Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Sizzlefish Review

Sunday, April 21st

2024 Seafood Company Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Sizzlefish Review 5 Star Rating


5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from: $9.99 to $455.15
  • E-gift cards
  • Free shipping on orders over $100
  • $10 to $25 flat-rate shipping on orders <$100
  • Subscription boxes
  • Certified sustainable wild-caught
  • Refunds within 7 days
  • Highest ratings with reviewers
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Sizzlefish originally emerged as a prominent supplier of fish and seafood to renowned natural and premium grocery companies in the United States. However, the owner had an epiphany: seafood and fish are excellent sources of protein for fitness and overall health, so why not make them accessible for direct shipping to individuals?

Pure, high quality fish

Their mission is straightforward: they aim to enhance customers' well-being and improve their lives by offering pure, top-notch fish that they can rely on, conveniently delivered to their doorsteps. Customers can count on them to provide natural fish portions, accompanied by useful tools and tips for easy and quick preparation, as well as transparent information about the benefits derived from Sizzlefish products.

Top option for variety

The abundance of options is staggering when it comes to what you can buy from this company. In fact, a more accurate question might be, what can't you buy? Their seafood selection includes tantalizing choices like shrimp, scallops, lobster, calamari, mussels, soft-shell crab, crab cakes, and king crab. But it doesn't stop there. Sizzlefish offers over a dozen fish varieties, ranging from well-known favorites like tuna and salmon to lesser-known delicacies such as sablefish and rockfish. Each product is conveniently packaged in individual portions, ensuring you can easily prepare the right amount for a single meal. Furthermore, their flash-freezing process guarantees peak freshness upon delivery.

Massive inventory and competitive pricing

In order to compare prices among different retailers in this review, we examined four specific products. We looked at the prices for traditional fish, shellfish, the highest-priced item in the store, and any bundled packages. Sizzlefish has a wide variety of fresh fish with over 84 individual products available. The prices for fish range from $9.99 for one 5 oz portion to $119.95 for Black Chilean sea bass. Sizzlefish also offers a wide variety of shellfish with prices ranging from $14.95 for 8 shrimp to $249.95 for 3 lbs of King Crab legs.

Best Seafood Stores

Bundle packs

Like many options in this review, the most expensive item is also a bundle pack, so we'll go over those first. At Sizzlefish, there are 31 different samplers and boxes to choose from. The prices range from $88.95 for a smoked fish box up to $455.15 for the "Wild Freezer Stuffer Seafood Bundle" . This is also, consequently, the most expensive item at Sizzlefish. With its wide range of prices, Sizzlefish is highly competitive. It offers affordable options as well as high-end seafood and provides comprehensive choices for lobster, crab, and fish.

Subscription for regular seafood shipments

To enhance convenience, Sizzlefish provides a subscription plan option. Whether for yourself or someone else, subscribing allows you to receive regular seafood deliveries according to a predetermined schedule. Sizzlefish offers three subscription choices: Wild Seafood Favorites, Prime, and Prime Plus. The Wild Seafood Favorites plan is meticulously curated by the Sizzlefish team, while the Prime and Prime Plus plans provide you with the flexibility to select 14 or 28 servings of your favorite seafood and fish.

Premium fish products

Both Prime and Prime Plus include popular products like crab cakes and wild Gulf shrimp. However, the Prime Plus package elevates the experience with premium products such as sea bass and halibut. The Prime subscription costs $139.95 for 14 portions and $229.95 for 28 portions per delivery. The Prime Plus subscription is priced at $145.95 for 14 portions and $257.95 for 28 portions per delivery. The cost for the Favorites plan only has one option which is $129.95 for 12 portions per delivery. The best part of the subscriptions is that you get regular shipments and you can change your mind at any time and cancel your membership.

Best Seafood Stores

Sustainably wild-caught

For those who prefer wild-caught seafood over farm-raised options, Sizzlefish is a perfect fit. Most of their seafood is sourced from the wild, catering to the preferences of those striving to avoid farm-raised animal products. However, it's worth noting that catfish, rainbow trout, and Atlantic salmon are the few exceptions to this, in case that distinction holds significance for you.

Give the gift of seafood

Sizzlefish goes above and beyond to facilitate gift-giving. Whether you're seeking inspiration or need suggestions, their user-friendly website allows you to explore various gift ideas conveniently. From Gifts Under $100 to Holiday Samplers and Smoked Fish, you'll find an array of options to suit every occasion. Additionally, they offer gift cards, available in both digital and physical formats, with denominations ranging from $50 to $500. If you prefer a custom amount, a simple phone call to Sizzlefish can accommodate your needs. During the checkout process, you have the opportunity to include a personalized gift note, ensuring your present is extra special.

Deals across the site

Sizzlefish doesn't shy away from offering extra savings to its customers. During our browsing experience, we received a pop-up notification offering a 10% discount on our first purchase if we signed up for their email newsletter. Furthermore, while exploring the site, we encountered another 10% discount code, suggesting that there are potential savings waiting to be discovered during the shopping process.

Shipping is free of charge on orders over $100

Free delivery? If you buy more than $100 worth of seafood from Sizzlefish, you can easily score free shipping. Each item is meticulously packed with dry ice to guarantee that it arrives still frozen. While this isn't as low of an order threshold as some companies in this review, the $100 threshold is still very competitive. With some competitors charging exorbitant amounts, sometimes up to $300, for delivery, Sizzlefish stands out as one of the more affordable shipping options.

Best Seafood Stores

Satisfaction guaranteed by Sizzlefish

The Sizzlefish team strives for your complete satisfaction with the quality of their products. If you happen to receive fish items that are thawed, significantly damaged, or encounter other substantial issues, they are committed to replacing them at no additional cost. You have 7 days from receiving the products to reach out to their customer service team, which is longer than many companies in this review who only allow you to complain within 24 or 48 hours. While not mandatory, they appreciate it if you can also include a photograph of the issue, as it aids their Quality Control department in addressing any packaging or shipping concerns. The replacement will be shipped using the same shipping method as the original order.

Top-rated with thousands of reviews

We couldn't find Sizzlefish listed on the Better Business Bureau, but we were pleasantly surprised to discover over 12,000 customer reviews on a third-party rating site. These reviews boast an impressive average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. What's even more remarkable is that these reviews come from seafood connoisseurs, including individuals who have experience catching their own squid or who are avid coastal fishermen. They praise Sizzlefish for providing seafood that rivals their own catches and filling the void of great fish to eat. With thousands of people awarding Sizzlefish a perfect five-star rating, it's clear why this seafood store receives such high praise.

Top performer across the board

With a health-focused business model, a-la-carte selections as well as the ability to sign up for a subscription box, Sizzlefish really allows you to make your seafood experience fit your needs. The prices are competitive, and not overpriced, and the shipping is also very reasonable even if you don't make it to the $100 threshold. And while there isn't a BBB page for Sizzlefish, this business is top-rated by customers, some of whom are experienced fishermen and cooks, lending further credibility to the reviews. Overall, there are no downsides to trying out Sizzlefish, and for this reason it's our top option for your next place to buy seafood online.

Where Can You Find the Best Seafood Stores?

Whether you're a seafood connoisseur or simply love indulging in a delicious seafood feast, finding a reliable supplier is essential. With options ranging from fresh fish to shellfish and everything in between, seafood stores provide a wide variety of choices for seafood lovers. And the best part? Many of these stores offer the convenience of online shopping, allowing you to explore their offerings from the comfort of your home.

Seafood stores offer a wide range of products, including fish, shrimp, lobster, crab, oysters, and more. The variety and quality of the selection can vary from store to store. Whether you're searching for a specific type of fish or want to explore new flavors, it's important to consider the diversity of options offered by each seafood store. A store with a diverse selection allows you to try new and exciting seafood dishes, ensuring a satisfying culinary experience.

The Best Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Companies Compare Seafood Company Reviews What are the best Seafood Companies Best Seafood Company Reviews

Seafood Company FAQ

If it's aquatic and edible, it's probably classified as seafood. This includes crustaceans like lobsters and shrimp, mollusks such as clams and oysters, plus most varieties of fish.
The clue is in the name: one type is raised similar to livestock, while the other is caught out in open waters. Farm-raised seafood is often considered more sustainable than wild-caught and is usually less expensive.
Have you ever gone to the supermarket and caught a whiff of that fishy smell? That usually means that the seafood isn't fresh. Buying it online shortens the process from catch to consumption, eliminating many of the middle steps of transportation and shelving that lead to less flavorful seafood.
Online seafood companies take great care to carefully prepare and package your delivery. Boxes often include cold packs and insulation to make sure it's in perfect shape when it arrives at your doorstep.
Sometimes. It depends on the seafood company you select and how much you order. Some retailers offer free shipping with a certain minimum order amount.
That's where the fun really starts. How about a paella dinner box, some chowder or dessert to go along with your seafood? There are so many options you can include to really round out your special occasion meal or just for the halibut. (Sorry.)
Yes, and your dinner guests thank you for asking. Most online seafood retailers have both raw and prepared choices among their seafood offerings. When you get a little more confident in your abilities, trust that you'll be able to find plenty of step-by-step instruction - either included with your delivery or on the website (or both).
Please and thank you! While not every online seafood store has robust gift-giving options, some want to make it as easy as possible to send a delightful gift to your lucky recipient. From oil/vinegar samplers to dark chocolate or even just a gift card to spend as they like, your loved ones will appreciate your thoughtfulness. You can usually include a personalized note to accompany the delivery; just look for that feature during the checkout process.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Seafood is a popular choice for many people, and it's no wonder considering its versatility and health benefits. According to research, seafood is a rich source of essential nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals. It is also associated with numerous health benefits, including improved heart health and brain function and protection against heart attack or Alzheimer's. With seafood being in high demand, it's important to find a seafood store that consistently delivers the freshest and highest quality products.

When it comes to seafood, freshness is key. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) advises consumers to choose seafood that is fresh, properly handled, and stored at the correct temperatures to reduce the risk of foodborne illnesses. This makes it crucial to find a seafood store that prioritizes freshness and follows proper handling procedures. This is especially important if you're hoping to make dishes that aren't cooked as thoroughly, like sushi or sashimi dishes.

For this reason, it can be particularly helpful to shop for your seafood online. Reputable vendors prioritize the freshness and quality of their products through rigorous quality control measures. Some even source their fish directly from fishermen or sustainable fisheries, promoting a farm-to-table experience. And online markets often offer access to rare or specialty fish that may not be readily available locally, allowing you to indulge in unique culinary experiences. Online fish markets offer a wide variety of fish and seafood products, giving you the opportunity to explore a diverse range of species and try new flavors.

When choosing a seafood store online, there are so many options to choose from. If you're not sure how to get started, don't worry! We've got your back. Below is a list of factors you can keep in mind to help you choose the best seafood store for your needs.

  • Price. Price is a significant consideration for many individuals when it comes to choosing an online store for seafood, especially with shipping costs. The affordability of seafood can determine how much you can buy and how often you can enjoy barbecue salmon or whitefish nigiri. Being mindful of your budget and the fairness of market value for fish can help you decide where to buy.
  • Variety. Are you just looking for the basics? Or do you want a very specific or rare kind of fish? It's important to look at the kind of variety offered by each seafood store to ensure they have what you want or that you don't need to shop in multiple places.
  • Shipping. Shipping is a two-pronged issue for seafood. While you want to make sure you can get good deals on shipping, it's also very important to know how fast and how well refrigerated an online seafood store will send your food. You want to make sure the high-quality fish you buy stays high quality by the time it reaches you.
  • Sustainability. If you're one of the customers worried about sustainability, you may want to check out the eco-friendliness of the seafood store you're shopping with. Keep an eye on their specific moves to highlight sustainability in their business model.
  • Customer satisfaction. Customers aren't professional fishermen (most of the time), but they do provide good insight into things you love. Keeping an eye on a company's reputation with customers can help you decide if it's the right place for you to pick up a red snapper or crawfish.

To make the process of finding the seafood store go swimmingly, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best options for seafood stores on the market today. We hope this information helps you enjoy your seafood fix and prioritize your health and wellness at the same time!

Compare Seafood Companies

Select any 2 Seafood Companies to compare them head to head

  • Sizzlefish
  • Wulf's Fish
  • Cameron's Seafood
  • Fulton Fish Market
  • Rastelli's
  • Know Seafood
  • Vital Choice
  • Giovanni's Fish Market
  • Riviera Seafood Club
  • Global Seafoods
Sizzlefish vs Wulf's Fish Sizzlefish vs Cameron's Seafood Sizzlefish vs Fulton Fish Market Sizzlefish vs Rastelli's Sizzlefish vs Know Seafood Sizzlefish vs Vital Choice Sizzlefish vs Giovanni's Fish Market Sizzlefish vs Riviera Seafood Club Sizzlefish vs Global Seafoods Wulf's Fish vs Cameron's Seafood Wulf's Fish vs Fulton Fish Market Wulf's Fish vs Rastelli's Wulf's Fish vs Know Seafood Wulf's Fish vs Vital Choice Wulf's Fish vs Giovanni's Fish Market Wulf's Fish vs Riviera Seafood Club Wulf's Fish vs Global Seafoods Cameron's Seafood vs Fulton Fish Market Cameron's Seafood vs Rastelli's Cameron's Seafood vs Know Seafood Cameron's Seafood vs Vital Choice Cameron's Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market Cameron's Seafood vs Riviera Seafood Club Cameron's Seafood vs Global Seafoods Fulton Fish Market vs Rastelli's Fulton Fish Market vs Know Seafood Fulton Fish Market vs Vital Choice Fulton Fish Market vs Giovanni's Fish Market Fulton Fish Market vs Riviera Seafood Club Fulton Fish Market vs Global Seafoods Rastelli's vs Know Seafood Rastelli's vs Vital Choice Rastelli's vs Giovanni's Fish Market Rastelli's vs Riviera Seafood Club Rastelli's vs Global Seafoods Know Seafood vs Vital Choice Know Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market Know Seafood vs Riviera Seafood Club Know Seafood vs Global Seafoods Vital Choice vs Giovanni's Fish Market Vital Choice vs Riviera Seafood Club Vital Choice vs Global Seafoods Giovanni's Fish Market vs Riviera Seafood Club Giovanni's Fish Market vs Global Seafoods Riviera Seafood Club vs Global Seafoods
Compare the Best Seafood Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Seafood Companies
The Best Reviews of Seafood Companies