Best Senior Dating Sites in New York

We've analyzed the best Senior Dating Sites to help you find the right solution for your needs.

The Best Senior Dating Sites in New York

Where can I find the best Senior Dating Sites in New York? New York makes you picky in the best way when you're shopping online for senior dating sites. You want tools that actually help you meet folks around the state, whether you're upstate on weekends or staying close to the Q train. You can filter by borough or ZIP, check who's active nearby, and still keep things flexible for travel. With so many choices, you'll want clear pricing, strong safety features, and easy ways to set age and distance.

The Best Senior Dating Sites in New York

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • 1 month for $29.95
  • 3 months for $59.95 (or $19.98 per month)
  • 6 months for $95.95 (or $15.99 per month)

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the Senior Match website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Priced from $24.99 to $44.99 per month
  • In-depth personality questionnaire
  • Send smiles for free

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.5

On the Silver Singles website

4.4

GREAT

3

Great

  • Free trial
  • Pricing starts at $24.99 per month for 3 months
  • The original dating site, in operation since 1995

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.4

On the Match website

4.0

VERY GOOD

4

Very Good

  • Basic Membership: free
  • Paid membership is from $40 to $60 per month
  • One of the most successful relationship-creating dating sites

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the Eharmony website

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • Limited free membership
  • Basic membership from $14.99 to $44.99 per month
  • Premium membership from $22.49 to $54.99 per month

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the OkCupid website

3.0

AVERAGE

6

Average

  • Limited free version
  • Pricing starts at about $5 per month
  • Fantastic free features

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

3.0

On the Plenty of Fish website

2.5

FAIR

7

Fair

  • Limited free access
  • Subscriptions starting at $12.99 per month
  • One of the first online senior-focused dating sites

Read Full Review

FAIR

2.5

On the OurTime website

2.0

SUBPAR

8

Subpar

  • Price from $19.99 to $59.99 per month
  • Intended for ages 40+
  • Video call feature

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Singles50 website

1.9

SUBPAR

9

Subpar

  • Limited free membership
  • $19.99 per month for 150 credits per month
  • $149.99 per month for 600 credits per month

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

1.9

On the DateMyAge website

1.0

POOR

10

Poor

  • Price depends on which company you are handed off to
  • Refers you to other senior dating sites
  • Your cost is determined by which actual dating company you're recommended

Read Full Review

POOR

1.0

On the Mature Dating Only website

Continued from above...

Where Can I Find the Best Senior Dating Sites in New York?

New York makes you picky in the best way when you're shopping online for senior dating sites. You want tools that actually help you meet folks around the state, whether you're upstate on weekends or staying close to the Q train. You can filter by borough or ZIP, check who's active nearby, and still keep things flexible for travel. With so many choices, you'll want clear pricing, strong safety features, and easy ways to set age and distance.

From Buffalo to Syracuse, you can narrow the pool fast with location filters, but you still get reach when you feel like casting a wider net. You might've seen Pew Research note that about 13% of adults 65+ have tried online dating, and New York's older crowd keeps growing - roughly 18% of residents are 65 or older, according to recent census estimates. That matters because you'll see more active profiles at your age, not just dormant accounts. When you see daily activity counts or last-login stamps, you can gauge how lively things look in your corner of New York.

On a rainy afternoon, you might be scrolling between coffee sips and wondering which features actually protect you. You'll see repeated FTC warnings that older adults can face higher median losses in romance scams than younger users, so you'll want ID or photo verification, in-app reporting, and clear guidance on avoiding money requests. You can stick to in-app messaging, set up a first meeting in a busy spot like Bryant Park or a well-lit diner, and let a friend know the plan. When video chat comes built in, you can do a quick face-to-face before you can lock in a time.

Meanwhile, you can try a couple of senior-focused options to see what fits. With OurTime, you get straightforward profiles and simple search tools, while SilverSingles starts you with a personality questionnaire - you'll answer once and get curated matches. With eHarmony, you can go deeper on compatibility across New York, though you might spend a bit more for premium filters and read receipts.

In Albany, you might appreciate apps that list community events or interest groups, so you can pick something like a matinee at The Egg or a river walk when the weather cooperates. You can watch trial periods closely - those can run as short as 3 or 7 days - and you'll want to check renewal terms so a promo price doesn't jump. New York winters can nudge you to date by video first, then meet when sidewalks aren't slushy. With alerts set for new matches and a profile that shows recent photos, you'll give yourself a clear shot at meeting someone who fits your rhythm.

When deciding that you'd like to try online dating, especially for seniors, here are some points to consider:

To help you find someone for a long-term relationship, a new friend, or perhaps a travel partner, Top Consumer Reviews has carefully reviewed senior dating sites to help you find the best and avoid the worst. Whether you choose a dating website or app, we're confident you can meet someone special.

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Senior Dating Site FAQ

How "young" do you have to be to use a dating site for seniors?
Believe it or not, some of these services consider you a senior if you're at least 40! However, the majority are geared towards people 50 and up.
Are Senior Dating websites legitimate?
Absolutely! You might spot a few newer services, but many of them have been around for a long time.
Why would I use a site for seniors instead of a general dating service?
That's a matter of preference, but if you're looking for a mature individual for friendship, companionship, romance or even marriage, you're more likely to find him or her on a site that caters to seniors. If you don't want to have to wade through inquiries from people who are considerably younger than you, a dating service for more "seasoned" people can spare you the hassle.
How many people use these sites?
Thousands of seniors create online dating profiles every year. But, not every site has an equally robust membership, so it's a good idea to choose a service with plenty of people in your area.
How much does it cost to use a Senior Dating site?
Most of them are free to join and create a profile. Once you start getting messages and want to respond to them, you'll need to choose a paid membership plan. These are usually priced between $9.99 and $36 per month.
Is it safe to use an online dating website?
Lots of people of all ages have used online dating to find the right companion. But, it's always wise to exercise caution as you start interacting with people through the service. Be selective with the personal information you give out, and consider meeting in a public place when you see each other in person for the first time.
Is there a satisfaction guarantee?
Unfortunately, not most of the time. (Like the Genie says in Aladdin, these services can't make anyone fall in love with you!) On the other hand, since paid plans are usually month-to-month, you're not locked into a contract if you use the senior dating service for a while and decide it's not the right fit.
Do people really find love and companionship on Senior Dating sites?
Of course! For people of all ages, online dating sites make it easier to find someone who is a great match: sharing the same interests, goals and dreams as you. Your results may vary, but there's very little risk involved in creating a profile and seeing if you get any nibbles!

Compare Any 2 Products

Senior Match
Silver Singles
Match
Eharmony
OkCupid
Plenty of Fish
OurTime
Singles50
DateMyAge
Mature Dating Only
vs
Senior Match vs Silver SinglesSenior Match vs MatchSenior Match vs EharmonySenior Match vs OkCupidSenior Match vs Plenty of FishSenior Match vs OurTimeSenior Match vs Singles50Senior Match vs DateMyAgeSenior Match vs Mature Dating OnlySilver Singles vs MatchSilver Singles vs EharmonySilver Singles vs OkCupidSilver Singles vs Plenty of FishSilver Singles vs OurTimeSilver Singles vs Singles50Silver Singles vs DateMyAgeSilver Singles vs Mature Dating OnlyMatch vs EharmonyMatch vs OkCupidMatch vs Plenty of FishMatch vs OurTimeMatch vs Singles50Match vs DateMyAgeMatch vs Mature Dating OnlyEharmony vs OkCupidEharmony vs Plenty of FishEharmony vs OurTimeEharmony vs Singles50Eharmony vs DateMyAgeEharmony vs Mature Dating OnlyOkCupid vs Plenty of FishOkCupid vs OurTimeOkCupid vs Singles50OkCupid vs DateMyAgeOkCupid vs Mature Dating OnlyPlenty of Fish vs OurTimePlenty of Fish vs Singles50Plenty of Fish vs DateMyAgePlenty of Fish vs Mature Dating OnlyOurTime vs Singles50OurTime vs DateMyAgeOurTime vs Mature Dating OnlySingles50 vs DateMyAgeSingles50 vs Mature Dating OnlyDateMyAge vs Mature Dating Only Mature Dating Only vs DateMyAgeMature Dating Only vs Singles50Mature Dating Only vs OurTimeMature Dating Only vs Plenty of FishMature Dating Only vs OkCupidMature Dating Only vs EharmonyMature Dating Only vs MatchMature Dating Only vs Silver SinglesMature Dating Only vs Senior MatchDateMyAge vs Singles50DateMyAge vs OurTimeDateMyAge vs Plenty of FishDateMyAge vs OkCupidDateMyAge vs EharmonyDateMyAge vs MatchDateMyAge vs Silver SinglesDateMyAge vs Senior MatchSingles50 vs OurTimeSingles50 vs Plenty of FishSingles50 vs OkCupidSingles50 vs EharmonySingles50 vs MatchSingles50 vs Silver SinglesSingles50 vs Senior MatchOurTime vs Plenty of FishOurTime vs OkCupidOurTime vs EharmonyOurTime vs MatchOurTime vs Silver SinglesOurTime vs Senior MatchPlenty of Fish vs OkCupidPlenty of Fish vs EharmonyPlenty of Fish vs MatchPlenty of Fish vs Silver SinglesPlenty of Fish vs Senior MatchOkCupid vs EharmonyOkCupid vs MatchOkCupid vs Silver SinglesOkCupid vs Senior MatchEharmony vs MatchEharmony vs Silver SinglesEharmony vs Senior MatchMatch vs Silver SinglesMatch vs Senior MatchSilver Singles vs Senior Match
See the Best Senior Dating Sites in Your State

Dating Profiles That Work

Most of us know people who have had great success using a dating website while other friends see little or no dating action. Often the reason between the two stories is simply their profile and what impression it gave off to potential suitors. Writing about yourself doesn't come natural and putting relationship needs and wants into a one page summary takes practice so it's easy for people to make mistakes.

Spend time figuring out what you want in a potential mate and then focus on the following attributes of your profile to improve your chances of attracting the right person.

Tone
The tone of your profile is one of the biggest aspects of the impression you give off. Do you sound confident and upbeat or lacking self confidence. Do you spend more time explaining what you don't want or more time talking about your interests in a positive light? A negative Nelly or a selfish Sally are big turn offs. A nice balance of what you can bring to the table as well as what you're looking for will attract attention from others.

Username
The username is often the first thing someone sees about your profile and will create an initial first impression. A user name that uses profane language or sexual content is likely to turn off many quality singles. In turn, a boring or meaningless username can also have the same effect. Spend time coming up with a username that favorably depicts you and will grab someone's attention.

Mistakes
Bad grammar and spelling can be a huge turn-off for most. This can give the impression that you're lacking brain power and wouldn't put much effort into a relationship. If the website doesn't offer spell check, cut and paste your writing into a word document and search for errors.

Pictures
A profile with no pictures typically receives very few inquiries if any. Appearance is an important aspect of finding someone you have a chemical response to and people tend to avoid those profiles lacking photos. Be sure to include at least one picture but adding various shots of you from face to full body is ideal.

Honesty
Be honest in what you write in your profile. If you really don't want to date anyone older than you than make sure you indicate an accurate age range, height, body shape, religion or any other aspect of a potential mate you find critical. Also be honest about yourself. Lying about your age, income, kids or anything else will eventually lead to failure.

Feedback
While it may seem a little awkward, ask a close friend that knows you to give you honest feedback regarding your profile. How does it sound? Does it send the wrong message. What would they change?

Only the Best Reviews

Los Angeles Times

Seniors get back in the dating game

BALTIMORE — The bell rang, and Dorothy Binder greeted the man taking a seat across from her. “I want to tell you that I’m very nervous, but I’m here to have a good time today,” said Binder, a petite ...

Sun, 12 Nov 2006

Only the Best Reviews

Business Wire

First in 50+ Dating: SeniorMatch Launches Selfie Liveness ...

LOS ANGELES--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Identity fraud and catfishing are increasingly prevalent concerns, with online scams frequently targeting vulnerable groups—especially older adults. According to the ...

Wed, 16 Apr 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Insider Monkey

15 Senior Dating Sites Without Payment

According to a report by the Washington Post, almost 30% of adults above the age of 50 are single in the United States. Such is primarily due to the rising divorce rate in the United States. On ...

Fri, 09 Feb 2024

Only the Best Reviews

MSN

7 Best Dating Sites for Over-50 Singles

Let’s face it: finding love is hard regardless of age. However, dating apps can help make finding a soulmate a little easier for over-50 singles. Joining one of these sites can be a great way to find ...

Fri, 08 Aug 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Wall Street Journal

Dating in Your 70s Has Never Been This Much Fun

ROMEOVILLE, Ill.—On the Friday before Halloween, Lynn Phillips hurried home from work to change. She put on black slacks and a “dressy top,” then blow-dried her bangs before carefully applying silvery ...

Tue, 19 Dec 2023

Only the Best Reviews

Cleveland Scene

Best Senior Dating Sites and Mobile Apps

The senior dating site is also of special interest to polyamorous people, swingers, and other non-monogamous seniors. Statistically speaking, boomers are the most sexually active generation, and many ...

Tue, 01 Aug 2023

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.