Mr. Steak Review

Friday, March 24th

2023 Steak Club Reviews

Mr. Steak

• Family owned and operated
• All USDA Prime meats sourced within 250 miles of Omaha, Nebraska
• Steaks are hand-cut, hand-selected
• 4 boxes to choose from
• Priced from $145.80 to $336.60 per delivery
• Can get deliveries every 4, 6 or 8 weeks
• Add-ons available to customize the box
• Free shipping on $175+, $10 per delivery for smaller orders
• Committed to sustainability and social responsibility
• "Grill School" to help you cook your steaks perfectly
• 7-day refund policy

Could there be more of an expert on all things beef than a company called Mr. Steak? You can rely on this business to help you get your grill on, on the regular, with high-quality steaks and other cuts. All of the meat in their Steak of the Month Club is USDA Prime, raised on family farms with the highest of standards for ethical and humane processing and sustainability.

Head to Grill School for an education in steak

Need some guidance to get your steak cooked to perfection? Mr. Steak's got you covered. Just check out their super-cool Grill School to find everything from recipes to tips-and-tricks videos. After all, no one is born knowing how to make the perfect steak, so why not take advantage of the decades of experience behind this family-owned and operated company?

Four Steak of the Month Clubs to consider

Mr. Steak's monthly club lets you choose among four different boxes:

• USDA Prime Starter: priced at $145.80, this package comes with 1 USDA Prime Flat Iron Steak - 8oz, 1 USDA Prime New York Strip, Center Cut - 10oz, 1 USDA Prime Bone-In New York Strip - 20oz, 1 USDA Prime Boneless Ribeye - 12oz, and 1 pack Wagyu Burgers (2 8oz patties).
• USDA Prime Family Favorites: for $188.10, you'll get 2 USDA Prime Flat Iron Steaks - 8oz, 1 USDA Prime New York Strip, Center Cut - 14oz, 1 USDA Prime Filet Mignon, Center Cut - 10oz, 1 USDA Prime Boneless Ribeye Steak - 12oz, and 1 pack Wagyu Burgers (2 8oz patties).
• USDA Prime Grill Masters: this subscription sells for $260.96, and it comes with 2 USDA Prime New York Strips, Center Cut - 14oz, 2 USDA Prime Filet Mignons, Center Cut - 6oz, 1 USDA Prime Boneless Ribeye - 12oz, 1 USDA Prime Bone-In Ribeye - 20oz, and 1 pack Wagyu Burgers (2 8oz patties).
• USDA Prime Big Boys Bone-In: priced at $336.60, Mr. Steak's biggest subscription box has 2 USDA Prime Bone-In New York Strips - 20oz, 1 USDA Prime Cowboy Ribeye - 32oz, 1 USDA Prime Porterhouse - 24oz, and 2 USDA Prime Bone-In Ribeyes - 20oz. This one must be really popular, because it was sold out during our last visit to the website.

Add extras and save on shipping

What if you'd like a little extra something with your Steak of the Month delivery? No problem. Once you've chosen the box you want and the preferred delivery schedule (every four, six or eight weeks), you'll be taken to a list of all of the add-ons you can include in your first box. How about beer bratwurst with cheddar cheese? A four-pack of Craft Brisket Blend burgers? An extra steak for dinner guests? Your extras will only come with the initial shipment; if you'd like something added to your subsequent boxes, you'll have the opportunity to specify that the week before it ships. It might be worth it to add just enough to reach a total of at least $175; otherwise, you'll be paying $10 per delivery for shipping fees on each box.

No problem to give as a gift

Mr. Steak makes it pretty easy to give their Steak of the Month Club as a gift, too. On their main Subscriptions page, just look for the button for gifting a membership. You'll follow the same steps as a regular subscription, including any add-ons, but the final page will ask you for your gift recipient's name and email address. Be aware that your person will get an email notification right away: you can't specify a delivery date for it. They'll get a second email when their order ships.

Solid reputation for quality and attention to customers

Each of the Steak of the Month options has two or three dozen reviews, which is actually pretty impressive; many of their rivals only have a handful of comments from subscribers. Strangely, though, we couldn't find a way to actually read those reviews: the stars are displayed but that's it. Fortunately, we were able to find shoppers who describe individual steaks as "the best they've had" and who won't get their beef from any other store. Better yet, we've found that Mr. Steak's representatives always respond to their customers, whether they're offering praise or reporting an issue.

Trust this steak club to deliver

We love that shoppers can choose from four different Steak of the Month Clubs here, and that there's always the option to add on a little (or a lot). We're not as impressed with the $10/month delivery fee on the lowest-priced subscription, or with the fact that gift-givers can't choose a date for their gift announcement to go out. But, those are pretty minor issues compared with the excellent reputation and high-quality steaks on offer. Mr. Steak gets a strong recommendation from us.