Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Whether you're shopping for your relatives, an important client, or a barbeque buff, finding the right gift can be a challenge. The internet has brought us access to a number of great choices for gift giving. One practical and welcomed idea in today's economy is steak.
In the past, shopping at the supermarket to find quality steaks and preparing them as a gift would have been an unfeasible option. Providing the appropriate packaging and successfully keeping the steak cold is a significant challenge. Today, however, a number of companies provide high quality steaks and meal options as a great gift idea.
Tuesday, January 19th
Located in the heart of the Midwest, known for some of the best steaks in the world, Omaha Steaks has provided grain-fed beef to thousands of happy customers since 1917. Flash frozen and individually vacuum-wrapped to maintain premium quality, Omaha Steaks consistently receives the highest comments and ratings from their customers.
Ideal for gift giving
Gift giving is easy with Omaha Steaks. They offer an ideal array of gift options including steaks, pork, seafood, poultry, desserts, and more. For the steak lover, you can choose from a variety of cuts including Filet Mignon, Strip steaks, Top Sirloins, Ribeyes, T-Bones, and Porterhouses, just to name a few. Once you choose your cut of steak, you can then select type and size you want.
Choose your steak and size
For example, if you want to order a set of Filet Mignon, you can choose from a Regular Filet, a Triple-trimmed Filet, a Bacon-wrapped Filet, or a Private Reserve Filet. Within each of these options you can choose the size of steak - 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 10oz, depending on the type of Filet you choose.
Options like these give you fantastic control over precisely what kind of steak you want to order, and are unmatched by the other steak companies we reviewed. All steaks are cut lean for the best results. Prices range based on the type of steak ordered, of course, but are generally very competitive with the competition.
Not just steak
Beyond steak, we were surprised at the variety of other fine meats offered by Omaha Steaks. Chicken, Duck, Turkey, Veal, Pork, and Lamb are all represented well. And to top it off, they even offer appetizers, sauces, glazes, and wine pairings for every entree.
When ordering as a gift, you can choose to have your selections delivered in an elegant burgundy gift box and paired with a distinctive personalized greeting card. This really does make a distinctive gift, sure to impress.
Omaha Steaks provide excellent customer service as well as an unconditional satisfaction guarantee. If you're not satisfied with your purchase for any reason at all, you can request either a replacement order or a full refund of your money. As far as customer guarantees go, this is as good as it gets, folks.
Omaha Steaks caters to the gift giver and provides an almost endless list of options to choose from. They seal the deal with top-quality meat, great gift giving ideas, excellent customer service and one of the best customer guarantees we've seen. For steak companies, Omaha Steaks leads the pack and has earned our highest rating.
Chicago Steak Company is a provider of gourmet steaks, seafood and desserts. They offer corn-fed USDA beef from cattle raised in the Midwest. The Chicago Steak Company allows their meat to wet age for a minimum of 28 days to maximize tenderness and enhance the flavors. The selection of steaks and gift options are significant.
Great gift combinations
Finding a gift from the Chicago Steak Company is easy. You simply click on "Gift Selections" category to review a number of options. You may choose from several nice combination boxes with hamburgers, steaks, chicken, and more all packaged in nice gift boxes. You may also select a box of steaks, a steak of the month club, gourmet meat, seafood and desserts. Gift certificates are available from this site and all purchases come with grilling tips and a suggested temperature chart for better results.
Wide variety of cuts and quality
In selecting a steak, you may choose from three different qualities of meat including premium choice, black angus, and USDA prime five star reserve. While the selection of cuts and quality are abundant there was some limitation with buying your size of choice. For example, black angus filet mignon are only offered in the 10 oz size versus other sites that offer 4 oz, 6 oz and 8 oz sizes. Steak prices range based on the quality of steak selected but were generally in the middle- to higher- range of the companies we reviewed.
Good refund policy
In the event that you aren't satisfied with your purchase from Chicago Steak Company they will replace the purchase or refund your money - whichever you prefer. We found several accounts of happy customers that loved the taste of the meat and the entire shopping experience with this company.
Wonderful shopping experience
Chicago Steak Company offers a wonderful shopping opportunity for those looking to purchase quality meat for friends and family on their holiday list. We appreciated the customer service at this company along with all of the gift options available. If you are looking to buy steaks you should definitely consider Chicago Steak Company for all your needs.
Snake River Farms is part of a company that has been in business since the 1960's. Their goal of producing the highest quality beef in the United States is backed up by a business model which involves them in all processes of the beef lifecycle: from feeding and nutrition to marketing and packaging. This holistic approach makes Snake River Farms a full ranch to table operation and differentiates them from larger steak delivery companies.
Wet aged beef
Snake River Farms steaks are wet aged, which is said to produce a juicier, more tender piece of meat. They do this with both USDA Prime and American Wagyu cuts of beef. Snake River Farm's American Wagyu, beef that grades higher than USDA Prime, uses the Japanese Beef Marbling Standard grading scale (1 to 12 with 12 being the best) and is designated at two levels. The Black level grades at 6 or higher and their Gold level grades at 9 or higher on the Japanese Beef Marbling Standard. For comparison, USDA Prime beef reaches 4 to 5 on the Japanese scale.
Good selection of gift options
The website for Snake River Farms is both user friendly and appealing. Shoppers looking for a gift option will uncover a decent selection at Snake River Farms. From popular and budget, friendly packages to premium options and business gifts, there is something for everyone. Also, custom gifting options are available to customers ordering 5 or more gifts. Along with easily accessible product categories, customers will find cooking guides and recipes that create an all-around positive shopping experience.
Very competitive prices
Snake River Farms is very competitive regarding price, and in many cases less expensive, when compared to other reviewed companies, both for their American Wagyu and USDA Prime beef. Their shipping charges are competitive as well, ranging from $9.99 for standard shipping up to $79.99 for overnight.
No matter the shipping preference, recipients can expect every cut of meat to arrive safely in an insulated cooler, packed with dry ice to maintain an appropriate shipping environment. All items are sent frozen and will arrive frozen, partially thawed, or chilled. Customer service representatives are available on weekdays to assist in fixing any issues with the quality, condition, or accuracy of products received.
Near the top
Whether you're shopping for friends or family their gift box options are a great present. From quality and price to selection and shopping experience, Snake River Farms is near the top. And another reason to choose Snake River Farms is the opportunity to enjoy high-grade Wagyu beef, which is available at a small handful of websites. Snake River Farms is a great option for all your steak delivery needs.
Crowd Cow wants to put the best beef in your hands - or better yet, on your plate. Where does the best beef come from? Local farms, of course. But if you've ever tried to buy steaks from a local farm, you're aware of the challenges: you often have to commit to buying 1/4 or more of an entire cow, so you're out of luck if you don't own a large freezer.
Shop individual cuts
Maybe you've done this in the past, dividing your "share" with friends or neighbors. At Crowd Cow, you can shop individual cuts of the very best steak, pork, chicken and seafood - bringing the highest-quality ground beef and other cuts to their doorsteps.
What's a typical price when buying steak or other cuts through Crowd Cow? Here's a sampling of what we found:
Free shipping options
Shipping on subscriptions is free at $99. If you just want to place a single order, you'll get free shipping over $150.
If you want to give someone a gift of delicious steak, Crowd Cow delivers. You can choose the specific cut of beef yourself, or you can have Crowd Cow send a Gift Card anywhere from $25 to $250.
Check it out
Crowd Cow may be an ideal option for beef lovers who want the best quality meat, and who like to know exactly where their steak, roast, or burgers came from - without having to commit to purchasing hundreds of pounds of meat at a time. We recommend checking the site out for yourself so that you can see what farms are currently sharing in your area (or that ship to your zip code).
Stock Yards allows you to order top-quality beef, aged for 21-30 days, for yourself or for your gift-giving needs. Partnering with Harry & David's, customers also have access to a wide range of products, from flowers to chocolate and much more. That also lets you take advantage of an exceptional guarantee across all of their partner companies: love what you receive, or get a replacement or refund, no questions asked.
Turf, surf, and more
So, what mouth-watering goodness can you find with a Stock Yards membership? You'll see a total of 30 items ranging from New York Strip Steak to Chateaubriand Tenderloin Roast and much more. If surf and turf is more your style, they've got that too. You'll also find options for extras: look for the button that says "Add Something Special" to add in wine, savory finishing butters, seasonings, and other items that can enhance your Steak or Seafood choice.
2 steak clubs
Stock Yards offers 2 monthly subscription steak clubs: the Stock Yards Club and the Steakhouse Club. Now, as you might expect, these clubs don't come cheap. Both offer the option to have monthly deliveries for 3, 6, or 12 months, and you can choose the month that your membership begins - either the current month or one of the following two months.
The steak clubs are comprised of the following:
Club prices do not include shipping fees of $9.99 per delivery.
Celebrations Passport program
While there is a Celebrations Passport program that allows shoppers to get free shipping and other perks for a year, all for a fee of $29.99, be aware that the shipping discount would only apply to your a la carte order, not to either of the Steak clubs. However, if you're planning on ordering several gifts over the course of 12 months - flowers for Mother's Day, chocolates for Valentine's Day, popcorn for Christmas, and so on - you should decide if the Passport membership might be worth the investment.
Overall, Stock Yards is a solid choice for Steak, and their two membership clubs give them an advantage over some of their competitors. Their clubs are worth your consideration.
Fresh, chilled, and right to your doorstep, US Wellness Meats, also known as Grassland Beef, has served Americans delicious steaks since 2000. Located in Northeastern Missouri, US Wellness Meats takes pride in offering healthy meat that includes no antibiotics, no growth hormones, no pesticides, and ensures that the surrounding land involves no advanced artificial irrigation systems.
US Wellness Meats provides a wide range of healthy and affordable premium steaks including Ribeye, Filet Mignon, T-Bone, and Flat Iron, just to name a few. Price ranges of the steaks are on the lower end of the scale in comparison to other companies reviewed. While free shipping is offered, there is a handling fee of $9.50 and a couple of requirements that must be met. All orders must be over $75 in total and must be at least 7 pounds in weight. Once shipped, the steak arrives within 24-48 hours. Customers can expect their meat to arrive safely in a non-recyclable and well-insulated Styrofoam cooler.
Excellent customer service
US Wellness Meats provides excellent customer service, available with just a phone call, email, or fax. Although their meat selections are affordable, with no membership required, their gift giving options are limited. Shoppers will find gift cards and gift messages (upon checkout) but, unfortunately no steak gift packages are available at this time.
For those unsatisfied customers, US Wellness Meats stands behinds their steaks. Currently any refunds must be approved by the customer service team and fall under certain conditions. Returned items will be refunded with a store credit or credit to the credit card on file. Please keep in mind, refunds are not accepted if the customer does not like the taste of the meat, since the meat is not re-sellable once shipped.
Good choice for steak
Overall US Wellness Meats is a good choice for affordable, premium cut steaks that are free of growth hormones, pesticides, and antibiotics. If one of their gift giving options suits your need, US Wellness Meats is worth your consideration.
Wilson & Wilson operates out of Omaha Nebraska and provides premium steaks. Gift giving is available but the prices are higher and the selection is less abundant. Wilson & Wilson sells only Certified Angus Beef and that's evident in the price.
Gift giving options
Gift giving options include gift certificates, a few combination boxes and the ability to mix and match to make your own. With each order a message is sent to the recipient letting them know a gift of fine beef has been personally selected by you and will arrive soon.
Higher prices, no return policy
Prices range on the higher side when compared with the competition. Unfortunately, Wilson & Wilson provides no return policy. If you are not satisfied with your order you are out of luck. The company appears to be committed to provided quality beef but if something happens in the shipping then you are out of luck.
Better choices elsewhere
As a result of the fewer choices in gifts and steaks, the higher prices, and the poor guarantee we recommend you select a higher ranked company for your steak needs.
S&G, a division of Gourmet Food World, bills itself as "the ultimate destination for steak and meat lovers." Its offerings include standard grass-fed beef cuts - NY Strip, Tenderloin, Porterhouse, and so forth - along with the trendy-and-pricey Wagyu beef. Not limited to beef, however, S&G also has a wide selection of other meats: bison/buffalo, pork, venison, elk, poultry, and even exotic meats such as alligator and antelope.
With respect to pricing, S&G definitely falls on the higher end; some of its most expensive meats cost more than $2,000. They do offer a Grill Club; membership includes a 10% discount on the first order, members-only offers, and an e-mail newsletter. Shipping is advertised as a flat-rate of $8.00 for orders over $50, but as many items need to be sent overnight, the cost to ship is likely to be an expensive $25.
Gift certificates available
Unfortunately, this merchant does not accept returns of perishable items, and any returns of non-perishable items must be authorized by phone and may be subject to a restocking fee of 20% or $5. They do however, offer gift certificates available in any amount, and can be delivered by regular mail or e-mail, for those in a hurry.
S&G's website seems to be incomplete; many items are missing photos, the links to buyers guides (for example, "The Difference between Wagyu and Kobe Beef") don't go anywhere, and the spelling mistakes give the impression of S&G not being as premium as their products and prices would indicate. At the time of our analysis, none of the products listed on the site have reviews, contributing to the impression that this is not yet a well-established business. We look forward to S&G cleaning up their website for future shoppers.
Steak companies range in the level of gift giving services available. Some offer steaks, combination meat options, desserts, recipe books, special seasonings and more - while others have much more limited options.
For those looking to send steak as a gift, finding the right steak company is important in your overall satisfaction. Significant factors to consider before buying include:
TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best steak companies available today. We hope this information helps you find the best steaks to meet your needs!
Select any 2 Steak Companies to compare them head to head
Mr. Steak review: Is this food delivery service worth the cost?
While you may have mastered homemade bread or even a few complicated dishes from the comfort of your own kitchen, a steakhouse-style dinner is hard to replicate. No matter how proficient a home chef ...
Thu, 14 Jan 2021
Des Moines Register ...
SNEAK PEEK: New Steak 'n Shake to open Monday in West Des Moines
The metro's long-awaited Steak 'n Shake will open Monday at 10 a.m. The burger restaurant will be located at 815 S. 51st St. in West Des Moines. To celebrate the opening, the store's first customer ...
Sat, 09 Jan 2021