Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Rastelli's Review

Sunday, April 21st

2024 Seafood Company Reviews

Rastelli's Review 4 Star Rating


4 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $12 to $249
  • Gift options available
  • Full sourcing transparency
  • Sustainable fishing and aqua farming
  • Free shipping on orders over $200
  • $10 flat-rate shipping
  • 21-day refund policy
  • "A-" rating from the BBB

Open since 1976, Rastelli's is a family-owned butcher shop that has grown into a renowned provider of premium meats and seafood. Over the years, Rastelli's expanded to multiple locations, always maintaining their commitment to exceptional butchery and ensuring customers received perfect cuts of meat. Today, Rastelli's is not only known for their superior products but also for their responsible sourcing practices, partnerships with farming and fishing families, and unwavering dedication to trust and quality. In addition to a full range of fish options, Rastelli's is the ultimate meat one-stop shop providing a selection of beef, poultry, pork, and even specialty meats like lamb or bison.

20 seafood options to choose from

To get started at Rastelli's you just need to select the fish section of the website and you're good to go. You can limit the search by the cut which includes the product filters like burgers, fish, and shellfish. While there aren't as many total listings at Rastelli's as some other fish-focused websites, the 20 seafood options include fresh, pre-seasoned, smoked, and pre-made fish burgers all in one place. With super-easy navigation and a modern website, Rastelli's online store is a pleasure to shop.

Great prices, but not many options

To compare the prices at Rastelli's with other competitors, we checked on the cost of various products available including their fish filets, the shellfish selection, the most expensive fish item at Rastelli's, and finally bundled items. In terms of fish, Rastelli's offers a relatively focused selection compared to other competitors in our review. Their assortment includes 14 traditional fish, ranging from $12 for 2 filets to $40 for 8 filets. When it comes to shellfish, Rastelli's provides a limited array of 6 products. The shellfish prices range from $25 for one 5 oz Maine lobster tail to $49 for 2 lbs of gulf shrimp. The most expensive individual seafood item at Rastelli's is the $49 gulf shrimp.

Bundle pack pricing

The most expensive pack of fish is the $249 salmon-lovers super pack. There are two other "super packs" available from Rastelli's that focus on seafood. Both are very salmon-focused and range in price from $235 to $249. While we wish there were some more options available here, the pieces are highly competitive.

Best Seafood Stores

Transparency and sustainable partners

In their quest for transparency, Rastelli's has embarked on a global search for the most suitable partners to meet their diverse sourcing needs. These partnerships are viewed as true collaborations, where both parties are mutually invested in each other's well-being. They actively seek out farming and fishing families with a rich heritage, a genuine passion for their work, and a proven track record of responsibly caring for their animals and the environment. Through close collaboration and adherence to rigorous standards, all products sourced by the company are guaranteed to be free of antibiotics, steroids, and hormones. If Rastelli's quality control staff don't feel confident about the origin of a product, they refuse to endorse it, and they encourage their customers to do the same.

Gifting to multiple people

Rastelli's has a unique approach to gifting. You can choose any item on their website to send as a gift, but if you have more than one family member or loved one that you want to give tasty seafood, you can use the "Multiple Gifts" form to simultaneously send gifts to different people in different locations. There are also a variety of "super bundles" you can send as gifts. There are also digital gift cards that range in price from $50 to $300.

Free shipping on orders over $200

Rastelli's ensures a seamless shopping experience for its customers within the continental U.S. To provide added convenience, Rastelli's offers different shipping options based on the order value. Orders over $200 are eligible for free shipping, while a nominal shipping fee of $10 is charged for orders ranging from $100 to $199. For orders under $100, a shipping fee of $25 applies. However, it is important to note that shipments to Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada are currently unavailable, and they are unable to deliver to military bases.

Refund policy is customer-focused

Rastelli's prioritizes customer satisfaction above all else. If there are any concerns or issues with your products, Rastelli's encourages you to inform them. They value your feedback and are committed to resolving any concerns. Simply reach out to them within 21 days of receiving your shipment, and they promise to offer a refund, either for the entire shipment or a partial refund based on the specific circumstances.

Best Seafood Stores

Sustainable on all their products

Rastelli's seafood selection is exclusively sourced through a combination of wild-caught methods or responsible aquaculture practices that prioritize sustainability and the preservation of natural ecosystems. They get their salmon from the Faroe Islands in the North Atlantic, their yellowtail tuna from Indonesia, and jumbo shrimp from the balmy Gulf of Mexico. On top of these promises, they also provide a page on their site dedicated to each type of fish they offer, so you can see the sustainable practices for each individual product. This is also mirrored on their land-food side where they are equally focused on sustainability.

High ratings but low buzz

In terms of the company's reputation, the site isn't as talked-about as we had hoped for a company that's been open so long. However, the reviews that are out there are really good. Customers have ranked Rastelli's 4.2 stars out of 5 on average. On top of this, they also have an "A-" rating from the Better Business Bureau, showing a commitment to customer satisfaction overall. However, with just over 100 total reviews online we felt there wasn't quite enough feedback to verify how happy customers really are with Rastelli's, so you may want to keep that in mind before you buy.

Top one-stop shop for meats

Overall, we love the commitment to sustainability at Rastelli's. On the other hand, with only 20 total products available for seafood enthusiasts, this isn't the top retailer in terms of variety. However, if you're looking for a one-stop shop for all your butchery needs, Rastelli's is a great place to check out and fully deserving of its 4-star rating overall. The only reason it isn't ranked higher is the general lack of reviews and slightly lower BBB rating than some other options in this review. But, if you like group gifts and low prices, it's worth your time to look at Rastelli's for your next meat or fish fix.

Where Can You Find the Best Seafood Stores?

Whether you're a seafood connoisseur or simply love indulging in a delicious seafood feast, finding a reliable supplier is essential. With options ranging from fresh fish to shellfish and everything in between, seafood stores provide a wide variety of choices for seafood lovers. And the best part? Many of these stores offer the convenience of online shopping, allowing you to explore their offerings from the comfort of your home.

Seafood stores offer a wide range of products, including fish, shrimp, lobster, crab, oysters, and more. The variety and quality of the selection can vary from store to store. Whether you're searching for a specific type of fish or want to explore new flavors, it's important to consider the diversity of options offered by each seafood store. A store with a diverse selection allows you to try new and exciting seafood dishes, ensuring a satisfying culinary experience.

The Best Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Company Reviews What are the best Seafood Companies Best Seafood Company Reviews

Seafood Company FAQ

If it's aquatic and edible, it's probably classified as seafood. This includes crustaceans like lobsters and shrimp, mollusks such as clams and oysters, plus most varieties of fish.
The clue is in the name: one type is raised similar to livestock, while the other is caught out in open waters. Farm-raised seafood is often considered more sustainable than wild-caught and is usually less expensive.
Have you ever gone to the supermarket and caught a whiff of that fishy smell? That usually means that the seafood isn't fresh. Buying it online shortens the process from catch to consumption, eliminating many of the middle steps of transportation and shelving that lead to less flavorful seafood.
Online seafood companies take great care to carefully prepare and package your delivery. Boxes often include cold packs and insulation to make sure it's in perfect shape when it arrives at your doorstep.
Sometimes. It depends on the seafood company you select and how much you order. Some retailers offer free shipping with a certain minimum order amount.
That's where the fun really starts. How about a paella dinner box, some chowder or dessert to go along with your seafood? There are so many options you can include to really round out your special occasion meal or just for the halibut. (Sorry.)
Yes, and your dinner guests thank you for asking. Most online seafood retailers have both raw and prepared choices among their seafood offerings. When you get a little more confident in your abilities, trust that you'll be able to find plenty of step-by-step instruction - either included with your delivery or on the website (or both).
Please and thank you! While not every online seafood store has robust gift-giving options, some want to make it as easy as possible to send a delightful gift to your lucky recipient. From oil/vinegar samplers to dark chocolate or even just a gift card to spend as they like, your loved ones will appreciate your thoughtfulness. You can usually include a personalized note to accompany the delivery; just look for that feature during the checkout process.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Seafood is a popular choice for many people, and it's no wonder considering its versatility and health benefits. According to research, seafood is a rich source of essential nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals. It is also associated with numerous health benefits, including improved heart health and brain function and protection against heart attack or Alzheimer's. With seafood being in high demand, it's important to find a seafood store that consistently delivers the freshest and highest quality products.

When it comes to seafood, freshness is key. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) advises consumers to choose seafood that is fresh, properly handled, and stored at the correct temperatures to reduce the risk of foodborne illnesses. This makes it crucial to find a seafood store that prioritizes freshness and follows proper handling procedures. This is especially important if you're hoping to make dishes that aren't cooked as thoroughly, like sushi or sashimi dishes.

For this reason, it can be particularly helpful to shop for your seafood online. Reputable vendors prioritize the freshness and quality of their products through rigorous quality control measures. Some even source their fish directly from fishermen or sustainable fisheries, promoting a farm-to-table experience. And online markets often offer access to rare or specialty fish that may not be readily available locally, allowing you to indulge in unique culinary experiences. Online fish markets offer a wide variety of fish and seafood products, giving you the opportunity to explore a diverse range of species and try new flavors.

When choosing a seafood store online, there are so many options to choose from. If you're not sure how to get started, don't worry! We've got your back. Below is a list of factors you can keep in mind to help you choose the best seafood store for your needs.

  • Price. Price is a significant consideration for many individuals when it comes to choosing an online store for seafood, especially with shipping costs. The affordability of seafood can determine how much you can buy and how often you can enjoy barbecue salmon or whitefish nigiri. Being mindful of your budget and the fairness of market value for fish can help you decide where to buy.
  • Variety. Are you just looking for the basics? Or do you want a very specific or rare kind of fish? It's important to look at the kind of variety offered by each seafood store to ensure they have what you want or that you don't need to shop in multiple places.
  • Shipping. Shipping is a two-pronged issue for seafood. While you want to make sure you can get good deals on shipping, it's also very important to know how fast and how well refrigerated an online seafood store will send your food. You want to make sure the high-quality fish you buy stays high quality by the time it reaches you.
  • Sustainability. If you're one of the customers worried about sustainability, you may want to check out the eco-friendliness of the seafood store you're shopping with. Keep an eye on their specific moves to highlight sustainability in their business model.
  • Customer satisfaction. Customers aren't professional fishermen (most of the time), but they do provide good insight into things you love. Keeping an eye on a company's reputation with customers can help you decide if it's the right place for you to pick up a red snapper or crawfish.

To make the process of finding the seafood store go swimmingly, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best options for seafood stores on the market today. We hope this information helps you enjoy your seafood fix and prioritize your health and wellness at the same time!

Compare Seafood Companies

Select any 2 Seafood Companies to compare them head to head

  • Sizzlefish
  • Wulf's Fish
  • Cameron's Seafood
  • Fulton Fish Market
  • Rastelli's
  • Know Seafood
  • Vital Choice
  • Giovanni's Fish Market
  • Riviera Seafood Club
  • Global Seafoods
Sizzlefish vs Wulf's Fish Sizzlefish vs Cameron's Seafood Sizzlefish vs Fulton Fish Market Sizzlefish vs Rastelli's Sizzlefish vs Know Seafood Sizzlefish vs Vital Choice Sizzlefish vs Giovanni's Fish Market Sizzlefish vs Riviera Seafood Club Sizzlefish vs Global Seafoods Wulf's Fish vs Cameron's Seafood Wulf's Fish vs Fulton Fish Market Wulf's Fish vs Rastelli's Wulf's Fish vs Know Seafood Wulf's Fish vs Vital Choice Wulf's Fish vs Giovanni's Fish Market Wulf's Fish vs Riviera Seafood Club Wulf's Fish vs Global Seafoods Cameron's Seafood vs Fulton Fish Market Cameron's Seafood vs Rastelli's Cameron's Seafood vs Know Seafood Cameron's Seafood vs Vital Choice Cameron's Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market Cameron's Seafood vs Riviera Seafood Club Cameron's Seafood vs Global Seafoods Fulton Fish Market vs Rastelli's Fulton Fish Market vs Know Seafood Fulton Fish Market vs Vital Choice Fulton Fish Market vs Giovanni's Fish Market Fulton Fish Market vs Riviera Seafood Club Fulton Fish Market vs Global Seafoods Rastelli's vs Know Seafood Rastelli's vs Vital Choice Rastelli's vs Giovanni's Fish Market Rastelli's vs Riviera Seafood Club Rastelli's vs Global Seafoods Know Seafood vs Vital Choice Know Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market Know Seafood vs Riviera Seafood Club Know Seafood vs Global Seafoods Vital Choice vs Giovanni's Fish Market Vital Choice vs Riviera Seafood Club Vital Choice vs Global Seafoods Giovanni's Fish Market vs Riviera Seafood Club Giovanni's Fish Market vs Global Seafoods Riviera Seafood Club vs Global Seafoods
Compare the Best Seafood Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Seafood Companies
The Best Reviews of Seafood Companies