The Best Steak Clubs

Wednesday, January 15th

2025 Steak Club Reviews

Good Chop

• From $149/month
• USDA-certified organic beef and poultry
• Customizable boxes of beef, pork, poultry, and seafood
• No artificial ingredients, no added hormones, no antibiotics
• Pause or cancel anytime
• $9.99 standard shipping
• 100% satisfaction guarantee
• "A+” Better Business Bureau

Good Chop is a meat and seafood subscription service where you can choose from over 60 different chicken, pork, beef, and seafood cuts. All products come straight from farms and fisheries in America. The family farmers and independent ranchers ensure all their animals are handled compassionately and humanely with sufficient space, shelter, food, and water free of antibiotics and hormones. You may have even seen the company featured by Food & Wine, BuzzFeed, the New York Post, and the Food Network.

All-natural meats

With Good Chop, you can feel confident that you're getting meat from a company that shares a concern for animal welfare and sustainability. Their beef and poultry is USDA-organic, their pork is PQA-certified, and their seafood is MSC-certified. They don't use any artificial ingredients, added hormones, growth promotants, or antibiotics.

Customizable boxes

Good Chop lets their customers take the reins with what's included in their monthly boxes (delivered every 4 weeks). You'll select your own cuts of beef, pork, chicken, and seafood. The company will preselect some recommended cuts based on their selections of the week, but you'll be able to swap and choose the rest. Some of the beef cuts available here include ribeye steak, New York strip, filet mignon, stew beef, flat iron steak, ground beef, ranch steak, and T-bone steak. For a full list of the cuts of the pork, chicken, and seafood, you can see everything listed on their website.

Medium, large, and extra large boxes

Every box can be completely different since you can customize your selections for recurring orders until 5 days before the next delivery at 11:59 pm PT. You can choose between medium, large, or extra large boxes in your subscription. A medium box is $149 per box and is great for individuals and small families. It includes up to 36 portions or 14 lbs of your meat of choice. The large box is $269 and best for mid-sized families and large freezers. You'll get up to 72 portions or 28 lbs of your choice. The extra large box is $359 and ideal for large families since it comes with up to 108 portions or 42 lbs of your choice of meats. Standard shipping on all boxes is just $9.99.

Wings for life

There's a pretty sweet deal available to customers if they sign up for Good Chop's email list. You'll get 3 lbs of free chicken wings added to every subscription order for as long as you're getting shipments from the company.

Love it or your money back

Good Chop proudly boasts that they put their money where their mouth is by offering a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If you're unhappy with their products or services for any reason, you can reach out to them and they'll either credit your account or give you a full refund.

Great feedback from customers

Good Chop earns an "A+” from the Better Business Bureau. They also have thousands of excellent reviews from customers. People appreciate the fresh, natural, clean taste of the meats here and say deliveries are always as expected and on time. People are happy to know that the animals are humanely treated and free of antibiotics and other hormones. Some people prefer some cuts of meat over others here, so we recommend reading reviews to gather as much info as possible before ordering.

Almost too good to be true

We're so thrilled with Good Chop that we almost feel like they are too good to be true. The pricing is incredible and very competitive for the amount of quality meat you're getting. The fact that you can customize your boxes and the meat is organic and free of antibiotics is everything we would hope for. If you want quality meats for your family all year round, Good Chop is the ideal place to get a steak club.

Good Ranchers

• Boxes starting at $129
• Born, raised, and packaged in America
• Grass-fed and grain-finished
• One-time purchases or subscription options
• Satisfaction guarantee
• Free shipping
• Thousands of loyal customers and high reviews
• "A+” Better Business Bureau

Good Ranchers is making efforts to push back on the broken food system in the US that inflates prices and incentivizes importing poor quality meats. The company was founded by a husband and wife duo as a result of their search for quality foods to feed their growing family. Good Ranchers connects people to good foods they can't get anywhere else from local, independent farms in the U.S.

14 curated box options

You can get signed up with Good Ranchers within just a couple of minutes. Customers have the option of buying a one-time box or to sign up for a subscription and get regular deliveries. There are quite a few meat boxes to choose from, so we have no doubt that you can curate a steak club subscription specifically to fit your tastes. There's a weekly essentials box that includes pre-trimmed cuts of beef and chicken, the "Better Than Organic” chicken box with 34 pieces of chicken in different cuts and seasonings, boxes that include beef and seafood, an all-beef or all-pork box, a burger box, and other varieties.

Prices from $129 - $799

If you want to secure pricing for several years and get a 10% discount, you can provide your email address to Good Ranchers to unlock the offer. By choosing to get deliveries every 2, 4, or 6 weeks instead of a one-time box, you'll save $25 on each order too. The least expensive boxes from Good Ranchers is the burger box for $129 that includes 9 lbs of Wagyu ground beef or the small Game Day box (comes in large option for $229) with 8 smoked brats, 2 signature angus ground beef packs, 2 jumbo chicken wing packs, 2 strip-cut plain chicken packs, and a 14 oz jar of bacon butter.

Ultimate meat kit

The most expensive choice from Good Ranchers is their Prepper Kit for $799. It can be delivered every 6, 8, or 10 weeks. It's the ultimate bundle with 8.5 lbs of bone-in steaks, 6.25 lbs of boneless steaks, 8 lbs of signature angus beef, and 18 lbs of pre-trimmed, plain chicken breasts. In total, you'll get over 40 lbs of meat, so you'll want to make plenty of room in your freezer. At Good Ranchers, shipping is always free, so the prices you see listed are all that you pay.

Learn where the meat comes from

Something cool about Good Ranchers is their ranch partner highlight. It gives a bio on one of the farms that they source their meats from and gives an overview of their history. Good Ranchers also goes over the fine details of their meats and why they matter. For example, their beef is rare, grass-fed, and grain-finished and they explain why that makes a difference. If you want a little lesson on some of the terms surrounding the quality of different meats and why you should care, Good Ranchers does a good job of explaining.

Freezer-safe for up to a year

All the meat from Good Ranchers can be stored in your freezer for up to a year. All orders are shipped with 10 lbs of dry ice and insulation to ensure safety during transit. If you have any issues with your delivery upon arrival, Good Ranchers has a satisfaction guarantee to make sure everything is to your standards. You can reach the company by phone or email to discuss any questions or issues.

5-star experience

Customers say that Good Ranchers provides a 5-star experience with every order. There are over 5,500 reviews from buyers who are dedicated to eating healthy and buying from local farmers, so they're thrilled with Good Ranchers. The meat is all said to be fantastic, each box comes on time, customer service is reliable, and everything is reasonably priced. The Better Business Bureau gives Good Ranchers an "A+” rating, which is another reason to feel confident buying here.

Phenomenal choice

Good Ranchers is a phenomenal company. Their prices are great and we are excited about how many meat options there are to choose from. Doing a subscription here will give you the most value, but it also feels affordable to get a unique one-off box as well. We like that this company has a high standard of grass-fed beef and better than organic chicken because that's becoming more important and harder to find from companies. Good Ranchers is a top company for meat delivery and they've earned one of our highest ratings among steak clubs.

Heartstone Farm

• Starting at $149 for a custom box
• Family-owned
• Grass-fed cattle
• Free shipping
• Free ground beef for a year with signup
• Cancel anytime
• Satisfaction guarantee
• "A+” Better Business Bureau

Heartstone Farm is one of the newer meat subscription companies online. They were established in 2013 by a husband and wife team who had a passion for animals and a desire to break free from "big ag” to obtain their own food. Heartstone Farm's mission is to raise good food in a natural way that avoids the use of antibiotics. Their cattle are grass-fed and live in a stress-free environment to create optimal nutrition. Heartstone Farm is over 500 acres of woods, streams, and pastures in Maine recognized for its perfect grass-growing environment due to climate and soil.

Pick your box size, pick your meats

At Heartstone Farm, the meat delivery boxes are called the "Farmer Dan Meat Box Subscription”. You get to choose your box size (regular or large), pick your meat cuts, and get your fast, fresh, frozen delivery every 4 weeks. There are 13 choices for grass-fed beef boxes, 7 choices of pasture-raised chicken, and 7 options for pasture-raised pork.

Long list of cuts

The regular box includes 10 cuts for $149. This is ideal for individuals and small families. The large box is double the size, with 20 cuts and best serves larger families for $267. You can select a mix of beef like fajita meat, stew meat, ground beef, burger patties, ribeye steak, filet mignon, shaved steak, all natural turkey, pasture raised chicken, pork, soup, or even pies. There are plenty of choices, so you'll never get bored of your meals throughout the year if you're buying from Heartstone Farm.

Free ground beef for a year

There are curated boxes available from Heartstone Farm if you don't want to mix and match your selections. There is a burger box ($109), chicken stock up box ($149), The Maine box (35 lbs of steaks, roasts and more for $449), and soon they'll be launching a homestead and singles box. When you sign up for emails from Heartstone Farm, you'll unlock $25 off your next order. You can also get free ground beef for a year when you sign up for one of Heartstone Farms' meat boxes.

7-day guarantee

Hearthstone Farm doesn't outline exactly how they package your meat shipment, but they do have a guarantee on their products. If you contact them within 7 days of the date you received your order, they will either replace it or provide a full or partial refund depending on the circumstance if you are dissatisfied.

Thousands of loyal customers

Heartstone Farm doesn't have quite as many third-party reviews as other steak clubs we've found. However, they do have over 7,000 unfiltered reviews on their website and they are almost all a 5/5 rating. Customers are extremely pleased with the flavor, delivery, and service from Heartstone Farm. There are many loyal customers here because of the consistently reliable service provided. The Better Business Bureau gives Heartstone Farm an "A+” rating and we see no red flags or concerns about buying anything here.

Highly recommend

We love that this is a family-run business that is focused on providing healthy, high quality meats to customers. We're big fans of the grass-fed beef and pasture-raised chicken and pork. We want to support companies dedicated to higher levels of farming practices and Heartstone Farms is a good example of this. We highly recommend subscribing to one of their meat boxes, so they've earned one of our top ratings as a steak club.

Allen Brothers

• Subscriptions starting at $550
• 6- and 12-month delivery options
• 5 Steak of the Month options
• Focus on USDA Prime beef
• Satisfaction guarantee
• Lamb, pork, seafood, poultry, and veal options
• Unfiltered customer reviews

Allen Brothers has been around since 1893, with company principles that revolve around meticulous aging methods, artisanal hand-cut portions, and a commitment to excellence. The company focuses on USDA Prime beef that's grain fed and pasture raised, from superior breeds to ensure that their meats are a "cut” above the rest. Allen Brothers supplies steaks to some top steakhouses throughout the country and has helped them earn strong reputations.

Starting at $550

Aside from steak, Allen Brothers proudly offers humanely raised veal, lamb, pork, and seafood. They also sell ready-to-eat side dishes and prepared desserts to add an element of convenience to your meal. They offer five Steak of the Month club choices for meat lovers who want top quality steak delivered straight to their door. The prices range from $550 to $2,000 depending on the type of meat and frequency of deliveries.

Quantity and frequency of delivery varies

You'll undoubtedly save money by doing a Steak of the Month Club rather than ordering individual steaks each month. For $550 you can get smaller pack sizes (usually two 8-12 oz. steaks or burgers monthly) for either 6 months or 12 months. Subscribers can choose odd or even months if you want to go the half-year route. For $2,000, you'll get things like 4 USDA boneless steaks one month, 8 domestic lamb rib chops another month, and 16 prime steak burgers another month. To decide which subscription is right for you, be sure to review the schedule and quantity. This way you'll know if it's enough for your family or if it's overkill and you could do smaller portions or a lower frequency for delivery. Each product listing shows exactly what you'll be receiving month-by-month along with pictures of the cuts so you know what to expect.

Delivery price included

If you sign up for Allen Brothers' emails, you'll get free shipping on your first order over $199 and get email-only exclusive offers, private sales, and information on new products. We like that all the pricing on their website includes the delivery fees, so you don't have to worry about exorbitant shipping costs on top of the price of your meats.

Guaranteed frozen or partially thawed

When you're dealing with food, especially the perishable kind like meat, you can't really "return” any of it. If you have concerns about your delivery, Allen Brothers asks that you give them a call to sort it out. They guarantee that as long as you provide accurate delivery information, your order will arrive either frozen or partially thawed. Anything partially thawed can safely be re-frozen or used within 3-5 days without any issues. The company says that if they fail to live up to their guarantee, they'll either replace your order or issue you a gift card.

Refer to product reviews

The "D-” rating the Better Business Bureau (BBB) gives Allen Brothers is concerning. However, upon further evaluation we found that this rating is only based on their failure to respond to four customer reviews. Their BBB profile is not where most customers are leaving comments, but rather directly on product listings for different types of meat. We noticed that there are only a handful of reviews on the monthly subscription options, but there are hundreds on their individual cuts. If you review these, you'll find that people are highly satisfied with Allen Brothers, saying they exceed expectations, the meat is tender, arrival is fantastic, and they've never been disappointed.

Won't go wrong

Allen Brothers is a top quality choice for a steak club. Although you won't get the option to add anything to your monthly deliveries per se (unless you submit a separate order), it's nice that your options aren't overwhelming, you'll be getting phenomenal meat, you can choose between 6- and 12-month deliveries, and this company is committed to customer satisfaction. You won't go wrong here if you like what's offered monthly, so we've given Allen Brothers our a very good rating.

Chicago Steak Company

• Starting at $999.95
• Free welcome gift
• Free shipping
• Different cuts of meat each month
• Satisfaction guarantee
• Phenomenal reviews from thousands of customers
• "A+” Better Business Bureau rating

Since the founding of the union stockyards in 1865, Chicago has been well-known for their high-quality American meats. Chicago Steak Company carries on the tradition with hand-cut, Midwest-raised, USDA Prime beef. The company raises, trims, and ages their own steaks (usually for 4-6 weeks), then vacuum seals them individually to maximize flavor and freshness. Aside from steak, Chicago Steak Company also sells gourmet seafood, burgers, hams, roasts, poultry, desserts, and sides. The company has a well-rounded, mouth-watering selection that you can't go wrong with.

Four subscription choices

There are four choices of steak clubs from Chicago Steak Company. They vary between 6 and 12 months of deliveries and you can choose between Five Star Reserve Steaks and Premium Angus Beef in your deliveries. Depending on how often you want a delivery and the cuts, you'll pay anywhere from $999.95 to $2,099.95 for a subscription.

Premium Angus Beef Plan

The 6-month delivery can be sent in either even or odd months, depending on your preference. The Premium Angus Beef plan is $999.95 with free shipping for 6 months, and $1,899.95 for 12 months. The contents of your box will be different each month with things like beef filet mignons, Angus beef boneless strips, gourmet steak burgers, beef medallion filets, flat iron steaks, beef ribeyes, and more. You can see which meats are included month-by-month within the product listing.

Five-Star Reserve Steaks Plan

The Five-Star Reserve Steaks Plan is slightly more expensive with a 6-month membership listed at $1,149.95 and a 12-month plan for $2,099.95, both with free shipping. Included are some of the finest steaks you'll find on the market. Boxes may include things like prime top sirloins, wagyu beef steak burgers, filet mignons, and more. This subscription also lists the contents month-by-month so you know what you'll be getting ahead of time.

Free welcome gift

When you land on Chicago Steak Company's website, there is an offer for a free welcome gift worth $169. It includes 8 burgers, seasoning, a $25 reward, and free shipping. You might as well snag this deal by providing your email address if you choose to subscribe here. At the time of this review, there was also a discount code provided that would add a free cheesecake sampler to any order over $199. Yes, please!

Commitment to quality

Chicago Steak Company has dedicated themselves to the highest quality of service, so they guarantee that they will ship exactly what you order in excellent condition. Their steaks pass many quality and safety inspections before being branded by Chicago Steak Company. If for any reason you aren't satisfied with your order, you can contact their customer service team for a replacement or a refund, whichever you prefer.

Incredible reviews

Chicago Steak Company passes the customer satisfaction test with flying colors. They have extremely high customer reviews from thousands of people. Customers say they are never disappointed and the meat is far better than anything you can find at the grocery store. Buyers report that packaging is great, orders are always complete and accurate, delivery is fast, and every other good thing you'd hope to see from a company selling gourmet meats. Chicago Steak Company also has an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, so we couldn't be more pleased about their performance.

One of the best

We are big fans of everything about Chicago Steak Company. They no doubt have some of the finest quality of meats available, so you're in for a real treat when your delivery shows up. We like that their customer service is reliable, their ratings are off the charts, the cuts of meat rotate monthly to change things up, and their pricing is reasonable. We've easily given Chicago Steak Company one of our top ratings as a steak club.

Porter Road

• Fresh meat subscriptions starting at $65
• Hormone-free, no antibiotics, pasture-raised
• 10 curated boxes
• Deliveries every 1, 2, 4, or 8 weeks
• Most meats shipped chilled, not frozen
• 10% off order with email signup
• Flat-rate shipping on orders over $125

Porter Road was founded in 2010 by two men who became friends in a Nashville kitchen, hit it off, and decided to open their own catering business. As the business grew, the co-founders discovered how hard it was to get your hands on quality, local meat sources you could trust. It began as a butcher shop, but expanded nationwide by going online in 2017 so everyone could get access to incredible meat. Porter Road has been featured by Business Insider, TechCrunch, Food & Wine, Bloomberg, Fox Business, and the Wall Street Journal.

Pasture-raised meats

The meat you get from Porter Road is all pasture-raised in Kentucky and Tennessee. They vet their partners against standards above and beyond organic and cage-free. They regularly visit these farms to make sure the animals are raised outside, fed a vegetarian diet, and given proper attention throughout their life. Once the meat reaches Porter Road's facility, they hand-cut all the meat, then dry age the beef to create an intense flavor. Every step of the way, Porter Road goes to great lengths to ensure that customers get the healthiest and highest-quality meats.

10 curated choices

There are 10 curated boxes you can choose from at Porter Road. You could subscribe to something as simple as their 40 pack of beef stick bundle for $68 or go all out on their butcher's choice box for a subscription price of $140. This includes 2 dry aged steaks, 2 sirloin filets, 2 pork chops, 1 lb of dry aged ground beef, and 1 lb of pork bacon. Plus, you'll get an assortment that changes each month like short ribs, kielbasa, pork butt, or brats. Some of Porter Road's other curated boxes include their Road Classics box for $145 that includes a variety of steaks, pork chops, ground beef, dry aged hot dogs, breakfast sausage, and roast seasoning. They have a breakfast box, Grilling Heroes box, ground beef sampler, dry aged beef box, and more. If you're a meat lover, you'll undoubtedly find a variety pack here that includes everything you want. Plus, with your email signup, Porter Road will give you 10% off your next order.

Shipping costs vary by state

Shipping can get pretty pricey from Porter Road, depending on the state you're ordering from. Orders over $125 are eligible for flat-rate shipping, but if you live on the west coast, that shipping fee is $40. Some East Coast states and the middle region of the US pay $15 for shipping, and if you're lucky and live somewhere like Minnesota, Illinois, South Carolina, or Florida, your shipping is free. Porter Road has a shipping map that makes it easy to identify what you'll pay.

Deliveries every 1, 2, 4 or 8 weeks

It's important to note that not every curated box is eligible for recurring deliveries. Some of them are one-time purchase boxes, so look for the "Subscribe and Save” label. Deliveries are available in 1, 2, 4, or 8 week increments. You can modify or cancel your subscription at any time. Your box will arrive with your meats chilled in insulation along with gel packs in a standard cardboard shipping. Porter Road isn't a fan of shipping completely frozen meats (except for ground beef, sausages, and large roasts), so don't expect that. You should consume the meat within 5-7 days upon arrival or freeze it.

Contact Porter Road with concerns

If you aren't happy with part or all of your order, Porter Road doesn't specifically outline how they handle this situation. They encourage customers to reach out to them as soon as possible since their goal is to do right by their customers. We assume they'll replace or refund your order, but they don't necessarily say this.

Few customer reviews than competitors

Porter Road has posted testimonials from customers on their website, but they aren't unfiltered, so you won't get a full spectrum of opinions. They don't have a rating or profile with the Better Business Bureau, and there aren't a ton of third-party reviews either. It's hard for us to gauge the experiences from a big sample of people, but everything we see is very promising. From the few reports we found from customers, people feel like they never want to buy meat from a grocery store again after subscribing with Porter Road.

Fresh, not frozen

It's great to see that Porter Road has high standards for their farmers and the meat quality they sell to customers. Their prices are competitive here and you can try a variety of meats by either sticking with one of their subscriptions or trying a one-time assortment. Porter Road is a good option for fresh, not frozen steak clubs.

Golden Steer

• Subscription costs $780.30
• Mystery gift with email signup
• 3 months of steaks
• USDA-certified
• Rooted in history since 1958
• Satisfaction guarantee
• Free shipping over $100
• "A+” Better Business Bureau rating

The brick-and-mortar location for the Golden Steer is the oldest operating steakhouse in Las Vegas. Since 1958, the restaurant has been serving "The Best Steaks on Earth” and has welcomed celebrities from near and far to its signature red leather booths named after historical figures like Marilyn Monroe and Frank Sinatra. During 2020, Golden Steer reimagined how they could bring their steaks to their loyal customers and they came up with the plan to take their brand online and ship their steaks around the country.

Single subscription box

There are no complicated decisions when it comes to which steak club you want from Golden Steer, since there's only one to choose from. The Gunslinger 3-Month Subscription is inspired by the wild frontier of the Nevada Desert and is built for the "knock-about maverick lifestyle”. You can find free recipes on Golden Steer's website to make sure you're getting the most out of the meats you buy. There's also a mystery offer for customers willing to sign up for Golden Steer's email list. In future communications you'll get recipes, tips, and a gift on your birthday.

3 months of ribeyes

The Gunslinger bundle ships every month for three months and costs $780.30. In each box you'll get over 5 lbs. of USDA-certified prime bone-in ribeye steak (feeds 4-6 people). All of it is butchered in-house, so no two steaks are alike. Each Gunslinger steak weighs between 20 and 22 oz, depending on the cut, and comes with a decadent seasoning of salt, spice, celery salt, onion, garlic, turmeric, and paprika. It also is smothered in Maitre d' Butter made up with spices like rosemary, tarragon, parsley, lemon juice, worcestershire sauce, onions, chili powder, oil, and more. You're getting the total experience here!

Unique add-on products

You could always choose to buy individual steaks from Golden Steer if you want to mix it up and taste some of their other cuts. This is a bit more expensive than going with the subscription, but it might be fun to do some add-ons every once in a while. You can also shop their seasoning collection and butters. These would make for delicious on-hand items or unique gifts for a loved one.

Steaks carefully packaged for transport

For all orders over $100, Golden Steer will ship your items for free. Upon arrival, you have 24 hours to inspect your steaks and request a replacement or refund if for some reason they are damaged or inedible. You'll need to provide a photo of the issue in order to qualify for a refund if an issue does occur. Each item is vacuum-sealed, then frozen prior to shipment. They are placed inside insulated cooler boxes and filled with enough ice packs to safely transfer your steaks to their destination.

Steaks second to none

You can read unfiltered reviews on Golden Steer's website about their steaks, seasonings, and butters. There aren't many reviews about the subscription, but the steaks alone are known to be second to none. Many people love Golden Steer's Las Vegas location and are excited that they can have the experience from home. Golden Steer receives an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau and third-party sites have high ratings from customers for the company as well.

Splurge-worthy, but not our #1

If you want top of the line, fancy, gourmet, splurge-worthy steaks, Golden Steer is where it's at. We were hungry just reading about their cuts on their website and the fact that they come with seasoning and a delicious butter makes it sound even better. Looking at Golden Steer strictly from a steak club perspective, we aren't as sold. We wish there were more options than just three back-to-back monthly deliveries. Some people prefer skipping months and others might want deliveries all year long. If you were to do 4 subscriptions in order to get a full year's worth of steaks, you'd be spending over $3,100, which is extremely expensive. It's quite a bit more than most other places, so this might not be an option for some people.

Amazing Clubs

• Prices starting at $147.95/month
• Free shipping
• Choose between 3, 4, 6, or 12 deliveries per year
• Fresh, never frozen
• Satisfaction guarantee
• Fantastic customer reviews
• "A+” Better Business Bureau rating

Amazing Clubs is home to a variety of subscription services, not just for steaks. You can get auto-deliveries of wine, hot sauce, cheesecake, honey, marshmallows, and even teddy bears. Whatever you fancy, Amazing Clubs can make sure you never run out. The company was founded in 2003 with the goal of bringing exclusive, high quality gourmet items to customers wherever they are. Amazing Clubs has been featured by Good Morning America, The Early Show, Today, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today.

Three different cuts

When you sign up for Amazing Clubs' monthly subscription of steaks, you'll be getting four premium steaks delivered monthly, all certified USDA choice. You can choose between 6 oz filet mignons, 8 oz boneless ribeye, 10 oz New York strips, or a surprise variety pack of 2 varieties. Unless you go with the surprise box, you'll get the same cuts with each delivery, so make sure you choose wisely when you do the initial sign up. If you're sending the steak subscription as a gift, you can include a gift announcement by mail or email with your order.

Starting at $147.95/month

You can choose to have steaks delivered from Amazing Clubs 3 months of the year for $449.85 ($149.95/month), quarterly for $599.80 ($149.95/month), every other month for $893.70 ($148.95/month), or every month for $1,775.40 ($147.95/month). Deliveries usually start the month following your signup date. For example, if you sign up in March, you'll get your first delivery in April. Shipping is always free, so you don't need to worry about factoring that into your overall cost.

Never frozen

Amazing Clubs always send their steaks to your door fresh, never frozen. They'll arrive in specialty packaging with dry ice to ensure safe delivery. In each box you'll also receive their newsletter, gourmet recipes, grilling tips, and serving suggestions.

Guaranteed satisfaction

If you're ever unsatisfied with the steak selections from Amazing Clubs, they'll allow you to cancel your membership and receive a refund for any unshipped product. To contact the company, they have an email and phone number provided on their website.

Well-loved company

We were impressed with how well-liked Amazing Clubs is. They have an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, but better yet, their customer reviews are sky high. People describe their subscription boxes as "superb”, "prompt”, "excellent”, "effortless”, "outstanding”, and more. There are thousands of reviews on third-party sites from real customers who are big fans of this company and all that they produce. Because of this, we fully trust that Amazing Clubs will follow through with timely deliveries and provide exactly what they show on their site.

Great brand, weak variety

In the end, Amazing Clubs has tons of different product options, great customer service, reliable deliveries, and quality products, but also has one of the least customizable plans out there. If you just want to make sure you have steak on-hand and aren't worried about a unique variety throughout the year, Amazing Clubs will do the job. It isn't significantly cheaper than some steak clubs that seem to be of higher quality and that focus on more gourmet beef cuts. We want to give this company a higher rating, but when you can get a better variety of steak from other companies, it's hard not to want to look elsewhere first.

SteakChop

• Regular boxes for $169.99
• 3 curated meat boxes or customize your own
• USDA Prime and Premium Choice
• Livestock is born, raised, and harvested in America
• Free shipping

SteakChop's mission is to make top quality meat and seafood available to everybody. Co-founders Todd and Andy have spent over 25 years forging relationships with the best butchers, ranchers, and fishmongers to source the highest quality proteins for their customers. SteakChop works to bring a worry-free, hassle-free experience by letting you choose the items you want in a subscription, set your schedule, and enjoy a delicious meal from home.

A higher standard of meat

SteakChop says they cater to those who love the fine-dining quality of Morton's, Ruth's Chris, Flemings, or Capitol Grill. They have "Center of the Plate Specialists” who continually search for specialty items alongside top quality meat and seafood to delight their customers. All their livestock are born, raised, and harvested in America and earn USDA Prime and Premium Choice designations. If you're ordering seafood from SteakChop, all of it will be wild caught from fishmongers who use sustainable practices. Their pork is pasture-raised and their poultry is all-natural.

All boxes for $169.99

There are three main plans to choose from when you sign up for a SteakChop club and all of them are $169.99. The most popular is "Butcher's Feast” that includes 2 Prime NY Strip, 4 flat iron steaks, 6 chicken thighs, 1 pork tenderloin, and 4 chicken breasts. This is the regular size, but you can double it for bigger portions. There's also "The Whole Shebang” box with 2 filet mignons, 2 petite tender steaks, 1 wild-caught shrimp bag, 4 wild-caught Icelandic cod loins, 1 pork tenderloin, and 4 chicken breasts. This option has the most variety and gives you a small taste of everything. Finally, if you're into fine dining, you'll like the "Land and Sea” box that includes 2 Prime NY strip steaks, 2 petite choice tender steaks, 4 wild-caught Mahi-mahi filets, 1 wild-caught shrimp bag (1.5 lbs), and 4 chicken breasts.

Build your own box

If you're looking for a mix outside of the curated boxes available from SteakChop, you can build your own pack. First you'll pick your proteins, then you'll see a list of items you can swap until you've mixed and matched your meats to perfection. The custom box is also $169.99 and shipping at SteakChop is always free.

Frozen deliveries

SteakChop delivers nationwide and packs their deliveries with enough dry ice to keep your meat frozen for 12 hours after it arrives. All items are vacuum-sealed for easy storing and portioning too. Deliveries automatically get scheduled every 4 weeks, so if you end up with too much meat after a few deliveries and need to skip or cancel your next delivery, you can do it without any fees. On the flipside, you can always push up a delivery if you can't wait for your next batch of meat to arrive too.

No satisfaction guarantee

SteakChop doesn't offer a satisfaction guarantee to their customers. Their website is pretty basic and doesn't include as many FAQs or as much customer information as some other places do. They do provide contact information in the form of a phone number or email where you can reach them, so if you have delivery issues, we recommend contacting SteakChop right away to get the issue taken care of.

Few customer reviews

There are no unfiltered customer reviews on SteakChops' website, they don't have a Better Business Bureau profile, and there isn't a lot about them on third-party sites. This doesn't mean that they don't provide high-quality meat or good service, but SteakChop isn't as popular or well-known yet as some other steak clubs.

Not outshining the competition yet

SteakChop offers great pricing and it's awesome that they have simple subscription box options all for the same price. Since shipping is free, this is a really affordable option compared to some other places. We do wish they had a satisfaction guarantee and more customer reviews, though. Also, if grass-fed beef is important to you, it doesn't seem like SteakChop fits the bill. They aren't entirely clear about the diet of their cattle and how they are treated, which we aren't big fans of. Overall, this is an intriguing company, but they don't quite stand out above some of their competition just yet.

Omaha Steaks

• Starting at $139.99/box
• Family-owned and operated
• 8 steaks per box
• Monthly, bi-monthly, and quarterly steak shipments
• 100% guarantee
• $30 off your first order over $159 with email signup
• Free shipping on orders over $169
• "A+” Better Business Bureau

Omaha Steaks began with a father and son, J.J., and B.A., who escaped Riga, Latvia to avoid religious persecution and eventually settled in Omaha, Nebraska. They worked in several meat markets around the city before founding their own in 1917. It's now operated by 5th generation family members but remains headquartered in Omaha where their meat is processed, prepped, and packaged.

3 subscription timelines

Although Omaha Steaks is known for their steaks and is even named after them, the company has a selection of burgers, franks, chicken, pork, seafood, and other meats you can choose from. Their steak subscription plans are straightforward and don't come with much variation. You'll get up to 8 steaks each month of different varieties. You could choose to have your deliveries scheduled every other month or quarterly, if it better suits your needs.

Lacking information

We would have liked to see more information about exactly what types of steaks you'll get each month. Most steak clubs are more transparent about what they ship than Omaha Steaks is. When you click on their "preparation” section in the product listing, it says that for ingredients and nutrition information you'll need to contact the company directly. The nutrition tab lists out all the months of the year where you'd presume the types of steak would be listed for each month, but the information isn't there. We'd like to see where exactly the steaks are sourced from and more information on the cattle's diet and treatment, just to know how high of quality we'd be getting here.

Cheaper boxes with more deliveries

The monthly steak box is best for big families and costs $139.99/month. Over the full course of the subscription, this adds up to $1,679.88, which isn't bad. If you'd rather have a bi-monthly delivery, you'll pay $149.99/box or $899.94 over the whole course. The quarterly steak box is good for one-off parties and get-togethers, but is the most expensive per box. You'll pay $169.99 for each delivery, which is a total of $679.96 after 4 boxes. For new customers, Omaha Steaks will give you $30 off your first order over $159 if you sign up for their emails.

Tons of meat assortments

As long as you are spending over $169 at Omaha Steaks, your order will ship for free. If your order total is between $140 and $169, shipping is $9.99, but if it's under $140 then shipping is a hefty $19.99. There are so many individual meats and products here you could easily add onto your order for free shipping. Between burger packs, seasonal best sellers, custom assortments, or a value freezer filler, you can spend plenty of money. When you're adding your steak club to your cart, Omaha Steaks will give you a list of suggested add-on products you could throw in with your order.

Love it or your money back

Omaha Steaks is confident that you'll love their meats. If you don't, they'll either replace your order or refund your purchase. To reach the company, a phone number is provided on the website with their department hours listed.

Disappointing reviews

The Better Business Bureau gives Omaha Steaks an "A+” rating, which we love to see. The company has unfiltered reviews on their website, but they are few and far between. Products show a rating from customers, but we weren't able to see them listed individually, so it wasn't helpful to us. Unfortunately, third-party reviews aren't anything to get excited about. Some of them mention disappointing texture and flavor of the meats received from Omaha Steaks, poor service and communication, issues with delivery, and more. We read enough to talk us out of trusting that this company supplies high-quality, flavorful meats.

Better options out there

We aren't sure where exactly Omaha Meats is sourcing their steaks from and they offer so many different meats and packages that it doesn't seem like steak is their top specialty. It would be nice to know what you're getting each month and have some more variety than what is promoted in their steak boxes too. Overall we aren't nearly as excited about Omaha Steaks as we are about some other higher-rated companies, so they've earned the lowest ranking on our list of steak clubs.