The Best Steak Companies

Monday, January 13th

2025 Steak Company Reviews

US Wellness Meats

• Steaks starting at $9.83
• 60 types of steak
• Quantity discounts
• 100% grass-fed
• No pesticides or herbicides used on farms
• No growth hormones or antibiotics given to cattle
• Free shipping on orders over 15 lbs.
• Fantastic customer reviews
• "A+” Better Business Bureau rating

US Wellness Meats has been in business for over 20 years. Their mission is to offer 100% grass-fed, nutritious, pasture-raised meats from sustainable farms. They promise that the family farms they supply from use no pesticides, no herbicides, no added growth hormones, no GMOs, and no antibiotics. US Wellness Meats also boasts superior animal treatment as they raise their cattle to be stress-free as they roam wide open pastures.

Nutritious for everyone

The variety of meats from US Wellness Meats screams "fresh”. Their farms sustainably raise cattle the way nature intended and in turn you receive nourishing food for you and your family. The list of products they offer is too long for us to list, but we can almost guarantee that whatever you're looking for can be found here. They sell all types of beef, bison, lamb, pork, seafood, poultry, and even organs and broths. If you're on a special diet, you can select from keto, ancestral diet, Whole30 Approved, paleo, AIP-friendly, and sugar-free to view all the selections that fit those requirements.

Superb snacks

We want to highlight some of the non-steak products that US Wellness Meats sells because if you're someone searching for healthy snacks to "graze” on throughout the week, you should consider adding some of what can be found here to your order. There are charcuterie boards that would make a fancy addition to a party or a classy staple in your home that include beef head cheese, chicken feta and spinach sausages, summer sausage, beef bologna, sharp cheddar cheese, salami, and more. There is a wide selection of chocolates and treats as well as meat sticks you could keep in your bag for on-the-go. You can tell these snacks are all high-quality and go the extra mile to remove unnecessary sugars and ingredients that aren't going to support your body. You could also try a seasoning, sauce, or honey here too. So many fun options!

Quantity discounts

There are 60 types of steaks sold by US Wellness Meats. We have to add that the product photography here is gorgeous and you'd think these steaks are just as pretty to look at as they are delicious to the taste. You can sort them by in-stock options and price. We found that all 35 steaks were in-stock, which is fantastic. The lowest priced steak is a 6 oz. beef top sirloin butt steak for $9.83. There are quantity discounts here, so if you were to order 4 or more of these, the price drops to $8.85 each. If you buy 8 or more, the cost is just $8.36 per steak. For $175.34 you'll get the most expensive steak, which is a 15 lb. whole primal beef inside round. Once your order from US Wellness Meats reaches 15 lbs., it ships for free, so this product would qualify for that alone.

Impressively thorough

The listings for each type of steak provide an estimated shipping date, details about where the particular steak is sourced from and why, reviews from customers, nutrition facts, and an explanation of how they'll ship it. No other company gives as much thorough information about their steaks as US Wellness Meats does.

Chat, call, or email

We have no concerns about not being satisfied with our orders from US Wellness Meats. However, if you do have questions or issues to discuss with the company you can chat with them live straight from their website, call them, or send an email. They're known for having a great customer service team, so we know they'll take good care of you.

Very happy customers

US Wellness Meats fares really well among the public. They have an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau and no one can compete with their customer reviews. People applaud US Wellness Meats for their healthy and delicious meats and are happy with their incredible customer service. There are a lot of people looking for true grass-fed meats and they find peace of mind here knowing that this company offers this and pledges to always provide fresh, high quality products. Across the board, US Wellness Meats nearly earns a perfect 5 out of 5 stars from thousands of customers.

What's not to love?

We found our go-to steak store when we discovered US Wellness Meats. What's not to love here? We are so impressed with the beautiful, delicious steaks and thrilled with their variety. We are anxious to try all their other types of meats and snacks as well. The transparency US Wellness Meats offers, the commitment to nourishing foods they stand by, and of course, their incredible customer reviews are just a few of the reasons they've earned our highest rating among steak companies.

Chicago Steak Company

• From $29.99
• USDA-Prime Angus
• Free welcome gift
• Free shipping on orders over $179
• Subscription options available
• Satisfaction guarantee
• Positive reviews from thousands of customers
• "A+” Better Business Bureau rating

Chicago has been well-known for their high-quality American meats ever since the founding of the union stockyards in 1865. The company holds onto the tradition of providing hand-cut, Midwest-raised, USDA Prime beef to their customers. Before carefully vacuum-sealing all of their meats to maximize flavor, Chicago Steak Company raises, trims, and ages their own steaks (usually for 4-6 weeks). If you want an assortment of other goodies to order alongside your steaks, you can choose from gourmet seafood, burgers, hams, roasts, poultry, desserts, and sides. This company has a well-rounded selection that you won't easily get bored with.

Ultimate experience

Chicago Steak Company promises the ultimate steak experience with award-winning meats, USDA Prime Angus (the top 1% of beef), up to 6 weeks of aging, and superior flavor. Through their "Steak University”, you can find articles about aging, types of beef cuts, recipes, cooking guides, and more. Once you know what type of meat you're looking for, you can easily browse Chicago Steak Company's website and choose between filet mignon, ribeye, tomahawk, strip steaks, top sirloin, flat iron, T-bone, and porterhouse.

Individual cuts and assortments

In total, there are 69 steak products to choose from at Chicago Steak Company. This includes individual cuts or an assortment/sampler, or recurrent subscription packages. You could sort your results by grade or price to easily narrow down your preferences. The least expensive steaks we found were on sale at the time for $29.95. This included two 8 oz. flat iron steaks. The priciest steaks came in the Ultimate Prime Collection for $609.99. This includes 4 filet mignons, 4 Angus boneless strips, 4 Angus top sirloins, and 4 Angus prime ribeyes. If you're spending over $179, you'll always get free shipping here.

Free gifts

Chicago Steak Company always provides discount codes you can use on your order for things like free shipping and free gifts. At the time of this review, they were offering 4 free bourbon peppercorn top sirloins with free shipping, all worth $160. Another offer we could select was a sampler cheesecake with our order or 8 half pound burgers with free shipping. With offers like this, it's hard to choose between them but you can't go wrong.

Grain-fed cattle

The steaks from Chicago Steak Company are grain-fed, rather than grass-fed. They have an article that goes over the differences between these at a surface level and they even acknowledge that grass-fed steaks are better for you. However, the company says, "We're a taste-first kind of people, which is why we stick with corn-fed, USDA rated steaks.” So there you have it. If you're buying from Chicago Steak Company, it's because you're looking for meat that is rich in taste and texture, not necessarily because you know what farms the steaks come from or you're wanting to maximize the health benefits from eating it.

"Finest in every way”

Chicago Steak Company stands behind their products and processes with a satisfaction guarantee ensuring that from marbling to packaging, the steaks are "the finest in every way”. If you have any problems with your order, you can contact Chicago Steak Company's customer service team and discuss a refund or replacement.

Great customer reviews

There are options for customers to leave reviews on each product listing, which we like. Some don't have any, others have a handful, and some popular cuts of steaks have up to 35 or so. These are helpful if you want an idea of the taste and texture before choosing a steak. We also found that the Better Business Bureau gives Chicago Steak Company an "A+” rating and third-party sites host thousands of customer reviews that are almost 5 out of 5 stars across the board. People agree that you'll get excellent quality with fast shipping, and top notch customer service.

A solid choice

Chicago Steak Company is a fantastic choice for steaks. They're highly-rated by customers, have fair prices, there is a good variety of cuts, and you can add on plenty of other types of meats and sides as well. If you're going for maximum health benefits, the one downside of Chicago Steak Company is that their cattle is grain-fed and they don't fully disclose details about the farms they work with or other processes their cattle go through. Still, Chicago Steak Company is a great company and they earn an excellent rating in our review.

Snake River Farms

• Steaks starting at $18
• 100% US raised
• Family owned and operated
• Receive your order in 1-3 business days
• 4 channels of communication with customer service
• Email sign up perks
• Free shipping on orders over $199
• "A+” Better Business Bureau rating

Snake River Farms considers themselves pioneers of sorts who have been breeding Wagyu cattle since 1980 for its deep flavor and marbling. Their parent company, Agri Beef, was founded by Robert Rebholtz Sr. with the purchase of Snake River Cattle Feeders in American Falls, Idaho. They sell categories of meats including American Wagyu, USDA Choice and Prime, Kurobuta Pork, dry-aged meats, surf and turf, and pre-smoked BBQ.

Choose your cut and size

There are 11 Wagyu steaks and 10 USDA-Prime or Choice steaks from Snake River Farms. When you select a particular cut that looks good to you, you can select the grade you want and choose the size. These variations will affect the price of your steak, but once you find what you want, you can add it to your cart and you'll receive it in 1-3 business days. The least expensive steak you will find is a 6 oz. SRF black-graded Wagyu top sirloin for $18. The most you'll spend on a single cut of meat is for the 2 lb. Prime Cowboy Steak that costs $76.

Free shipping on orders over $199

If you're up for getting some marketing emails, you can sign up for Snake River Farms' list and get a code for 10% off and free standard shipping on your first order over $99. Outside of this, free shipping usually doesn't kick in until you've spent over $199.

Learn your cuts

Under each listing for a particular cut of meat, you'll find cooking tips that we recommend referring back to. This will ensure that you thaw your steak correctly, cook it to the perfect temperature, get the most juice and flavor, and top it off with perfect presentation. They also include a beef diagram showing what part of the cow your steak is cut from. This is helpful for people who aren't steak experts and want a better idea of which type of cut they might enjoy most.

Arrives fresh and frozen

All meat from Snake River Farms is packaged in a reusable thermal bag with dry ice to keep everything frozen until it arrives at your door. All products can be stored in the freezer for up to 6 months or in the refrigerator for 7 days. If you have any concerns about your steaks after their arrival, the company gives you 30 days to contact them and sort it out. There are a few ways of reaching Snake River Farms: you can chat directly from their website, email, text, or call them.

Reviews right on the site

If you scroll to the bottom of the cut you're viewing on Snake River Farms' website, you'll see unfiltered customer reviews. There are often thousands of them, so this is the most reliable thing to go off of when choosing to shop here. By far, the majority of people give them 5 out of 5 stars with feedback about the high quality, delicious taste, beautiful marbling, and excellent price point. The Better Business Bureau gives Snake River Farms an "A+” rating as well, so all around this is an excellent place to purchase steaks.

Top-of-the-line

If you want top-of-the-line steaks and are willing to spend the money for them, Snake River Farms is a great company. Their website is insightful and has articles about what American Wagyu is, all of their policies, FAQ, recipes, tips and tricks, and more. We appreciate that they allow customers to leave honest feedback about their meats, so we trust that people genuinely are pleased with this company and enjoy what they buy. Snake River Farms has earned a top rating from us as a fantastic company for ordering steaks and other meats.

Good Chop

• Plans starting at $149/month
• USDA-certified organic beef and poultry
• Customizable boxes of beef, poultry, pork, and seafood
• No artificial ingredients, no added hormones, no antibiotics
• Pause or cancel subscription anytime
• $9.99 standard shipping
• 100% satisfaction guarantee
• Extremely positive customer reviews
• "A+” Better Business Bureau

Good Chop is a meat and seafood subscription service where all products come straight from farms and fisheries in America. You can choose from over 60 different chicken, pork, beef, and seafood cuts to add to your customizable order. The family farmers and independent ranchers behind Good Chop ensure all their animals are handled compassionately and humanely with plenty of space, shelter, food, and water free of antibiotics and hormones. If you think you've heard of this company before, it may be from their features by Food & Wine, BuzzFeed, the New York Post, and the Food Network.

Top quality meats

Good Chop has a simple, modern, straightforward website that makes it fun and easy to shop for quality meats. When you buy here, you can feel confident that you're supporting a company that shares a concern for animal welfare and sustainability. They don't use added hormones, growth promotants, antibiotics, or any artificial ingredients in their meats. All their beef and poultry is certified USDA-organic, their pork is PQA-certified, and their seafood is MSC-certified.

Make your own box

Rather than buying one single steak at a time, Good Chop lets you get the most bang for your buck by choosing what's included in a monthly box (delivered every 4 weeks). The company will preselect some recommended cuts of beef, pork, and seafood but you can easily swap them out for other products and completely customize your selections. Some of the steaks available include ranch steaks, tri tip, porterhouse steak, and boneless ribeye.

Three box sizes

Just because you select your favorite meats and cuts for your first order doesn't mean that future orders need to include the same things. Customers can customize their selections for recurring orders until 5 days before the next delivery at 11:59 pm PT. You can choose between medium, large, or extra large boxes in your subscription, depending on the quantity of meat you are needing. A medium box is $149 and ideal for individuals and small families since it includes up to 36 portions or 14 lbs.of your meat of choice. The large box is $269 and caters to mid-sized families with up to 72 portions or 28 lbs. of your choice. The extra large box is $359 and comes with up to 108 portions or 42 lbs. of your choice of meats, so it's best for big families. Standard shipping on all boxes is just $9.99 regardless of the size of box you choose.

100% satisfaction guarantee

Good Chop proudly boasts that they completely stand behind their products with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If for any reason you're unhappy with their products or services, you can reach out to customer service by phone or live chat straight from the website and they'll either credit your account or give you a full refund for your order.

Thrilled customers

Good Chop earns a satisfying "A+” from the Better Business Bureau. They also have thousands of fantastic reviews from customers who loyally buy their meats from Good Chop. Compliments about their superb service, delicious meats, prompt deliveries, and consistent quality are easy to find since people are so happy with the company. They have a big customer base and seem to be growing quickly, which is no surprise.

Great if you want variety

We are pretty over the moon about Good Chop and all that they have to offer. However, if you're a steak connoisseur and looking exclusively for a range of cuts to curate a top-of-the-line beef box, Good Chop won't have as many steak varieties as you'll find some other places. This option is best if you want to mix in other types of meats with your box and you plan on getting recurrent deliveries. Since the meat choices and subscription-based platform of Good Chop might not be everyone's cup of tea, Good Chop hasn't earned our highest rating, but it's still up there with some of our favorite steak companies.

Heartstone Farm

• Starting at $19
• 12 cuts of steak
• Grass-fed, antibiotic-free cattle
• Options for recurring subscription boxes
• Free shipping on orders over $129
• Save $25 with email signup
• Unfiltered product ratings

Heartstone Farm is a 10-year old company run by a husband and wife. Their mission is to raise and supply food "the way nature intended”. They raise their cattle on grass and don't use antibiotics. Heartstone Farm also focuses on ensuring their cattle are loved and never stressed, maintaining a calm environment for them. The Heartstone Farm includes 500 acres of woods, streams, and pastures in Maine, recognized for their ideal grass-growing environment because of the climate and soil.

Honest and positive reviews

There's a fun variety of meats at Heartstone Farm, including burgers, ground beef, roasts, stew meat, organ meat, chicken breasts and wings, poultry sausage, pork chops, bacon, sausage, and of course, steak. There are 12 cuts of steak available, all of which have sky high customer ratings. We like that you can read what people have to say about each type of steak because it's really insightful and helpful when choosing what to spend money on here. People report experiencing unbelievable taste and quality, perfect tenderness, good prices, and fast delivery. We recommend finding a type of steak you want to try, then reading what people have said and viewing the pictures they've posted.

From $19 to $219

The cuts of steak you can select from at Heartstone Farm includes ribeye steak, filet mignon, porterhouse, sirloin, flat iron, T-bone, sirloin tip, Prime rib roast, strip steaks, hanger steaks, and chuck steak. That's a fantastic variety and should serve you with everything you'd want. The costs range from $19 for a single pound sirloin tip steak to $219 for a 7-8 lb. prime rib roast that would serve 10-15 people. Some meats are out of stock and clearly listed this way, so sign up for notifications about when a particular cut comes back in stock if you're willing to wait on it.

Purchase single steaks or subscribe to a box

When you sign up for Heartstone Farm's email list, you'll save $25 on your next order. This could equate to a free (small) steak, so it wouldn't hurt to take advantage. If you want to purchase steaks individually, you can totally do that. Or, if you want to make the most out of a single order, Heartstone Farm lets you do subscriptions of either 10 cuts ($149) or 20 cuts ($267) that includes premium ground beef for free in each box for a year. Boxes are delivered every 4 weeks and could include just steak or a mix of other types of beef, pork, and poultry. If you spend over $129 here, your order will ship for free, otherwise the cost is $19.95.

Only ships to a few states

The major kicker with Heartstone Farm is that they only ship to a select few states. They don't actually list exactly which states they supply meat to on their website because they just say they deliver throughout the Northeast. This is extremely limiting and many prospective customers may not qualify to order here, which is disappointing.

7-day guarantee

Heartstone Farm ships their steak and all other meat in a cool, refrigerated condition to ensure the temperature stays below 40 degrees. If for any reason a customer is dissatisfied with delivery, they should contact the company within 7 days of the date they receive the order to have their items either replaced at no cost or refunded by Heartstone Farm.

High ratings

Heartstone Farm receives an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau. We've established that their reviews on their website are very positive, but so are the verified customer ratings from third-party sites. For the lucky ones who are able to get deliveries from this company, it seems they are rarely (if ever) let down by the service and quality.

Wish it was widely available

We like the variety of steak from Heartstone Farm and the strong customer reviews make us excited about the different cuts offered. We would give this company one of our highest ratings if they were available in more areas. If you live in the northeast, we highly recommend giving the steaks from Heartstone Farms a try. Otherwise, check out one of our other top-rated steak companies for a delicious order of steak delivered straight to your doorstep.

Omaha Steaks

• Family-owned and operated
• Grass-fed steaks
• Options for steak subscription boxes
• 100% satisfaction guarantee
• $30 off your first order over $159 with email signup
• Free shipping on orders over $169
• "A+” Better Business Bureau

Omaha Steaks is a steak company you may have heard of before, since they were founded back in 1917. J.J. and B.A. Simon, a father and son team started the company based out of (surprise!) Omaha, Nebraska. The fifth generation of the family still runs Omaha Steaks today and focuses on quality and consistency, as they boast that they've been grading steaks longer than the USDA and no one knows beef better than them. But does the quality really live up to their marketing?

More than just steaks

Based on their name, you might think Omaha Steaks only sells steaks. However, this is just a small part of what's on their menu. You can also get burgers, franks, chicken, pork, seafood, and other meats here. You might decide to pick and choose individual steak cuts or select a steak-only package that includes over 10 items each and range from $186.98 to $315.46. They can be a one-time purchase or delivered every 1, 2, or 3 months with a 10% discount. You can make boxes with a mix of meats and completely customize what comes inside. There is a lot of flexibility here with orders and selection, which is fantastic.

Recurrent deliveries

If you decide to go the subscription route, the monthly steak box is best for big families and costs $139.99/month. This adds up to $1,679.88 over the full course of deliveries, which isn't bad. If you'd rather have a delivery every other month, you'll pay $149.99/box or $899.94 over the whole course. The quarterly steak box is good for parties and big get-togethers and is also the most expensive box. You'll pay $169.99 for each delivery, which is a total of $679.96 after 4 boxes. A small perk is that for new customers, Omaha Steaks will give you $30 off your first order over $159 if you sign up for their email list. Regardless of how you decide to order your meats, shipping is free if you spend over $169, otherwise the shipping fee is $19.99.

Plenty of steak cut variations

When you're looking at steak options, you can sort by customer favorites like filet mignons, ribeyes, top sirloins, T-bones and porterhouses, and strip steaks. We wish you could view all the selections at once, but that's not how this website is designed. Pricing varies quite a bit and will depend on the cut and type of steak you're interested in. You can also search through the 12 different cuts they have available if you want to browse selections this way.

Custom steak cuts

They even have a "custom cuts” section of their website where you can work one-on-one with someone from the company to get a steak just how you like it. All the 40+ steak cuts here are hand-carved from grass-fed, grain-finished beef and then aged at least 28 days to maximize the tenderness. They're shipped in reusable, temperature-controlled coolers to ensure freshness. The company isn't very clear on whether the steaks come frozen or not, so it's hard to know the temperature the company intends their meats to be at upon arrival.

Confident in their steaks

Omaha Steaks is confident in their products and processes and knows you'll love their meats. If you don't, they'll either replace your order for free or give you a partial or full refund. To reach the company and discuss an issue, a phone number is provided on the website with their department hours listed.

Mixed reviews

The Better Business Bureau (BBB) gives Omaha Steaks an "A+” rating, which we are happy to see. The company has reviews on their website and their steak choices have more than some of their other products, which is helpful. Most reviews are short and to the point, but the majority are 5 out of 5 stars saying things about how great the flavor is, that the steaks are perfectly tender, the steaks are unbeatable. We hope these are honest and unfiltered reviews and we wish we could click on the one-star reviews to see the negative things people have to say, but we'd have to sort through hundreds of reviews to do this. Unfortunately, third-party reviews don't line up with the good BBB rating or positive reviews from the website, with people mentioning disappointing texture and flavor of the meats received from Omaha Steaks, poor service and communication, issues with delivery, and more. We read enough bad things to make us concerned about buying steaks here.

Try a test run

We aren't entirely sure where exactly Omaha Meats is sourcing their steaks from, but we like that there is a wide variety. Pricing seems competitive and there is a lot of flexibility with designing your own box for a one-time purchase or subscription. It might be worth doing a single order here to test out the promptness of delivery and the flavor of the steak, but we aren't entirely confident that this will ultimately be your best choice. After reading disgruntled customer reviews, we're worried that Omaha Steaks has oversold themselves and isn't providing as good of a service and as high quality of meats as we'd hoped. They've earned an average rating from us since there are other steak companies we're more excited about.

Rastellis

• Steak boxes starting at $179
• Curated and custom boxes
• Cancel anytime
• Boxes ship free

Rastelli's is a family name that came from brothers Ray and Toni Rastelli who opened and expanded butcher shops together. They wanted places where customers could count on meticulous standards and perfect cuts with no fat or gristle left behind. Over the years, the shop has grown to include seafood and chicken in their product portfolio and they have served their food to people all over the world. When shopping online at Rastelli's, you pick either a curated or custom protein box, tailor your 4-week delivery schedule, and then enjoy high-quality meats delivered straight to your doorstep.

Ready-to-ship curated boxes

If you want to go the curated box route and avoid decision fatigue altogether, there are 10 choices you can pick between. If you're a beef lover, you'll either want to go straight for the "Ray's Favorite Grass-fed Beef Box” or the "Ray's Favorite Beef Box” option depending on how you like your meats. The grass-fed box is $208 if you subscribe to recurrent shipments or $260 for a one-time delivery. It includes over 17 lbs. of meat and up to 42 servings of things like filet mignon, New York strip, ribeye, sirloin, and more. The non-grass-fed beef box is $268 for a subscription and $335 for a one-time delivery since it includes up to 49 servings instead. Some of the other boxes have mixes of seafood cuts and poultry or bacon mixed in if you want more variety. A fun option is the "Kid Approved Box” for $188 with subscription or $235 for a one-time purchase with a 10 lb. mix of chicken bites, beef round dog, butcher burgers, meatballs, and bacon.

Make your own box

If you want to choose everything in your box, you should go the custom route. It's either $179 for 15 lbs. of meat per box or $289 for 30 lbs. First, you'll get to choose a free protein of either grass-fed ribeye, Faroe Island salmon filets, pork chops, or ground beef. Then you'll select two items from the "favorites” category like organic grass-fed ribeyes, organic grass-fed filet mignon, or chicken breast, salmon, pulled pork, crab cakes, or another type of meat. Lastly, you can add up to four types of other beef like New York strip, ground beef, beef meatballs, Wagyu ground beef, and more. Other options include seafood selections, burgers, poultry, and pork. You can create a varied, delicious box here easily. The hardest part will be narrowing down your favorite cuts.

Flexible deliveries

Once you've signed up for your subscription, you can adjust the delivery schedule to fit your needs or cancel at any time. You can also switch up the contents of your box before it arrives so that you get to try new things throughout the year. If you have issues with a delivery or questions about where the meats come from or anything else, Rastelli's provides an email address and phone number where they can be reached.

Free, frozen, raw

All boxes ship free, frozen, and raw. With every order you'll receive a cooking guide for your meats that will guide you through thawing and cooking to get the most flavor and tenderness out of your steaks. They have recipes on the website if you want more ideas of how to use your meats. We also noticed that on our first purchase we received a free black tote bag.

Few customer reviews

Even though Rastelli's has gained the attention of big platforms like Good Morning America, Real Simple, CNN, and Rolling Stone, they don't have a Better Business profile or many customer reviews. We wish they had some listed on their website at least, but there isn't a lot by way of buyer feedback. We did find a couple poor reviews on third-party sites, but there were only a handful, which isn't enough for us to go off of.

Looking for more feedback

We like how straightforward Rastelli's website is. It makes it easy to see exactly what is offered, quickly create a box of our own, and get on with our day. We wish there were customer reviews on their website and more to see elsewhere, which is our biggest complaint. If you like what you see here, we recommend starting out with a one-time box instead of a subscription or canceling right away if you want to subscribe for the cheaper box and give it a try. Rastelli's seems to have a lot to offer and we are really intrigued by their steaks, so they've at least earned an okay rating from us.

Steaks & Game

• Cut-to-order steak choices starting at $264
• 166 options for steaks
• Exotic meats
• Customer rewards program
• Unfiltered customer reviews

Steaks and Game carries an assortment of gourmet meats sourced from premium cattle. What makes them unique is their selection of exotic game birds, reptiles, and wild game. These include alligator, ostrich, frog, rabbit, kangaroo, turtle, and Nilgai antelope. These are definitely not for everyone, but if you're searching for something unusual to shake up your nightly meals, Steaks and Game is one of the few places you can find that.

Extensive list of meats

The full list of meat categories include Wagyu beef, grass-fed beef, bison/buffalo, pork, venison, elk, lamb, poultry, exotic meats, grilling sausages, smoked and cured meats, and burgers, grinds, and hot dogs. This is definitely one of the most broad varieties of meats we've found through any other store. If you just search for "steak” in the search bar, there are 166 results. They vary by cut, quantity, and weight, so it helps to filter through these and narrow down what you want. You can even specify the marble score you prefer and even pick "Cut to Order” steaks to ensure you get exactly what you want.

Tons of cut, weight, and marbling choices

The cut to order steaks range from $264.36 for a 6 lb. 1-inch Wagyu tenderloin MS3 steak to a whopping $1,130.74 for a 13 lb. ¾ inch Wagyu ribeye MS7. Nothing is itty bitty at Steaks and Game. If you're shopping here, prepare for a big hunk of meat as well as needing to hand over a small fortune. Most individual products are over $100 since they come with 2 or more steaks and weigh a few pounds. You can find some lower-priced items like 1.5 lbs of Elk flank steaks for $31.18 or a Wagyu top sirloin center cut steak MS6 that includes two 8 oz pieces for $54.87. When you select a steak cut, you'll usually see a couple options of sizes you can pick from before adding it to your cart.

Earn points, save money

You can join Steaks and Game's "Grill Club” by providing your name and email address. This gives you access to exclusive specials, recipes, and a 10% off coupon with 50 reward points. For every 200 points you earn, you'll receive a $5 gift certificate. You'll earn one point for every dollar spent at Steaks and Game, but you can also earn points for writing product reviews, liking them on Facebook, following them on Pinterest, or sharing a product page (or picture of an order you placed) on Facebook.

Most expensive shipping prices

Like most companies, Steaks and Game packs your steak into an insulated styrofoam box with dry ice or reusable ice packs to ensure full product freshness during transit. Most orders placed by 2 pm ET will ship same-day unless it's a cut-to-order request. Those have a 1-3 day processing time. Steaks and Game doesn't offer free shipping, so be prepared to add a little chunk of change to your overall total. For orders under $200, you'll pay $49.95 for standard shipping. Orders between $200 and $299 incur a $44.95 shipping charge, and anything over $300 costs $39.95 to ship. We've yet to find another steak company charging this much for shipping.

Sales are final

Under most circumstances, Steaks and Game does not accept returns. Since meats are perishable, they can't re-sell them. This means that all sales are final, but you can contact the company through phone or email within 24 hours of receipt if there's any sort of issue with your steak when you receive it. They can arrange an exchange or re-shipment of the items if necessary.

No company background details

The "About Us” page of Steaks and Game's website is pretty uninformative. As far as how long this company has been in business, how it originated, how their cattle is raised, and what farms they work with, we don't have a clue. They don't have a rating from the Better Business Bureau and there isn't a lot of chit-chat about the company happening on third-party sites. The only information we can really gather is through their customer reviews and product Q&A straight from their own website. Some cuts of steak have no reviews and others only have a handful. It's not nearly as many as we'd like to see, but be sure to read reviews from previous buyers if you're interested in something on this site.

Good options, just missing some details

Steaks and Game has one of the biggest steak selections and most customizable inventory. It feels like this is the kind of place that big time hunters or homesteaders would buy from. You need to know the cut you'd choose and the weight you want in order to buy anything here. It's highly customizable to buy as much as you need, but the shipping is extremely expensive. You're already likely going to be spending hundreds of dollars on meat, so to add nearly $50 on top of this just to have your order arrive seems exorbitant. We also would like to see more transparency about the company's history and how their cattle is raised before making a purchase here. However, going off of what we've seen, Steaks and Game looks like a good choice for those who want to be picky about their steaks and maybe even expand their meat horizons.

Crowd Cow

• Starting at $19.99
• 27 varieties of steak
• Grass-fed steak
• Free standard shipping on orders over $149
• One-time purchases or recurrent deliveries
• Curated or custom boxes
• Positive customer reviews on products

Crowd Cow began in 2015 with a mission to bring delicious, sustainable food to customers from ethical farms worldwide. The company aims to help people enjoy great meals from home with food that's better for you, better for the earth, better for the animals, and better for hard working farmers. Crowd Cow says they taste-test every product they sell, from free-range organic chicken to pasture-raised beef.

27 steak varieties

The categories of meats you can buy from Crowd Cow include grass-fed beef, Japanese wagyu, pasture-raised chicken, sustainable seafood, heritage pork, American wagyu, and even bison, lamb, and duck. There are 27 varieties of steak available including filet mignon, New York strip steak, boneless ribeye, flank steak, Denver steak, and more. Prices range from $19.99 for a 16 oz flank steak to $34.99 for a filet mignon. Each product listed shows exactly what farm it comes from and its location. We like this transparency and it's not something we see from very many online steak companies.

Free steaks with subscription

For first-time customers, you can cash in and get free steaks for a year with your recurrent orders. You can choose between an A5 wagyu striploin, 2 mishima top sirloins, or 2 New York strips. You can create custom boxes at Crowd Cow or choose one of their curated options that include a mix of steak strips, tenderloin steaks, whole chickens, ground beef, ribeyes, salmon, chicken breasts, bacon, and other quality meats. The cost of custom boxes vary based on the meats and quantities you choose to add. All boxes can be a one-time purchase or become a recurrent delivery every 4, 6, or 8 weeks.

Subscribe and save

For every dollar spent at Crowd Cow, you can earn one point that adds up to save you money on future orders. However, if you're an email subscriber you get double points, so you can save more faster. 500 points could get you two sirloin steaks, $10 off an order total, two packages of ground lamb, or a filet mignon. If you earn up to 2,000 points, you'll be able to earn two Japanese Wagyu ribeye steaks, cold cracked wild Maine lobster, $50 off your next order, or another great product.

No explicitly-stated customer satisfaction promises

Most orders are shipped the day after they are placed and take 1-3 days to arrive. They are packed with dry ice, but Crowd Cow does say that unexpected transit delays could cause an order to arrive slightly thawed. As long as it is at 40 degrees or below, it is still safe to consume or re-freeze. Partial thawing may reduce the quality, but it's still safe to eat. Crowd Cow doesn't explicitly say they have a satisfaction guarantee, but they do recommend getting in contact with their customer service team by phone if you have any issues.

Some glaring issues

Crowd Cow has an "F” rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Yikes! Sometimes this is due to one or two complaints that have gone without responses, but in this case Crowd Cow had 31 complaints and failed to respond to 12 of them. What makes it even harder to turn a blind eye to this is the fact that their third-party reviews are just as bad. Most people are extremely disappointed with the quality of meat they receive here and some people even say they ended up throwing a lot of it away. For the price, customers complain that portions are small and packaging is terrible. Their customer service seems like it's mostly unreliable, which is extremely disappointing.

Unfiltered reviews

On the flipside, Crowd Cow allows unfiltered reviews on their products (hundreds of them). We found these to be incredibly insightful since the meats are sourced from different places and some people are delighted by a particular product and especially love all the meats that come from one farm or another. We aren't overlooking Crowd Cow's poor BBB rating and won't give them a pass on some of their issues, but they do have high ratings from people directly on their website and that's worth looking into if you're considering buying from this steak company.

Pros and cons

There are a lot of pros and cons with Crowd Cow. We like their selection, transparency with where their steaks come from, and how easy it is to mix and match products to create boxes for yourself. However, the steaks at Crowd Cow are not USDA-graded. Because of their small operations, the company says it doesn't make sense for them, but they stand by the quality of their products. USDA-graded meats like Prime, Choice, or Select usually fall into the top 1% of all meats and are known for their rare and supreme quality. This is something that many people look for when buying steak online, so it's important to note that you won't get it here. Some negative customer reviews and their poor Better Business Bureau rating are also concerning. Overall, Crowd Cow isn't a top pick for us, but it's a steak company we will keep an eye on in future years to see if they can improve their customer satisfaction all around.

Farm Foods

• Steaks starting at $7.95
• 13 grass-fed steak cut varieties
• Non-GMO, no antibiotics, hormone-free, sustainably raised
• Save 10% with email signup
• Free shipping on orders over $125

After finding themselves puzzled about where their meat came from and how it was raised, the founders of FarmFoods decided to set out on their own journey of transparency. Their aim is to do a better job for customers looking for safe, healthy meats for their families.

Newer company

FarmFoods isn't a very old company, having just originated in 2018. They aim to move away from the anonymous, mass-produced model of supplying food that we've become so accustomed to. The three key things FarmFoods revolves around are first, knowing how your beef was raised and the principles the farmer follows; second, having confidence that your meat is both high quality and affordable; and, third, having the flexibility to choose the meats that are right for your family and budget.

Low stock

At FarmFoods, you'll have your pick of grass-fed beef, pasture-raised chicken, heritage pork, turkey, and wild caught seafood. You can read about some of the farms these come from straight on the website. There are 13 options for steaks alone including grass-fed filet mignon tenderloin, boneless New York steak, boneless ribeye steak, London broil steak, flank steak, hanger steak, and more. We were shopping during the first week of the month and noticed that 9 of the 13 cuts were already sold out. This either means this is a well-liked company with a lot of subscribers and customers who quickly order as soon as certain cuts come available, or FarmFoods doesn't have a big enough quantity of steak to keep their stock up.

Buy single steaks or subscribe to recurrent deliveries

If you want to sign up for emails from FarmFoods, they'll send you a code for 10% off your next order. This could save you a good amount of money, so it's worth doing. Prices for steak range from $7.95 for a 5-7 oz grass-fed beef eye of round steak to $42.95 for 2-3 lbs. of grass-fed beef sirloin bavette/flap steak. If you wanted to subscribe to deliveries every 2, 4, 6, or 8 weeks, you'd save 10% on each product. There are value packs of salmon, beef, or pork starting at $76.95 and going up to $805.60 if you want to buy meats in larger quantities.

Steep shipping fees

When you spend over $125 from FarmFoods, your order will ship free. For orders between $99 and $125, shipping costs $30.99 and for any order under $99, you'll be paying $59.99 for shipping. At that point, you might as well just pay to add more meat to your order instead of forking out the money for that steep shipping.

7-day satisfaction guarantee

Since the foods sold by FarmFoods are perishable (they come frozen and vacuum-sealed), you can't return them for a refund. However, if you're unhappy with your delivery for any reason, you can contact the company within 7 days of the date you received your products and they'll either be replaced for free or provide a full or partial refund.

Lousy customer reviews

FarmFoods has been featured by Business Insider, Forbes, Food & Wine, and Kitchn. They don't have a Better Business Bureau profile, but we did find quite a few unfortunate customer reviews about the company. Customers and even some ex-employees warned that delivery timeframes are not dependable, customer service is nearly impossible to work with, food quality is not consistent, and more. People who are really satisfied with FarmFoods primarily tend to be people who shop at their in-person location. Those who have done online orders tend to run into major problems, so that's a red flag for us.

It's a risk

FarmFoods has a respectable mission and we like the idea behind transparency of farmers and suppliers about the life cycle of our food. Unfortunately, the selection of steaks here is underwhelming, since their already small inventory was mostly sold out. Their shipping fees are high for those who aren't looking to stock up on steak, and their customer reviews definitely scared us off. When there are so many high quality steak companies online, it's best to stick with those instead of risking your money with a supplier like FarmFoods.