The Best Seafood Companies

Tuesday, October 8th

2024 Seafood Company Reviews

Sizzlefish

• Prices range from: $9.99 to $455.15
• E-gift cards
• Free shipping on orders over $100
• $10 to $25 flat-rate shipping on orders <$100
• Subscription boxes
• Certified sustainable wild-caught
• Refunds within 7 days
• Highest ratings with reviewers

Sizzlefish originally emerged as a prominent supplier of fish and seafood to renowned natural and premium grocery companies in the United States. However, the owner had an epiphany: seafood and fish are excellent sources of protein for fitness and overall health, so why not make them accessible for direct shipping to individuals?

Pure, high quality fish

Their mission is straightforward: they aim to enhance customers' well-being and improve their lives by offering pure, top-notch fish that they can rely on, conveniently delivered to their doorsteps. Customers can count on them to provide natural fish portions, accompanied by useful tools and tips for easy and quick preparation, as well as transparent information about the benefits derived from Sizzlefish products.

Top option for variety

The abundance of options is staggering when it comes to what you can buy from this company. In fact, a more accurate question might be, what can't you buy? Their seafood selection includes tantalizing choices like shrimp, scallops, lobster, calamari, mussels, soft-shell crab, crab cakes, and king crab. But it doesn't stop there. Sizzlefish offers over a dozen fish varieties, ranging from well-known favorites like tuna and salmon to lesser-known delicacies such as sablefish and rockfish. Each product is conveniently packaged in individual portions, ensuring you can easily prepare the right amount for a single meal. Furthermore, their flash-freezing process guarantees peak freshness upon delivery.

Massive inventory and competitive pricing

In order to compare prices among different retailers in this review, we examined four specific products. We looked at the prices for traditional fish, shellfish, the highest-priced item in the store, and any bundled packages. Sizzlefish has a wide variety of fresh fish with over 84 individual products available. The prices for fish range from $9.99 for one 5 oz portion to $119.95 for Black Chilean sea bass. Sizzlefish also offers a wide variety of shellfish with prices ranging from $14.95 for 8 shrimp to $249.95 for 3 lbs of King Crab legs.

Bundle packs

Like many options in this review, the most expensive item is also a bundle pack, so we'll go over those first. At Sizzlefish, there are 31 different samplers and boxes to choose from. The prices range from $88.95 for a smoked fish box up to $455.15 for the "Wild Freezer Stuffer Seafood Bundle”. This is also, consequently, the most expensive item at Sizzlefish. With its wide range of prices, Sizzlefish is highly competitive. It offers affordable options as well as high-end seafood and provides comprehensive choices for lobster, crab, and fish.

Subscription for regular seafood shipments

To enhance convenience, Sizzlefish provides a subscription plan option. Whether for yourself or someone else, subscribing allows you to receive regular seafood deliveries according to a predetermined schedule. Sizzlefish offers three subscription choices: Wild Seafood Favorites, Prime, and Prime Plus. The Wild Seafood Favorites plan is meticulously curated by the Sizzlefish team, while the Prime and Prime Plus plans provide you with the flexibility to select 14 or 28 servings of your favorite seafood and fish.

Premium fish products

Both Prime and Prime Plus include popular products like crab cakes and wild Gulf shrimp. However, the Prime Plus package elevates the experience with premium products such as sea bass and halibut. The Prime subscription costs $139.95 for 14 portions and $229.95 for 28 portions per delivery. The Prime Plus subscription is priced at $145.95 for 14 portions and $257.95 for 28 portions per delivery. The cost for the Favorites plan only has one option which is $129.95 for 12 portions per delivery. The best part of the subscriptions is that you get regular shipments and you can change your mind at any time and cancel your membership.

Sustainably wild-caught

For those who prefer wild-caught seafood over farm-raised options, Sizzlefish is a perfect fit. Most of their seafood is sourced from the wild, catering to the preferences of those striving to avoid farm-raised animal products. However, it's worth noting that catfish, rainbow trout, and Atlantic salmon are the few exceptions to this, in case that distinction holds significance for you.

Give the gift of seafood

Sizzlefish goes above and beyond to facilitate gift-giving. Whether you're seeking inspiration or need suggestions, their user-friendly website allows you to explore various gift ideas conveniently. From Gifts Under $100 to Holiday Samplers and Smoked Fish, you'll find an array of options to suit every occasion. Additionally, they offer gift cards, available in both digital and physical formats, with denominations ranging from $50 to $500. If you prefer a custom amount, a simple phone call to Sizzlefish can accommodate your needs. During the checkout process, you have the opportunity to include a personalized gift note, ensuring your present is extra special.

Deals across the site

Sizzlefish doesn't shy away from offering extra savings to its customers. During our browsing experience, we received a pop-up notification offering a 10% discount on our first purchase if we signed up for their email newsletter. Furthermore, while exploring the site, we encountered another 10% discount code, suggesting that there are potential savings waiting to be discovered during the shopping process.

Shipping is free of charge on orders over $100

Free delivery? If you buy more than $100 worth of seafood from Sizzlefish, you can easily score free shipping. Each item is meticulously packed with dry ice to guarantee that it arrives still frozen. While this isn't as low of an order threshold as some companies in this review, the $100 threshold is still very competitive. With some competitors charging exorbitant amounts, sometimes up to $300, for delivery, Sizzlefish stands out as one of the more affordable shipping options.

Satisfaction guaranteed by Sizzlefish

The Sizzlefish team strives for your complete satisfaction with the quality of their products. If you happen to receive fish items that are thawed, significantly damaged, or encounter other substantial issues, they are committed to replacing them at no additional cost. You have 7 days from receiving the products to reach out to their customer service team, which is longer than many companies in this review who only allow you to complain within 24 or 48 hours. While not mandatory, they appreciate it if you can also include a photograph of the issue, as it aids their Quality Control department in addressing any packaging or shipping concerns. The replacement will be shipped using the same shipping method as the original order.

Top-rated with thousands of reviews

We couldn't find Sizzlefish listed on the Better Business Bureau, but we were pleasantly surprised to discover over 12,000 customer reviews on a third-party rating site. These reviews boast an impressive average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. What's even more remarkable is that these reviews come from seafood connoisseurs, including individuals who have experience catching their own squid or who are avid coastal fishermen. They praise Sizzlefish for providing seafood that rivals their own catches and filling the void of great fish to eat. With thousands of people awarding Sizzlefish a perfect five-star rating, it's clear why this seafood store receives such high praise.

Top performer across the board

With a health-focused business model, a-la-carte selections as well as the ability to sign up for a subscription box, Sizzlefish really allows you to make your seafood experience fit your needs. The prices are competitive, and not overpriced, and the shipping is also very reasonable even if you don't make it to the $100 threshold. And while there isn't a BBB page for Sizzlefish, this business is top-rated by customers, some of whom are experienced fishermen and cooks, lending further credibility to the reviews. Overall, there are no downsides to trying out Sizzlefish, and for this reason it's our top option for your next place to buy seafood online.

Wulf's Fish

• Prices range from $9 to $360
• Reward program
• Gifting available
• Eco-friendly shipping and packaging
• Buy wholesale
• Subscription boxes available
• Refunds when requested within 12 hours of delivery
• Top rated with reviewers

Founded in 1926, Wulf's Fish has a rich history rooted in the passion of its founder, Sam Wulf. Today, in its second generation, Wulf's Fish has evolved into a national brand while maintaining its unwavering commitment to quality.

Direct relationships with fishermen

Direct sourcing remains a priority, as they continue to forge direct relationships with fishermen and partners. This approach creates a transparent customer experience with traceability as a fundamental principle. Despite their growth, Wulf's Fish remains based in Boston, serving as a testament to their heritage. Their reach has expanded to ensure the delivery of the highest quality products, regardless of location.

Clean website but needs finishing

For a company that started its business journey in 1926, Wulf's Fish has an impressively polished website. Their products are easy to browse from their top menu and there are excellent filters that break down the different options including pricing filters so you can limit to products that are within your budget. The images of fish are crisp and clean, and we especially loved the little icon badges Wulf's FIsh puts on their images that show which products are sushi-grade fish. The only thing we would have loved more was for the pricing to be visible before you click the listings.

Best value per ounce of fish

To see how the Wulf's Fish prices stack up among different retailers, we analyzed four specific products including traditional fish, shellfish, the highest-priced item, and bundled packages. Wulf's Fish boasts an extensive inventory of fresh fish, offering over 84 individual products. The fish prices range from $9 for a 4 oz portion of sliced salmon to $58 for a 16 oz filet of sushi-grade yellowtail hiramasa. Wulf's Fish provides a slightly less diverse range of shellfish, but still offers competitive options with major delicacies on sale. The shellfish prices start at $13 for 3 lbs of green crabs to $99 for 5 Maine lobster tails pre-shucked.

Bundle packs

Notably, the most expensive item is a bundle pack of caviar that offers 3 jars of caviar for $360. In terms of packages or bundles, Wulf's Fish presents customers with a choice of 3 boxes. The prices include $150 for the Fishmonger Favorites box which includes 6 items each at a minimum of 16 oz of fish. The second box is $270 for the Greatest Hits box which includes 10 fish at 16 oz each. Finally, there is the aforementioned Super-Premium Caviar Gift Set which is $360 and includes 3 types of caviar and accessories. With such a wide price range, Wulf's Fish remains highly competitive, catering to both budget-minded and high-end seafood customers. While the shellfish selection is more limited than with some rival seafood stores, the prices are highly competitive especially for the amount of fish you get in each package, making this one of the best value-for-money companies out there.

Rewards for buying seafood

You can enjoy a rewarding dining experience by becoming a member of The Chef's Table rewards program at Wulf's Fish. By joining, customers can accumulate points that can be redeemed for a variety of fantastic seafood offerings. Every purchase made through the online store earns points, ensuring that members are rewarded for their loyalty. Additionally, spreading the word about Wulf's to friends and acquaintances also grants points. As a Chef's Table member, individuals gain exclusive privileges such as early access to new products and the opportunity to receive thoughtfully curated gifts. Becoming a member is a simple and complimentary process, and new sign-ups are instantly rewarded with 500 points to kick-start their membership. With general purchases, you earn 1 point per dollar and 500 points equals $10 in store credit. And, as a bonus as you spend more, you can get to higher membership tiers awarding you 2x and 3x the number of points per purchase.

Save with subscription boxes

While there aren't a lot of boxes on offer, you can choose to subscribe and save on any of the three. Each box has the choice to ship either every month or every 2 months depending on how often you want your seafood and how much you can eat in a particular time period. We like that there is some customizability there. Further, the listings show how much money you save on the items in the box rather than buying the same items a-la-carte. For example, customers save $20 in seafood purchases by getting the Greatest Hits box instead of buying all of the items separately.

Gifting is easy

On top of offering a range of gift cards including electronic and physical options, you can also send boxes and a-la-carte selections of seafood to your family or friends. The prices for the gift cards range from $50 to $500, so you can give seafood as a gift multiple times over, given the pricing for a-la-carte fish at Wulf's Fish. Additionally, you can send the boxes as a gift or pantry items to help your loved one complement their fish selections with spices or sides.

Sourcing and sustainability page isn't ready yet

While the website in general promises to have good clean fishing practices, when we searched for a sustainability statement, there wasn't one available yet. There is a sustainability page, but it appears that Wulf's hasn't finished building out this part of the website. The otherwise blank page has only one sentence of text on it that reads "Sourcing and sustainability text to go here.” While everything else about Wulf's is generally impressive, this sets them back a little bit. On the other hand, although we can't find a sustainability statement on their page for fishing, Wulf's Fish is committed to sustainable packaging and reducing waste. They prioritize eco-friendly shipping materials, such as their plant-based renewable shipping boxes and insulated liners, which are 100% curbside recyclable along with other paper recycling.

Wholesale purchase

If you're a chef or someone who needs lots of fish on the regular, Wulf's Fish is a great place to shop. They have a separate wholesale tab where you can buy fish in bulk from Wulf's fishing partners. This way you can easily stock your restaurant or maybe just your freezer if you're a private chef (or a huge fish enthusiast). We love that they have a separate spot on the website for this to keep it clear what the average customer can buy and what is set aside for business-level seafood purchases.

Shipping is priced by zone

For national shipping, Wulf's Fish calculates shipping charges based on zones after applying any discounts.

• Zone 1 is for the northeast with the cutoff at Ohio, Virginia, and Kentucky. For customers who live in Zone 1, shipping is a flat rate of $40 for 2-3 day shipping, with free shipping offered on orders of $150 or more. It's important to note, Zone 1 is the only area that can qualify for free shipping on orders of $150+. To account for additional dry ice needed during warmer months, a $5 summer surcharge has been added to the Zone 1 shipping fee.
• Zone 2 is for the middle states and Florida. The cutoff is from the border line that runs from Louisiana and Montana. Customers who live in this zone get flat rate overnight shipping at $85.
• Zone 3 is the rest of the western US and this zone pays flat rate overnight shipping at $105.

For shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, or Puerto Rico, shoppers can contact Customer Care for a quote. All orders for home delivery are shipped frozen, individually vacuum-packed, and super-frozen. This method preserves the highest quality seafood at its peak freshness, ready to be enjoyed on your own schedule. The fish is carefully packed in an insulated box with dry ice and a temperature indicator for safety. While the fish may arrive partially thawed, it is perfectly safe to store in the freezer upon receipt.

Refunds and returns within 12-hour window

Wulf's Fish maintains what they call a "standard return/refund policy” to ensure customer satisfaction. They take pride in providing the best quality seafood and are committed to resolving any issues with orders. If customers are not completely satisfied with the condition or contents of their order, they are encouraged to contact their service center immediately for assistance. Wulf's Fish may request photos of the product and any reported damage to assess the situation and offer an appropriate solution. For concerns regarding product thawing during transit, customers must contact Customer Care within 12 hours of UPS delivering the package. This is one of the shortest windows for returns due to problems with shipping in this review, so customers need to be on the ball with that.

Amazing reviews across the board

Like some other top performers in our evaluation of seafood stores, Wulf's Fish didn't appear listed on the Better Business Bureau. But we were stoked to find over 1000 customer reviews on a third-party rating site. These reviews are off the charts, averaging a whopping 4.8 out of 5 stars. Customers across the board complimented the quality and flavor of the seafood they purchased from Wulf's. One repeat customer noted that the shipments were "consistently fresh” and definitely worth the cost. Other customers loved working with the Wulf's customer service, noting that the Wulf's Fish team did everything they could to resolve issues with orders.

Close second to our top pick

Overall Wulf's Fish is a highly competitive option and it easily makes the top two in our evaluation. We love the selection and the pricing is competitive, offering a great value for your money. However, it's clear they are still building out their website as the prices are missing from listings until you click on them, and their sustainability page has placeholder text. However, with all of the benefits including competitive flat-rate shipping and options for subscription boxes, Wulf's Fish is one of the best seafood stores out there - whether you want basic fish, sushi-grade fish, or premium selections like caviar. You should definitely check out Wulf's Fish for your next seafood stop.

Cameron's Seafood

• Prices from $23 to $272.99
• E-gift cards from $20 to $250, gift messages, samplers
• Free shipping on orders over $250 for "local” orders
• Shellfish-focused
• Certified sustainable
• Same-day shipping offered
• "A+” rating and accreditation by the BBB

Based in Maryland, Cameron's Seafood offers an exquisite selection of fresh crabs and delectable seafood treats like their famous crab cakes. While they also provide Alaskan Snow and king crab, gulf shrimp, lobster, sea scallops, and more, it's important to note that these products are sourced from locations outside of Maryland. However, when it comes to Maryland Blue Crabs, Cameron's Seafood is unrivaled, with its own fleet of crabbers catching and selling over 75,000 bushels each year.

Getting started is easy

Customers can enjoy the convenience and excellence of this seafood delivery service in just three simple steps. First, they have the option to build their own box by selecting from a range of premium Maryland crabs, crab cakes, and seafood. Afterward, they can choose a preferred delivery date that suits their needs. In the second step, on the designated shipping day, the company catches, prepares, and carefully packages the order with the utmost care, ensuring the freshness and quality of the seafood. Finally, customers can relish the convenience of having fresh, top-notch seafood delivered right to their doorstep.

Focus on shellfish

To compare prices at different retailers in our review, we decided to look at four different products. At most places, we looked at the prices for traditional fish, shellfish, the most expensive item in the store, and finally any bundles or packages offered. While Cameron's is primarily shellfish, they do have a decent range of fresh fish ranging from salmon to Chilean sea bass to a fresh tuna steak. These all ship frozen not fresh though, which could be important for some cooks.

Pricing is high for 1-3 lbs of fish

The prices for fish range from $23.99 to $49.99 for one pound of fish in each package. For shellfish, Cameron's has a huge variety. However, we're going to focus on their specialty (Maryland Blue Crabs). The options range from just crab claws up to premium or "colossal jumbo” crabs. Most of the crab selections come in 6-crab packages or 3 lbs for the claws. The prices range from $48.99 to $124.99 for the Blue Crabs. The most expensive item at Cameron's Seafood is the Alaskan King Crab Legs priced at $272.99. Finally, Cameron's offers 3 different packages or "samplers.” They offer a crab cake sampler, a crab soup sampler, and a Maryland seafood sampler. The prices for these range from $139.99 to $225.99. Overall the pricing is a bit high compared to other seafood stores.

Top-notch quality every time

One notable aspect of Cameron's Seafood is its commitment to providing top-grade seafood. Regardless of your choice, you can be confident that only the highest quality grades are offered, ensuring a premium dining experience. To guarantee the optimal condition of your seafood during shipping, Cameron's Seafood meticulously packages your order with the appropriate amount of gel packs or dry ice. Each package is clearly labeled with easy-to-follow preparation instructions, ensuring that even novice chefs can confidently prepare their seafood.

Save the date

An exciting feature offered by Cameron's Seafood is the ability to choose the date your crabs are caught. With the option to place your order up to 60 days in advance, your seafood is caught, prepared, and packaged on the same day it is scheduled to ship. This means that your order arrives at your doorstep as fresh as possible, sometimes within just 24 hours from the time it was pulled from the water.

High shipping costs outside of local shipping

Shipping costs with Cameron's Seafood depend on your location, order amount, and desired delivery speed. For states east of the Mississippi, considered "local," ground shipping is free on orders over $250 and costs $29.99 for purchases below that threshold, but will arrive by 8 pm the second day. Overnight shipping in "local” states costs $84.99. For the rest of the US, 2-Day Air shipping is priced at $69.99, overnight shipping is $99.99, both also requiring a minimum order of $199. This is a significant increase in shipping costs compared to several years ago, which can significantly impact a customer's decision to purchase seafood from Cameron's.

Sales and deals available

Cameron's Seafood offers various discount opportunities to enhance your shopping experience. Upon visiting the website, you may be presented with a spin-and-win chance to receive a discount or freebies. While entering your email and name is required for participation, coupons obtained through this spin-and-win can be redeemed within 12 hours, offering potential savings of up to 10% or free products. Additionally, a $10 off code was prominently displayed on the website without requiring any personal information, so keep an eye out for any similar promos in effect when you're ready to order your seafood.

Give crab legs to your loved ones

Cameron's Seafood is a great place to send gifts. They offer gifts "under $50”, "under $150”, and "under $250”. They also provide options for gift cards from $20 to $250, allowing recipients to select their desired seafood. A personalized gift message can also be included during the checkout process, ensuring a thoughtful touch. The focus at Cameron's Seafood is on the quality of the food rather than elaborate packaging.

100% satisfaction guarantee

Despite our concerns about high costs for shipping, Cameron's does offer a guarantee to make customers more comfortable about shelling out for shellfish. Every purchase from Cameron's Seafood is backed by a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If anything is not to your liking with your seafood order, you can contact Cameron's within 24 hours of delivery to request a reshipment or a full refund, ensuring your utmost satisfaction. While they won't accept returns of perishable items, they do promise to replace or refund the products you purchased.

Certified sustainability

Cameron's Seafood takes pride in being a certified partner of the True Blue program, a recognition that underscores its commitment to offering only authentic Maryland crabs, crab meat, and crab cakes. To maintain this certification, the company undergoes an annual auditing process, thoroughly examining its invoices to ensure that every product they sell aligns with the highest standards of authenticity and quality associated with Maryland's renowned blue crabs. By upholding the True Blue certification, Cameron's Seafood provides their customers with the confidence and assurance that they are receiving genuine Maryland crab products, known for their exceptional taste and culinary appeal.

Top-rated with return customers

Cameron's Seafood has established a strong reputation over its more than 30 years in business. The Better Business Bureau gives them a perfect "A+" rating and accreditation, with no complaints filed against the company. Additionally, their average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars from over 2,800 independently-verified customer reviews further attests to their exceptional service and quality. Customers praise the generous size of the crab cakes, the exceptional packaging that maintains freshness upon delivery, and the responsive customer service. Many customers even express their loyalty to Cameron's Seafood, having switched from other online seafood stores, due to this company's impressive practices in customer service and fresh seafood offerings.

Top choice for shellfish

If you're looking for sustainably-sourced and locally-caught shellfish, Cameron's is the place to go. All of their Blue Crabs are caught daily and can be shipped to you within 1-2 business days depending on the delivery date you choose. The day they ship is the day the crabs are caught, ensuring the freshest delivery possible. While shipping costs and product costs are quite high with Cameron's, they do offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee, so if something is wrong with your order you will be reimbursed completely. Overall, this is a top choice for customers who are interested in shellfish and locally-caught Blue Crabs. For this reason, this is one of the highest-rated seafood store options in our review.

Fulton Fish Market

• Prices range from $6.49 to $229.99
• Subscribe and save options
• Seafood bundles and gift cards for gifting
• One-stop shop for seafood types
• Preparation options available
• Savings options available
• Quality assurance team chooses fish
• Sustainable practices

Fulton Fish Market, established in 2014 in New York, is a relatively new player in the online seafood industry. Their mission is to reintroduce seafood into home dining experiences, often referring to themselves as the "Amazon of Fish."

Handle almost 2 million pounds of fish a day

As the second-largest fish market globally, the Fulton Market handles nearly two million pounds of fish every night, surpassed only by Tokyo's fish market. Fulton Fish Market prioritizes sourcing sustainably caught or ethically farmed fish from local waters within the United States. Their wide range of seafood options includes salmon, halibut, scallops, shrimp, swordfish, and more. Customers can easily navigate to their preferred seafood category through the links provided or explore customer favorites to see what others have purchased.

Subscribe and save with Fulton

Getting started with Fulton is a little different than some of the other retailers we looked at. Fulton Fish Market stands out by offering a subscription plan allowing customers to receive regular seafood deliveries. Subscribers can choose from two options: frozen seafood and fresh seafood. The subscription is similar to the "subscribe and save” feature seen at some other retailers, where instead of paying a subscription fee monthly, you pay a smaller fee for your fish and commit to getting repeat shipments of the same item every 1, 2, 4, or 8 weeks. Every item available at Fulton is eligible to subscribe and save. However, to be eligible, you must commit to a minimum purchase of $70. This service is ideal for restaurants or chefs, for example. You can also purchase a-la-carte from Fulton, which is perfect for the average customer. The price a-la-carte is slightly higher than the subscribe and save, but the prices remain competitive.

Huge range of traditional fish and competitive bundles

In our review, we compared prices for various products, including traditional fish, shellfish, the most expensive item in the store, and any bundled packages. It's important to note that the prices listed below are the a-la-carte pricing, and the pricing with subscribe and save will be cheaper. Fulton Fish Market has a wide variety across the board. The price range for fish varies from common fish like salmon to less common fish like monkfish. The prices start as low as $6.49 (per filet) to $151.99 for eight 7 oz portions. When it comes to shellfish, Fulton Fish Market has a smaller variety than other retailers with only 11 total listings of crab, lobster, and shrimp. The prices for Fulton shellfish range from $20.49 for a pound of jumbo shrimp to $109.99 for 16 oz of cooked crabmeat. The priciest single item at Fulton Fish Market is the Classic Osetra Caviar for $229.99.

Fish bundles

There are a total of 11 different bundles at Fulton. These include options for bundles with only one fish (like salmon or halibut), raw bar bundles, caviar bundles, and assorted seafood bundles. The prices range from $64.99 for 8 servings of salmon to $192 for a 4-person serving of Japanese caviar. The prices at Fulton are competitive and generally reasonable per item.

Detailed preparation available for your shipments

When you're shopping there are a few things to keep in mind. Depending on the type of seafood chosen, there may be additional steps involved in the ordering process. For instance, when purchasing halibut, the default option is for the fish to be delivered whole with the head removed. Customers can select additional preparations such as fileting, skin removal, or portioning into pieces by specifying their preferences in the dropdown menu before adding the product to their cart. Please note that there may be an extra charge for the selected preparation. Detailed information regarding nutritional values, preparation methods, and even helpful chef videos for grilling or pan-searing are provided for many of the seafood items.

Quality assurance is part of their business model

The quality of products at Fulton Fish Market is highly commendable. Each of their fresh seafood offerings undergoes rigorous taste tests conducted by food enthusiasts, chefs, and experts before being selected for their store. They even employ a quality director who is a seafood chef and a graduate of the Culinary Institute of America.

Savings and deals offered regularly

There are plenty of ways to save money at the Fulton Fish Market. By subscribing to Fulton Fish Market's email list, Fulton was offering a 15% discount on our initial purchase at the time of this review. Additionally Fulton Fish Market offered 15% off our first 3 subscription orders if we used the code MEALPLAN, though this code may change from time to time. So, if you're worried about pricing, you can check back to see what kinds of deals Fulton Fish Market is offering when you're ready to order.

Shipping is free for subscribers

In terms of shipping, Fulton Fish Market offers free shipping when the order total exceeds $125 after applying any discounts. For orders that don't reach the threshold, the flat-rate shipping is $19.99. However, it's important to note that this shipping cost only applies in the following states: Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington D.C. For orders outside of this group of states, there is no free shipping available, and all orders are charged a flat rate fee of $19.99. This is still a very competitive flat rate, which still makes Fulton Fish Market appealing as a seafood store.

Options for full-meal gifts

Fulton Fish Market provides convenient selections for gift-giving occasions. Customers can send gift cards via email, with denominations ranging from $25 to $200. You have the option to send a digital card via email or a physical card via mail. The subject line and message are pre-filled with appropriate content, or customers can personalize their messages. You can also easily send seafood bundles for gifting, such as the Seafood Dinner Party Box for 4.

Sustainability in fish selection

Fulton Fish Market notes that it is committed to ensuring a sustainable future for generations to come, striving to procure a wide variety of responsibly-sourced seafood from well-managed wild fisheries and sustainable aquaculture producers. Each item offered by Fulton Fish Market undergoes meticulous evaluation, taking into account factors such as species health, environmental impact, support for fishing communities, and responsible packaging and delivery.

No specific details regarding returns

Unfortunately, Fulton Fish Market's satisfaction guarantee and return policy aren't the best among seafood stores in our review. Customers are advised to thoroughly examine their order upon delivery and promptly reach out to Fulton Fish Market if they encounter any concerns regarding the quality, damage, missing or incorrect items. Providing photographs of the boxes, packaging materials, and products can help resolve any issues. It is important to keep the product frozen or refrigerated, as appropriate. If a refund is deemed necessary after reviewing the matter, the amount will be reimbursed to the original payment method. However, there is no specific statement regarding how this decision will be reached.

Good reviews, but no BBB presence

In terms of customer feedback, Fulton Fish Market does not have as extensive a review presence as some other businesses in the industry. Their website and other platforms display limited customer reviews, and they weren't listed with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) when we looked. On the other hand, the company does have a decent presence at some third-party review sites which are independently verified. For example, Fulton Fish Market has an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 with over 8,000 individual reviews to back up the score. Customers praise the flavor of the fish and the free shipping subscription as one of their favorite ways to buy seafood online.

Great one-stop shop

Overall, Fulton Fish Market is a reputable and high-quality seafood provider. Their website features a clean and user-friendly layout, and they offer a "subscribe and save” to reduce total price as well as bundles for entertaining and gifting, and a commitment to sustainability. Their fish selections provide a fantastic one-stop shop where you can buy all kinds of seafood. With the return policy and potential refunds as the only drawback, this retailer stands out as one of the best options in this review for ordering fish, especially with only $19.99 flat-rate shipping across the US. Fulton Fish Market is an excellent destination for purchasing seafood.

Rastelli's

• Prices range from $12 to $249
• Gift options available
• Full sourcing transparency
• Sustainable fishing and aqua farming
• Free shipping on orders over $200
• $10 flat-rate shipping
• 21-day refund policy
• "A-” rating from the BBB

Open since 1976, Rastelli's is a family-owned butcher shop that has grown into a renowned provider of premium meats and seafood. Over the years, Rastelli's expanded to multiple locations, always maintaining their commitment to exceptional butchery and ensuring customers received perfect cuts of meat. Today, Rastelli's is not only known for their superior products but also for their responsible sourcing practices, partnerships with farming and fishing families, and unwavering dedication to trust and quality. In addition to a full range of fish options, Rastelli's is the ultimate meat one-stop shop providing a selection of beef, poultry, pork, and even specialty meats like lamb or bison.

20 seafood options to choose from

To get started at Rastelli's you just need to select the fish section of the website and you're good to go. You can limit the search by the cut which includes the product filters like burgers, fish, and shellfish. While there aren't as many total listings at Rastelli's as some other fish-focused websites, the 20 seafood options include fresh, pre-seasoned, smoked, and pre-made fish burgers all in one place. With super-easy navigation and a modern website, Rastelli's online store is a pleasure to shop.

Great prices, but not many options

To compare the prices at Rastelli's with other competitors, we checked on the cost of various products available including their fish filets, the shellfish selection, the most expensive fish item at Rastelli's, and finally bundled items. In terms of fish, Rastelli's offers a relatively focused selection compared to other competitors in our review. Their assortment includes 14 traditional fish, ranging from $12 for 2 filets to $40 for 8 filets. When it comes to shellfish, Rastelli's provides a limited array of 6 products. The shellfish prices range from $25 for one 5 oz Maine lobster tail to $49 for 2 lbs of gulf shrimp. The most expensive individual seafood item at Rastelli's is the $49 gulf shrimp.

Bundle pack pricing

The most expensive pack of fish is the $249 salmon-lovers super pack. There are two other "super packs” available from Rastelli's that focus on seafood. Both are very salmon-focused and range in price from $235 to $249. While we wish there were some more options available here, the pieces are highly competitive.

Transparency and sustainable partners

In their quest for transparency, Rastelli's has embarked on a global search for the most suitable partners to meet their diverse sourcing needs. These partnerships are viewed as true collaborations, where both parties are mutually invested in each other's well-being. They actively seek out farming and fishing families with a rich heritage, a genuine passion for their work, and a proven track record of responsibly caring for their animals and the environment. Through close collaboration and adherence to rigorous standards, all products sourced by the company are guaranteed to be free of antibiotics, steroids, and hormones. If Rastelli's quality control staff don't feel confident about the origin of a product, they refuse to endorse it, and they encourage their customers to do the same.

Gifting to multiple people

Rastelli's has a unique approach to gifting. You can choose any item on their website to send as a gift, but if you have more than one family member or loved one that you want to give tasty seafood, you can use the "Multiple Gifts” form to simultaneously send gifts to different people in different locations. There are also a variety of "super bundles” you can send as gifts. There are also digital gift cards that range in price from $50 to $300.

Free shipping on orders over $200

Rastelli's ensures a seamless shopping experience for its customers within the continental U.S. To provide added convenience, Rastelli's offers different shipping options based on the order value. Orders over $200 are eligible for free shipping, while a nominal shipping fee of $10 is charged for orders ranging from $100 to $199. For orders under $100, a shipping fee of $25 applies. However, it is important to note that shipments to Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada are currently unavailable, and they are unable to deliver to military bases.

Refund policy is customer-focused

Rastelli's prioritizes customer satisfaction above all else. If there are any concerns or issues with your products, Rastelli's encourages you to inform them. They value your feedback and are committed to resolving any concerns. Simply reach out to them within 21 days of receiving your shipment, and they promise to offer a refund, either for the entire shipment or a partial refund based on the specific circumstances.

Sustainable on all their products

Rastelli's seafood selection is exclusively sourced through a combination of wild-caught methods or responsible aquaculture practices that prioritize sustainability and the preservation of natural ecosystems. They get their salmon from the Faroe Islands in the North Atlantic, their yellowtail tuna from Indonesia, and jumbo shrimp from the balmy Gulf of Mexico. On top of these promises, they also provide a page on their site dedicated to each type of fish they offer, so you can see the sustainable practices for each individual product. This is also mirrored on their land-food side where they are equally focused on sustainability.

High ratings but low buzz

In terms of the company's reputation, the site isn't as talked-about as we had hoped for a company that's been open so long. However, the reviews that are out there are really good. Customers have ranked Rastelli's 4.2 stars out of 5 on average. On top of this, they also have an "A-” rating from the Better Business Bureau, showing a commitment to customer satisfaction overall. However, with just over 100 total reviews online we felt there wasn't quite enough feedback to verify how happy customers really are with Rastelli's, so you may want to keep that in mind before you buy.

Top one-stop shop for meats

Overall, we love the commitment to sustainability at Rastelli's. On the other hand, with only 20 total products available for seafood enthusiasts, this isn't the top retailer in terms of variety. However, if you're looking for a one-stop shop for all your butchery needs, Rastelli's is a great place to check out and fully deserving of its 4-star rating overall. The only reason it isn't ranked higher is the general lack of reviews and slightly lower BBB rating than some other options in this review. But, if you like group gifts and low prices, it's worth your time to look at Rastelli's for your next meat or fish fix.

Know Seafood

• Prices from $10 to $145
• Curated boxes available
• Offers gift cards
• Sustainable practices
• Aqua-farm-sourced options available
• Fish tracking
• 48-hour refund policy
• "A” rating with the BBB

KnowSeafood is a direct-to-consumer seafood store that prioritizes transparency and traceability. Through their blockchain system, every aspect of the seafood's journey is meticulously recorded, allowing customers to scan a barcode on each piece of seafood and access information about its origin, processing, and transportation. The seafood is flash-frozen to maintain its freshness, and KnowSeafood exclusively sources from trusted fisheries worldwide.

Get creative or let them curate

To get started at KnowSeafood, you can choose from their two main options: to curate your own "box” or buy one of the curated boxes already available on the website. The best thing about this style of purchase is that the customer has the flexibility to tailor their seafood experience to their preferences. The customer can craft their own personalized box of seafood from the KnowSeafood selection that includes an array of fish, shellfish, and prepared foods like delicious salmon and tuna burgers. Alternatively, you can explore the curated seafood boxes available on their online market, which present a thoughtfully curated assortment of healthy fish, delivering a diverse and delicious culinary experience.

Pricing is very competitive

To compare the prices at KnowSeafood with other competitors, we examined the cost of various products here, encompassing classic fish filets, shellfish, the highest-priced item in their store, and any bundled packages. One thing to note about KnowSeafood is that compared to other competitors in this review, their selection is fairly narrow. KnowSeafood offers only 15 traditional fish products. The prices range from $10 for 3-4 oz of fish to $28 for 10-12 oz of sushi-grade tuna. KnowSeafood also has a limited array of shellfish, featuring 3 listings for lobster and crab and only 2 for shrimp and scallops. The shellfish prices range from $22 for 16 oz of shrimp to $89 for golden King Crab.

Bundle boxes

The most expensive item at KnowSeafood is one of their bundle boxes: the Sushi and Sashimi box for $145. In terms of the other boxes, KnowSeafood has 5 total boxes and they range from $119 to $145. While there aren't a lot of selections here, the prices are much lower than some options in our review, making KnowSeafood more competitive.

Full transparency on catching and shipping

At KnowSeafood, they take a lighthearted approach to their work, but their commitment to seafood is unwavering. With its blockchain technology, KnowSeafood ensures full transparency by revealing the precise sources of its catches. By offering consumers complete trust, traceability, and transparency, starting with their Wild Caught Sea Scallops, KnowSeafood enables customers to know the entire story of their seafood even before placing an order, fostering confidence and promoting a healthier consumption of seafood. Harvesters affiliated with KnowSeafood upload crucial information about harvesting, processing, and shipping onto their blockchain application, creating an immutable record that accurately documents when and where each seafood item was caught, processed, and shipped.

Gift cards and curated box gifts

When it comes to gift options, KnowSeafood offers gift cards ranging in price from $25 to $250. Additionally, you can easily build a box or buy one of the curated boxes for a special someone who loves tasty and sustainable fish. Also, the website offers a ton of free recipes, so once you buy your loved one the gift of seafood, you can also make sure they know exactly how to use it to make the best meal they can get.

Free shipping on all orders

If the other features weren't enough, fish enthusiasts are going to love this: KnowSeafood offers free shipping on all orders, with no exceptions. KnowSeafood ensures delivery to the designated address specified during order placement and shipment, as well as on the scheduled delivery date indicated in the tracking details. If a package has not been received despite the tracking information indicating delivery, customers are advised to promptly reach out to KnowSeafood for assistance within 24 hours of the delivery status being marked as completed.

Refund policy available

Customers who have valid reasons for not being fully satisfied with their products are encouraged to reach out to customer support within 48 hours of receiving their order. KnowSeafood is committed to promptly addressing reported concerns and will carefully review the order and any associated issues. Appropriate resolutions, such as replacing the specific product, providing credit for a future purchase, or issuing a partial or full refund, will be offered on a case-by-case basis. As KnowSeafood cannot physically examine the product, customers are kindly requested to provide detailed photographs showcasing the product, its label, and the specific damage or issue experienced.

Farm-to-table business

One of the places KnowSeafood stands out is its sustainability. Not only can you track where your fish comes from and know exactly how it got to your table, but KnowSeafood also offers aqua-farm-raised seafood as a sustainable and nutritious option in addition to wild-caught seafood. Produced within controlled environments, it mitigates the risks of overfishing and the presence of harmful contaminants. Many of the seafood products offered at KnowSeafood are from aqua farms and contribute actively to ocean sustainability.

Not enough buzz for Know Seafood

In terms of the company's reputation, there isn't a lot to go on with KnowSeafood. The company has good reviews with an average star rating of 4.5, but there are just under 100 total customer reviews available online. As a bonus, the company does have an "A” rating with the BBB. However, we would love to see more buzz about KnowSeafood, especially with all the bonuses they offer.

Needs more fish, but a great option

If you're looking for the company with the best shipping price, KnowSeafood is it. Completely free shipping on all orders is impressive and is one of the main things that earn this company a 4-star rating despite having very few reviews and not enough product listings. With that in mind, if you're looking for the largest variety, KnowSeafood isn't it. But, their slim pickings for fish are sustainably-sourced, making it an ideal option for customers who are worried about the oceans. For these reasons, it's definitely worth checking out this seafood store for your next purchase.

Vital Choice

• Prices range from $29.99 to $469.99
• Sustainable wild-catching
• Gift options include gift cards and subscription boxes
• Monthly subscription boxes
• Prices range from $29.99 to $469.99

Vital Choice is an exceptional choice for individuals who prefer wild seafood over farm-raised alternatives. With nearly two decades of experience, this online store initially focused on offering wild Alaskan salmon but has since expanded its selection to include premium whitefish and shellfish as well.

Impressive variety of seafood

The variety of seafood options available at Vital Choice is impressive. From lingcod and mahi in the fish department to spot prawns, crab, calamari, and more in the shellfish category, customers may find it challenging to narrow down their choices. Furthermore, the store offers numerous canned and pouched products, providing even more versatility and convenience. In addition to seafood, Vital Choice offers marine-sourced nutritional supplements, organic foods, and pastured proteins, making it a comprehensive one-stop shop for health-conscious individuals.

Website needs some navigation help

When shopping at Vital Choice, customers have access to a wealth of information about their selected seafood. From nutritional value to preparation instructions and customer reviews, everything needed to make an informed decision is readily available. The website even features video recipes for those seeking culinary inspiration. However, we did find that the website felt a little cluttered overall. For users who have trouble reading small fonts or too-busy text blocks, this site may not be a favorite place to shop. Additionally, the sub-pages don't have filters: for example, if you want to narrow down your salmon options on the salmon page, it is very difficult to do so.

Huge inventory and good value for money

To compare prices among different retailers in our review, we evaluated four specific products, including traditional fish, shellfish, the highest-priced item in the store, and bundled packages. Vital Choice offers a huge range of fresh fish including 74 listings for salmon and 52 for whitefish. The prices for fish vary from $29.99 for two 8 oz portions to $469.99 for 24 portions at 6 oz. Their selection of shellfish is smaller with 17 different listings. The prices range from $49.95 to $299.99. The most expensive seafood item available at Vital Choice is their MSC Wild Chilean Sea Bass prepared skinless and boneless in a 24-count of 6 oz filets for $469.99. In terms of boxes, Vital Choice offers 6 products which are "subscription” boxes that are charged monthly. These range in price from $139.99 to $199.99. Since you get large sizes of fish in each order, there is a great value for money at Vital Choice.

Subscription for monthly seafood

For those seeking a more convenient and recurring seafood supply, Vital Choice offers three subscription box options. There are six different combinations for subscription boxes, which is a little limited compared to other companies that have subscriptions. They only offer monthly payments, unlike other companies that let you decide between different frequencies. However, the prices are still competitive if you want monthly deliveries of fish.

Complicated shipping tiers

Shipping is priced depending on the total price of your order at Vital Choice. As such, there are a lot of pricing tiers that range in cost from $6.99 to $25.99+. The total breakdown comes out as follows:

• Cart total between $0.01 - $15.00 = $6.99 shipping
• Cart total between $15.01 - $30.00 = $8.99 shipping
• Cart total between $30.01 - $60.00 = $14.99 shipping
• Cart total between $60.01 - $100.00 = $19.99 shipping
• Cart total between $100.01 - $200.00 = $25.99 shipping
• Cart total $200.01 and over = 16% of order subtotal

While it's certainly fair to have shipping costs based on your order total, it makes it much harder to figure out what your shipping will cost by the time you check out. This could be much less convenient for customers, compared with other seafood stores who only have one or two tiers of delivery fees.

Gifting is great here

One place where Vital Choice is great is with its gifting options. Whether opting for traditional physical gift cards or e-gift cards, customers can select their preferred designs and choose from various denominations. Additionally, the store offers gift packs and samplers beyond seafood, including oil/vinegar/seasonings and dark chocolate. Specialized subscription boxes can also be sent as gifts to loved ones if you want to treat them to a seafood feast.

Sustainable and wild-caught fish

One of the standout features of Vital Choice is its commitment to sustainability. Only seafood that is sustainably caught is sold, and a portion of the company's profits is dedicated to supporting planet-protecting programs and environmental strategies.

Top-rated for customer service

Vital Choice's reputation speaks for itself. The company holds an "A+" rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, highlighting its commitment to customer satisfaction. Notable experts such as Dr. Andrew Weil and Dr. Joseph Mercola endorse the quality of the seafood and fish, further attesting to its excellence. With over 18,000 customer reviews and an outstanding 4.7 out of 5-star average rating, it is clear that Vital Choice has garnered significant positive feedback from its satisfied customers.

Competitive but website needs an update

Vital Choice caters to various preferences, and with its wide selection, sustainability focus, and exceptional customer reviews, it's definitely still worth checking out. But because of the lack of filters and difficulty navigation as well as complicated shipping prices, this seafood store sits a little lower than other competitors in this review.

Giovanni's Fish Market

• Prices range from $14.99 to $399.99
• Gift shop with seafood tools, accessories and clothing
• Offers raw and smoked filets
• 24-hour return policy
• Some sustainability focus

For several decades, Giovanni's Fish Market has been a California-based, family-owned and operated business, founded by a commercial abalone diver in 1973. They primarily source their seafood locally, although they also include some imported seafood products. They provide a mom-and-pop feel with an in-person shopping experience in California as well as online shipping to customers across the US. With a full range of options from traditional fish to shellfish, to sushi-grade selections, Giovanni's provides competitive listings for Californians and beyond.

Easy to use, but not web-focused

The online shopping experience at Giovanni's Fish Market is straightforward. While browsing their main page is one way to look through their inventory, it's more convenient to directly access the links provided at the top of the website to filter through the different fish options available at this seafood store. Their product range includes abalone, crab, filet of fish, lobster, oysters, shellfish, shrimp, smoked fish, sushi, and various sauces and spices to enhance the dining experience.

The latest deals

To find the latest deals, customers can click on the Specials link, and they shouldn't miss the featured items section, which currently includes items like live abalone, Chilean sea bass, rock crab claws, sablefish, and smoked salmon belly. As this is a mom-and-pop style place with an in-person shopping experience, it seems like they haven't put as much work into the website as other companies in our review. However, the website is still functional and easy enough for the average shopper to navigate.

Competitively low pricing overall

In our review, we thoroughly examined seafood stores' prices for a range of products, including classic fish, shellfish, the most expensive item in the store, and bundled packages. Giovanni's offers an extensive selection of traditional fish including filets, sushi and sashimi, and smoked fish. The pricing for the filets starts at $14.99 for 1 lb of thresher shark and goes up to $399.99 for 10 lbs of Alaskan halibut. For the sushi-grade filets, the prices start at $14 for 11 oz of ebi shrimp and go as high as $39.99 for 1 lb of flying fish roe. Finally, for filets, the price of pre-cooked (smoked) filets ranges from $19.99/lb- $39.99/lb. Giovanni's also has a competitive variety of shellfish. Prices for shellfish range from $12.49 per pound of black mussels to $299.99 for 10 lbs of Dungeness Crab sections. The most expensive item at Giovanni's is $399.99 for the Alaskan Halibut mentioned in the filet section.

Big box specials

Finally, Giovanni's offers a few "Big Box Specials”. Bundle prices at Giovanni's vary from $149 to $399.99. In terms of individual orders of fish, this retailer is one of the most affordable in our review, especially given how many pounds of fish you can get for the listed price.

Gifts of food or cooking tools available

When it comes to gift options, Giovanni's Fish Market offers the expected choices such as gift cards, usable both in-store and for online purchases. These gift cards are available in denominations ranging from $25 to $250. Additionally, the gift section of Giovanni's website provides gift products like sushi mats, cooking or knife sets, or Giovanni's-themed gifts like branded tumblers or t-shirts. Finally, you can also buy any of the fish boxes described earlier as a gift. During the checkout process, customers can enter a gift message in the same section where delivery instructions are provided, whether they opt for a gift card or choose to send specific seafood products to someone else.

Exceptionally high shipping prices

One aspect where Giovanni's Fish Market falls short is shipping costs. Free delivery is only available for orders exceeding $399, whereas some competitors offer free shipping at lower thresholds or on every purchase. Shipping fees for orders below that free delivery threshold are calculated based on weight, ranging from $25 to $199.99 for California residents and from just under $49.99 to $299.99 for those outside of the state. Ouch! Overnight shipping is the only available option, and customers need to select the inclusion of dry ice (for an additional $10) during checkout. Orders can be shipped immediately or delivered on a specified date.

Return the fish to Giovanni's

Regarding returns, Giovanni's Fish Market has a peculiar policy. Like many online seafood stores, they guarantee the freshness of their deliveries. Customers have 24 hours from the time of delivery to request a return authorization form. Interestingly, customers are expected to return the seafood for a refund, which is provided in the form of full store credit. While this return policy may raise some eyebrows, the store's positive customer feedback suggests that the need for returns is rare.

Baseline sustainability

In terms of sustainability, Giovanni's makes a statement about prioritizing locally-sourced fish in an effort to support sustainability. However, compared to other companies that work in sustainability, this seems to be the bare minimum. Giovanni's claims to have over 100 different fish options available but don't specifically mention how they ensure sustainability with those fish.

Popular with local and online reviewers

Despite the slightly outdated appearance of the Giovanni's Fish Market website (with a copyright date of 2006), their customer reviews are current and overwhelmingly positive. On top of good online reviews (an average of 4.5 stars on Google Reviews), the company is also popular with local visitors with a high 4.5-star average on sites like TripAdvisor. The only place where Giovanni's doesn't stand out is that it has no presence on the Better Business Bureau, which isn't ideal. However, with good reviews to balance out the missing rating with the BBB, it's clear that this seafood store is still worth checking out.

High shipping costs, but worth looking into

Giovanni's Fish Market has established itself as a reputable source of seafood, backed by a stellar reputation and unique gift selections. However, when considering their above-average delivery costs and unusual return policy, they fall behind our top-ranked seafood stores. Nevertheless, Giovanni's Fish Market remains a trustworthy online seafood provider and is worth considering for seafood enthusiasts.

Riviera Seafood Club

• Prices range from $9.99 to $242.30
• Free shipping on orders of $175
• Gift cards available
• Sushi-grade fish
• Sustainably sourced
• Refunds available within 7 days

If you're in search of an extraordinary experience with tuna belly, hamachi, or yellowtail - whether for grilling or savoring sashimi-style - look no further than Riviera Seafood Club. Established in July 2019, this Los Angeles-based online seafood provider, owned by the Ito family, specializes in sourcing top-tier sushi-grade fish, along with other popular catches like wild salmon, black cod, prawns, and unagi. Riviera Seafood Club ensures nationwide delivery of fresh or flash-frozen fish to all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Most of their fish is of sashimi-grade quality, allowing you to slice and savor it without the need for cooking.

Focused on sushi-style fish options

To get started you can just select the "shop” tab and choose whether you want to look for seafood, wagyu beef, wasabi, pantry items, or select a "dinner pack”. The items available at Riviera Seafood Club follow the range of a full sushi bar, allowing you to have that sushi experience right in the comfort of your home. This retailer is going to be a favorite with fans of Japanese cuisine or those who are craving some nigiri or sashimi right now.

Prices are competitive for sushi-grade

To compare the prices at Riviera Seafood Club with other competitors, we checked out the cost of various products, including their fish filets, shellfish options, the priciest fish item on offer, and bundled items. When it comes to fish, Riviera Seafood Club offers a range of sushi-grade selections. The prices for fish range from $9.99 for 4 oz of rockfish to $74 for 3.5 oz of sea urchin. As for shellfish, they provide a limited array with only 3 listings for shrimp and scallops. There are absolutely no products for crab or lobster here. Prices for shellfish range from $38.49 to $41.79 and one of the items was out of stock, so the price wasn't listed.

Fish bundle packs

The priciest seafood item at Riviera Seafood Club is also one of the packs: there are 5 sashimi packs and 4 cooking packs priced between $65.22 and $242.30. The Oshii Sahimi Pack is the most expensive item ($242.30) and offers 7-8 servings of a variety of sushi-grade fish. The prices are competitive for sushi-grade, but this seafood store is missing some key selections like crab or lobster.

Navigation could use an update

One place that Riviera Seafood Club didn't stand out was its website. While the site is perfectly usable, the lack of filters including fish and price filters in the general search was disappointing. While the site does separate each item by fish species, this can be a little time-consuming. And if you want to browse all the fish, it's one long scrolling window with no way to filter the options down. For a site launched so recently, it's a little disappointing that some of these modern must-haves aren't included.

Hand-picked and responsibly-sourced

Every product available on this website is carefully hand-selected and evaluated for quality, responsible sourcing, and, most importantly, taste. Riviera Seafood Club takes great pride in its offerings and only includes products that they would serve in their own homes. With a focus on responsible sourcing and practices, they ensure that each item is freshly caught or harvested to order, bringing a direct and responsible seafood sourcing experience right to your doorstep.

Basic gift cards available

In terms of gifting, the Riviera Seafood Club offers the basics. There are gift cards that range from $15 to $375. The gift cards are digital and will be delivered via email. Beyond that, you can buy any of the items and send them to a friend, family member, or loved one. The packs are particularly useful for sending as gifts, though none of them are directly listed as such.

Free shipping on orders over $175

Riviera Seafood Club offers free expedited delivery within the continental US for all orders amounting to $175 or more. Customers residing in Southern California with zip codes starting from 90, 91, and 92 can get free expedited delivery on orders of $125 or more, benefiting from the proximity to the warehouse. Processing and handling times may vary depending on seafood availability, ranging from 1 to 2 days before shipping. Frozen perishables and non-perishable items typically require up to 24 hours for processing, while non-frozen perishable items may take 24 to 48 hours.

Refund policy is case-by-case

Riviera has a food-item-specific return policy. This states that customers should contact Riviera Seafood Club within seven days if they suspect any quality issues with their fish purchase. Depending on supply chain restrictions, the company may replace the item or provide a credit/refund. Riviera Seafood Club may request photographic evidence before issuing a credit/refund, but they do seem committed to providing one on a case-by-case basis.

Nobody is talking about Riviera

Another place that Riviera doesn't stand up against some of the competition is the complete absence of the company at the Better Business Bureau. On top of that, there are no reviews of Riviera Seafood Club on any of the major third-party review sites. While there are reviews on the Riviera Seafood Club site itself, we prefer having some verified third-party reviews. The company does have a 4.5-star average on Yelp, but there were only just over 30 total reviews at the time we checked, which doesn't show comprehensive customer feedback.

Good if you want Japanese-style sushi

After weighing the positives and negatives we have to give this seafood store 3 stars total. While the offerings are good if you're a sushi fan, there are some distinct limitations on the menu at Riviera Seafood Club, especially if you want crab or lobster. On top of that, the website is a little hard to use if you want to narrow your search. Although the prices are good and the sustainability focus is on point, we would feel more confident about Riviera Seafood Club if they had more buzz from reviewers and the BBB. It's a decent seafood store for sushi-grade snacks and competitive prices, but maybe not your top option for variety or selection.

Global Seafoods

• Prices range from $60 to $490
• $100 VIP Membership for free shipping
• "A+” rating from the BBB

Global Seafoods would like to be your trusted source of fresh seafood, catering to the discerning palates of seafood enthusiasts, but this seafood store may not deserve that trust. Promising to highlight the importance of preserving freshness, Global Seafoods theoretically employs exceptional packaging solutions that safeguard the seafood's delicate flavors and attributes, ensuring that customers receive a premium product with every order. However, according to reviewers, in addition to being an expensive option overall, Global Seafoods isn't the most trustworthy seafood shipper. And for us, that's a major deal-breaker.

Bare bones website needs updating

The online shopping experience at Global Seafoods is one of the more disappointing on this list. Not only are there no filters beyond basic fish types, but every individual fish is listed separately. While this may be useful for customers only looking for "frozen fish” or "whitefish”, it would be easier to browse if there were also larger categories and filters to shop through. On the bright side, they do have everything in one place, but that "everything” is mixed in with navigation buttons like "VIP Member” pages or "shipping details” in one long scroll which makes it hard to find what you need on the sidebar. Confusingly, the top navigation bar also has "free shipping” and "shipping” tabs separately, and on closer inspection, the "free shipping” tab is the VIP membership which is what separates it from regular shipping.

Not enough options and very expensive

To show a clear price comparison, we checked out the prices of various products at Global Seafoods, including a classic fish (filet), shellfish, the priciest item at the store, and any bundled packages. Global Seafoods provides a somewhat limited range of traditional fish filets, and they are spread all over the website. We looked at the prices under the "fresh fish” tab where there are unfortunately only 18 total listings for fish. The pricing ranges from $60 for 3 lbs of rockfish to $180 for 2 lbs of sushi-grade bluefin tuna. Global Seafoods offers more selections for shellfish with 27 different items including lobster, crab, shrimp, and oysters. The prices range from $90 for 2 lbs of Maine lobster claws to $490 for one 5 lb King Crab. This also appears to be the most expensive item on the menu. Unfortunately for this price comparison, Global Seafoods does not offer any bundles or packages. Overall, this is more expensive than many stores in our review.

Gifts of food or cooking tools available

When it comes to gift options, Global Seafoods offers one gift card that ranges from $50 to $500 depending on what amount you want to give. The gift card is digital and will be delivered via email to your loved one. If you want something more personalized, you can send your family member individual fish or you could send the assortment of kitchen accessories like specialty knives to a seafood lover in your family.

Exceptionally high shipping prices

Global Seafoods has two types of shipping, their regular shipping prices and those under the VIP membership. The VIP membership costs $100 per year and offers the customer completely free shipping for that calendar year. There are also 6-month and 3-month options titled "Gold membership” and "Silver membership” respectively. The regular shipping prices are not listed on the Global Foods website unless you complete a purchase.

Replace but no refunds

Global Seafoods ensures that customers receive their orders in a frozen condition, providing a guarantee for replacement in the event of thawing, spoilage, or damage upon delivery. This guarantee is applicable for one year without any exceptions. However, this guarantee doesn't give you your money back. Instead, the website states that your order will be replaced. So, if you don't like what you get from Global Seafoods and the problem isn't with freezing during transit, you can't get your money back from this company.

Baseline sustainability

Another place that Global Seafoods doesn't impress is its sustainability. We couldn't find any statement on their website that explored their sustainability practices. While they say they support marine ecosystems in their quality control statements, there is no real focus on sustainability that stands out. So, if eco-first practices are a deal breaker, you might want to check out one of the higher-rated services in our review.

Not so popular with local and online reviewers

In terms of the company's reputation, there isn't a lot to go on with Global Seafoods. While the company does have an "A+” rating with the BBB, there aren't a lot of customer reviews there that help us get a clear understanding of the business and customer satisfaction. There are some reviews on Trustpilot for Global Seafoods, but only just over 1,000 total reviews and the ratings aren't stellar. The company only has an average score of 2.8 out of 5 stars in total. We found some customers that accuse Global Seafoods of deleting negative reviews from their site, making it hard to complain about the company or its practices. Other customers complained about items being shipped unfrozen and coming out "funky” or dirty when they received them.

High shipping costs, not worth looking into

Overall, there aren't a lot of positives with Global Seafoods. From the poorly designed website to the low user ratings, it doesn't stand out as a place where you want to buy something as expensive and hard to ship as seafood. Keeping in mind your health and safety, as well as how much you're willing to spend, there's nothing at Global Seafoods that recommends it to customers. Keep going for your fish fix and check out our top-rated seafood stores instead.