The Best Steak Clubs

Monday, October 14th

2024 Steak Club Reviews

Good Chop

Good Chop lets customers select from medium, large, or extra large boxes and select their own cuts and type of meat in each box, delivered every 4 weeks. Prices are low, considering the meat is USDA-organic and free of antibiotics, plus shipping is just $9.99. Customers can pause or cancel their subscription at any time, and Good Chop offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee on their products and services. They also have an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau and great reviews from customers. Good Chop is a fantastic, customizable option for steak and other meat deliveries, so they've earned our highest rating.

Good Ranchers

Good Ranchers is focused on working with local farmers to provide customers with grass-fed, grain-finished beef and chicken that reaches higher than organic standards. Here you can also get seafood and pork in over 14 curated boxes to choose from. Customers have nothing but great things to say about the customer service here, quality of meats, pricing, and delivery. Good Ranchers is a safe bet among steak clubs if you want healthy, quality meats in a variety of cuts. They are one of our favorite places for steak and other meat deliveries.

Heartstone Farm

Heartstone Farm is a family-owned business in Maine. They specialize in grass-fed cattle and pasture-raised poultry and pork. You can choose pre-made boxes or customize your own regular or large size to be delivered every 4 weeks. Customers can choose a one-time box or save with a subscription that can be canceled at any time. There are over 7,000 customer reviews on Heartstone Farms' website and they receive an "A+'' rating from the Better Business Bureau. You can trust you're getting high quality meat from Heartstone Farms at an affordable price, so they've earned one of our top spots for steak clubs.

Allen Brothers

Allen Brothers is a top quality choice for USDA Prime beef with a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. They have 5 options for subscription boxes depending on if you want your meat delivered every month or every other month. You can view what's included monthly and decide on a subscription based on the quantity included with the box. Customers can leave unfiltered reviews on Allen Brothers' website and have nothing but incredible things to say about the tastiness of what they get here. Although you don't have a ton of subscription variations at Allen Brothers, you'll get some of the best meats here, so it's a solid option for a steak subscription.

Chicago Steak Company

Chicago Steak Company specializes in gourmet meats, among other high quality foods. You can choose between two types of steak boxes for monthly deliveries and either get your subscription every month or every other one. Chicago Steak Company prides themselves in quality and their amazing customer reviews reflect this. Chicago Steak Company is reasonably priced and earns an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau. Your satisfaction is guaranteed here, so it's one of our top choices for steak clubs.

Porter Road

Porter Road is based out of Nashville, but sells pasture-raised meats from Kentucky and Tennessee. The company promises that their animals are hormone-free and don't take antibiotics. Porter Road has a variety of one-time purchase curated boxes or subscriptions that you can have delivered every 1, 2, 4, or 8 weeks. Their shipping can get pricey if you're ordering from a western state, but otherwise the boxes here are reasonable. Porter Road has few customer reviews, but all of them are positive. They don't have a rating from the Better Business Bureau, but if they live up to their promises on their website, Porter Road makes for a great option among steak clubs.

Golden Steer

Golden Steer is a well-loved steakhouse in Las Vegas that's been operating since 1958. During the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the company reinvented itself and found a way to bring their meats to people throughout the country. Golden Steer has a subscription box of premium steak that will arrive at your doorstep for 3 consecutive months. It comes with a delicious seasoning and butter to top off the juicy flavor. The $780 price tag for the 3-month subscription is pretty steep considering you might pay close to this for almost double the amount of meat through another company. If you want to splurge, we recommend trying out at least one of Golden Steer's individual steaks for purchase, but their subscription options aren't our favorite or the most robust.

Amazing Clubs

Amazing Clubs is a fantastic place to look if you want to either get or gift a unique subscription. Their variety of products will blow you away and their customer reviews are the cherry on top. People are very pleased with Amazing Clubs because of their great customer service, quality products, and timely deliveries. However, there aren't very many cuts of steak to choose from and your boxes will basically be the same each month. Since Amazing Clubs dabbles in so many products, we wouldn't expect top-of-the-line meats from them compared to some other companies. We are sure that they offer a tasty selection, but for the price there are some steak clubs that offer a wider variety with each delivery.

SteakChop

SteakChop works to make meat subscriptions easy for customers by offering 3 curated boxes or a custom box for $169.99 with free shipping. Boxes are delivered every 4 weeks, but you can easily pause or cancel your shipments to fit around your schedule. SteakChop has a solid variety of beef, chicken, seafood, and pork to choose from in either regular or double sizes depending on the size of your family. Unfortunately, the company doesn't mention a satisfaction guarantee, so we aren't sure what the process is for rectifying any issues that may occur. They don't have many customer ratings or a Better Business Bureau profile, so we don't have as much to go off of as we do with some top-rated steak clubs. SteakChop probably has good things to offer, but they aren't one of the first places we would turn for a steak subscription.

Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks is one of the more well-known meat subscription companies on the market, but unfortunately they aren't as high-quality as other steak clubs we've found. There are 8 steaks in each box that can be delivered monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly, but Omaha Steaks isn't very transparent about where their meat is from or how their cattle is raised. The company doesn't outline what types of steak are in your monthly boxes, which we'd like to see. Although they have an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, customers have had disappointing experiences with the taste, delivery, and communication of Omaha Steaks.