Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Collecting sports memorabilia is an important hobby for many sports enthusiasts young and old. If this rings true for you, maybe you've found yourself looking for a few small collector's items, or have been compiling favorite sports teams' swag for years. Either way, you'll want the biggest possible selection of memorabilia at your fingertips.
With a click of a few buttons, avid sports memorabilia collectors will discover treasure trove of signed player cards, jerseys, trophies, or gear signed by their favorite athletes. It's likely that sports enthusiasts will find keepsakes they didn't even know existed on the market as they browse the inventory of different online retailers. This makes one's hobby of collecting sports memorabilia even more fun and exciting!
Thursday, March 30th
Press Pass Collectibles is your one-stop-shop for old-school memorabilia. Not only do they have sports memorabilia, but they also carry fascinating historical items as well. This may include stumbling across a letter signed by Alexander Graham Bell, signed photographs of members of Apollo missions, or a comic book signed by Stan Lee. Press Pass Collectibles has earned our highest rating for sports memorabilia shopping.
If you're an avid sports memorabilia collector looking for a specific item, the Fanatics Authentic website will make your search a breeze. Not only are their categories of products straightforward, but their search function thoroughly narrows down results by keywords like dates, players, teams, numbers, and more. There are thousands of certified collectors' items at Fanatics Authentic, making it a good place to browse for memorabilia.
Fan's Edge is owned and operated by Fanatics Authentic, which is a good thing considering the good reputation of Fanatics. Both of their websites are very similar, along with their inventory. At the time of this review, both sites were running a sale, but discounts were bigger at Fan's Edge, making their pricing more affordable.
Gameday Sports Memorabilia specializes in autographed products. Whether it be a football, photo, jersey, or helmet, almost everything for sale has been signed by an athlete. The only products sold without autographs are display cases. We are impressed with the customer-oriented policies at Gameday Sports Memorabilia, making it a good sports memorabilia retailer.
Sports Memorabilia is another Fanatics-owned company that exclusively sells sports memorabilia. With tens of thousands of signed items featuring NBA, NFL, MLB, and other professional teams and athletes, the company is average among their competitors. Many of the products listed can be found for similar prices through other sports memorabilia retailers.
Steiner Sports is owned by Fanatics and sells many similar products. Since its acquisition in 2019, their inventory has been full of high-end sports memorabilia like other sister sites owned by Fanatics. Steiner exclusively sells sports memorabilia from the NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, NCAA, soccer, and other sports. Because of its similarity to other sports memorabilia sites, it does not stand out as anything extraordinarily unique.
Sports Integrity offers fewer selections of sports memorabilia than their competitors. Some redeeming factors that we liked about their online store are the ability for customers to leave reviews about the company and products, unsigned memorabilia items, and a blog about important dates and products. However, for customers looking for a big selection of sports memorabilia, this wouldn't be the first place we would suggest.
Sports Collectibles sells autographed jerseys, helmets, balls, photos, and other gear. In addition to their sports memorabilia department, they also have political, movie, TV, music and celebrity memorabilia for sale. Disappointingly, some of their categories have either a slim product selection or have no items in stock.
Sports lovers used to have to go store to store to find memorabilia of sports teams and players they admire. This took time and was very limiting as far as finding exactly what they were looking for. Now with a convenient, online search it is easy to find the priceless items you may be wanting and compare costs between retailers. With a bit of online browsing, you can add to or start a collection of what used to be hard-to-find items you can be proud of.
Before jumping online to browse the world of sports memorabilia, we suggest you keep the following criteria in mind when choosing a retailer:
To help you identify the best sports memorabilia retailers, TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked a variety of options to give you an idea of which choice might be the most effective for you. We hope this information helps you find all the memorabilia you have been searching for!
Select any 2 Sports Memorabilia Stores to compare them head to head
KMBC Kansas City
Patrick Mahomes memorabilia expected to sell for $200,000 at auction
The MINT Collective in Las Vegas will feature several pieces of Mahomes sports memorabilia An auction set to be hosted in Las Vegas will feature multiple pieces of sports memorabilia tied to Kansas ...
Tue, 28 Mar 2023