Tuesday, January 21st
2025 Steak Company Reviews
Omaha Steaks
- Family-owned and operated
- Grass-fed steaks
- Options for steak subscription boxes
- 100% satisfaction guarantee
- $30 off your first order over $159 with email signup
- Free shipping on orders over $169
- "A+” Better Business Bureau
Omaha Steaks is a steak company you may have heard of before, since they were founded back in 1917. J.J. and B.A. Simon, a father and son team started the company based out of (surprise!) Omaha, Nebraska. The fifth generation of the family still runs Omaha Steaks today and focuses on quality and consistency, as they boast that they've been grading steaks longer than the USDA and no one knows beef better than them. But does the quality really live up to their marketing?
More than just steaks
Based on their name, you might think Omaha Steaks only sells steaks. However, this is just a small part of what's on their menu. You can also get burgers, franks, chicken, pork, seafood, and other meats here. You might decide to pick and choose individual steak cuts or select a steak-only package that includes over 10 items each and range from $186.98 to $315.46. They can be a one-time purchase or delivered every 1, 2, or 3 months with a 10% discount. You can make boxes with a mix of meats and completely customize what comes inside. There is a lot of flexibility here with orders and selection, which is fantastic.
Recurrent deliveries
If you decide to go the subscription route, the monthly steak box is best for big families and costs $139.99/month. This adds up to $1,679.88 over the full course of deliveries, which isn't bad. If you'd rather have a delivery every other month, you'll pay $149.99/box or $899.94 over the whole course. The quarterly steak box is good for parties and big get-togethers and is also the most expensive box. You'll pay $169.99 for each delivery, which is a total of $679.96 after 4 boxes. A small perk is that for new customers, Omaha Steaks will give you $30 off your first order over $159 if you sign up for their email list. Regardless of how you decide to order your meats, shipping is free if you spend over $169, otherwise the shipping fee is $19.99.
Plenty of steak cut variations
When you're looking at steak options, you can sort by customer favorites like filet mignons, ribeyes, top sirloins, T-bones and porterhouses, and strip steaks. We wish you could view all the selections at once, but that's not how this website is designed. Pricing varies quite a bit and will depend on the cut and type of steak you're interested in. You can also search through the 12 different cuts they have available if you want to browse selections this way.
Custom steak cuts
They even have a "custom cuts” section of their website where you can work one-on-one with someone from the company to get a steak just how you like it. All the 40+ steak cuts here are hand-carved from grass-fed, grain-finished beef and then aged at least 28 days to maximize the tenderness. They're shipped in reusable, temperature-controlled coolers to ensure freshness. The company isn't very clear on whether the steaks come frozen or not, so it's hard to know the temperature the company intends their meats to be at upon arrival.
Confident in their steaks
Omaha Steaks is confident in their products and processes and knows you'll love their meats. If you don't, they'll either replace your order for free or give you a partial or full refund. To reach the company and discuss an issue, a phone number is provided on the website with their department hours listed.
Mixed reviews
The Better Business Bureau (BBB) gives Omaha Steaks an "A+” rating, which we are happy to see. The company has reviews on their website and their steak choices have more than some of their other products, which is helpful. Most reviews are short and to the point, but the majority are 5 out of 5 stars saying things about how great the flavor is, that the steaks are perfectly tender, the steaks are unbeatable. We hope these are honest and unfiltered reviews and we wish we could click on the one-star reviews to see the negative things people have to say, but we'd have to sort through hundreds of reviews to do this. Unfortunately, third-party reviews don't line up with the good BBB rating or positive reviews from the website, with people mentioning disappointing texture and flavor of the meats received from Omaha Steaks, poor service and communication, issues with delivery, and more. We read enough bad things to make us concerned about buying steaks here.
Try a test run
We aren't entirely sure where exactly Omaha Meats is sourcing their steaks from, but we like that there is a wide variety. Pricing seems competitive and there is a lot of flexibility with designing your own box for a one-time purchase or subscription. It might be worth doing a single order here to test out the promptness of delivery and the flavor of the steak, but we aren't entirely confident that this will ultimately be your best choice. After reading disgruntled customer reviews, we're worried that Omaha Steaks has oversold themselves and isn't providing as good of a service and as high quality of meats as we'd hoped. They've earned an average rating from us since there are other steak companies we're more excited about.
More Steak Company Reviews
The 10 Best Steak Companies
Which Steak Company is the Best?
Whether you're in a warm climate and anxious to start grilling up your favorite meats for your friends and family or want to make a classy, cozy, indoor home-cooked meal with some high-quality steaks, you'll need the right place to get them from. We don't all live close to a farm with a local butcher on call to supply us with all the cuts of beef we want, but that doesn't mean we can't keep our fridge and freezer stocked with juicy, sustainably-sourced, grass-fed ribeye or filet mignon.
Knowing where your food comes from is important, and it's easiest when you have highly-rated companies you can learn and buy from. Buying steaks online can actually be a much smarter way to shop since you can vet the company and get more information on the meat you're buying, rather than if you just grabbed something off a shelf at your local store.
Steak Company FAQ
Continued from above...
Online, you can learn how a company started, where their meat comes from, what their cattle is fed, whether or not they follow organic practices, what types of experiences customers have had with the company, and so much more. When you're browsing through all the delectable options that a steak company offers, you may be surprised to find some other great perks as well.
Many companies offer free shipping, free gifts, loyalty points, and sitewide sales. Buying meat online is probably less expensive than you'd imagine. There are also options to add on other items like chicken, pork, turkey, seasonings, dressings, desserts, and anything else you fancy. You can get days or even months worth of meals delivered straight to your doorstep.
And last but not least, while you're stocking up on steaks for yourself, think about those people in your life who are hard to find gifts for. Steaks make an enjoyable, thoughtful gift that can easily be sent to anyone you want. Steak companies carefully package and prepare the meats they send in a way that ensures their freshness upon arrival no matter how far they have to travel. Wouldn't you be excited to find top-tier beef on your porch?
There are quite a few variables that come into play when choosing where to buy steaks online. No two companies are the same, so we have come up with a short list of things to keep in mind when you're deciding who to buy from:
- Quantity. If you're living on your own or have a small family, it's ideal to find a steak company that lets you purchase smaller quantities of meat at a time. This way you have what you want and don't overspend for extra food you don't need right away. On the other hand, if you have a big family, you'll want big portions and possibly enough to keep your freezer stocked for a rainy day. Find a company that lets you have some flexibility as far as how much meat you can buy at a time.
- Availability. Does the steak company clearly list what meats are in stock? Are there plenty of other meats and sides you could add on if you want to get the most value out of a single order? Some companies let you subscribe to recurring deliveries of their steaks, so be sure to consider this if you want to make sure you never run out.
- Customer satisfaction. What have other customers said about the steak company? Would they recommend it to other potential buyers? What does the Better Business Bureau rate the company?
Some of the highest-quality steaks are out there and ready for you to enjoy. Top Consumer Reviews has thoroughly researched the most important details about popular steak companies you can buy from online. We hope this information helps you find a company that will allow you and your family to indulge in tender, juicy steaks whenever you have a craving for them.
Compare Steak Companies
Select any 2 Steak Companies to compare them head to head
Trending Steak News
Related Steak Company Reviews
Since you're interested in Steak Companies, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
