Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Fulton Fish Market Review

Sunday, April 21st

2024 Seafood Company Reviews

Fulton Fish Market Review 4.5 Star Rating

Fulton Fish Market

4.5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $6.49 to $229.99
  • Subscribe and save options
  • Seafood bundles and gift cards for gifting
  • One-stop shop for seafood types
  • Preparation options available
  • Savings options available
  • Quality assurance team chooses fish
  • Sustainable practices

Fulton Fish Market, established in 2014 in New York, is a relatively new player in the online seafood industry. Their mission is to reintroduce seafood into home dining experiences, often referring to themselves as the "Amazon of Fish."

Handle almost 2 million pounds of fish a day

As the second-largest fish market globally, the Fulton Market handles nearly two million pounds of fish every night, surpassed only by Tokyo's fish market. Fulton Fish Market prioritizes sourcing sustainably caught or ethically farmed fish from local waters within the United States. Their wide range of seafood options includes salmon, halibut, scallops, shrimp, swordfish, and more. Customers can easily navigate to their preferred seafood category through the links provided or explore customer favorites to see what others have purchased.

Subscribe and save with Fulton

Getting started with Fulton is a little different than some of the other retailers we looked at. Fulton Fish Market stands out by offering a subscription plan allowing customers to receive regular seafood deliveries. Subscribers can choose from two options: frozen seafood and fresh seafood. The subscription is similar to the "subscribe and save" feature seen at some other retailers, where instead of paying a subscription fee monthly, you pay a smaller fee for your fish and commit to getting repeat shipments of the same item every 1, 2, 4, or 8 weeks. Every item available at Fulton is eligible to subscribe and save. However, to be eligible, you must commit to a minimum purchase of $70. This service is ideal for restaurants or chefs, for example. You can also purchase a-la-carte from Fulton, which is perfect for the average customer. The price a-la-carte is slightly higher than the subscribe and save, but the prices remain competitive.

Huge range of traditional fish and competitive bundles

In our review, we compared prices for various products, including traditional fish, shellfish, the most expensive item in the store, and any bundled packages. It's important to note that the prices listed below are the a-la-carte pricing, and the pricing with subscribe and save will be cheaper. Fulton Fish Market has a wide variety across the board. The price range for fish varies from common fish like salmon to less common fish like monkfish. The prices start as low as $6.49 (per filet) to $151.99 for eight 7 oz portions. When it comes to shellfish, Fulton Fish Market has a smaller variety than other retailers with only 11 total listings of crab, lobster, and shrimp. The prices for Fulton shellfish range from $20.49 for a pound of jumbo shrimp to $109.99 for 16 oz of cooked crabmeat. The priciest single item at Fulton Fish Market is the Classic Osetra Caviar for $229.99.

Best Seafood Stores

Fish bundles

There are a total of 11 different bundles at Fulton. These include options for bundles with only one fish (like salmon or halibut), raw bar bundles, caviar bundles, and assorted seafood bundles. The prices range from $64.99 for 8 servings of salmon to $192 for a 4-person serving of Japanese caviar. The prices at Fulton are competitive and generally reasonable per item.

Detailed preparation available for your shipments

When you're shopping there are a few things to keep in mind. Depending on the type of seafood chosen, there may be additional steps involved in the ordering process. For instance, when purchasing halibut, the default option is for the fish to be delivered whole with the head removed. Customers can select additional preparations such as fileting, skin removal, or portioning into pieces by specifying their preferences in the dropdown menu before adding the product to their cart. Please note that there may be an extra charge for the selected preparation. Detailed information regarding nutritional values, preparation methods, and even helpful chef videos for grilling or pan-searing are provided for many of the seafood items.

Quality assurance is part of their business model

The quality of products at Fulton Fish Market is highly commendable. Each of their fresh seafood offerings undergoes rigorous taste tests conducted by food enthusiasts, chefs, and experts before being selected for their store. They even employ a quality director who is a seafood chef and a graduate of the Culinary Institute of America.

Best Seafood Stores

Savings and deals offered regularly

There are plenty of ways to save money at the Fulton Fish Market. By subscribing to Fulton Fish Market's email list, Fulton was offering a 15% discount on our initial purchase at the time of this review. Additionally Fulton Fish Market offered 15% off our first 3 subscription orders if we used the code MEALPLAN, though this code may change from time to time. So, if you're worried about pricing, you can check back to see what kinds of deals Fulton Fish Market is offering when you're ready to order.

Shipping is free for subscribers

In terms of shipping, Fulton Fish Market offers free shipping when the order total exceeds $125 after applying any discounts. For orders that don't reach the threshold, the flat-rate shipping is $19.99. However, it's important to note that this shipping cost only applies in the following states: Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington D.C. For orders outside of this group of states, there is no free shipping available, and all orders are charged a flat rate fee of $19.99. This is still a very competitive flat rate, which still makes Fulton Fish Market appealing as a seafood store.

Options for full-meal gifts

Fulton Fish Market provides convenient selections for gift-giving occasions. Customers can send gift cards via email, with denominations ranging from $25 to $200. You have the option to send a digital card via email or a physical card via mail. The subject line and message are pre-filled with appropriate content, or customers can personalize their messages. You can also easily send seafood bundles for gifting, such as the Seafood Dinner Party Box for 4.

Sustainability in fish selection

Fulton Fish Market notes that it is committed to ensuring a sustainable future for generations to come, striving to procure a wide variety of responsibly-sourced seafood from well-managed wild fisheries and sustainable aquaculture producers. Each item offered by Fulton Fish Market undergoes meticulous evaluation, taking into account factors such as species health, environmental impact, support for fishing communities, and responsible packaging and delivery.

Best Seafood Stores

No specific details regarding returns

Unfortunately, Fulton Fish Market's satisfaction guarantee and return policy aren't the best among seafood stores in our review. Customers are advised to thoroughly examine their order upon delivery and promptly reach out to Fulton Fish Market if they encounter any concerns regarding the quality, damage, missing or incorrect items. Providing photographs of the boxes, packaging materials, and products can help resolve any issues. It is important to keep the product frozen or refrigerated, as appropriate. If a refund is deemed necessary after reviewing the matter, the amount will be reimbursed to the original payment method. However, there is no specific statement regarding how this decision will be reached.

Good reviews, but no BBB presence

In terms of customer feedback, Fulton Fish Market does not have as extensive a review presence as some other businesses in the industry. Their website and other platforms display limited customer reviews, and they weren't listed with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) when we looked. On the other hand, the company does have a decent presence at some third-party review sites which are independently verified. For example, Fulton Fish Market has an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 with over 8,000 individual reviews to back up the score. Customers praise the flavor of the fish and the free shipping subscription as one of their favorite ways to buy seafood online.

Great one-stop shop

Overall, Fulton Fish Market is a reputable and high-quality seafood provider. Their website features a clean and user-friendly layout, and they offer a "subscribe and save" to reduce total price as well as bundles for entertaining and gifting, and a commitment to sustainability. Their fish selections provide a fantastic one-stop shop where you can buy all kinds of seafood. With the return policy and potential refunds as the only drawback, this retailer stands out as one of the best options in this review for ordering fish, especially with only $19.99 flat-rate shipping across the US. Fulton Fish Market is an excellent destination for purchasing seafood.

Where Can You Find the Best Seafood Stores?

Whether you're a seafood connoisseur or simply love indulging in a delicious seafood feast, finding a reliable supplier is essential. With options ranging from fresh fish to shellfish and everything in between, seafood stores provide a wide variety of choices for seafood lovers. And the best part? Many of these stores offer the convenience of online shopping, allowing you to explore their offerings from the comfort of your home.

Seafood stores offer a wide range of products, including fish, shrimp, lobster, crab, oysters, and more. The variety and quality of the selection can vary from store to store. Whether you're searching for a specific type of fish or want to explore new flavors, it's important to consider the diversity of options offered by each seafood store. A store with a diverse selection allows you to try new and exciting seafood dishes, ensuring a satisfying culinary experience.

The Best Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Company Reviews What are the best Seafood Companies Best Seafood Company Reviews

Seafood Company FAQ

If it's aquatic and edible, it's probably classified as seafood. This includes crustaceans like lobsters and shrimp, mollusks such as clams and oysters, plus most varieties of fish.
The clue is in the name: one type is raised similar to livestock, while the other is caught out in open waters. Farm-raised seafood is often considered more sustainable than wild-caught and is usually less expensive.
Have you ever gone to the supermarket and caught a whiff of that fishy smell? That usually means that the seafood isn't fresh. Buying it online shortens the process from catch to consumption, eliminating many of the middle steps of transportation and shelving that lead to less flavorful seafood.
Online seafood companies take great care to carefully prepare and package your delivery. Boxes often include cold packs and insulation to make sure it's in perfect shape when it arrives at your doorstep.
Sometimes. It depends on the seafood company you select and how much you order. Some retailers offer free shipping with a certain minimum order amount.
That's where the fun really starts. How about a paella dinner box, some chowder or dessert to go along with your seafood? There are so many options you can include to really round out your special occasion meal or just for the halibut. (Sorry.)
Yes, and your dinner guests thank you for asking. Most online seafood retailers have both raw and prepared choices among their seafood offerings. When you get a little more confident in your abilities, trust that you'll be able to find plenty of step-by-step instruction - either included with your delivery or on the website (or both).
Please and thank you! While not every online seafood store has robust gift-giving options, some want to make it as easy as possible to send a delightful gift to your lucky recipient. From oil/vinegar samplers to dark chocolate or even just a gift card to spend as they like, your loved ones will appreciate your thoughtfulness. You can usually include a personalized note to accompany the delivery; just look for that feature during the checkout process.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Seafood is a popular choice for many people, and it's no wonder considering its versatility and health benefits. According to research, seafood is a rich source of essential nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals. It is also associated with numerous health benefits, including improved heart health and brain function and protection against heart attack or Alzheimer's. With seafood being in high demand, it's important to find a seafood store that consistently delivers the freshest and highest quality products.

When it comes to seafood, freshness is key. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) advises consumers to choose seafood that is fresh, properly handled, and stored at the correct temperatures to reduce the risk of foodborne illnesses. This makes it crucial to find a seafood store that prioritizes freshness and follows proper handling procedures. This is especially important if you're hoping to make dishes that aren't cooked as thoroughly, like sushi or sashimi dishes.

For this reason, it can be particularly helpful to shop for your seafood online. Reputable vendors prioritize the freshness and quality of their products through rigorous quality control measures. Some even source their fish directly from fishermen or sustainable fisheries, promoting a farm-to-table experience. And online markets often offer access to rare or specialty fish that may not be readily available locally, allowing you to indulge in unique culinary experiences. Online fish markets offer a wide variety of fish and seafood products, giving you the opportunity to explore a diverse range of species and try new flavors.

When choosing a seafood store online, there are so many options to choose from. If you're not sure how to get started, don't worry! We've got your back. Below is a list of factors you can keep in mind to help you choose the best seafood store for your needs.

  • Price. Price is a significant consideration for many individuals when it comes to choosing an online store for seafood, especially with shipping costs. The affordability of seafood can determine how much you can buy and how often you can enjoy barbecue salmon or whitefish nigiri. Being mindful of your budget and the fairness of market value for fish can help you decide where to buy.
  • Variety. Are you just looking for the basics? Or do you want a very specific or rare kind of fish? It's important to look at the kind of variety offered by each seafood store to ensure they have what you want or that you don't need to shop in multiple places.
  • Shipping. Shipping is a two-pronged issue for seafood. While you want to make sure you can get good deals on shipping, it's also very important to know how fast and how well refrigerated an online seafood store will send your food. You want to make sure the high-quality fish you buy stays high quality by the time it reaches you.
  • Sustainability. If you're one of the customers worried about sustainability, you may want to check out the eco-friendliness of the seafood store you're shopping with. Keep an eye on their specific moves to highlight sustainability in their business model.
  • Customer satisfaction. Customers aren't professional fishermen (most of the time), but they do provide good insight into things you love. Keeping an eye on a company's reputation with customers can help you decide if it's the right place for you to pick up a red snapper or crawfish.

To make the process of finding the seafood store go swimmingly, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best options for seafood stores on the market today. We hope this information helps you enjoy your seafood fix and prioritize your health and wellness at the same time!

Compare Seafood Companies

Select any 2 Seafood Companies to compare them head to head

  • Sizzlefish
  • Wulf's Fish
  • Cameron's Seafood
  • Fulton Fish Market
  • Rastelli's
  • Know Seafood
  • Vital Choice
  • Giovanni's Fish Market
  • Riviera Seafood Club
  • Global Seafoods
Sizzlefish vs Wulf's Fish Sizzlefish vs Cameron's Seafood Sizzlefish vs Fulton Fish Market Sizzlefish vs Rastelli's Sizzlefish vs Know Seafood Sizzlefish vs Vital Choice Sizzlefish vs Giovanni's Fish Market Sizzlefish vs Riviera Seafood Club Sizzlefish vs Global Seafoods Wulf's Fish vs Cameron's Seafood Wulf's Fish vs Fulton Fish Market Wulf's Fish vs Rastelli's Wulf's Fish vs Know Seafood Wulf's Fish vs Vital Choice Wulf's Fish vs Giovanni's Fish Market Wulf's Fish vs Riviera Seafood Club Wulf's Fish vs Global Seafoods Cameron's Seafood vs Fulton Fish Market Cameron's Seafood vs Rastelli's Cameron's Seafood vs Know Seafood Cameron's Seafood vs Vital Choice Cameron's Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market Cameron's Seafood vs Riviera Seafood Club Cameron's Seafood vs Global Seafoods Fulton Fish Market vs Rastelli's Fulton Fish Market vs Know Seafood Fulton Fish Market vs Vital Choice Fulton Fish Market vs Giovanni's Fish Market Fulton Fish Market vs Riviera Seafood Club Fulton Fish Market vs Global Seafoods Rastelli's vs Know Seafood Rastelli's vs Vital Choice Rastelli's vs Giovanni's Fish Market Rastelli's vs Riviera Seafood Club Rastelli's vs Global Seafoods Know Seafood vs Vital Choice Know Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market Know Seafood vs Riviera Seafood Club Know Seafood vs Global Seafoods Vital Choice vs Giovanni's Fish Market Vital Choice vs Riviera Seafood Club Vital Choice vs Global Seafoods Giovanni's Fish Market vs Riviera Seafood Club Giovanni's Fish Market vs Global Seafoods Riviera Seafood Club vs Global Seafoods
Compare the Best Seafood Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Seafood Companies
The Best Reviews of Seafood Companies