would. If you're using a scar cream with harsh chemicals, you might experience a burning sensation. However, we don't recommend this since you are trying to heal your skin, not cause more damage.
Every product is different, but you should expect to see results within a few weeks. The best thing to do is follow the application instructions perfectly for the best outcome. When you start seeing your skin look better, don't stop using the product. Continue using it until you are instructed to stop and your skin is at a place you're happy with. On the flip side, don't give up on a scar cream if you don't see a change in your skin within only a few days. It takes time and it will be worth it!
Almost all scar creams are the same when it comes to application. Whether you buy a product that comes in liquid or cream form, you'll apply it directly to the affected area. You might need to use it more than once daily for best results. You'll gently massage the scar cream into your skin until it's all soaked in.

Compare Scar Creams

Select any 2 Scar Creams to compare them head to head

See the Best Scar Cream
The Best Reviews of Scar Creams