Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Steiner Sports Review

Wednesday, February 28th

2024 Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews

Steiner Sports Review 2 Star Rating

Steiner Sports

2 Star Rating
  • Prices for MLB memorabilia from $19.99 to $1,425,459.99
  • Prices for NFL jerseys from $19.99 to $454,549.99
  • Sale prices from $3.99 to $1,399.99
  • Holographic authentication
  • Returns within 30 days
  • Free shipping on $49+

Steiner Sports is a go-to destination for all things sports memorabilia. They offer a wide array of collectibles, from autographed balls, trading cards, and jerseys, to display cases and hats.

Sister sites in our review

If you're thinking "this looks familiar" you would be right. Steiner Sports is another company under the ownership of Fanatics Authentic and shares many of its product offerings with sister sites that cater to similar tastes. However, given the striking resemblances between these sports memorabilia giants, it becomes a tad challenging to discern what sets Steiner Sports apart from the rest, or to come up with a reason why any shopper should choose this retailer over its competitors.

Site helps you stay informed on sports

It's not just the inventory that is similar, Steiner Sports also sports almost the same site design and functionality as its sister sites. One difference that does stand out at Steiner Sports is the spotlight at the bottom of the page that shows the leading teams and players across various sports leagues, including the NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, UFC, golf, and more. While the presentation might appear somewhat text-heavy, it serves as a convenient and quick reference for sports enthusiasts looking to stay updated on relevant events and explore related memorabilia to enrich their collections. It offers an easy-to-digest overview that's beneficial for staying in the know about the latest happenings in the sports world.

Best Sports Memorabilia Stores

Same inventory as sister site

The cost of each product at Steiner Sports fluctuates considerably, contingent on factors such as its age, the signature it bears, and the type of product itself. To compare prices between Steiner Sports and other reviewed retailers, we analyzed the range of prices within three distinct shopping categories: autographed MLB merchandise, autographed NFL jerseys, and the pricing of clearance or discounted items. Here's a brief overview of what you can anticipate when shopping at Steiner Sports:

  • MLB autographed memorabilia: $19.99 to $1,425,459.99. This includes items from a Sun Sox baseball card to a signed baseball from Josh Gibson. Notably, these are the exact same items sold by Sports Memorabilia.
  • NFL autographed jerseys: $19.99 to $454,549.99. This includes items from a worn jersey card to a signed jersey worn by Michael Jordan. Again, these are precisely the same items as the sister site.
  • Sale items: $3.99 to $1,399.99. This includes items from a photo (unsigned) of a football player to a game-used hockey stick. Unsurprisingly, these are also the same items that were seen at Sports Memorabilia at the time of this review.

Bottom line? The inventory at Steiner Sports isn't just similar to its sister site, it's almost completely identical.

Unique hologram authentication

Each product available at Steiner Sports includes a one-of-a-kind hologram authentication feature. To confirm the authenticity of your memorabilia, simply input the code found on your hologram tag into their online verification tool. These hologram stickers are designed to be tamper-proof, so any attempt to duplicate them will result in the authenticator's disintegration.

Free shipping on $49+ and 30-day returns

Steiner Sports periodically runs site-wide sales, offering enticing discounts and free shipping once you reach a specific spending threshold. For example, the offer at the time of this review was free shipping on orders $49+. Generally, the pricing, whether during sales events or regular times, closely aligns with those of competing sites, occasionally even matching them identically. Another matching feature at Steiner Sports is its return window, which is identical to its sister site Sports Memorabilia. For customers' peace of mind, the return policy grants a 30-day window for returns, provided that the products remain unused and in their original condition.

Best Sports Memorabilia Stores

BBB says "yikes" to Steiner Sports

While Steiner Sports is similar to its sister sites in most aspects, its reputation isn't one of them. Unfortunately, Steiner Sports only holds a "D-" rating from the Better Business Bureau, which isn't very encouraging. While ratings on third-party review sites are a little bit better with an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5, there are only a handful of reviews to back up this rating. In general, the positive comments focus on the customer support, and not the items themselves, which raises some questions about why there aren't more positive reviews about the actual purchases.

Not unique enough to make up for low ratings

Steiner Sports undoubtedly offers an extensive selection of sports memorabilia that can delight avid collectors. However, the inventory includes many of the products available at other retailers, going so far as to be identical in many cases to its sister sites. Basically, there isn't a compelling reason to favor Steiner Sports over most other retailers we've reviewed. Given this fact and the low scores from the BBB, we recommend beginning your sports memorabilia shopping journey with our top-rated retailers, where you're likely to find a more unique and wide-ranging selection of products.

Where's the Best Spot to Score Sports Memorabilia?

Sports memorabilia holds a special place in the hearts of fans and collectors alike. It's a tangible connection to the sports heroes and iconic moments that have shaped our passion for the games we love. From autographed jerseys and baseball cards to vintage equipment and championship trophies, sports memorabilia captures the essence of athletic history.

Each sports item tells a unique story, whether it's the ball that sailed over the outfield fence during a historic home run or the jersey worn by a legendary athlete during a championship game. Collecting sports memorabilia is more than just a hobby; it's a way of preserving the memories and traditions that define our love for sports. As such, sports memorabilia is a booming market, worth billions annually, and it just keeps on growing.

The Best Sports Memorabilia Stores Compare Sports Memorabilia Stores Compare Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews What are the best Sports Memorabilia Stores Best Sports Memorabilia Store Reviews

Sports Memorabilia Store FAQ

Sports memorabilia can be anything from sports cards to trophies, to equipment, to autographs. They are collectibles associated with sports from teams and players of the past and present. The items can be traded or sold for up to millions of dollars. Sports memorabilia is a multi-billion dollar industry worldwide.
Anyone can collect sports memorabilia! The hobby is most common among middle-aged men, but children and women get into it as well. Anyone who is a sports lover understands the excitement of having items that represent their favorite teams and athletes.
To know if a sports memorabilia item is authentic, first make sure you are buying and trading from a reputable company. Most companies will provide a certificate of authenticity with their items that includes a tamper-proof holographic sticker with a serial number. The serial number is used to match the certificate with the collector's item.
Yes! When it comes to collecting sports memorabilia or any other kind of antiques, they usually become more valuable the longer they are around - when there are fewer of them left. This is especially the case for items that are signed by or were used by legends like Babe Ruth, Michael Jordan, or Muhammad Ali. These types of collector's items are in high demand and therefore grow in value year after year.
If you're collecting sports memorabilia for trading or selling purposes, you'll likely have different items coming and going all the time. This is a fun hobby and potentially a way to make some extra cash on the side. For those who are collecting sports memorabilia to keep, you could find unique ways to display your items around your home or office. This might mean framing photos to hang on walls or put on a desk, framing jerseys, or getting a display case for balls and other equipment. You can get really creative with ways to highlight your hobby of collecting sports memorabilia that is important to you.
When it comes to finding out the worth of a collector's item, the internet can pretty much tell you all you need to know. If you happen to have a local antique store or know a sports memorabilia expert, you could get their opinion on the worth of your items. However, a quick internet search of what your item is can at least show you what similar items are going for. You might be able to find listings for that exact item from the past and use that to gauge what it might go for now. There are online appraisers that you can message online to guide you in the right direction as well. Some people like to use an auction house when it comes to selling their item to make sure they get top dollar.
If collecting sports memorabilia sounds like something you are interested in, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked a variety of retailers that sell a huge range of items. Decide what type of collector's items you're interested in and what team or athlete you'd like to own something from. Browse through the company's site for items that fit what you're looking for and start there. You'll likely find a lot of other cool items that excite you! You don't have to buy a lot at once, but get an idea of what's out there and slowly start building your collection. You'll learn a lot along the way and have a great time doing it!
Some companies offer a return policy on their sports memorabilia items. Typically, you can send things back within 30 days of purchase. However, the market for buying and selling sports memorabilia is so big that you could always turn around and resell any items that you have if needed. Pay close attention to the company policies of the place you do your online shopping so that you know what your return options are.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Baseball and American football are the fan favorites, but they're closely followed by basketball, hockey, and soccer - they've got their fair share of die-hard collectors too. Autographed goods like jerseys, baseballs, and those beloved trading cards are the most coveted items in general, but hardcore collectors look for the rare gems like game-worn jerseys, championship rings, and gear that legends once used - these treasures can fetch jaw-dropping prices at auctions.

For all you die-hard sports aficionados out there, the quest for sports memorabilia is practically a sacred journey. Whether you're hunting for those hard-to-find collector's specials or have been amassing your favorite team's swag for ages, you need a one-stop shop with an epic inventory. But first - let's rewind a bit.

Gone are the days when sports lovers had to embark on an arduous store-to-store pilgrimage in search of memorabilia from their beloved teams and athletes. It was a time-consuming and often disappointing ordeal. Thanks to the magic of online shopping, you can now easily find those priceless items you've been yearning for while effortlessly comparing prices across different retailers. With a few keyboard strokes, you can kickstart your collection or expand it with once-elusive treasures that'll make you the envy of your fellow fans.

In today's digital age, sports memorabilia collectors are in for a real treat. Just a few clicks and you'll be diving into a world of autographed player cards, jerseys, trophies, and gear inked by your sports heroes. Who knows, you might stumble upon hidden gems you never knew existed, taking your collecting game to a whole new level of excitement.

Before you dive into the vast world of online sports memorabilia, we've got a few pointers for you:

  • Price. Sports memorabilia can be akin to treasure for collectors. Prices vary widely based on factors like type, age, and autograph quality. It's a good idea to scout around and check if you can nab the same item elsewhere for less. Ultimately, it's all about what it's worth to you.
  • Return policy. Sometimes, that signed baseball arrives with an autograph so faint you need a magnifying glass. Having the option to return such a purchase can be a lifesaver. Keep an eye out for any restocking fees as well.
  • Selection. Imagine eagerly searching for a specific item only to draw a blank. Talk about a buzzkill. Opting for a retailer with a massive selection will not only up your chances of finding what you want but also help you uncover delightful surprises along the way.
  • Reputation. Finally, if you're stuck between some favorites, check out the customer reviews and ratings from the Better Business Bureau. Nothing can help your shopping confidence like knowing other fans like you have found what they need.

Ready to score some stellar sports memorabilia? We're here to assist you in finding the ultimate sports memorabilia retailers. At Top Consumer Reviews, we've dived deep into the world of sports memorabilia, evaluating and ranking a range of options to guide you toward the best choice. We aim to help you fulfill all your memorabilia dreams!

Compare Sports Memorabilia Stores

Select any 2 Sports Memorabilia Stores to compare them head to head

  • Fanatics Authentic
  • Press Pass Collectibles
  • Sports Integrity
  • Sports Memorabilia
  • Fan's Edge
  • Gameday Sports Memorabilia
  • ASG Memorabilia
  • Total Sports Enterprises
  • Steiner Sports
  • Sports Collectibles
Fanatics Authentic vs Press Pass Collectibles Fanatics Authentic vs Sports Integrity Fanatics Authentic vs Sports Memorabilia Fanatics Authentic vs Fan's Edge Fanatics Authentic vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Fanatics Authentic vs ASG Memorabilia Fanatics Authentic vs Total Sports Enterprises Fanatics Authentic vs Steiner Sports Fanatics Authentic vs Sports Collectibles Press Pass Collectibles vs Sports Integrity Press Pass Collectibles vs Sports Memorabilia Press Pass Collectibles vs Fan's Edge Press Pass Collectibles vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Press Pass Collectibles vs ASG Memorabilia Press Pass Collectibles vs Total Sports Enterprises Press Pass Collectibles vs Steiner Sports Press Pass Collectibles vs Sports Collectibles Sports Integrity vs Sports Memorabilia Sports Integrity vs Fan's Edge Sports Integrity vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Sports Integrity vs ASG Memorabilia Sports Integrity vs Total Sports Enterprises Sports Integrity vs Steiner Sports Sports Integrity vs Sports Collectibles Sports Memorabilia vs Fan's Edge Sports Memorabilia vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Sports Memorabilia vs ASG Memorabilia Sports Memorabilia vs Total Sports Enterprises Sports Memorabilia vs Steiner Sports Sports Memorabilia vs Sports Collectibles Fan's Edge vs Gameday Sports Memorabilia Fan's Edge vs ASG Memorabilia Fan's Edge vs Total Sports Enterprises Fan's Edge vs Steiner Sports Fan's Edge vs Sports Collectibles Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs ASG Memorabilia Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs Total Sports Enterprises Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs Steiner Sports Gameday Sports Memorabilia vs Sports Collectibles ASG Memorabilia vs Total Sports Enterprises ASG Memorabilia vs Steiner Sports ASG Memorabilia vs Sports Collectibles Total Sports Enterprises vs Steiner Sports Total Sports Enterprises vs Sports Collectibles Steiner Sports vs Sports Collectibles
Compare the Best Sports Memorabilia Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Sports Memorabilia Stores
See the Best Sports Memorabilia Store
The Best Reviews of Sports Memorabilia Stores