Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

J.Crew Review

Friday, May 24th

2024 Swimsuit Store Reviews

J.Crew Review 3.5 Star Rating


3.5 Star Rating
  • Most swimsuits are between $35 and $55
  • 30-day return policy
  • Seasonal sitewide sales
  • Exceptionally great sizing information
  • Unfiltered customer reviews on products
  • "A+" Better Business Bureau rating

J. Crew is an upscale clothing store that sells classic styles for men, women, and children. Here you'll find loungewear, outerwear, sweaters, dresses, denim, bags, jewelry, shoes, and swimwear. They are sister stores with Madewell, another popular retail store that sells beautiful, classy, and trendy clothing. When you shop at J. Crew, you know you're getting well-made, timeless clothing that will last.

Tasteful selection of swimsuits

When people shop at J. Crew, they likely don't think of swimwear, but they do have some good options. There are 80 bikini tops, 85 bikini bottoms, 32 beach coverups, 75 one-piece swimsuits, and 8 swim dresses. The styles here are timeless, so you won't buy a swimsuit here and want to ditch it next year because it's out of style and you're bored of the wild design. These swimsuits are tasteful and work for all times of year and seasons of life.

Organized website

If you scroll through all of the swimwear at J. Crew, it will go by color scheme. This makes it feel organized and gives you a good taste of what they have to offer. Most swimsuits have quite a few color choices, so you have a good variety here. Like most websites, you could also sort their swim collection by silhouette, coverage, support, size, color, pattern, and price.

Best Swimsuit Stores

True to size

Most of the swimsuits from J. Crew are solid colors or minimal patterns like stripes or checked. We were viewing one of their light blue bikini tops for just $29.99 and found that their sizing potentially ranges from XX-small to 3X. They have a size chart, but they also take data from people who leave reviews to let you know if the swimsuit fits true to size or not. You can read all the customer reviews for yourself at the bottom of a product page and get information about quality, comfort, and size accuracy.

Reasonably priced

Swim bottoms range anywhere from $10 - $35 depending on the color you select. Most of their swim tops or one-pieces are between $35 and $55 with some exceptions. Some of their priciest swimwear is nearly $200 for a swimsuit and up to $600 for a swim dress. For the most part, the swimsuits here are reasonably priced, especially when you consider that J. Crew is not known for being "cheap" by any means. Depending on the time of year you're shopping, J. Crew will run sales that help to offset the cost of their clothing. At the time of this review, they had a code for up to 50% off select styles and 40% off others.

30 days to make a return

As part of a sale, J. Crew will sometimes offer free shipping. Otherwise you should expect to pay $5 for standard shipping on your order. If you need to make a return, you have 30 days to send your swimwear back (with the hygienic liner and in new condition, of course) for a full refund, minus $7.50 if you use J. Crew's shipping label.

Best Swimsuit Stores

Rocky reputation over the last few years

J. Crew earns an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. Interestingly, we also saw that they filed for reorganization bankruptcy in 2020 which allows them to continue operating with court supervision while they go through a reorganization process. This company took a big hit during the pandemic and has been trying to recover ever since. Most product reviews are really positive and J. Crew has long been a reliable, high quality retailer. However, some recent reviews shed light on the frustrations people have experienced here. These include price discrepancies, website glitches, difficulty with returns, and poor customer service.

Better than average

We aren't concerned that J. Crew's swimwear will fall apart after a few uses or that you'll order a one-piece swimsuit and receive a pair of denim jeans instead. This company is legit and most people have a good experience when they shop online at J. Crew. Based on customer reports, our only concern is if you need to make a return and it doesn't go as smoothly as you'd like. We're optimistic that people will like the swimsuits they purchase from J. Crew, so if you're in the market for something simple and classic, check out their site and see if they're a good match for you. J. Crew is a good store and has in turn earned a higher-than-average rating from us.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Swimsuits Online?

Shopping for swimsuits probably means the weather is heating up or you're headed out for a fun vacation. Either way, there are about a million styles of swimsuits to choose from, that you can wear when you're soaking up the sun. However, not everyone loves shopping for swimsuits because it can be hard finding something that fits well and makes you feel confident in yourself.

It's important to find the right store that has options you can be excited about. While there will always be a few brick-and-mortar swimsuit stores you can visit to see their selection in-person, online swimsuit stores are becoming increasingly popular. Peek under the covers (or the towel), and it's easy to see why.

The Best Swimsuit Stores Compare Swimsuit Stores Compare Swimsuit Store Reviews What are the best Swimsuit Stores Best Swimsuit Store Reviews

Swimsuit Store FAQ

The sky's the limit! From cute, crocheted bikinis to high-performance racing suits for triathletes, there's an abundance of variety when it comes to shopping for swimsuits.
That's easy: to get the best selection! Local inventory can be limited, particularly if you're looking for a swimsuit out of season (like buying a tankini in January for an escape to the Caribbean!). Shopping online makes it so much more likely that you'll find something you love in your size.
As much or as little as you wish. You can find swimwear for as little as $15 or as expensive as $1500! But, most swimsuits will fall somewhere in the $30-$100 range.
Most online retailers of swimwear have helpful sizing guides. Take accurate measurements and buy the suit that's the closest fit. Another option is to buy 2-3 sizes in the same suit and return the ones that don't fit. Just be sure to check the store's return policy first!
Not necessarily. Most swimsuits stretch out over time, so starting off with one that feels just a little bit too snug can actually be a good thing. This is especially true with competitive swimsuits, where loose swimwear = slower race times!
Fortunately, yes: the majority of swimsuit retailers offer you a 30-day return period, and some even cover the cost of return shipping. Make sure not to remove any hygienic liners that may come with your swimsuit bottoms until you're sure you're keeping your purchase.
For women, the best option is typically a one-piece racing suit, although in more recent years many manufacturers have offered two-piece designs suitable for lap swimming (usually with a drawstring on the bottoms!). For men, avoid board shorts and look for either a bikini-style bottom or "jammers" (which are like biker shorts without the padding).
Given that swimsuits aren't cheap and that they can wear out quickly, you'll want to take good care of it to help it last as long as possible. Some tips for keeping your suit in good condition include rinsing before and after you get in the water, letting it air dry flat instead of hanging it by the straps, and keeping it out of direct sunlight. (And try not to forget it in your swim bag because it will mildew!)
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

First, shopping online for swimsuits is super convenient. Online, the stores are accessible 24/7, which lets you browse and purchase at your leisure without the constraints of store hours or proximity. This is especially important to those of us who have busy schedules or limited shopping options.

Undeniably, the vast array of swimsuits available to you online contributes significantly to their popularity. These stores often feature an extensive selection of swimsuit styles, sizes, colors, and designs. You simply can't match that with the limited selections and sizes at a traditional store. With just a few clicks, you can explore an abundance of styles and colors, and find a swimsuit that works for your body type.

Online swimsuit stores give you plenty of information to help ensure you get the right size while allowing you thousands of options and competitive pricing. It's also a perk that you get to try your swimsuit on from the comfort of your own home rather than in a cold dressing room with harsh lighting (and we all know how THAT goes).

As long as you leave the hygienic liner on the unwashed swimsuit, you can buy as many as you want and return the ones you don't love. Your spouse or friends can help you make a decision about which swimsuits are most flattering and the whole experience can be fun and exciting. As an added plus, online stores typically have prices less (sometimes far less) than what you can find in a local store.

When deciding where to purchase a swimsuit (or a few) online, take the following things into consideration:

  • Customer reviews. What do customers have to say about their experience with the retailer and the quality of the swimming suits? There's nothing worse than paying a lot for a swimming suit that turns out to be thin and sometimes even see-through when it gets wet. Customers will be honest about the fit and how easy it is to care for the swimming suit, so pay close attention to what people say if there are unfiltered reviews on the ones you're eyeing.
  • Selection. Whether you're looking for kids' swim trunks, a men's Speedo (not judging), a bikini, or a full coverage one-piece, you'll want to find a store that has a lot of great patterns and details to fit your personal style. It's also nice to find somewhere that has accessories like swim skirts, kids' floaties, cover ups, and even water shoes.
  • Return policy. Buying a swimsuit may be one of the pickiest purchases you ever make, so there's a good chance you'll need to take advantage of a return policy. It's great if you shop somewhere that offers a generous return window and will give you a full refund without any restocking fees. Pay attention to customer reviews to make sure the store is reliable with their refunds and credits their customers quickly.

Are you ready to get shopping for a swimming suit to enjoy the summer sun (or a tropical winter getaway)? Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best places for you to find good looking, high-quality swimsuits online. We hope this information helps you be able to get out and relax at the beach or pool!

The Best Reviews of Swimsuit Stores