Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Rastellis Review

Monday, February 10th

2025 Steak Company Reviews

Rastellis Review 3 Star Rating

Rastellis

3 Star Rating
  • Steak boxes starting at $179
  • Curated and custom boxes
  • Cancel anytime
  • Boxes ship free

Rastelli's is a family name that came from brothers Ray and Toni Rastelli who opened and expanded butcher shops together. They wanted places where customers could count on meticulous standards and perfect cuts with no fat or gristle left behind. Over the years, the shop has grown to include seafood and chicken in their product portfolio and they have served their food to people all over the world. When shopping online at Rastelli's, you pick either a curated or custom protein box, tailor your 4-week delivery schedule, and then enjoy high-quality meats delivered straight to your doorstep.

Ready-to-ship curated boxes

If you want to go the curated box route and avoid decision fatigue altogether, there are 10 choices you can pick between. If you're a beef lover, you'll either want to go straight for the "Ray's Favorite Grass-fed Beef Box” or the "Ray's Favorite Beef Box” option depending on how you like your meats. The grass-fed box is $208 if you subscribe to recurrent shipments or $260 for a one-time delivery. It includes over 17 lbs. of meat and up to 42 servings of things like filet mignon, New York strip, ribeye, sirloin, and more. The non-grass-fed beef box is $268 for a subscription and $335 for a one-time delivery since it includes up to 49 servings instead. Some of the other boxes have mixes of seafood cuts and poultry or bacon mixed in if you want more variety. A fun option is the "Kid Approved Box” for $188 with subscription or $235 for a one-time purchase with a 10 lb. mix of chicken bites, beef round dog, butcher burgers, meatballs, and bacon.

Make your own box

If you want to choose everything in your box, you should go the custom route. It's either $179 for 15 lbs. of meat per box or $289 for 30 lbs. First, you'll get to choose a free protein of either grass-fed ribeye, Faroe Island salmon filets, pork chops, or ground beef. Then you'll select two items from the "favorites” category like organic grass-fed ribeyes, organic grass-fed filet mignon, or chicken breast, salmon, pulled pork, crab cakes, or another type of meat. Lastly, you can add up to four types of other beef like New York strip, ground beef, beef meatballs, Wagyu ground beef, and more. Other options include seafood selections, burgers, poultry, and pork. You can create a varied, delicious box here easily. The hardest part will be narrowing down your favorite cuts.

Flexible deliveries

Once you've signed up for your subscription, you can adjust the delivery schedule to fit your needs or cancel at any time. You can also switch up the contents of your box before it arrives so that you get to try new things throughout the year. If you have issues with a delivery or questions about where the meats come from or anything else, Rastelli's provides an email address and phone number where they can be reached.

Best Steak Companies

Free, frozen, raw

All boxes ship free, frozen, and raw. With every order you'll receive a cooking guide for your meats that will guide you through thawing and cooking to get the most flavor and tenderness out of your steaks. They have recipes on the website if you want more ideas of how to use your meats. We also noticed that on our first purchase we received a free black tote bag.

Few customer reviews

Even though Rastelli's has gained the attention of big platforms like Good Morning America, Real Simple, CNN, and Rolling Stone, they don't have a Better Business profile or many customer reviews. We wish they had some listed on their website at least, but there isn't a lot by way of buyer feedback. We did find a couple poor reviews on third-party sites, but there were only a handful, which isn't enough for us to go off of.

Looking for more feedback

We like how straightforward Rastelli's website is. It makes it easy to see exactly what is offered, quickly create a box of our own, and get on with our day. We wish there were customer reviews on their website and more to see elsewhere, which is our biggest complaint. If you like what you see here, we recommend starting out with a one-time box instead of a subscription or canceling right away if you want to subscribe for the cheaper box and give it a try. Rastelli's seems to have a lot to offer and we are really intrigued by their steaks, so they've at least earned an okay rating from us.

Which Steak Company is the Best?

Whether you're in a warm climate and anxious to start grilling up your favorite meats for your friends and family or want to make a classy, cozy, indoor home-cooked meal with some high-quality steaks, you'll need the right place to get them from. We don't all live close to a farm with a local butcher on call to supply us with all the cuts of beef we want, but that doesn't mean we can't keep our fridge and freezer stocked with juicy, sustainably-sourced, grass-fed ribeye or filet mignon.

Knowing where your food comes from is important, and it's easiest when you have highly-rated companies you can learn and buy from. Buying steaks online can actually be a much smarter way to shop since you can vet the company and get more information on the meat you're buying, rather than if you just grabbed something off a shelf at your local store.

The Best Steak Companies Compare Steak Companies Compare Steak Company Reviews What are the best Steak Companies Best Steak Company Reviews

Steak Company FAQ

Definitely not! Why rely on your local supermarket's less-than impressive cuts when you can get the best sirloin, Porterhouse, filet mignon or T-bone - delivered right to your doorstep!
If you can name it, you can get it online. Angus? Aye. Wagyu and Kobe? Hai. And, companies that specialize in delivering steak know how to package it perfectly so it arrives fresh.
As with most things in life, you get what you pay for. When buying steak online, you'll tend to find the more premium cuts and grades of meat, but there are plenty of deals that make it affordable to get an unforgettable meal.
Most retailers offering food delivery understand that sometimes things go wrong in transit. If your steak arrives in less-than-perfect condition, you'll probably get a new shipment at no extra charge. Or, the store may give you a full refund or a store credit. Policies vary, so be sure you look for the company's satisfaction policy if you're concerned.
That depends. Steak can be ordered a la carte, and shipping costs usually depend on the size of your order. Some companies offer subscription clubs that deliver your meat on a regular, scheduled basis; with those plans, shipping is often included at no extra charge.
Yes! Can you think of a better way of making sure that you have a delicious steak dinner every single month? You can typically choose plans ranging from 3 to 12 months.
Depending on which store you select, you may only have cuts of beef to choose from. However, retailers that offer gift-giving options tend to have a wide range of possibilities, from seafood to desserts.
Why not? Maybe you'd love to treat your parents to a nice dinner, but they live a thousand miles away. Or you've got a hard-to-please boss and you really want to impress her at the holidays. Sending steak, a surf-and-turf combo, or a complete meal package will be a gift they'll remember.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Online, you can learn how a company started, where their meat comes from, what their cattle is fed, whether or not they follow organic practices, what types of experiences customers have had with the company, and so much more. When you're browsing through all the delectable options that a steak company offers, you may be surprised to find some other great perks as well.

Many companies offer free shipping, free gifts, loyalty points, and sitewide sales. Buying meat online is probably less expensive than you'd imagine. There are also options to add on other items like chicken, pork, turkey, seasonings, dressings, desserts, and anything else you fancy. You can get days or even months worth of meals delivered straight to your doorstep.

And last but not least, while you're stocking up on steaks for yourself, think about those people in your life who are hard to find gifts for. Steaks make an enjoyable, thoughtful gift that can easily be sent to anyone you want. Steak companies carefully package and prepare the meats they send in a way that ensures their freshness upon arrival no matter how far they have to travel. Wouldn't you be excited to find top-tier beef on your porch?

There are quite a few variables that come into play when choosing where to buy steaks online. No two companies are the same, so we have come up with a short list of things to keep in mind when you're deciding who to buy from:

  • Quantity. If you're living on your own or have a small family, it's ideal to find a steak company that lets you purchase smaller quantities of meat at a time. This way you have what you want and don't overspend for extra food you don't need right away. On the other hand, if you have a big family, you'll want big portions and possibly enough to keep your freezer stocked for a rainy day. Find a company that lets you have some flexibility as far as how much meat you can buy at a time.
  • Availability. Does the steak company clearly list what meats are in stock? Are there plenty of other meats and sides you could add on if you want to get the most value out of a single order? Some companies let you subscribe to recurring deliveries of their steaks, so be sure to consider this if you want to make sure you never run out.
  • Customer satisfaction. What have other customers said about the steak company? Would they recommend it to other potential buyers? What does the Better Business Bureau rate the company?

Some of the highest-quality steaks are out there and ready for you to enjoy. Top Consumer Reviews has thoroughly researched the most important details about popular steak companies you can buy from online. We hope this information helps you find a company that will allow you and your family to indulge in tender, juicy steaks whenever you have a craving for them.

Compare Steak Companies

Select any 2 Steak Companies to compare them head to head

best-steak-companies
  • US Wellness Meats
  • Chicago Steak Company
  • Snake River Farms
  • Good Chop
  • Heartstone Farm
  • Omaha Steaks
  • Rastellis
  • Steaks & Game
  • Crowd Cow
  • Farm Foods
US Wellness Meats vs Chicago Steak Company US Wellness Meats vs Snake River Farms US Wellness Meats vs Good Chop US Wellness Meats vs Heartstone Farm US Wellness Meats vs Omaha Steaks US Wellness Meats vs Rastellis US Wellness Meats vs Steaks & Game US Wellness Meats vs Crowd Cow US Wellness Meats vs Farm Foods Chicago Steak Company vs Snake River Farms Chicago Steak Company vs Good Chop Chicago Steak Company vs Heartstone Farm Chicago Steak Company vs Omaha Steaks Chicago Steak Company vs Rastellis Chicago Steak Company vs Steaks & Game Chicago Steak Company vs Crowd Cow Chicago Steak Company vs Farm Foods Snake River Farms vs Good Chop Snake River Farms vs Heartstone Farm Snake River Farms vs Omaha Steaks Snake River Farms vs Rastellis Snake River Farms vs Steaks & Game Snake River Farms vs Crowd Cow Snake River Farms vs Farm Foods Good Chop vs Heartstone Farm Good Chop vs Omaha Steaks Good Chop vs Rastellis Good Chop vs Steaks & Game Good Chop vs Crowd Cow Good Chop vs Farm Foods Heartstone Farm vs Omaha Steaks Heartstone Farm vs Rastellis Heartstone Farm vs Steaks & Game Heartstone Farm vs Crowd Cow Heartstone Farm vs Farm Foods Omaha Steaks vs Rastellis Omaha Steaks vs Steaks & Game Omaha Steaks vs Crowd Cow Omaha Steaks vs Farm Foods Rastellis vs Steaks & Game Rastellis vs Crowd Cow Rastellis vs Farm Foods Steaks & Game vs Crowd Cow Steaks & Game vs Farm Foods Crowd Cow vs Farm Foods
Compare the Best Steak Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Steak Companies
See the Best Steak Company
The Best Reviews of Steak Companies