Tuesday, March 18th
2025 Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews
Sports Integrity
- Prices for MLB: $9.99 - $69,999.99
- Prices for NFL jerseys: $99 - $1,799.99
- Options to buy vintage items
- Returns available within 14 days
- Free shipping on $199+
- Third-party authentication
- 200% refund for authentication guarantee
- "A+” rating from the BBB
Sports Integrity offers an inventory of various sports memorabilia categories, encompassing football, baseball, basketball, hockey, entertainment, cases, and boxing. However, it's worth noting that they offer limited to no products for categories that may be of lesser interest to collectors, such as horse racing, soccer, tennis, and wrestling. The company touts daily additions to its inventory, but it's apparent that these items have a brief shelf life. This could be attributed to their relatively slimmer product selection or the rapid depletion of stock.
Site could use some updates
At first glance, the site for Sports Integrity is a solid design. They've got good navigation with dropdown menus and well-organized products. On its homepage, Sports Integrity highlights a new product weekly, presenting it with multiple photos and an accompanying explanation detailing why the featured item deserves special attention. However, there are a few places where the site has fallen behind. For example, the blog hasn't seen updates for over a year, suggesting it may not be currently active. On top of that, some pages yield no results due to products presumably selling out quickly.
Solid inventory with competitive prices
In terms of pricing, we found that the sports memorabilia offered by Sports Integrity is generally in line with what competitors offer. In particular, we loved seeing options for new and vintage items here, which offers a good mix with a range of prices. To take a closer look at the pricing, we looked at the prices for two categories: baseball memorabilia and signed NFL jerseys. While we usually check out the sales prices too, there wasn't a dedicated sales section at Sports Integrity. So, we just checked out two popular categories. The prices at Sports Integrity shake out to:
- MLB memorabilia: $9.99 for a stadium pin - $69,999.99 for a baseball signed by Babe Ruth.
- NFL signed jerseys: $99 for a jersey signed by Darius Slay Jr. - $1,799.99 for a jersey signed by Patrick Mahomes.
14-day returns and free shipping on $199+
Customers can enjoy free shipping on orders exceeding $199, though this only includes customers who live in the United States. However, customers need to be aware that Sports Integrity's return policy is much stricter than some of its competitors. Customers only have a 14-day window to initiate returns. On top of that, all of the items must be unused and in their original condition to qualify for a full refund.
Ironclad authenticity guarantee
Sports Integrity is all about authenticity, and the company wants you to know it. Sports Integrity backs its products with a tamper-proof hologram and a Certificate of Authenticity for each hand-signed collectible. The retailer goes the extra mile by participating in private and public autograph sessions with athletes across the country so that all of the items sold by Sports Integrity have been signed in person for full authenticity. Plus, Sports Integrity offers third-party authentication options like Beckett (BAS), PSA DNA, and JSA (Spence) to make extra sure. In fact, they're so confident that they provide the Sports Integrity IRONCLAD Guarantee, promising a 200% refund if an item fails authentication by PSA, JSA, or Beckett.
Strong ratings from happy customers
According to our research, Sports Integrity is living up to its name. The company has a top-tier rating of "A+” with the Better Business Bureau. Further, Sports Integrity also holds a full 5-star rating from the BBB. Outside of that, Sports Integrity holds up with customers also. On average, across multiple review sites, customers have given Sports Integrity a 4.6-star average out of 5. The reviews praise Sports Integrity for high-quality items coming in perfect condition, quick shipping, and all the promised authentication materials ready to go.
Top option for vintage finds
In general Sports Integrity is a solid option. While the company doesn't have quite as many memorabilia options as some of its competitors, it's a solid option for cost and trustworthiness, which is a huge bonus. We were particularly impressed with the 200% refund guarantee if the authentication of any item sold by Sports Integrity fails at any of their third-party authentication partners. We love a company that stands behind its products, and with some options in our review being less than trustworthy, Sports Integrity shows up the competition. While its limited inventory keeps it out of the top two, it's still a solid choice, especially if you want a mix of new and vintage memorabilia.
More Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews
The 10 Best Sports Memorabilia Stores
Where's the Best Spot to Score Sports Memorabilia?
Sports memorabilia holds a special place in the hearts of fans and collectors alike. It's a tangible connection to the sports heroes and iconic moments that have shaped our passion for the games we love. From autographed jerseys and baseball cards to vintage equipment and championship trophies, sports memorabilia captures the essence of athletic history.
Each sports item tells a unique story, whether it's the ball that sailed over the outfield fence during a historic home run or the jersey worn by a legendary athlete during a championship game. Collecting sports memorabilia is more than just a hobby; it's a way of preserving the memories and traditions that define our love for sports. As such, sports memorabilia is a booming market, worth billions annually, and it just keeps on growing.
Sports Memorabilia Store FAQ
Continued from above...
Baseball and American football are the fan favorites, but they're closely followed by basketball, hockey, and soccer - they've got their fair share of die-hard collectors too. Autographed goods like jerseys, baseballs, and those beloved trading cards are the most coveted items in general, but hardcore collectors look for the rare gems like game-worn jerseys, championship rings, and gear that legends once used - these treasures can fetch jaw-dropping prices at auctions.
For all you die-hard sports aficionados out there, the quest for sports memorabilia is practically a sacred journey. Whether you're hunting for those hard-to-find collector's specials or have been amassing your favorite team's swag for ages, you need a one-stop shop with an epic inventory. But first - let's rewind a bit.
Gone are the days when sports lovers had to embark on an arduous store-to-store pilgrimage in search of memorabilia from their beloved teams and athletes. It was a time-consuming and often disappointing ordeal. Thanks to the magic of online shopping, you can now easily find those priceless items you've been yearning for while effortlessly comparing prices across different retailers. With a few keyboard strokes, you can kickstart your collection or expand it with once-elusive treasures that'll make you the envy of your fellow fans.
In today's digital age, sports memorabilia collectors are in for a real treat. Just a few clicks and you'll be diving into a world of autographed player cards, jerseys, trophies, and gear inked by your sports heroes. Who knows, you might stumble upon hidden gems you never knew existed, taking your collecting game to a whole new level of excitement.
Before you dive into the vast world of online sports memorabilia, we've got a few pointers for you:
- Price. Sports memorabilia can be akin to treasure for collectors. Prices vary widely based on factors like type, age, and autograph quality. It's a good idea to scout around and check if you can nab the same item elsewhere for less. Ultimately, it's all about what it's worth to you.
- Return policy. Sometimes, that signed baseball arrives with an autograph so faint you need a magnifying glass. Having the option to return such a purchase can be a lifesaver. Keep an eye out for any restocking fees as well.
- Selection. Imagine eagerly searching for a specific item only to draw a blank. Talk about a buzzkill. Opting for a retailer with a massive selection will not only up your chances of finding what you want but also help you uncover delightful surprises along the way.
- Reputation. Finally, if you're stuck between some favorites, check out the customer reviews and ratings from the Better Business Bureau. Nothing can help your shopping confidence like knowing other fans like you have found what they need.
Ready to score some stellar sports memorabilia? We're here to assist you in finding the ultimate sports memorabilia retailers. At Top Consumer Reviews, we've dived deep into the world of sports memorabilia, evaluating and ranking a range of options to guide you toward the best choice. We aim to help you fulfill all your memorabilia dreams!
Compare Sports Memorabilia Stores
Select any 2 Sports Memorabilia Stores to compare them head to head
Trending Sports Memorabilia News
Related Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews
Since you're interested in Sports Memorabilia Stores, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
