Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Omaha Steaks Review

Friday, March 24th

2023 Steak Club Reviews

Omaha Steaks Review 3 Star Rating

Omaha Steaks

3 Star Rating
  • $129.99 to $169.99 per month (doesn't include shipping)
  • Choose monthly, every other month, or quarterly deliveries
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • "A+" rated and accredited by the BBB

Omaha Steaks calls itself "America's Original Butcher" , with origins dating back to 1917 for this family-run business. When most people think of mail-order meat, this is the brand that usually comes to mind.

Get steak every 1, 2 or 3 months

Choosing your Steak of the Month Club with Omaha Steaks is based on the answer to just one question: how often do you want it to be delivered? You can choose monthly, bimonthly or quarterly shipments. You may find it helpful to look at their "steak schedule" to see which months have the cuts you like best. For example, at the time of this review, January and October had four 5-oz Butcher's Cut Filet Mignons and four 5-oz Butcher's Cut Top Sirloins, while six of the 12 months included bacon-wrapped Filet Mignons. Plus, most months you'll get eight steaks but June's package only has six (because two of them are 18-oz T-Bones).

Shipping gets costly

If you opt to get your steaks monthly, you'll pay $129.99. The bimonthly box is priced at $149.99, and quarterly deliveries are $169.99 each. Unfortunately, shipping is only included on the quarterly box, because it meets the minimum order to qualify for free delivery. That means you should expect to tack on an additional $19.99 per delivery, making this Steak of the Month Club that much more expensive.

Rewards program is worth it

The only other way to get free delivery is to sign up for Omaha Steaks' Steaklover Rewards Gold program. For an annual fee of $39.99, you'll qualify for free shipping on every delivery priced over $79.99 (essentially every Steak of the Month Club shipment), free products, and double the reward points you'd get with their complimentary rewards program. Do the math: if you're doing the month-to-month or bi-monthly membership, it's worth it to spend $39.99 once to not pay $19.99 every time you get your steaks. Still, compared with other steak subscriptions that include the delivery fees, Omaha Steaks comes across more than a little nickel-and-dime.

Best Steak Clubs

Decent gift-giving options (even Braille)

Omaha Steaks' clubs can be sent as a gift. During checkout, you'll enter the shipping address and on that page you can enter your personalized message - either just on the first shipment or have it included with every delivery. There's no special gift packaging option, however. Alternately, it's easy to send gift cards, whether you prefer an electronic one delivered via email or a physical card that gets sent in the mail. (We thought it was pretty cool that Omaha Steaks offers Braille gift cards by special request!)

Mixed reviews from clients

For the most part, Omaha Steaks maintains the kind of reputation you'd expect from a steak company with over 100 years in business. The BBB continues to give them an "A+" and accreditation, and there were only a few dozen complaints registered there in the year prior to this evaluation. Foodie feedback in other places doesn't look as good. We found comments saying that the steaks were much smaller than expected, or that the quality wasn't even as good as what they could get from their local butcher. (Of course, we doubt that the butcher is packaging up their steaks to ship nationwide.) The retailer seems to do a good job of honoring their 100% satisfaction guarantee, and most people have no issues with the customer service here, but in our experience the steaks aren't nearly as impressive as you'd imagine for what you're paying.

Get more for your money somewhere else

Omaha Steaks gets points for being around for a long time. It's not easy to maintain a reputation for so many years. But, lots of options have emerged for Steak of the Month Clubs, and some of Omaha Steaks' competitors are, frankly, doing it better. This isn't a terrible way to get steaks delivered on the regular or as a gift, but we recommend taking a look at the other possibilities before settling on this one.

Which Steak of the Month Club is the Best?

Subscription boxes are all the rage, but it might surprise you to know that something as delicious as a USDA Prime Porterhouse can show up on your doorstep every month. Meat lovers, rejoice!

There are two main types of Steak Clubs to choose from: gourmet, special occasion cuts or time-saving packages that let you skip the supermarket. Most fall into the first category, giving you the chance to sample steaks from around the nation (or even the world) that you wouldn't find at your local grocery store. These Steak of the Month Clubs don't typically let you customize what you receive, because you're on a set schedule of steaks that the company chooses for you.

The Best Steak Clubs Compare Steak Clubs Compare Steak Club Reviews What are the best Steak Clubs Best Steak Club Reviews

Steak Club FAQ

Yes! Can you think of any other club you'd like more?! Steak of the Month Clubs deliver all of the best ribeyes, filet mignons and other cuts right to your home - or to a lucky gift recipient.
Most steak clubs take great pride in sourcing their beef from top farms, mostly in the United States. Some even tell you exactly which farms your steaks come from, where they're processed, and so on.
That depends on the steak club you select. Almost all of them have monthly deliveries and you just choose how long you want your membership to last: three months, six months, or a full year are the most common lengths. A few providers also offer bimonthly or quarterly steak shipments.
Maybe, maybe not. Some Steak Clubs are set up more as a recurring stock-the-freezer plan, and those usually let you select from a list of steaks, ground beef, or even other meats like pork and seafood. However, many Steak of the Month Clubs have a set schedule of products and you don't get to pick and choose.
Are they more costly than a steak from the supermarket? Yes, almost always. But, for high-quality beef that comes right to you, they're usually worth the price. Keep an eye on delivery fees, though: some clubs include shipping in the cost, while others charge fees of up to $20 (or more!) per shipment on top of what the Steak of the Month membership costs.
Yes, most of the time! Many Steak of the Month Clubs would be very happy to deliver to the recipient of your choice, allowing you to enter a gift message during checkout. Gift certificates are usually an option too.
Not much, most of the time. A few Steak of the Month Clubs pull out all the stops and include recipes, pairings, and details about the steaks' origins, but the majority just deliver your beef.
Yes, almost always. Steak of the Month Clubs go to great lengths to package your products carefully, so that the meat arrives in perfect condition. But, things happen and sometimes your steaks might be thawed or spoiled before delivery. The best providers will give you a full refund or a new shipment, no hassle involved.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

On the other hand, the memberships meant to fill your freezer often let you specify several types of steak or other meats you prefer. Either type of Steak Club can be an impressive gift to give!

The foodie-focused ones tend to have more gifting features, like personalized messages or fancy wrapping, but almost every Steak of the Month Club lets you set how often you'd like the steak to be delivered and can accommodate you if you need to pause or skip a shipment.

Best of all, the most reliable Steak of the Month Club providers make your purchase risk-free with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. They understand that customers might feel a little nervous about buying steak online, with all of the potential for spoilage during transit. Your purchase will almost always be protected by a refund/replacement policy that will make it right if your meat doesn't come in perfect condition.

Which Steak of the Month Club is right for you? Here are some things to keep in mind as you decide:

  • Value. What will you get for what you pay? If you're paying top dollar for a steak, it should taste amazing. Watch out for delivery fees that can significantly raise the price per month, too.
  • Options. How many choices do you get for the length of the club, what's included, and when deliveries can be paused? How much say-so do you get over what's in your package? Are there add-ons like extra steaks, ground beef, or even other types of meat that you can include with your first delivery (or subsequent ones)?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about their experience with the Steak of the Month Club - or with the company as a whole? Does it tend to impress or disappoint?

TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the best Steak of the Month Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you choose the best subscription to keep your grill going year-round!

Compare Steak Clubs

Select any 2 Steak Clubs to compare them head to head

  • Chicago Steak Company
  • US Wellness Meats
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Larder Meat Co.
  • Porter Road
  • Mr. Steak
  • Greensbury
  • Snake River Farms
  • Omaha Steaks
  • Good Chop
Chicago Steak Company vs US Wellness Meats Chicago Steak Company vs Amazing Clubs Chicago Steak Company vs Larder Meat Co. Chicago Steak Company vs Porter Road Chicago Steak Company vs Mr. Steak Chicago Steak Company vs Greensbury Chicago Steak Company vs Snake River Farms Chicago Steak Company vs Omaha Steaks Chicago Steak Company vs Good Chop US Wellness Meats vs Amazing Clubs US Wellness Meats vs Larder Meat Co. US Wellness Meats vs Porter Road US Wellness Meats vs Mr. Steak US Wellness Meats vs Greensbury US Wellness Meats vs Snake River Farms US Wellness Meats vs Omaha Steaks US Wellness Meats vs Good Chop Amazing Clubs vs Larder Meat Co. Amazing Clubs vs Porter Road Amazing Clubs vs Mr. Steak Amazing Clubs vs Greensbury Amazing Clubs vs Snake River Farms Amazing Clubs vs Omaha Steaks Amazing Clubs vs Good Chop Larder Meat Co. vs Porter Road Larder Meat Co. vs Mr. Steak Larder Meat Co. vs Greensbury Larder Meat Co. vs Snake River Farms Larder Meat Co. vs Omaha Steaks Larder Meat Co. vs Good Chop Porter Road vs Mr. Steak Porter Road vs Greensbury Porter Road vs Snake River Farms Porter Road vs Omaha Steaks Porter Road vs Good Chop Mr. Steak vs Greensbury Mr. Steak vs Snake River Farms Mr. Steak vs Omaha Steaks Mr. Steak vs Good Chop Greensbury vs Snake River Farms Greensbury vs Omaha Steaks Greensbury vs Good Chop Snake River Farms vs Omaha Steaks Snake River Farms vs Good Chop Omaha Steaks vs Good Chop
Compare the Best Steak Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Steak Clubs
See the Best Steak Club
The Best Reviews of Steak Clubs