Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
It would be nice if we all had access to a nearby butcher with locally-sourced, sustainably raised beef at prices we could afford, but that's just not the reality for most people. But don't let that stand in the way of getting a juicy ribeye or a surf-and-turf package for your next special occasion or "just because" !
Buying steaks online is convenient, safe and reliable, often allowing you to choose cuts you can track all the way back to the farms and ranches they came from and right to your doorstep. You might be surprised by how customer-friendly some steak companies can be, often offering perks like free shipping, promotional savings, and loyalty points that can be redeemed for discounts on future orders.
Monday, May 23rd
Chicago Steak Company specializes in "the very best steaks money can buy" : hand-cut, USDA Prime beef raised in the Midwest, wet- or dry-aged as you prefer. In March of 2015, these steaks went head-to-head with seven top competitors at Manhattan's American Cut steakhouse and came away with the People's Choice Award. If you're looking for a truly exceptional cut that's perfectly packaged and delivered right to your home, you don't need to look much further than Chicago Steak Company.
Average pricing with above-average bonuses
To make an equal comparison across steak companies, we looked at three items: filet mignon, prime rib, and a sampler. Chicago Steak Company had several sizes of filet mignons to choose from, and the basic four 8-oz. steak package we used to compare was priced at $179.95. That was a little more expensive than some, but at the time of our visit we saw a promo code that gave us free shipping and some tasty extras like 12 gourmet steak burgers and seasoning (a $99 value). Sadly, there was no prime rib that we could find (though it was mentioned on the Ribeye page).
Fortunately, we had more luck with a steak sampler: their "Finer Things Assortment" - the top package in their steak category - was sold out, but the Classic Prime Steak sampler was a respectable next-best option. For $349.95, customers get USDA Prime Wet Aged filet mignons (two 6-oz), boneless strips (two 12-oz), ribeyes (two 12-oz), top sirloins (six 6-oz), Angus steak burgers (16 4-oz), and a bottle of steak seasoning. Even better: that promo code applied to the sampler too. Hungry yet?
Lots of other meats and add-ons to consider
You've got a lot to choose from here if you're trying to put together a very special meal. In Chicago Steak Company's online store, you'll also find desserts like cheesecake and bread pudding, sides like chicken wings and green bean casserole, and other main courses such as baby back ribs, whole boneless hams, and pork chops.
Abundant options for giving gifts
Sending a gift? No problem. Chicago Steak Company doesn't merely offer gifts but rather "Perfect Gifts" - For Him, For Her, For the Holidays, For Corporate Gift-Giving, and naturally there's always the option of giving a gift card. We appreciate that this steak retailer gives every package the royal treatment - gift box and personalized message, anyway - at no extra charge.
Free shipping (sometimes)
You won't automatically get free shipping here; standard fees are based on your order total and start at $19.99. However, almost every time we've shopped with Chicago Steak Company, our order has qualified for a promo that included complimentary delivery so keep an eye out when you're ready to make a purchase.
Generous rewards program
When you create an account with Chicago Steak Company, you're enrolled in their rewards program. Earn points on every purchase that can be redeemed for discounts on future orders (basic) or for gift cards from some of your favorite big-name retailers (impressive!). You can earn bonus points for placing two orders in a month, leaving a review on a purchase or submitting one on a third-party site - but take note that you'll have to email or call Chicago Steak Company to get the credit for those bonus points.
Thousands of five-star shopper reviews
The Better Business Bureau gives Chicago Steak Company a disappointing "B-" rating - but since the reason was the company's lack of response to a single complaint filed there, we're not too concerned. On the other hand, there were 20 reviews there too and almost all of them gave this steak company a perfect five stars. But who needs 20 five-star reviews at the BBB when you've got over 3,000 of them elsewhere? Time and again, customers say that the steak here practically melts in your mouth. Chicago Steak Company's customer service team gets lots of praise for being responsive and helpful, and for packaging orders so that they arrive in perfect condition.
Best steak company on the market
For so many reasons, Chicago Steak Company earns our first-place ranking. Excellent prices on delicious cuts of meat, phenomenal attention to customer satisfaction, and thousands of five-star ratings from delighted shoppers are just a few. This steak company should be the first on your list to consider too.
You might get the idea that a place like Mr. Steak knows a thing or two about... well, steak, of course! You'd be right. Decades of love for grilling, cooking and selecting the best meats have all been lovingly poured into this family owned-and-operated steak company. Everything you'll find here is USDA Prime, hand-cut and selected, raised on family farms with strict standards for sustainability, ethics and humane processing (using a facility designed by Dr. Temple Grandin).
Go to "Grill School" for an education
If you need to take your steak game to the next level (or any level, if you're a novice chef or griller), you won't want to miss Mr. Steak's Grill School. Full of recipes like Grilled Bone-In NY Strip Steak with Chimichurri, tips and techniques with funny titles like "10 Commandments of Steak" , and videos to show you the differences among various cuts of meat, it'll give you plenty to chew on (pun intended).
Great prices and selection
So, let's say you're looking at those three cuts we used for comparison across the steak companies in our review: filet mignon, prime rib, and a sampler package. How did Mr. Steak do? You could get a 6-oz filet mignon for $38.95, or go big and get the 10-oz cut for $64.95. Prime rib came up empty (probably because it's technically a roast and not a steak, after all). On the other hand, Mr. Steak offers sampler boxes galore, often with a holiday-themed name but always with the same top-quality meats. Their most popular combo is the USDA Prime Grill Masters box: two 14-oz NY Strip steaks, two 6-oz filet mignons, one 12-oz boneless ribeye, one 20-oz bone-in ribeye, and a four-pack of half-pound craft steak burgers, priced at $289.95.
Keep your freezer full with a subscription
And, that's not the only way to save some cash on these first-rate steaks. You can choose to have your meats on a subscription basis, keeping your freezer full and your grill going year-round: just look for that option during checkout, because it will save you 10% on your order. Also, Mr. Steak gives you complimentary shipping when your order is over $175.
Lots of gift-giving possibilities
How about gifts? Gift cards are easy and can be purchased in increments of $50. You'll also see several fun boxes in Mr. Steak's Gift Center: for example, in December you might spot a "Santa's Sampler" or a "Merry Meats Holiday Box" . Or, if you're doing some corporate gifting, fill out the online form so that someone from Mr. Steak can reach out to you and help you create a personalized experience with a short lead time and fast turnaround.
Limited but enthusiastic customer feedback
We think Mr. Steak might be a well-kept secret: we were surprised to not find much feedback from their customers, and even their most popular item (that USDA Prime Grill Masters Box we mentioned) only had around three dozen ratings on the site. The good news? Everywhere we found customer comments, they were almost universally ecstatic about the quality of the steaks here. It was impressive to see praise from meat connoisseurs who said that this is the best of all the steak companies they've tried, or from repeat customers who won't buy their steaks anywhere else. It's also a good sign that, positive or negative, comments almost always get a response from Mr. Steak representatives.
Shop here for amazing steak
Great meat. Great prices. Great customer service. Do you get the impression that we think Mr. Steak is pretty great? It's one of our all-time favorite steak companies, and we encourage you to visit them before word gets out about how fantastic they are.
Founded in 2000, US Wellness Meats (also known as Grassland Beef) knows how important it is to take good care of livestock and of the land where the animals are raised. They believe that healthy meat makes for a healthier planet, and they allow their cattle to graze as nature intended: no growth hormones, antibiotics, pesticides or artificial irrigation systems necessary. You can also find an interesting range of other products here, from poultry and duck to pet food and even rabbit, elk and bison.
All grass-fed and finished beef, mostly domestic
85% of the beef sold here is domestic. The company's four founding cattle farms are alongside the Mississippi River in northeastern Missouri and western Illinois, and a handful of partner farms from throughout the US supply beef throughout the year. And the other 15%? That comes from a farm in Tasmania; if it's important to you that your steaks come from the US, check the product description carefully because all cuts from Tasmania will be clearly identified as such (no trickery involved). Regardless of source, all steaks sold by US Wellness Meats are 100% grass-fed and finished.
Very competitive prices
We were stunned to see how affordable the steaks are at US Wellness Meats. For example, you can buy a 9 oz. filet mignon for just $27.18 or get the Ultimate Grass-fed Steak Bundle (with over 10 cuts of steak weighing over 8 lbs.) for $201.21. That's much less than what you'll pay with almost any one of this steak company's competitors. (We didn't find any prime rib on offer, though.)
Not the easiest online retailer to shop
This steak company's online store isn't the most intuitive to shop. For example, when you get to the Steaks part of the site, there's no way to further sort by cut or size. Instead, you just have to browse until you find what you're looking for, keeping in mind that different weights of the same cut (tri-tip steak or ribeye) will be listed separately. That's not a huge downside, though, and it's worth a little extra effort to get such high-quality beef for the price.
Somewhat limited for gift-giving
As for gift-giving, your choices are a little light when using US Wellness Meats. Browse the Gifts section of the online store and you'll see e-gift cards (no option for a physical card) and extras like chocolate bars and seasonings. They also show several of their most popular bundles, like the Carnivore Collection and Keto Cravings, if you need some inspiration. Lastly, you can enter a gift message during checkout, but there's definitely no fancy packaging or any other way to dress up a delivery.
Minimum order requirements apply
We've started to see minimum order amounts popping up in the steak industry, and US Wellness Meats is one of a handful of retailers that has added such requirements: you'll need to order at least 7 pounds of meat and reach a minimum order amount of $75 to make a purchase. The good news is that you'll get free shipping, and the bad news is that you'll still be charged a $9.50 handling fee. (To us, that sounds like delivery will cost $9.50, just wrapped in different wording.)
Praiseworthy track record for customer service
Customers say that you can trust US Wellness Meats to deliver steak that tastes amazing. Almost everything they sell has ratings and reviews, so you can see for yourself what the consensus is on any steak or other product you're considering. Outside of the company's own site and feedback, we found over 3,000 five-star ratings praising this steak supplier: excellent customer service, fantastic value, and worth buying from again and again. While there's no obviously-posted satisfaction guarantee on US Wellness Meats' site, it's clear from their responses to shopper reviews that they're on the ball and want you to be completely happy with anything you buy here.
Terrific all-around choice for meat
While US Wellness Meats stops just shy of earning our highest rating, we still give this steak company our enthusiastic approval. We're always happy to see a company that gets thousands of recommendations from customers, particularly when prices are also reasonable. Be sure to check out everything US Wellness Meats has to offer if you're looking to order steak online.
Rastelli's began as "Meat Stop" , a small-town butcher shop with a reputation for hand-selected, premium meats. Expanding first into eight more brick-and-mortar locations and then into online sales, this business offers not just steaks but other cuts of beef, plus seafood, poultry, pork, lamb, veal and plant-based choices, and a selection of apps, sides, and rubs/butters.
Rastelli's sources its products from around the world, looking for farming (and fishing) families who take good care of their animals and the environment, and whose products are free of antibiotics, steroids and hormones. For more details about where their beef comes from, just visit the Sources page on their online store and click on the type of beef (pasture-raised, 100% grass-fed, Wagyu or private stock/prime). Most of it is US-raised, but you can also find cuts from Uruguay and other locales.
Attractive pricing, good availability
How did this steak company do with our apples-to-apples items? The grass-fed filet mignon was out of stock at the time of our most recent visit to Rastelli's, but it's normally priced at $16 for one 6-oz. steak; their regular filet mignon was available at $46 for two 5-oz. filets. There were several options for prime rib, including a 4.5-lb. roast for $159, a 5-lb. oven-ready roast seasoned with garlic and herbs for $185, and a 5-lb. private stock prime rib roast for $199. And, when we visited the Rastelli's site most recently, there was a pop-up offering a 15% discount on any order of $150+ if we entered our email address. All of those prices were very competitive, coming in quite a bit less than some of Rastelli's rivals. Unfortunately, there were no samplers in their online store; you'd have to create your own combo if you want to try several cuts of steak.
Subscribe to stay stocked up
One feature we really like here is the ability to turn pretty much any product into a subscription. If you run out of staples like ground beef as often as we do, you'll recognize the appeal of having your freezer restocked on a regular basis, no effort required. When you add steaks, chops, or anything else to your cart, you should see the option to make it into a subscription. Set your delivery schedule for anywhere from 1-6 weeks and you're done - and you'll get a 5% savings too.
How about a discount?
Rastelli's will regularly try to earn your business through promotions - and who can complain about that? During our most recent visit to their online store, we got a pop-up offer of 15% off an order of $150+, and there were also some seasonal promos that included free products with that same order minimum.
Loyalty program for return customers
You can also rack up points with Rastelli's free loyalty program. You're automatically included when you register for an account to make a purchase, and points add up with purchases, referrals, and so on. Subscription purchases earn extra points too.
Free shipping over $200
How about shipping? Orders here are sent out within five business days of being placed, or you can select a specific shipping week during the checkout process. If your order is over $200, delivery is complimentary; orders between $100-$199 ship for a $10 fee, while those under $100 have a fee of $25. In other words, it's worth your while to go big when you buy your steaks here.
Super-smooth gifting experience
Are you buying steaks as a gift? No problem. If it's just for one lucky recipient, shop the site as you would normally and then include a gift message during checkout. If you're buying for multiple people, we recommend that you click on the Gifting link on the site, then follow the next link under "Buying Up to 15 Gifts" : they say it's the "ideal way to send gifts... in one easy checkout" . Should your gift-giving needs include 15+ gifts, you're encouraged to fill out their Gifting Form so that a representative can reach out to you directly. (Or go the super-easy route and buy an e-gift card)
Some mixed reviews about delivery
Even though they've been in business for several decades, Rastelli's doesn't have a ton of feedback to consider, particularly with respect to their online steak delivery service. And, what we did find was pretty hot-or-cold - literally. Some people said that their steaks and other products arrived perfectly frozen, while others said they received thawed meats on more than one occasion.
Committed to customer satisfaction
Fortunately, Rastelli's has a solid refund policy: if you're unsatisfied for any reason, contact them within 21 days of your shipment. Depending on the circumstances, they'll refund all or a portion of your order.
A steak company you can trust
Thinking of buying your steaks (or other items) from Rastelli's? Not a bad choice. Overall they're a good option as a well-established business with a solid commitment to quality and to customer satisfaction. We'd like to see just a few more compliments about their steak delivery before boosting them higher in our rankings, but Rastelli's still earns a respectable rating.
Snake River Farms calls itself the "pioneers in American Wagyu" . All of the steaks they offer come from their own breed of cattle, first bred in the late 1980s and carefully raised ever since. From start to finish, this steak company keeps a careful watch over the process, from the fields where the cows graze to the processing facility and beyond.
Brace yourself, because the prices here are in line with the quality of the meat you're getting. Looking at our comparison cuts, you'll pay $61 for two 4-oz. filet mignons and $255 for the smallest, least expensive-grade prime rib roast (5 lbs., American Wagyu Black Grade). And the sampler? If you're looking for all-steak, we'd recommend the Steak Lovers with four 6-oz top sirloin, two 1.5" ribeyes, one cowboy steak, and four 6-oz filet mignons. Believe it or not, this assortment alone had nearly 48 five-star reviews - despite the $375 price tag. Shipping defaults to ground delivery for $9.99, unless you pay extra to upgrade to an expedited option.
Customer comments paint a questionable picture
That's good to know, because Snake River Farms has some mixed feedback. Out of more than 60 reviews we found in one place outside of the SRF website, the average was just 3 out of 5 stars. That's not what we would want to see when spending top dollar for best-quality steaks. Delivery issues formed the bulk of the complaints, along with having issues getting refunds and replacements in a way that was both timely and fair. Others described the meat as being sub-par for the price, especially disappointing when the steaks or other items were selected for a special occasion. Then again, elsewhere we found nearly 700 five-star reviews praising everything from the steaks to the service. We wish this weren't such an expensive experiment.
Quality guaranteed; check the timeframe
SRF says that they'll guarantee the quality of their frozen meats within 6 months of delivery; if you've ordered dry-aged items, they arrive fresh and you'll need to reach out to customer service within 15 days of delivery if there's a problem. Photos will always be required when asking this company to make good on their guarantee, just FYI.
Novel gift items that go beyond steak
How about gift-giving? We enjoyed browsing the Gift Center offered by Snake River Farms: from their best-selling bundles to gear like Yeti coolers and seasoning packs, we had plenty of inspiration for special-occasion shopping. You'll also find options for sending gift cards or corporate gifting.
Above average, with room for improvement
At the end of the day, this steak company gets a just-above-average rating: there's a lot to choose from and plenty of carnivores who say that they love the meat here, but that's not quite enough to make us entirely overlook the negative reviews out there - especially at these prices. We'll keep an eye on Snake River Farms and hope to see them move up in our rankings in the future.
Stock Yards is part of the 1-800-Flowers brand family, a collection of companies that specialize in gift-giving and often sell gourmet foods. They've got a decent selection to choose from, particularly if you'd like to order a little something extra with your steaks - like appetizers and sides, burgers and hot dogs, or pork and poultry.
Not as many steaks to choose from
The truth is, you may need some of those extras to round out your purchase here - there are only a little over a dozen items in their Steaks category, and that includes a peppercorn steak rub. Granted, in each item you may find multiple choices. For example, you'll see two options for filet mignon: the Complete Trim and Barrel-Cut. When you click on one of those, you'll see a range of possibilities, from four 5-oz. USDA choice cuts for $99.99 to eight 8-oz. USDA prime cuts for $369.99.
Prime rib and samplers
Same for the prime rib (under the Roasts category): three choices starting with a pre-seared boneless prime rib for $149.99 to a bone-in USDA prime cut for $399.99. Stock Yards has a few sampler-type packages, like the Ultimate Meat Collection: your choice of two or four servings each of USDA Prime center-cut NY strip steaks, Complete Trim filet mignon, and boneless ribeye steaks, priced at $179.99 for the two-portion package and $339.99 for the four-portion package.
Yes, you can finance a steak
Interestingly, this is one of the only steak companies where we noticed that financing is offered. Look for that option right below the part of the product description where you select which quantity of steaks you're ordering (above the "Add to Cart" button).
High marks for gift-giving services
Even though the selection at Stock Yards is somewhat limited in comparison with many of their competitors, there are still some nice gift-giving options. Surf and Turf is always popular, with two or four USDA Choice Complete Trim filet mignons (6 oz each) and the same number of lobster tails (8-9 oz each). Or how about the Kings and Queens collection, which pairs thick filet mignons with plate-filling NY strip steaks and adds a bottle of peppercorn spice rub? You can enter a gift message during checkout; we enjoyed the fact that you can get suggestions for what to say based on a holiday or special occasion you select, if you don't consider yourself an eloquent wordsmith.
Spendy delivery, but good customizability
There are a lot of important details you'll see in your cart and in the checkout process - not just the gift message (if applicable), but all of the possible delivery dates. For instance, when we selected Christmas as our gift-giving occasion, the delivery date was shown to be guaranteed by the 25th. We also had the option of selecting a different date, though some of them came with a shipment surcharge. Delivery fees can be hefty here: that Kings and Queens Collection cost $25.98 to send, and if you do the math that's 25% of the cost of the meat itself.
Get a Passport and save
Consider opting into the Celebrations Passport: for an annual fee of $19.99, you'll get unlimited free shipping and no minimum order requirements across the 1-800-Flowers brands. Even if you only use it for your Stock Yards order, it will probably pay for itself and then some. Unfortunately for us, we got a "technical issue" error when we tried to sign up during checkout.
Solid satisfaction guarantee
Most of the steaks sold by Stock Yards don't have ratings from customers, but the few we spotted were almost always a perfect five stars. This steak company (along with the rest of its sister brands) enjoys an "A+" rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, and they guarantee you'll get a no-hassle refund or replacement if your meats and other items don't delight you in every way.
Reliable option for steak
Stock Yards isn't a bad place to buy steak. Will you be blown away by all of the meaty possibilities? Not really, but you won't be disappointed by the quality or the service you get here either. And, if you enjoy buying from 1-800-Flowers and the other companies in the "family" , this could be an easy-peasy way to get a lot of gift-shopping done at once.
Who wouldn't be interested in buying steak from "America's Original Butcher" ? Omaha Steaks has been in business since 1917, delivering top-quality beef and many other giftable products like wine, desserts, and seafood.
Easy to shop and learn about steak
Shopping for steak here couldn't get any easier. On the main Steaks page, use the options on the left side to shop by cut, check out Omaha Steaks' Private Reserve category, or get your taste buds watering with specialty meats like veal or chicken fried steaks. There are plenty of visuals here in case you're not the most beef-educated customer, don't worry: you may even want to click on Chef Rose's Guide to Steaks video right in the center of the page for some additional guidance.
Exemplary variety of choices
How does Omaha Steaks compare price-wise? We took a look at three products (when available) across all of the steak companies in our evaluation: filet mignon, prime rib, and a sampler package. Here you can get a package of four 8-oz. Butcher's Cut filet mignons for $124.99, or upgrade to the Private Reserve and get six 7-oz. filet mignons for $199.99. Bonus: the upgraded package also gets you free shipping. A bone-in prime rib roast (6 lbs.) sells for $224.99, unless you choose the Private Reserve roast (4 lbs.) for $299.99.
And samplers? Omaha Steaks offers quite a few to choose from, most of which include not just steaks but also chicken breasts, hot dogs, and even apple tartlets for dessert. But, if you're looking for nothing but the very best beef, we'd recommend the Private Reserve Steak Flight: priced at $499.99 (with free shipping), this package includes six of their best filet mignons, four ribeye crown steaks, four boneless NY strips, four top sirloins, and a jar of Private Reserve steak rub.
Minimum order required
We spotted something during our most recent visit to Omaha Steaks that caught us off-guard: there was a little "minimum purchase may apply" disclaimer at the top of the site, due to "significant increases in demand" . While that might not still be in place when you're ready to place an order, be aware that you could be subject to a $79 minimum requirement. That's not to qualify for free shipping or anything else: you simply can't place an order of any kind from Omaha Steaks unless your total is at least $79.
Sign up for rewards
On a more positive note, Omaha Steaks offers a complimentary Steaklover Rewards program. You're not enrolled automatically, though, so be sure to sign up if you expect to order from this store more than once. It gives you rewards points on every purchase, exclusive offers via email, and even more benefits if you reach a spending level of $300 in a 12-month period.
Extra rewards with Gold membership
If you're really committed to buying your steaks and other gourmet foods from Omaha Steaks, you should consider their Steaklover Rewards Gold program. You'll get free standard shipping on all orders of $79.99+, double the rewards points on every purchase, and free products valued at least at $19.99. Oh, and that minimum purchase requirement? That's waived if you're a Gold member. Worth it for $39.99/year? You decide.
Plenty of gift choices
Are you considering sending something from Omaha Steaks as a gift? Look for the links at the top of the page; this retailer breaks it down by Gifts and Business Gifts, and within each category you can see different occasions, samplers, and other suggestions. Or, if you've already added some steaks to your shopping cart, you can always choose your preferences for gift wrap and/or a personalized greeting card at checkout. You'll pay $14.99 for both signature gift wrap and a personalized message. Gift cards are another easy option, but keep in mind what products cost here when choosing your card amount (to avoid the embarrassment of your recipient having to spend money out of pocket to use your gift).
Customer opinions: some good, some not
This company continues to have a rock-solid reputation if you look at their "A+" and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau. Despite those aforementioned supply-and-demand issues, there were only 30 or so complaints registered with the BBB in the year leading up to this review. But, when you look at customer comments in other places, it doesn't paint as pleasant of a picture. Many shoppers say they were disappointed in how small the steaks are, especially for what they paid. Some aren't happy with the quality either - we found more than one person who said they'd easily get better cuts at a local butcher (though we'd point out that their local meat shop likely doesn't send their beef across the country, either). Although we've never had an issue with Omaha Steaks' customer service, others have - and we, too, found the cuts to be small and the extras (like dessert and hot dogs) a bit underwhelming for the price.
Not bad, but check out competitors first
We give Omaha Steaks points for longevity and variety. Nonetheless, they're not the only brand in the online steak business now, and some of their rivals have done a solid job of giving them a run for their money. Omaha Steaks now ranks as a place that's "good enough" for your order, but that falls short of earning the highest ratings.
Have you ever wanted a really amazing steak but you worried that your lack of culinary skills would ruin it? Great Wisconsin Steak Company has the solution: all of their steaks are wet aged for 21 days, seasoned and vacuum-packed before being slow cooked (sous vide) to medium rare. All you have to do is sear and finish them to your liking. These are "idiot-proof" steaks if we've ever seen them.
Dedication to quality
We appreciate this steak company's dedication to quality. All of their animals are 100% grass fed, humanely raised on pastures in the US, never fed grain or animal byproducts. This is a relatively small, family-owned business; you'll see that reflected in this steak company's smaller-than-average selection of steaks. For example, we couldn't use the filet mignon or the prime rib as a comparison with other stores because Great Wisconsin Steak Co simply doesn't offer them.
Small selection, nice price
You can choose from a 3- or 6-pound pack of hanger steak or strip steak, a 6- or 12-pack of half-pound burgers, or a 6-pound variety family pack. That's it. Prices range from $49.99 for the smallest burger pack to $179.99 for either of the largest steak packs. Do the math and you'll see it works out to $17 to $30 per pound. Sounds like a lot compared with your local grocery store, but it's a bargain for what you get (and when looking at rival steak companies in the gourmet marketplace).
Delivery is cost-prohibitive
You may find that your delivery costs significantly raise that per-pound price, though. When we looked at the shipping fees to send a Hanger Steak Starter Pack (three pounds) to Florida, for example, expedited was the only option - for a jaw-dropping $50. $140 for three pounds of steak? Ouch. Great Wisconsin Steak Co. doesn't have published shipping costs; you won't know until you get to the checkout stage what yours will be.
Refund policy, please?
Know what else isn't published here? A satisfaction guarantee or refund policy. We're encouraged to see some positive feedback about this company on its social media channels, but we need more to reassure us that any issues are handled well. Most of Great Wisconsin Steak Co.'s rivals let you know upfront that they'll make it right if your steaks don't arrive in excellent condition or if they don't live up to expectations - and we'd like to see something similar here too.
Quality meat, but expensive to deliver
Don't get us wrong: the steaks produced by Great Wisconsin Steak Co. are delicious, and if you happen to live close enough to their location in Manitowish Waters you may want to visit one of the grocery stores where their meat is proudly featured. For everyone else, though, this company comes in a lot more expensive than many other online steak retailers - with a significantly smaller range of steaks and other beef products to choose from. We give Great Wisconsin Steak Co. a three-star rating: high points for the meat quality and approach to ranching, but lower-than-average because of the limited inventory and sky-high delivery fees.
Do you love meat but hate going to the supermarket all the time? Good Chop wants to take care of that for you. This steak company offers an every-four-weeks delivery program, filling your freezer with either 36 or 72 portions of mix-and-match ribeye steaks, filet mignon, even salmon and pulled pork. All of the steaks, pork, and other meats here are exclusively sourced in the US.
Choose the size for your family
How does it work? Your first decision is whether you want a Medium Box or a Large Box. The medium comes with up to 36 portions, and you select six items from the menu. This option is priced at $149 per delivery. If you've got a bigger family, the large includes up to 72 portions and you choose 12 items from the menu, all for $269. At the time of our visit to the Good Chop site, we spotted a promo offering an $80 discount throughout the first three deliveries, so keep an eye out for any specials on offer when you're setting up your account.
Free shipping, deliveries every 4 weeks
Shipping is always included at no cost; your steak and other meats arrive frozen and can be kept in the freezer for up to a year. Your box will come every four weeks, and you can pause your membership or skip a delivery anytime. Just remember that you won't get another steak shipment until the next month.
Not a good choice for gifting
Unfortunately, there are really no gift-giving options here. While you can include a comment during checkout to indicate that you're sending Good Chop boxes as a gift, that's about the extent of it. They don't even offer gift cards or certificates - leaving you in charge of your recipient's subscription, and making them have to tell you when they want to pause the membership. Awkward.
Not much feedback yet
Good Chop is still pretty new, and that makes feedback a little hard to come by. We couldn't find a listing for the company with the Better Business Bureau, and their social media channels were pretty quiet in the months leading up to this review. (We did call the customer service line to double-check that they're still in business.) Most of the positive buzz we found came from unboxing videos (where there may be a financial incentive involved). On the other hand, we read several negative comments on Good Chop's own social media posts from customers who said that their meat often arrived thawed and/or spoiled. This retailer offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee, but we'd rather see them consistently get it right the first time.
Wait and see
While we like the idea of getting our monthly supply of steak and other meats delivered automatically, no grocery trip required, Good Chop is still too new for us to give them a strong recommendation - especially with those subscriber complaints. We hope to see improvements and more satisfied customer reviews down the road, but for now we think you should use a different steak company instead.
Farm Foods seeks to help consumers be more aware of where their food comes from, specifically meat. Here you can choose beef, pork, chicken and other meats "of known origin at a reasonable price" .
Not the easiest online store for shopping
Shopping this site feels a little strange. When we went to compare our three reference products - filet mignon, prime rib, and a steak sampler pack - it wasn't as straightforward as we're used to. The grass-fed beef filet mignon tenderloin was listed as $13.99, ranging in weight from 7-10 oz. from multiple farms, and we weren't given any other details beyond that. Searching for prime rib gave us a lot of unrelated results, and the only correct match was listed as sold out.
Sampler packs available
Most of the sampler packs were also sold out, but one was reasonably priced and available: the Grass-Fed Beef Big Steak pack, which included 10 steaks (or up to 9 pounds of meat) for $119 and with free shipping. That package description included links to the three farms those steaks would be sourced from: the first time we got to see the "know where your meat comes from" in action.
Gift cards, that's it
You're not going to find much that excites you for gift-giving here. How about a gift card? That's literally it. Farm Foods doesn't even have an option during checkout to include a message.
Too many missing pieces
Farm Foods comes across more than a little sketchy when we start digging into customer feedback. The link on their own site to their Google reviews? "Not available." Their listing with the Better Business Bureau? "404 Not Found." (Using our sleuthing skills, we found that the BBB rating was an "F" about two months before this evaluation. Not a good look.) We found some positive reviews in other places, but even those had more than 25% of customers giving Farm Foods a rating of average, poor or bad.
Customer service on the decline
Many of the reviews said that this steak company was decent in the past but that meat quality and customer service have taken a nosedive recently - and that would seem to be the case with the Google ratings and the BBB listing both going "missing" . So many comments said that the meat received was well past the "best by" date, that it tasted spoiled after cooking it, or that the cuts were completely different from what was ordered (either in weight/size or the actual cut itself).
Company reachable via email only
It's also a big red flag to us when companies limit their contact options to online forms or email addresses; Farm Foods offers no phone number or other way to get help if something goes wrong (like it apparently does on a disturbingly regular basis).
Changes coming? Shop elsewhere until then
Our research revealed that Farm Foods was acquired by OpenStore in 2021, and that may have an impact on the way this steak company operates. We'll keep an eye on things and update our evaluation in the future, but until we see some big-time improvements, Farm Foods will remain one of our lowest-ranked steak retailers.
Crowd Cow got its start in 2015 with the goal of "creating a meaningful connection" between people and the food they eat. They want to help you find steaks, fish, poultry and more that's not only good for you but also good for the planet, so they partner with the most ethical farms, fisheries and producers worldwide. Every step from sourcing to shipping aims to reduce waste, offset carbon emissions and use planet-first packaging. This is a steak company you could get behind.
Starts out strong with good selection
Crowd Cow performs well when you consider the three things we used as a comparison across the steak companies in our review: filet mignon, prime rib, and a sampler box. With the filet mignon, they offer a choice between regular and Japanese A5 Wagyu; the former is priced at $17.67 for an 8-oz steak, and the latter is $131.25 for a 6-oz steak. Prime rib roasts come in at $187.94 for a three-bone roast or $240.44 for a four-bone cut, weighing in at six and eight pounds, respectively.
Plenty of samplers
And, there were plenty of samplers with both all-beef and mixed meats/fish; our favorite steak option is called "For the Love of Steak" (can I get an amen?) and it comes with one Japanese A5 Wagyu NY strip steaks, two regular NY strip steaks, and two boneless ribeyes for $204.20. (P.S. At the time of our visit, the product description included a code that gave us a $30 discount if we made it a gift order. Who says you can't gift yourself? We won't tell.)
Subscription or a la carte
While you're always welcome to place an a la carte order with Crowd Cow - being sure to meet their $75 minimum order threshold - you can save money (and time!) by choosing a membership box. You can choose from a curated box of best-selling products or create your own, set the delivery schedule, and get a 5% discount on each shipment. If your order is $99 or more, you'll get free shipping, and if you keep your subscription for 10 deliveries, you'll save $10 on each one. You can change, modify, pause or cancel your membership at any time.
Decent gifting options
There are also easy gift-giving choices here. Whether you send an e-gift card, a physical card with a personalized note, or you choose a gift box with just steaks, surf and turf, or any other combo, this site can save you some time and hassle.
Horrible reputation with customers
Looking at all that Crowd Cow offers and promises, we expected to be equally delighted by their customer feedback. Sadly, that didn't happen. The Better Business Bureau gives this steak company an "F" rating: there were almost two dozen complaints filed there in the year leading up to this evaluation, many of which received no response from Crowd Cow reps. We found similar results elsewhere, with a high percentage of customers giving them the lowest possible rating. Why? Reasons include a lack of response when problems arose (just like the BBB complaints mentioned), no-shows on important deliveries (like Thanksgiving turkeys, yikes!), and the fact that you can only get support via text or online form (and even that's iffy).
Just keep walking
Darn it, Crowd Cow. You really got our hopes up! Who wouldn't want to buy steak in a sustainable way? Unfortunately, all signs point to "no" when considering if this steak company delivers on its promises. We recommend that you look at the higher-ranked retailers in our review for a more hassle-free buying experience.
Steaks & Game probably has the most unique array of meats to choose from, among all of the steak companies we reviewed. Sure, you can get the average flank steak, a decent ribeye, or a tomahawk - but why not add bison burgers, elk chops, or ostrich steaks to your order?
Online shopping experience hasn't improved
The last time we evaluated Steaks & Game, we found a lot of issues with their online store and hoped to see big improvements. That hasn't happened yet. First and foremost, we had a hard time finding the steaks we wanted in stock. For example, the Grass Fed Beef Prime Rib page said that no products currently existed in that category; under Wagyu we found a listing but it was out of stock.
Filet mignon is listed under the Tenderloin category; even there, the cuts were all just "tenderloin" and not "filet mignon" (there's a difference), and almost all of them were out of stock. And samplers? Forget about it: you'd have to mix-and-match something for yourself, assuming you can actually find enough steaks you want that are ready to ship.
Lots of mistakes
Beyond inventory problems, we once again found random typos (like putting "PHONEPHONE" in the returns section for their contact information instead of the actual company phone number, or listing ground shipping fees for orders under $70 as $110.99 instead of - we assume - $10.99). In the hopes of finding more in-stock steaks, we clicked on the link for "Best Sellers" at the bottom of the site; it took us to a completely different company's online store, no warning. Like we said before, that kind of oversight gives the impression that this steak company isn't really at the top of their game - ever.
Is anyone buying steak here?
It's still hard to find customer feedback for Steaks & Game too. BBB listing? Nope. Independently-verified ratings from customers on third-party sites? No again. Reviews on individual cuts of meat? Few and far between. And when a retailer doesn't have a clear satisfaction guarantee or refund policy, shopper feedback can mean the difference between clicking "order now" or searching for a different steak company.
Lowest recommendation among steak companies
As much as we want to like this company (what adventurous eater wouldn't love to try some grilling sausages made of pheasant or wild boar?!), we're always disappointed with the experience of trying to buy...well, anything here. You'll literally have to shop elsewhere for your steaks because it's rare (pun intended) that Steaks & Game will have what you want in stock.
And let's not forget about steak as a gift! Yes, that's right: you can send a steak, a sampler, or an entire meal to someone special - or to an entire team of people at the holidays. We can almost guarantee that a delicious steak will be far more memorable than another pen or boring gift card. Wouldn't you rather get beef too? You can always strike a balance and give a steak company gift certificate: you get all of the thanks and they get to pick a cut they prefer.
You should be forewarned that what you'll pay for an online steak order is sometimes going to be more expensive than what you'd spend at your local supermarket. After all, you've got to factor in the costs to package and deliver the steak so that it arrives in perfect condition. However, it's well worth the extra cost to get a steak that delivers an unparalleled, mouth-watering dining experience, right?
Where to begin? No two steak companies are the same, and there are quite a few of them out there! But, there's no need to get overwhelmed. Here are some ways you can differentiate among the online options and find the steaks you want:
To help you get the most flavorful, high-quality steaks out there, TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the top steak companies on the market today. We're sure this information will guide you to the right place to buy your next favorite Porterhouse, T-bone or filet mignon!
When you think about steak, you may immediately think about popular options like sirloin, filet mignon and ribeye steaks. However, an average cow will provide roughly 880 pounds of meat. This is comprised of muscle and fat tissue from throughout the body. The actual amount varies considerably based on the species, the cow's weight and a variety of other factors. Generally, this meat is categorized in terms of primal cuts, which describe the area of the cow that the meat is derived from, and sub-primal cuts. Sub-primal cuts are specific types of steaks and other beef products that you may find at your local grocery store or in restaurants. What should you know about the different primal cuts before you prepare or order your next steak?
The sirloin cuts are found on the top of the cow toward the rear. They sit between the loin, round, and flank cuts. Sub-primal cuts of beef that are included in this group include strip steak, filet mignon, tri-tip steak, bavettes, and several types of roasts. These are flavorful cuts that have moderate marbling. That are generally leaner cuts than you may find from some of the other areas of the cow, so you should avoid overcooking them. Overcooking will result in tough, dry meat. Because of the location of the cow where the meat is sourced, sirloin cuts are generally tender when they are cooked properly.
When you're buying a present for someone, you have to consider a lot of social minutiae. Would that nice tie seem a bit extravagant for a co-worker? Could that motorcycle helmet somehow imply that you think that your father-in-law is a bad rider? What if your spouse doesn't find that stationery set thoughtful enough? Unlike other gifts, chocolate is not bound by so many social norms and implications. People love chocolate for so many reasons, so nobody is going to see your chocolate-related gift as a social faux pas.
Rib cuts are found near the upper back of the cow close to the shoulders. Because of their location, they have more marbling than many other primal cuts. Sub-primal cuts included in this group are ribeye steaks, ribeye roast, back ribs and more. Because of the marbling, steaks from rib cuts are juicier and more flavorful when they are cooked slowly over an open flame. The other sub-primal cuts can be grilled or roasted at a low temperature in the oven. The marbling makes rib cuts flavorful, so you may only need salt and pepper to dress these up before or during cooking.
Chuck cuts are derived from the area between the cow's neck and shoulders, and they are found next to the rib cuts. This is one of the larger areas of the cow, so you will find a wide range of sub-primal cuts from this section. These include blade chuck roast, ranch steak, flat iron steak, chuck eye steak, shoulder steak and more. Some of these cuts can be tough, so they should be cooked over high heat to preserve moisture. Select chuck cuts should also be cut against the grain for easier chewing. Because of the variety of sub-primal cuts that come from this area of the cow, you will find a wide range of preparation techniques and recipes for grilling, pan frying and even baking these cuts.
Situated below the chuck cuts at the front of the cow between the legs, you will find brisket cuts. There are two main sub-primal cuts that come from this area, and they are brisket point and brisket flat. The brisket flat cut usually is a leaner cut of meat. Both cuts, however, should be smoked over low heat or baked in the oven at a very low temperature. It generally takes several hours to properly cook these cuts of meat. Cooking faster and over high heat will cause them to be dry and excessively chewy. Many people choose to apply a dry rub to brisket cuts before cooking.
Shank cuts are pulled from the cow's front legs between the knee and the shoulder. They also come from the rear legs of the cow. This is often a tough section of meat because it is derived from connective tissue. A shank steak is the primary cut pulled from this area of the cow. It can be tough, so many people choose to cook it slowly using moist heat to lock in flavor and moisture. For example, this is a good cut of beef to simmer in your crockpot.
Plate cuts are from the underbelly of a cow between the shank and flank cuts. Sub-primal cuts that come from this area are short ribs, skirt steak and hanger steak. The plate cuts from the outer section of the cow are more tender. Both inner and outer cuts are loaded with flavor. The steaks are usually grilled over low heat, and the ribs are often slow-cooked in the oven using moist heat.
Flank cuts come from the cow's abdomen, and they are located between the plate cuts and the round cuts. Some of the cuts of meat from flank cuts are skirt steaks and flank steaks. These steaks are long and flat because they come from the cow's abdominal muscles. Because of the location of this meat on the cow, flank cuts are the leanest type of beef available. This can make them dry and relatively tough when they are not cooked properly. Grilling them slowly over low heat is one option. Another option is to cook them slowly on the stove using moist heat.
While chuck cuts provide the largest portion of meat from a cow, round cuts yield the second largest portion. The round cut is pulled from the entire rear length of the cow from the hip bones to the top of the shank area. It is located next to the flank, shank and sirloin sections of the cow. Several sub-primal cuts come from this section, including top round steak, bottom round steak, eye of round steak, rump roast and round roast. This is one of the leaner areas of the cow. The steaks are best prepared over high heat, and they can be grilled or fried. The roasts should be placed in the oven or slow cooker at a low temperature. Often, these meats are seasoned before they are cooked.
There are several other cuts of meat that you should be aware of. Generally, these are meats that do not specifically come from a primal cut area, but they are popular. Some of these are ground beef, stew meat, cubed steaks, beef strips and kebabs. These meats are pulled from other meaty areas of the cow near the primal cuts, and they can be prepared using a wide range of cooking methods.
You may have heard that cooking the perfect steak is an art. However, there is a science to cooking different primal and sub-primal cuts. This is because of the types of tissues that are in the cuts, how much marbling is in the cuts and more. Whether you are ordering steak at a restaurant or ordering beef online for home grilling, it is important to know what cut you are working with. The cut will help you to determine which cooking methods and pre-cooking preparations should be taken to create a meal that you will love!
Select any 2 Steak Companies to compare them head to head
Eat This%2c Not ...
The Best & Worst Cuts of Steak—Ranked by Nutritional Benefits!
A good steak dinner is synonymous with celebration and achievement. From the world's most popular restaurants to your backyard grill, there are few foods as quintessentially American as steak. While ...
Fri, 13 May 2022
NFL commentator Mike Florio's photo of a badly cooked steak does ...
There are plenty of steaks out there to enjoy, but everyone can agree that there is a steak out there that no one will like: A mis-steak. Such was Mike Florio's folly when he posted a photo of his ...
Wed, 18 May 2022