Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Rastellis Review

Wednesday, May 18th

2022 Steak Company Reviews

Rastellis Review 4 Star Rating

Rastellis

4 Star Rating
  • Can buy steaks as a one-time purchase or set for recurring delivery
  • Complimentary rewards program
  • 21-day refund policy
  • Free shipping on orders over $200

Rastelli's began as "Meat Stop" , a small-town butcher shop with a reputation for hand-selected, premium meats. Expanding first into eight more brick-and-mortar locations and then into online sales, this business offers not just steaks but other cuts of beef, plus seafood, poultry, pork, lamb, veal and plant-based choices, and a selection of apps, sides, and rubs/butters.

Carefully-sourced meat

Rastelli's sources its products from around the world, looking for farming (and fishing) families who take good care of their animals and the environment, and whose products are free of antibiotics, steroids and hormones. For more details about where their beef comes from, just visit the Sources page on their online store and click on the type of beef (pasture-raised, 100% grass-fed, Wagyu or private stock/prime). Most of it is US-raised, but you can also find cuts from Uruguay and other locales.

Attractive pricing, good availability

How did this steak company do with our apples-to-apples items? The grass-fed filet mignon was out of stock at the time of our most recent visit to Rastelli's, but it's normally priced at $16 for one 6-oz. steak; their regular filet mignon was available at $46 for two 5-oz. filets. There were several options for prime rib, including a 4.5-lb. roast for $159, a 5-lb. oven-ready roast seasoned with garlic and herbs for $185, and a 5-lb. private stock prime rib roast for $199. And, when we visited the Rastelli's site most recently, there was a pop-up offering a 15% discount on any order of $150+ if we entered our email address. All of those prices were very competitive, coming in quite a bit less than some of Rastelli's rivals. Unfortunately, there were no samplers in their online store; you'd have to create your own combo if you want to try several cuts of steak.

Subscribe to stay stocked up

One feature we really like here is the ability to turn pretty much any product into a subscription. If you run out of staples like ground beef as often as we do, you'll recognize the appeal of having your freezer restocked on a regular basis, no effort required. When you add steaks, chops, or anything else to your cart, you should see the option to make it into a subscription. Set your delivery schedule for anywhere from 1-6 weeks and you're done - and you'll get a 5% savings too.

How about a discount?

Rastelli's will regularly try to earn your business through promotions - and who can complain about that? During our most recent visit to their online store, we got a pop-up offer of 15% off an order of $150+, and there were also some seasonal promos that included free products with that same order minimum.

Loyalty program for return customers

You can also rack up points with Rastelli's free loyalty program. You're automatically included when you register for an account to make a purchase, and points add up with purchases, referrals, and so on. Subscription purchases earn extra points too.

Best Steak Companies

Free shipping over $200

How about shipping? Orders here are sent out within five business days of being placed, or you can select a specific shipping week during the checkout process. If your order is over $200, delivery is complimentary; orders between $100-$199 ship for a $10 fee, while those under $100 have a fee of $25. In other words, it's worth your while to go big when you buy your steaks here.

Super-smooth gifting experience

Are you buying steaks as a gift? No problem. If it's just for one lucky recipient, shop the site as you would normally and then include a gift message during checkout. If you're buying for multiple people, we recommend that you click on the Gifting link on the site, then follow the next link under "Buying Up to 15 Gifts" : they say it's the "ideal way to send gifts... in one easy checkout" . Should your gift-giving needs include 15+ gifts, you're encouraged to fill out their Gifting Form so that a representative can reach out to you directly. (Or go the super-easy route and buy an e-gift card)

Some mixed reviews about delivery

Even though they've been in business for several decades, Rastelli's doesn't have a ton of feedback to consider, particularly with respect to their online steak delivery service. And, what we did find was pretty hot-or-cold - literally. Some people said that their steaks and other products arrived perfectly frozen, while others said they received thawed meats on more than one occasion.

Committed to customer satisfaction

Fortunately, Rastelli's has a solid refund policy: if you're unsatisfied for any reason, contact them within 21 days of your shipment. Depending on the circumstances, they'll refund all or a portion of your order.

A steak company you can trust

Thinking of buying your steaks (or other items) from Rastelli's? Not a bad choice. Overall they're a good option as a well-established business with a solid commitment to quality and to customer satisfaction. We'd like to see just a few more compliments about their steak delivery before boosting them higher in our rankings, but Rastelli's still earns a respectable rating.

Where Can You Buy the Best Steaks?

It would be nice if we all had access to a nearby butcher with locally-sourced, sustainably raised beef at prices we could afford, but that's just not the reality for most people. But don't let that stand in the way of getting a juicy ribeye or a surf-and-turf package for your next special occasion or "just because" !

Buying steaks online is convenient, safe and reliable, often allowing you to choose cuts you can track all the way back to the farms and ranches they came from and right to your doorstep. You might be surprised by how customer-friendly some steak companies can be, often offering perks like free shipping, promotional savings, and loyalty points that can be redeemed for discounts on future orders.

The Best Steak Companies Compare Steak Companies Compare Steak Company Reviews What are the best Steak Companies Best Steak Company Reviews

Steak Company FAQ

Definitely not! Why rely on your local supermarket's less-than impressive cuts when you can get the best sirloin, Porterhouse, filet mignon or T-bone - delivered right to your doorstep!
If you can name it, you can get it online. Angus? Aye. Wagyu and Kobe? Hai. And, companies that specialize in delivering steak know how to package it perfectly so it arrives fresh.
As with most things in life, you get what you pay for. When buying steak online, you'll tend to find the more premium cuts and grades of meat, but there are plenty of deals that make it affordable to get an unforgettable meal.
Most retailers offering food delivery understand that sometimes things go wrong in transit. If your steak arrives in less-than-perfect condition, you'll probably get a new shipment at no extra charge. Or, the store may give you a full refund or a store credit. Policies vary, so be sure you look for the company's satisfaction policy if you're concerned.
That depends. Steak can be ordered a la carte, and shipping costs usually depend on the size of your order. Some companies offer subscription clubs that deliver your meat on a regular, scheduled basis; with those plans, shipping is often included at no extra charge.
Yes! Can you think of a better way of making sure that you have a delicious steak dinner every single month? You can typically choose plans ranging from 3 to 12 months.
Depending on which store you select, you may only have cuts of beef to choose from. However, retailers that offer gift-giving options tend to have a wide range of possibilities, from seafood to desserts.
Why not? Maybe you'd love to treat your parents to a nice dinner, but they live a thousand miles away. Or you've got a hard-to-please boss and you really want to impress her at the holidays. Sending steak, a surf-and-turf combo, or a complete meal package will be a gift they'll remember.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

And let's not forget about steak as a gift! Yes, that's right: you can send a steak, a sampler, or an entire meal to someone special - or to an entire team of people at the holidays. We can almost guarantee that a delicious steak will be far more memorable than another pen or boring gift card. Wouldn't you rather get beef too? You can always strike a balance and give a steak company gift certificate: you get all of the thanks and they get to pick a cut they prefer.

You should be forewarned that what you'll pay for an online steak order is sometimes going to be more expensive than what you'd spend at your local supermarket. After all, you've got to factor in the costs to package and deliver the steak so that it arrives in perfect condition. However, it's well worth the extra cost to get a steak that delivers an unparalleled, mouth-watering dining experience, right?

Where to begin? No two steak companies are the same, and there are quite a few of them out there! But, there's no need to get overwhelmed. Here are some ways you can differentiate among the online options and find the steaks you want:

  • What do you want? Some steak companies are heavily focused on gift-giving options, while others seek to help individuals and families keep their freezers well-stocked with high-quality beef. Start by choosing a store that fits what you're looking to accomplish with your purchase.
  • Availability. The best-tasting steaks in the world aren't of any use if they're not in stock! Make sure the steak company you're considering shows a lot of options that are available at the time you're browsing their online store.
  • Value. What will you get for what you spend? Is the per-pound price reasonable for the quality of the steaks you're buying? How does it compare with rival stores?
  • Reputation. This is probably the most important factor. What do other shoppers say about the steak company? Is the meat consistently of good quality? Does it arrive in appropriate condition, still frozen or fresh as expected? Do people report having positive interactions with the company's customer support representatives when needed?

To help you get the most flavorful, high-quality steaks out there, TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the top steak companies on the market today. We're sure this information will guide you to the right place to buy your next favorite Porterhouse, T-bone or filet mignon!

Compare Steak Companies

Select any 2 Steak Companies to compare them head to head

best-steak-companies
  • Chicago Steak Company
  • Mr. Steak
  • US Wellness Meats
  • Rastellis
  • Snake River Farms
  • Stock Yards
  • Omaha Steaks
  • Great Wisconsin Steak Company
  • Good Chop
  • Farm Foods
  • Crowd Cow
  • Steaks & Game
Chicago Steak Company vs Mr. Steak Chicago Steak Company vs US Wellness Meats Chicago Steak Company vs Rastellis Chicago Steak Company vs Snake River Farms Chicago Steak Company vs Stock Yards Chicago Steak Company vs Omaha Steaks Chicago Steak Company vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company Chicago Steak Company vs Good Chop Chicago Steak Company vs Farm Foods Chicago Steak Company vs Crowd Cow Chicago Steak Company vs Steaks & Game Mr. Steak vs US Wellness Meats Mr. Steak vs Rastellis Mr. Steak vs Snake River Farms Mr. Steak vs Stock Yards Mr. Steak vs Omaha Steaks Mr. Steak vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company Mr. Steak vs Good Chop Mr. Steak vs Farm Foods Mr. Steak vs Crowd Cow Mr. Steak vs Steaks & Game US Wellness Meats vs Rastellis US Wellness Meats vs Snake River Farms US Wellness Meats vs Stock Yards US Wellness Meats vs Omaha Steaks US Wellness Meats vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company US Wellness Meats vs Good Chop US Wellness Meats vs Farm Foods US Wellness Meats vs Crowd Cow US Wellness Meats vs Steaks & Game Rastellis vs Snake River Farms Rastellis vs Stock Yards Rastellis vs Omaha Steaks Rastellis vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company Rastellis vs Good Chop Rastellis vs Farm Foods Rastellis vs Crowd Cow Rastellis vs Steaks & Game Snake River Farms vs Stock Yards Snake River Farms vs Omaha Steaks Snake River Farms vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company Snake River Farms vs Good Chop Snake River Farms vs Farm Foods Snake River Farms vs Crowd Cow Snake River Farms vs Steaks & Game Stock Yards vs Omaha Steaks Stock Yards vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company Stock Yards vs Good Chop Stock Yards vs Farm Foods Stock Yards vs Crowd Cow Stock Yards vs Steaks & Game Omaha Steaks vs Great Wisconsin Steak Company Omaha Steaks vs Good Chop Omaha Steaks vs Farm Foods Omaha Steaks vs Crowd Cow Omaha Steaks vs Steaks & Game Great Wisconsin Steak Company vs Good Chop Great Wisconsin Steak Company vs Farm Foods Great Wisconsin Steak Company vs Crowd Cow Great Wisconsin Steak Company vs Steaks & Game Good Chop vs Farm Foods Good Chop vs Crowd Cow Good Chop vs Steaks & Game Farm Foods vs Crowd Cow Farm Foods vs Steaks & Game Crowd Cow vs Steaks & Game
Compare the Best Steak Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Steak Companies
See the Best Steak Company
The Best Reviews of Steak Companies