Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Paragon Sports Review

Tuesday, March 19th

2024 Sporting Goods Store Reviews

Paragon Sports Review 2.5 Star Rating

Paragon Sports

2.5 Star Rating
  • Priced from $16.99 to $699.99
  • Hundreds of items on sale
  • Kids' and adults' gear
  • Casual gear
  • 30-days for returns
  • Free shipping for orders $49+

Paragon Sports, a family-owned business since 1908, is renowned among sports enthusiasts worldwide for its top-notch sports equipment and apparel. They pride themselves on featuring well-known brands alongside unique and exceptional merchandise.

Seamless online shopping experience

Located at 18th Street and Broadway in New York City, their expansive store offers a "Specialty Shop" atmosphere. Paragon Sports is a destination where rugged functionality seamlessly marries elegance. While it's true that you'll invest a bit more in the apparel and gear available here, the payoff is a high-end product. And for those who aren't in or near the Big Apple, don't worry-Paragon Sports' online store provides a seamless shopping experience.

Clean UI makes shopping a breeze

Their website, a testament to professionalism and user-friendliness, ensures your virtual shopping expedition is a breeze. The clean design and easy-to-read tabs make it simple to find what you need at a glance. You can either start your initial browsing experience by choosing by gender or age or you can choose by sport. The sports are organized into helpful categories such as winter sports, training, outdoor, team sports, club sports, and wheels.

Tons of helpful filters

Once you decide what you want to shop for, you can use the helpful filters on the left-side navigation bar to limit your choices by gender, age, sport, brand, gear type, footwear type, or size. There are tons more filters to choose from too, so you can easily narrow down the gear no matter what you're looking for. However, there is one thing to look out for at Paragon Sports: some of the links are a little wonky. For example, the soccer link doesn't open up a page for all soccer gear like some of the other links do, leaving customers to scroll through hundreds of "sports" gear items in general while searching for soccer specifically.

Best Sporting Goods Stores

Inventory covers all the bases

Paragon Sports is dedicated to delivering the latest innovations in sports and outdoor gear. At Paragon Sports, the spotlight shines brightly on athletic and outdoor apparel in particular. While they do offer some gear specific to various sports and activities, their real strength lies in outfitting athletes in style. The apparel selection caters to men, women, and children, featuring name-brand offerings that span the alphabet from A to Z. Whether you're seeking performance attire or simply outfitting your family for your next adventure, Paragon Sports has something to suit every athlete's tastes and needs. Their categories extend beyond mere fashion to encompass sports, ensuring that every activity and season finds its perfect match. However, they do also have essential gear items like bats, balls, and clubs for actually playing different sports, which is impressive given the company's overall focus on apparel.

Competitive prices but missing some pro gear

To compare the pricing on sports gear at Paragon Sports to other companies in this review, we checked out the same three sports sections at each site.

  • Starting with football gear, at Paragon Sports there are 86 items in the inventory, which is much lower than other competitors in this review. The prices start at $16.99 for men's protective gear and go up to $199.99 for a football. However, items like shoulder pads are notably missing.
  • For golf gear, you can find 178 items in stock. The prices range from $15.99 for a golf glove to a $699.99 golf watch.
  • Finally for soccer gear, Paragon Sports offers plenty of items that work for soccer, but the site glitches when you click "soccer" specifically, so you see all of the sports gear in one place instead. This made it difficult to find an accurate price range for soccer gear specifically at Paragon Sports, which may frustrate customers who need gear for that sport.

30-day returns

In the event that your purchase doesn't align with your expectations - perhaps it doesn't fit quite right or doesn't meet your specific needs - Paragon Sports has you covered. Their customer-centric approach includes a competitive 30-day return policy. While this isn't as robust as some return policies in this review, it does fit with the industry standard. Plus, given the caliber of their products, quality concerns are unlikely to surface, as Paragon Sports exclusively stocks high-quality, name-brand items.

Best Sporting Goods Stores

Free shipping on $49+

One way to elevate your shopping experience with Paragon Sports further is by taking advantage of its free shipping offer. On orders over $49, customers can score totally free shipping for their sports gear. Given the quality and craftsmanship of their products, reaching this threshold is a breeze, as you'll likely find yourself investing around $50 or more per item.

Lower-than average ratings

While high-end products sound nice, there are some problems with Paragon Sports' reputation. According to the company's page on the Better Business Bureau, Paragon Sports only has a "C-" rating. This lower-than-average score from the BBB doesn't bode well for a place where expensive items are their top sellers. Further, when researching the company on verified review sites, there were tons of warnings from customers who shopped in person and online. Customers specifically complained about their return policy being "misleading" and Paragon Sports refusing to issue refunds or telling customers to return defective items to the manufacturer for repair instead of replacing them for the customer.

Missing key items for pros

Paragon Sports undoubtedly offers a slice of luxury within the realm of sporting goods. However, they do lean more towards apparel than sport-specific gear. While you can find some key sports items like bats or golf clubs, some of the big ticket or pro items are missing. If your sporting journey calls for a more specialized approach, we recommend exploring our top-rated sporting goods stores, which cater to the specific equipment needs of athletes. Plus, with Paragon Sports' lower-than-average ratings from customers and a low BBB score, it's definitely safer to pick a spot with more reliable returns and feedback.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Sporting Goods Online Today?

Sports, a significant part of our culture, come in various forms, appealing to a wide range of enthusiasts. These activities have produced iconic athletes who've left their mark on the sporting world, inspiring countless individuals. Over the years, sports have garnered immense popularity, with millions participating either as players or passionate supporters.

Thanks to the convenience of online shopping, acquiring the perfect sporting goods has become more accessible than ever before. Numerous online retailers offer not only convenience but also access to the latest and most innovative sports gear and apparel, empowering athletes to perform at their peak levels. Furthermore, customers sometimes have the option to customize items like equipment, providing a personalized touch to their sporting experience.

The Best Sporting Goods Stores Compare Sporting Goods Stores Compare Sporting Goods Store Reviews What are the best Sporting Goods Stores Best Sporting Goods Store Reviews

Sporting Goods Store FAQ

That's easy: if you need it to play or practice a sport, it's considered "sporting goods" ! Think of it as all the equipment involved in activities like baseball, lacrosse, or even yoga, from bats and balls to protective gear and uniforms.
Selection, availability and pricing. You'll have a hard time finding a local retailer that can beat online stores in all three of those aspects. Especially at the peak of the season, when inventory near you is at an all-time low, shopping online makes it easy to get what you need.
Choose a store that has what you need in stock and that has a great reputation for quality and customer service. You can also look for customer-friendly perks like a rewards program, free shipping, or frequent promotions and discounts. You may want to consider buying from a retailer that has a brick-and-mortar store near you, for simple returns and the ability to order online and get same-day pickup.
Many stores will give you free shipping on orders that meet a minimum amount (like $50). Given how spendy sporting goods can be, you should be able to qualify with most purchases.
If you're in a rush, you might have the option of paying for expedited shipping to get next-day or 2-day delivery. Otherwise, expect your order to take about a week to arrive.
Most online sporting goods stores offer a 30-day return policy on new, unused items. Some retailers go the extra mile and let you return your purchase with no time limit, as long as you have the receipt. Be aware that returns may incur a restocking fee and/or shipping fees to send the items back to the store.
Yes! Some sporting goods stores will give you a generous discount if you're buying equipment for a team. Look for that information in the links at the bottom of the retailers' websites, or reach out to their customer service team before placing an order.
Sometimes. You can usually see those options after you add an item to your cart (e.g. monogramming), or you may need to work with a customer service rep to place a manual order (e.g. putting team logos on shirts).
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

However, not every retailer has the same stuff. Whether you're looking for gear to spruce up your pro game, or if you're just getting into a new sport and need the essentials, different retailers focus on different types of players (or even some for just fans). There are even retailers that focus more on one sport than the other, which is why there are so many retailers out there in the modern marketplace. But this can also be a good thing. It means there's a sporting goods store out there for everyone.

From casual neighborhood games to professional leagues, there's a sport for everyone. According to data from the Sports & Fitness Industry Association (SFIA), approximately 9.6 million children aged 6 to 17 and around 12.5 million adults aged 18 and above engage in sports each year. From youth leagues to collegiate competitions and national leagues, sports cater to people of all ages.

Whether you're a parent supporting a youth league, a member of a local sports team, or someone aspiring to excel professionally, you recognize that athletes require more than just skill and dedication - they need top-quality equipment tailored to their chosen sport. A well-crafted set of gear, from the appropriate sporting equipment to the right apparel, plays a crucial role in enhancing a player's confidence and performance.

With the abundance of online options for sporting goods, it can be overwhelming to make a decision. If you're unsure where to begin, we've got you covered. Here are some key considerations to help you determine the best online sporting goods store for your needs:

  • Price: Comparing prices across retailers ensures you're getting the best value for your money. Some sites offer price matching, while others offer rebates or sales. So, keeping your budget in mind and which sites cater to that budget can help you make the best decision for sports gear.
  • Returns: Most companies have completely different return policies. Keeping in mind how long you want to be able to decide on new sporting goods or whether you can try out items before returning them can help you narrow down options for those that best serve your sporting needs.
  • Selection: A wide range of options is a winning strategy when looking for a sporting goods retailer. Options that offer inventory for casual players, fans, and pros are ideal. Or, if you're looking for specialized practice equipment, that might change where you need to look.
  • Reputation: Finally, check out the customer reviews if you're still not sure where to shop. Scores from the Better Business Bureau and verified reviews from customers just like you can help you stay in the know about which retailers best service sports players and fans just like you.

To enhance your sporting experience, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best options for purchasing sporting goods today. Our aim is to simplify your online shopping journey, allowing you to focus on enjoying your favorite sports activities to the fullest!

The Best Reviews of Sporting Goods Stores