Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Sizzlefish Review

Saturday, January 29th

2022 Seafood Company Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Sizzlefish Review 5 Star Rating

Sizzlefish

5 Star Rating
  • Gift Options: Gift suggestions, gift cards (physical or electronic), gift message available on all orders, samplers and holiday arrangements, subscription plans
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Sizzlefish started out as a supplier of fish and seafood to some of the best-known natural and premium grocery companies in America, and then it dawned on their owner: seafood and other fish is a great source of protein for fitness and overall health, so why not make it available for direct-ship to individuals too? Hence, Sizzlefish was born.

What can't you buy?

So, what can you buy through this company? The more accurate question may be what can't you buy? Their seafood options include shrimp, scallops, lobster, calamari, mussels, soft-shell crab, crab cakes, and king crab. But, that's not all: there are over a dozen options for fish too, from common varieties like tuna and salmon to lesser-known types such as sablefish and rockfish. All of their products come packaged in individual portions, so you don't have to worry about cooking up an entire filet if you only need enough for a single meal. It's also flash-frozen for peak freshness

Wild-caught seafood

Most of the seafood from this company is wild-caught, which appeals to those who are trying to avoid farm-raised animal products. The few notable exceptions are the catfish, rainbow trout, and Atlantic salmon, if that's an important distinction for you.

Easy gift-giving options

We like that Sizzlefish makes it easy to pick out gifts: either click on the Products dropdown or the left side of the page and click on Gift Ideas if you need some suggestions. You'll find plenty of ideas like Gifts Under $100, Holiday Samplers, Smoked Fish and more. You can also choose gift cards, either delivered via email or actual physical cards, in denominations ranting from $50 to $500. You can also call Sizzlefish if you'd prefer a gift card in a custom amount. Plus, on any order you'll have the option of adding a gift note during the checkout process - but it's also where you have to enter any special instructions or preferred delivery date, so you might be a little limited for space.

Best Seafood Stores

Subscription plan

Another handy option, for yourself or someone else, is a subscription plan. If you want your seafood delivered on a regular schedule, this is worth considering. Sizzlefish offers three choices: Wild Seafood Favorites, Prime, and Prime Plus. The first plan is hand-picked by Sizzlefish, while the Prime and Prime Plus allow you to choose 14 servings of the seafood and fish of your choice. Both of those two subscriptions include some of the same options, such as crab cakes and wild Gulf shrimp, while the Plus package has premium products like sea bass and halibut. You'll pay $97.86 per delivery for Prime and $111.86 for Prime Plus. (Mysteriously, Sizzlefish didn't list the price for the Favorites plan.)

Extra savings

You could get extra savings on your order from Sizzlefish: we got a pop-up as we browsed that offered a 10% discount on our first purchase if we signed up for their email newsletter. We saw another 10% discount code while looking around the site, so you might be able to find something when you're shopping too. Plus, everything you buy from this store ships for free, packed in dry ice to ensure that it's still frozen when it arrives. Considering that some of their competitors charge up to $100 for delivery, this is definitely a point in Sizzlefish's favor.

Over 12,000 customer reviews

Sizzlefish didn't turn up when we looked for a listing with the Better Business Bureau. However, on a third-party ratings site, we were pleasantly surprised to find more than 12,000 customer reviews - with an extraordinary 4.9 out of 5-star average. And those reviews were written by people who know their stuff when it comes to seafood: one person who used to catch their own squid said that what they got from Sizzlefish was the only seafood they found that compared, and another shopper that was once an "avid coastal fisherman" described how happy they were to finally fill the void of having great fish to eat. That's some praise! It's no wonder, then, that thousands of people have given this seafood store a perfect five stars.

Great customer attention

That customer satisfaction is partly because of Sizzlefish's solid replacement policy: if your seafood arrives thawed or with any other issues, you can get a prompt replacement as long as you let them know within 7 days of receipt. They request that you include a photo with your emailed replacement request, but it's not mandatory.

Above and beyond

Sizzlefish went above and beyond our expectations with not just their selection but their extremely high quality - as evidenced by the comments from clients who are themselves experts in what good seafood tastes like. Because of their customer-centric approach to delivering world-class products, Sizzlefish earns our highest rating among online stores that offer seafood.

Who Sells the Best Seafood?

If you're a fan of crab, lobster, shrimp, oysters and more, you already know how challenging it can be to find your favorites locally - especially if you live far from the coast. Getting the best seafood at a supermarket or even a specialty store can be extremely hit-or-miss, because of high prices and lack of variety most of the time.

Fortunately, like almost everything else you buy, seafood can easily be ordered online. Sound "fishy"? Not at all: some of the world's most renowned fishmongers make their products available for direct delivery to your home, giving you access to the freshest fish on the market (short of catching it yourself!).

The Best Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Company Reviews What are the best Seafood Companies Best Seafood Company Reviews

Seafood Company FAQ

If it's aquatic and edible, it's probably classified as seafood. This includes crustaceans like lobsters and shrimp, mollusks such as clams and oysters, plus most varieties of fish.
The clue is in the name: one type is raised similar to livestock, while the other is caught out in open waters. Farm-raised seafood is often considered more sustainable than wild-caught and is usually less expensive.
Have you ever gone to the supermarket and caught a whiff of that fishy smell? That usually means that the seafood isn't fresh. Buying it online shortens the process from catch to consumption, eliminating many of the middle steps of transportation and shelving that lead to less flavorful seafood.
Online seafood companies take great care to carefully prepare and package your delivery. Boxes often include cold packs and insulation to make sure it's in perfect shape when it arrives at your doorstep.
Sometimes. It depends on the seafood company you select and how much you order. Some retailers offer free shipping with a certain minimum order amount.
That's where the fun really starts. How about a paella dinner box, some chowder or dessert to go along with your seafood? There are so many options you can include to really round out your special occasion meal or just for the halibut. (Sorry.)
Yes, and your dinner guests thank you for asking. Most online seafood retailers have both raw and prepared choices among their seafood offerings. When you get a little more confident in your abilities, trust that you'll be able to find plenty of step-by-step instruction - either included with your delivery or on the website (or both).
Please and thank you! While not every online seafood store has robust gift-giving options, some want to make it as easy as possible to send a delightful gift to your lucky recipient. From oil/vinegar samplers to dark chocolate or even just a gift card to spend as they like, your loved ones will appreciate your thoughtfulness. You can usually include a personalized note to accompany the delivery; just look for that feature during the checkout process.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

The best online seafood stores guarantee that you'll be 100% satisfied with your order, so that you don't have to worry about the quality of the packaging or the food itself. Another great perk of buying seafood online from a reputable store is the ability to select package deals. Why settle for just crab legs or a lobster tail when you can mix-and-match all of your favorites?

Some retailers go beyond seafood and allow you to purchase full meal packages, surf-and-turf combos, and much more. And, best of all, many of these packages and individual seafood items can be sent as a gift to the foodies on your gift-giving lists. (Say goodbye to boring gift cards!)

Whether you're buying seafood for yourself or someone else, you've got lots of options. How can you tell which online seafood store is the right one? Here are several factors to keep in mind as you make your decision:

  • Selection. Does the company offer a wide variety of seafood to choose from, or do they specialize in just a few kinds? What gift-giving options are available?
  • Pricing. How much can you expect to spend for the seafood you're craving? Are prices competitive with what you'd find at a competitor's site?
  • Reputation. What do other shoppers say about their experiences buying seafood from the company? Is the customer service team knowledgeable and responsive if problems arise? Is there a strong satisfaction guarantee in place, in the event that your seafood arrives less-than-fresh?

TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the best sources of seafood available to order online. We hope this information helps you get the freshest, most flavorful seafood delivered right to your home - or to the home of your lucky gift recipient!

The Best Reviews of Seafood Companies