Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Free Tax USA vs Liberty Tax

Monday, February 10th

2025 Tax Preparation Service Reviews

Free Tax USA Review 2.5 Star Rating

Free Tax USA

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $0 to $14.99 for filing
  • Estimates your returns
  • State and Federal taxes
  • E-filing process
  • Guarantee for accurate returns and maximum refund
  • "A-” rating from the BBB

FreeTaxUSA is a free tax filing service for e-filing your taxes online. With a straightforward sign-up process and three guarantees - including accuracy and maximum refunds - it's easy to see why many people give it a try. However, mixed reviews about login issues, technical glitches, and problems with changing one's residential location earn it a more cautious rating in our review.

Liberty Tax Review 2.5 Star Rating

Liberty Tax

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $45.95 to $85.95
  • Estimates your returns
  • State and Federal taxes
  • In-person filing
  • E-filing process
  • Remote filing
  • Guarantee for accurate returns
  • Free consultation
  • "A” rating from the BBB

Liberty Tax offers a mix of in-person, online, and remote tax preparation options, giving a uniquely flexible approach to filing your taxes. While some perks like free consultations, and an accuracy guarantee are exciting, Liberty Tax doesn't stand out from the pack due to its high costs, especially for self-employed taxpayers. With concerning reviews from customers regarding service quality, Liberty Tax holds a below-average rating rather than a more competitive spot.

Where is the Best Site to Do Your Tax Preparation?

Let's face it: tax season is nobody's favorite time of the year. Whether you're a W-2 employee or an independent contractor, taxes are a source of stress every spring. But, it doesn't have to be that way. Tax preparation services are there to ease the process (and are particularly helpful if you own your own business).

So, what do tax preparation services actually do? Most services offer planning to understand your tax situation and filing. You may receive preparation of your actual return, or advice on different aspects of your taxes like individual tax returns, estate tax planning, personal financial planning, deductions, property tax assessments, tax credit reviews, and more. The tax advisor (individual or website) can make taxes make sense and help you avoid many of the pitfalls.

The Best Tax Preparation Services Compare Tax Preparation Services Compare Tax Preparation Service Reviews What are the best Tax Preparation Services Best Tax Preparation Service Reviews

Tax Preparation Service FAQ

Online Tax preparation services walk you through a series of questions, much like you'd get with a human tax preparer: are you married, do you have a mortgage, and so on. The program fills in your tax forms based on the answers you provide, and at the end your return is ready for filing. Tax preparation services allow you to file your returns electronically, but you always have the option to file them by mail.
That's up to you! Almost every tax preparation platform today makes it possible to do your entire return online, no downloads or CD-ROMs necessary. But, if you prefer to do it the more old-school way, you can still find tax preparation services that download to your computer and let you work offline.
That depends on several factors. The more complicated your financial situation, the more likely it is that you'll need a tax preparation service that goes beyond the basics. Most tax preparation services will walk you through the options and recommend the right product for your needs.
Yes, most of the time. Many services will take the information you entered during your federal return and carry it over into your applicable state return. Keep in mind that you may have to pay extra for your state's online tax service. You can opt to file your federal return electronically (often included at no extra charge) and file your state return by mail if you wish.
For the most basic tax returns (those that only have W2 income, no investments, no mortgage interest to deduct), some tax preparation services are completely free. Otherwise, you can expect costs ranging from $19 - $120, with the most expensive packages for those who have self-employment/business income and expenses to report.
You'll often find answers built right into the tax preparation service. Look for a button to click on the page where you're having trouble, for explanations and additional info. If you'd like to get help from a tax professional, you might be able to connect with someone by phone or online (though that may incur extra charges). A few online tax preparation services have in-person options if you get stuck and want a tax preparer to take over or just want to go over your return face-to-face.
The good news is that your tax preparation service will likely have a robust detection method for uncovering any errors you may have made. Of course, it can't tell if you entered the wrong numbers for your income, but if it spots anything obviously wrong you'll get a notification and a prompt to review that part of your return. If you file your taxes and later realize there was an error, you can file an amended return.
Getting an audit notification can be scary! Depending on which tax preparation service you use, you might have audit support and guidance built into your package. Some services also offer full audit representation for an additional fee.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

A few years ago, the IRS (Internal Revenue Service) estimated that there were around 1.2 million paid tax preparers available in the US. Tax preparation can be completed by a range of licensed agents, accountants, or businesses who can take the weight of tax season off your shoulders.

The most important thing about finding a tax preparation service is to make sure you work with one you trust. The three best professional credentials to look for include Enrolled Agents (or entities), who are licensed directly by the IRS and must pass an examination to demonstrate their understanding of federal tax planning, individual and business taxes, and representing you properly; Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) who have studied finance at a university and passed charter exams and requirements for accounting; and, Attorneys who are licensed by state courts and have passed a bar exam in financial law.

Now, keep in mind, there will be fees for using most tax preparation services, but these will be minimal compared to the high fines and charges from the IRS if you make a mistake on your return. For even small errors on your taxes, you could be looking at thousands of dollars in fines. A one-time fee for a tax preparation service is no sweat in comparison. Most tax preparation and filing costs between $30 to $500 (though some really comprehensive services cost more), so you'll want to make sure you know what you need before you start.

If you're ready to simplify tax season, but don't know which service to choose, we've put together some factors that can help you find the best tax preparation service for your financial situation:

  • Cost. The cost differs depending on the service and what you need in your final tax preparation. If you don't need to worry about itemized deductions or you're just submitting a 1040 form, you might get a great deal on tax preparation (or even free tax filing). However, for more comprehensive filings or different types of tax forms, you may want to pay a little extra for your tax preparation service, with or without assistance from a tax pro.
  • One-stop shop. The best tax preparation services offer a one-stop shop for your finances. Make sure that you can get everything handled by the same platform. For example, if you need specific forms, you'll want to make sure your chosen service offers those. Plus, some states require state and federal income taxes to be filed, so you'll want to be sure your chosen service offers filing options for both if necessary.
  • Reputation. Always remember to check out tax prep services with the IRS as well as online review sites. Third-party reviews from taxpayers like you can help you feel more confident in your choice. This way you can be sure you're getting the best deal and the highest-quality service.

To help you find the best service to get your return filed this tax season, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top tax preparation services out there today. Take the stress out of tax season and hand the nitty-gritty details over to an expert (or enjoy a guided DIY approach that is as simple as a step-by-step guide). After that, you just need to sit back, relax, and wait for those lovely tax returns!

See the Best Tax Preparation Service
The Best Reviews of Tax Preparation Services