Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Fanatics Authentic Review

Friday, April 19th

2024 Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Fanatics Authentic Review 5 Star Rating

Fanatics Authentic

5 Star Rating
  • Prices for MLB from $19.99 to $4,999.99
  • Prices for NFL jerseys from $119.99 to $3,799.99
  • Sale prices from $19.99 to $19,999.99
  • Options to buy meet-and-greets
  • Jersey protection program + jersey replacement
  • Holographic authentication
  • Returns within 365 days
  • Free shipping on $24+
  • "A+" rating from the BBB
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Fanatics Authentic's website is a treasure trove for fans of NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, NCAA, NASCAR, and soccer teams, with dedicated categories to explore each. They take pride in offering the world's largest collection of officially licensed, exclusive fan gear, including items dating back to the 50s.

Specialized items

In addition to traditional fan gear, Fanatics Authentic provides specialized sections, including game-used items and trading cards, offering a diverse selection for all collectors. Fanatics Authentic is part of a larger network, owning several other sports memorabilia retail stores like Steiner Sports, Fan's Edge, and Sports Memorabilia. This interconnected ecosystem of retailers lets Fanatics Authentic cater to a wide range of customer preferences in terms of products and pricing.

Easy to find new and exciting options

The standout feature at Fanatics Authentic is the ability to search for top players across all listed teams, making it incredibly convenient to find your favorite athlete's memorabilia. What sets Fanatics Authentic apart is their dynamic approach to purchasing and collecting. In addition to traditional sales, they've established meet-and-greet opportunities. (For example, one opportunity included the chance to meet Jonathan Marchessault & Jack Eichel in Las Vegas.) It's super easy to find what you need with the organization and filter options at Fantastic Authentic. So, if you're looking for unique finds on a clean shopping user interface, Fanatics Authentic is a great place to start.

Full range of costs and highly sought inventory

The products at Fanatics Authentic span a wide spectrum, from signed balls and autographed portraits to jerseys, framed player collages, and even signed flags. You can choose from a variety of ways to shop including by sport, by player, by items that were actually used in games, as well as items that are exclusive to Fanatics Authentic. No matter what you need, you'll easily be able to find it here.

Best Sports Memorabilia Stores

Price comparison

To check out the prices at Fanatics Authentic and how they compare to other companies in this review, we looked at two key items at each retailer: First, autographed memorabilia for Major League Baseball, and second, National Football League autographed jerseys. While there are tons of other sports represented, these are some of the most popular sports in the US. Finally, we also looked at the sale prices at each retailer to see which company offers the best deals in general. At Fanatics Authentic, the prices shake out to:

  • Autographed MLB Memorabilia: $19.99 to $4,999.99 which ranged from a 2021 signature ball from the World Series to a Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels Autographed First Career Home Run Game Ticket
  • Autographed NFL Jerseys: $119.99 to $3,799.99 which ranged from a Raheem Mostert San Francisco 49ers Autographed White Nike Game Jersey to a Tom Brady Tampa Bay Buccaneers Autographed Super Bowl LV Champions Jersey
  • Sale items: $19.99 to $19,999.99 ranging from a Boston Red Socks Game-Used Pen with authentic dirt to Zion Williamson New Orleans Pelicans Autographed Game-Used Red/White Jordan Shoes

Jersey replacement available

Fanatics Authentic offers a jersey protection program, providing replacement jerseys if a player is traded or changes teams. We were particularly excited about this feature as it shows the company's commitment to the customers in the long term. It also shows that they stand behind the memorabilia they sell, which will provide collectors with peace of mind.

356-day returns and free shipping offers

Fanatics Authentic offers a generous return policy that allows items to be returned up to 365 days from the ship date if they are unworn/unused and in original condition with tags and labels attached. On top of that, Fanatics Authentic offers regular deals for their shipping. For example, at the time of this review, Fanatics Authentic was offering a free shipping deal for any order over $24. This makes it super easy to score free shipping no matter what you're looking to buy at Fanatics Authentic.

Best Sports Memorabilia Stores

Hologram authentication

All items at Fanatics Authentic are protected with hologram authentication. Customers can easily check if their items are authentic by entering the code on their included hologram tags in the on-site checker. This makes it simple to see the proper authentication of each of your memorabilia items. Each code is unique to each item, so customers can be sure there are no companies or fakes with Fanatics Authentic.

Top-rated for customer service

Fanatics Inc. holds an impressive "A+" rating and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau. Further, Fanatics Authentic itself holds an average star rating of 4.2 out of 5 across multiple review sites, showcasing customer satisfaction. Customer reviews included praise for the customer service department at Fanatics Authentic which went above and beyond to get items to their new owners on time even during a holiday rush as well as solving problems with order errors or complications. Overall, customers feel that they are in good hands both with item quality and service at Fanatics Authentic.

Great choice for unique finds

Bottom line? Fanatics Authentic is a standout choice for sports memorabilia collectors. Their website's user-friendly interface and vast array of collector's items make the shopping experience enjoyable and hassle-free. Furthermore, their "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau reflects their commitment to maintaining high standards in the industry. Whether you're a seasoned collector, a novice enthusiast, or just someone looking to score a meet-and-greet with their favorite player, Fanatics Authentic is the #1 store for your sports memorabilia needs.

Where's the Best Spot to Score Sports Memorabilia?

Sports memorabilia holds a special place in the hearts of fans and collectors alike. It's a tangible connection to the sports heroes and iconic moments that have shaped our passion for the games we love. From autographed jerseys and baseball cards to vintage equipment and championship trophies, sports memorabilia captures the essence of athletic history.

Each sports item tells a unique story, whether it's the ball that sailed over the outfield fence during a historic home run or the jersey worn by a legendary athlete during a championship game. Collecting sports memorabilia is more than just a hobby; it's a way of preserving the memories and traditions that define our love for sports. As such, sports memorabilia is a booming market, worth billions annually, and it just keeps on growing.

The Best Sports Memorabilia Stores Compare Sports Memorabilia Stores Compare Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews What are the best Sports Memorabilia Stores Best Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews

Sports Memorabilia Store FAQ

Sports memorabilia can be anything from sports cards to trophies, to equipment, to autographs. They are collectibles associated with sports from teams and players of the past and present. The items can be traded or sold for up to millions of dollars. Sports memorabilia is a multi-billion dollar industry worldwide.
Anyone can collect sports memorabilia! The hobby is most common among middle-aged men, but children and women get into it as well. Anyone who is a sports lover understands the excitement of having items that represent their favorite teams and athletes.
To know if a sports memorabilia item is authentic, first make sure you are buying and trading from a reputable company. Most companies will provide a certificate of authenticity with their items that includes a tamper-proof holographic sticker with a serial number. The serial number is used to match the certificate with the collector's item.
Yes! When it comes to collecting sports memorabilia or any other kind of antiques, they usually become more valuable the longer they are around - when there are fewer of them left. This is especially the case for items that are signed by or were used by legends like Babe Ruth, Michael Jordan, or Muhammad Ali. These types of collector's items are in high demand and therefore grow in value year after year.
If you're collecting sports memorabilia for trading or selling purposes, you'll likely have different items coming and going all the time. This is a fun hobby and potentially a way to make some extra cash on the side. For those who are collecting sports memorabilia to keep, you could find unique ways to display your items around your home or office. This might mean framing photos to hang on walls or put on a desk, framing jerseys, or getting a display case for balls and other equipment. You can get really creative with ways to highlight your hobby of collecting sports memorabilia that is important to you.
When it comes to finding out the worth of a collector's item, the internet can pretty much tell you all you need to know. If you happen to have a local antique store or know a sports memorabilia expert, you could get their opinion on the worth of your items. However, a quick internet search of what your item is can at least show you what similar items are going for. You might be able to find listings for that exact item from the past and use that to gauge what it might go for now. There are online appraisers that you can message online to guide you in the right direction as well. Some people like to use an auction house when it comes to selling their item to make sure they get top dollar.
If collecting sports memorabilia sounds like something you are interested in, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked a variety of retailers that sell a huge range of items. Decide what type of collector's items you're interested in and what team or athlete you'd like to own something from. Browse through the company's site for items that fit what you're looking for and start there. You'll likely find a lot of other cool items that excite you! You don't have to buy a lot at once, but get an idea of what's out there and slowly start building your collection. You'll learn a lot along the way and have a great time doing it!
Some companies offer a return policy on their sports memorabilia items. Typically, you can send things back within 30 days of purchase. However, the market for buying and selling sports memorabilia is so big that you could always turn around and resell any items that you have if needed. Pay close attention to the company policies of the place you do your online shopping so that you know what your return options are.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Baseball and American football are the fan favorites, but they're closely followed by basketball, hockey, and soccer - they've got their fair share of die-hard collectors too. Autographed goods like jerseys, baseballs, and those beloved trading cards are the most coveted items in general, but hardcore collectors look for the rare gems like game-worn jerseys, championship rings, and gear that legends once used - these treasures can fetch jaw-dropping prices at auctions.

For all you die-hard sports aficionados out there, the quest for sports memorabilia is practically a sacred journey. Whether you're hunting for those hard-to-find collector's specials or have been amassing your favorite team's swag for ages, you need a one-stop shop with an epic inventory. But first - let's rewind a bit.

Gone are the days when sports lovers had to embark on an arduous store-to-store pilgrimage in search of memorabilia from their beloved teams and athletes. It was a time-consuming and often disappointing ordeal. Thanks to the magic of online shopping, you can now easily find those priceless items you've been yearning for while effortlessly comparing prices across different retailers. With a few keyboard strokes, you can kickstart your collection or expand it with once-elusive treasures that'll make you the envy of your fellow fans.

In today's digital age, sports memorabilia collectors are in for a real treat. Just a few clicks and you'll be diving into a world of autographed player cards, jerseys, trophies, and gear inked by your sports heroes. Who knows, you might stumble upon hidden gems you never knew existed, taking your collecting game to a whole new level of excitement.

Before you dive into the vast world of online sports memorabilia, we've got a few pointers for you:

  • Price. Sports memorabilia can be akin to treasure for collectors. Prices vary widely based on factors like type, age, and autograph quality. It's a good idea to scout around and check if you can nab the same item elsewhere for less. Ultimately, it's all about what it's worth to you.
  • Return policy. Sometimes, that signed baseball arrives with an autograph so faint you need a magnifying glass. Having the option to return such a purchase can be a lifesaver. Keep an eye out for any restocking fees as well.
  • Selection. Imagine eagerly searching for a specific item only to draw a blank. Talk about a buzzkill. Opting for a retailer with a massive selection will not only up your chances of finding what you want but also help you uncover delightful surprises along the way.
  • Reputation. Finally, if you're stuck between some favorites, check out the customer reviews and ratings from the Better Business Bureau. Nothing can help your shopping confidence like knowing other fans like you have found what they need.

Ready to score some stellar sports memorabilia? We're here to assist you in finding the ultimate sports memorabilia retailers. At Top Consumer Reviews, we've dived deep into the world of sports memorabilia, evaluating and ranking a range of options to guide you toward the best choice. We aim to help you fulfill all your memorabilia dreams!

Compare Sports Memorabilia Stores

Select any 2 Sports Memorabilia Stores to compare them head to head

  • Fanatics Authentic
  • Press Pass Collectibles
  • Sports Integrity
  • Sports Memorabilia
  • Fan's Edge
  • Gameday Sports Memorabilia
  • ASG Memorabilia
  • Total Sports Enterprises
  • Steiner Sports
  • Sports Collectibles
Fanatics Authentic vs Press Pass Collectibles Fanatics Authentic vs Sports Integrity Fanatics Authentic vs Sports Memorabilia Fanatics Authentic vs Fan's Edge Fanatics Authentic vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Fanatics Authentic vs ASG Memorabilia Fanatics Authentic vs Total Sports Enterprises Fanatics Authentic vs Steiner Sports Fanatics Authentic vs Sports Collectibles Press Pass Collectibles vs Sports Integrity Press Pass Collectibles vs Sports Memorabilia Press Pass Collectibles vs Fan's Edge Press Pass Collectibles vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Press Pass Collectibles vs ASG Memorabilia Press Pass Collectibles vs Total Sports Enterprises Press Pass Collectibles vs Steiner Sports Press Pass Collectibles vs Sports Collectibles Sports Integrity vs Sports Memorabilia Sports Integrity vs Fan's Edge Sports Integrity vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Sports Integrity vs ASG Memorabilia Sports Integrity vs Total Sports Enterprises Sports Integrity vs Steiner Sports Sports Integrity vs Sports Collectibles Sports Memorabilia vs Fan's Edge Sports Memorabilia vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Sports Memorabilia vs ASG Memorabilia Sports Memorabilia vs Total Sports Enterprises Sports Memorabilia vs Steiner Sports Sports Memorabilia vs Sports Collectibles Fan's Edge vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Fan's Edge vs ASG Memorabilia Fan's Edge vs Total Sports Enterprises Fan's Edge vs Steiner Sports Fan's Edge vs Sports Collectibles Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs ASG Memorabilia Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs Total Sports Enterprises Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs Steiner Sports Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs Sports Collectibles ASG Memorabilia vs Total Sports Enterprises ASG Memorabilia vs Steiner Sports ASG Memorabilia vs Sports Collectibles Total Sports Enterprises vs Steiner Sports Total Sports Enterprises vs Sports Collectibles Steiner Sports vs Sports Collectibles
Compare the Best Sports Memorabilia Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Sports Memorabilia Stores
See the Best Sports Memorabilia Store
The Best Reviews of Sports Memorabilia Stores