Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

My Smile Review

Tuesday, January 21st

2025 Teeth Whitener Reviews

My Smile Review 2.5 Star Rating

My Smile

2.5 Star Rating
  • Priced from $31 to $113
  • Offers a variety of whitening options and styles
  • Often have 10%-30% sale

My Smile is an online distributor that provides a variety of whitening treatments and oral care. The site sells individual products and bundles with options that range from tooth whitening powder to LED light treatments. At the time of this review, everything on the site was on sale by at least 20%, so prices may vary depending on when you shop. The price range for whitening products goes from $36.99 up to $113, so depending on which style of whitener you get, the prices aren't too bad.

Package options don't explain the contents

The site has a variety of whitening options, but the most cost-effective are the whitening bundles offered by My Smile. These are the Everyday Whitening Bundle, the Ultimate Whitening Bundle, and the Maximum Whitening Bundle. The bundles come with the following options:

  • Everyday: This option costs $36.99 and is for people who want to whiten while they brush their teeth. The process is gradual, and you shouldn't expect immediate results. The bundle includes:
    • Non-Sensitive Whitening Strips
    • Mint Flavor Whitening Powder
  • Ultimate: This option costs $41.99 and is for someone who wants to whiten while they brush, and shouldn't be used for immediate results. This includes:
    • Teeth whitening strips
    • Mint flavor whitening powder
  • Maximum: This option is $91.99 and is for people who want to see fast results. The package comes with:
    • 10-minute whitening formula
    • Peroxide gel pen
    • LED light tray
    • Teeth whitening strips

A familiar product for a budget price

My Smile also offers a standard LED and gel package called the Teeth Whitening Kit with LED Light. This product comes with a battery-powered LED and applicators with whitening gel. This LED kit is $31.99 at several retailers and is one of the top-reviewed items from My Smile.

Best Teeth Whiteners

The website could use some TLC

One of the things that stood out to us about My Smile is that the site doesn't seem very well-maintained. Many of the images used for product photos all appear to be just one promo image for each product. Many listings don't provide 360-degree views of products or even different angles of packaging and individual items. Further, the site has a variety of typos and inconsistencies across the copy, which doesn't make us feel very confident about their products.

Generally good reviews...

Surprisingly, the My Smile products have received decent reviews from consumers. The LED light and gel treatment has earned a 4.1 out of 5 stars on average. While that's lower than many others in our review, there are plenty of customers who enjoyed the My Smile products. One of the things that customers liked best about My Smile was the price. Their LED and gel kit is priced very reasonably and competes well with similar products that we evaluated.

...but some worrying feedback

However, reviewers also noted that while the initial kit is cheap, the maintenance isn't as inexpensive. Replacing the gels gets pricey quickly, and customers weren't as thrilled about maintaining their My Smile unit over time. The gel refills are $20 each and only contain 9 applications of gel each. Several customers also complained that the LED light in the unit didn't seem to help with the whitening as they could use the gel alone. Others noticed that their gums were very painful after use.

Not the best or the worst

My Smile has pros and cons. While the prices are competitive, their website is poorly made and doesn't inspire confidence in buyers. However, their basic whitening LED kit is well-reviewed and competes with other options in our rankings. Yet again, there were only 50% of happy customers, and the others had a lot to say about value, maintenance, and sore gums. Overall, it seems safer to go with a different option for maintaining a bright smile.

What is the Best Way to Whiten Your Teeth?

We all know that your smile is one of your most important features, and sometimes it's just not as bright as you like. Lots of people (coffee fans, we see you!) look for simple or over-the-counter solutions for teeth whitening. Not everyone has the time or the money to get their teeth professionally whitened.

Teeth whitening is useful to remove stains caused by external factors like coffee, tea, and smoking, as well as stains caused by medication, trauma, or aging. However, it is generally easier to remove external stains than those caused by aging or medication. It's also important to remember that teeth whitening solutions aren't permanent. How long the results last will depend on your lifestyle habits and oral hygiene. Touch-up treatments may be necessary to maintain the desired level of whiteness.

The Best Teeth Whiteners Compare Teeth Whiteners Compare Teeth Whitener Reviews What are the best Teeth Whiteners Best Teeth Whitener Reviews

Teeth Whitener FAQ

Many people have stains on their teeth from coffee, cola, and even just day-to-day foods. Most teeth whiteners work by combining oxygen from the air and carbon in the dentin layer of the teeth, which breaks apart any colored molecules still stuck to the teeth (and which aren't removed by regular dental cleanings). Some teeth whitening systems use a whitening gel in combination with an LED light appliance for increased effectiveness, while others only use topical application of liquids or strips.
The process itself usually takes anywhere from a few minutes to an hour, depending on which system you choose. How long will it take to see a whiter smile? Some teeth whiteners produce noticeably brighter teeth within one or two applications, while others take a week or more of regular applications.
Teeth whitening can result in sensitivity in the teeth and gums. If you're experiencing sensitivity, you can shorten your time during each application or use the product less often than recommended. There are also special toothpastes that can ease sensitivity. But, the whitening process itself is rarely painful, no matter which method you choose.
It is possible for teeth whiteners to damage tooth enamel when not used properly. However, if you follow the manufacturer's directions carefully, there should be no risk to your teeth. (In other words, don't try to whiten your teeth faster than recommended!)
Not much! Most in-office teeth whiteners use the same solutions (hydrogen peroxide, carbamide peroxide) and send you home with trays to use for maintenance that are exactly like what you'd buy to use on your own in the first place. Yes, having your teeth whitened at the dentist's office gives you the reassurance that you're not overdoing it, but you're paying a lot more for it too.
That depends on you! If you avoid smoking and teeth-staining foods and drinks (like coffee and blueberries!), use a straw whenever possible, and keep up with your regular dental cleanings, your pearly-white smile should last a long time - several months to a year or more.
At-home teeth whitening systems are surprisingly affordable! Some of the most effective products cost less than $50 for 20 applications (and you'd pay four times that much for a single in-office whitening application from your dentist).
Most manufacturers of teeth whitening products offer a satisfaction guarantee of at least 30 days, giving you plenty of time to try it out and see if you get results. Just be aware that some products' fine print says that you can only get a refund if the product is unused (not very helpful, we know).
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

There are a few different teeth whitening procedures. In-office teeth whitening is typically done by a dentist and involves applying a strong bleaching agent to the teeth. At-home teeth whitening can be done using over-the-counter products like whitening toothpaste or whitening strips or with custom trays and gels provided by a dentist. Both in-office and at-home methods are generally safe.

There are also natural remedies that people use to whiten their teeth, such as brushing with baking soda or using apple cider vinegar. However, these methods are not scientifically proven to be effective and may even damage the teeth if used incorrectly. It's always best to consult with a dentist before trying any teeth whitening method and follow instructions carefully once you begin.

So, if you've decided to go the DIY route, how do you choose a product to whiten your teeth? There are a lot of factors to consider, so keep in mind what you're looking for and what's most important to you. If you're not sure where to start, here are some things that might help you decide:

  • Cost. Are you looking for the most budget-friendly teeth whitener? Or are you more concerned with results?
  • Product format. Do you want toothpaste you can use every night? Or do you want to use white strips? Maybe you'd prefer another application that is gentle on your gums?
  • Timeframe. Do you want a product you need to use regularly to maintain whitening? Or are you looking for the longest-lasting solution?
  • Target. Do you just want a product that targets basic staining from coffee or tea? Or do you need something for more difficult stains?
  • Ingredients. Are you looking for a more natural solution? Or are you only looking for the fastest whitening solution out there?

To help you find a way to brighten your smile, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked today's most popular methods for whitening your teeth. We hope this information makes it easy to decide which whitener is best for you so you can start feeling confident with your bright new smile.

See the Best Teeth Whitener
The Best Reviews of Teeth Whiteners