Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
About 20 million Americans have some form of thyroid disease, with women being more likely to experience thyroid problems than men. While surgery, radioactive iodine procedures, and hormone replacement therapy are all commonly-used strategies for managing thyroid problems, many people are leery of such invasive methods that can often come with side effects.
Fortunately, there are a number of established, safe over-the-counter supplements that can offer support for thyroid health. They often contain nutrients like iodine, selenium, and vitamins B and D, which play vital roles in thyroid function.
Tuesday, January 21st
Thyroid Assist, one of our top choices for thyroid support, is a 100% herbal formula tailored to combat the fatigue and low energy frequently associated with hypothyroid issues. It's offered by Native Remedies, a company with a long, trusted history in the natural remedies industry.
Built for Thyroid maintenance
This product is designed for those struggling with hypothyroidism or who want to keep their thyroid functioning well. For those who struggle with hyperthyroidism, they will want to check out Native Remedies' other product in our review, ThyroSoothe.
3 all-natural ingredients
With just three key ingredients, Thyroid Assist provides an effective and straightforward approach to thyroid health:
No hard-to-swallow capsules here
What sets Thyroid Assist apart is its liquid form, unlike most thyroid supplements available in capsules or tablets. Adults and individuals aged 15 and above are advised to take 0.5 mL, 2-3 times daily, mixed with juice or water. So, a single bottle of Thyroid Assist, when taken at the full-strength dose (3 times daily at 0.5 mL), will last approximately 40 days.
A little pricey but discounts available
In terms of pricing, Thyroid Assist comes in at a slightly higher price point compared to other products in our assessment, priced at $39.95 per bottle. However, Native Remedies frequently offers discounts and promotions that can lead to substantial savings. During our recent visit to their website, we encountered offers such as free shipping and discounts of up to 40% for first-time email subscribers. There was also a promotion featured at the top of the site, offering a 20% discount and free shipping with the provided coupon code.
Buy 2 get 1 free
Plus, Native Remedies seems to have a "forever” Buy 2 Get 1 Free promotion, allowing you to get three bottles for the price of two. This deal allows you to mix and match remedies to address multiple health concerns within your household. And, if you become a devoted Thyroid Assist user and want to make sure you never run out, signing up for their Auto Delivery Service provides a 15% discount and free shipping on every order. So many ways to save.
365-day money-back guarantee
One of the biggest reasons that Native Remedies' two thyroid support products earn our five-star rating is their exceptional money-back guarantee. You have a full year to return any product, whether used or unused, for a complete refund, provided you try it for at least 30 days. The company's transparency shines through as they publish all customer reviews, reflecting a commitment to honesty and product integrity.
Great reputation with customers and the BBB
Regarding how well this thyroid support supplement works, Thyroid Assist had 35 customer testimonials on the Native Remedies product page at the time of this review, with the majority awarding it a perfect five-star rating. We were really encouraged by the users who said that their doctors let them stop taking their prescription thyroid meds because Thyroid Assist was effectively managing their condition. Many customers reported even better results when using Thyroid Assist alongside other supplements like AdrenoBoost or Fatigue Fighter. And, Native Remedies' parent company (Silver Star Brands) has an "A+” rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau.
#1 supplement for hypothyroidism
Thyroid Assist owns our top recommendation for thyroid support products, particularly if you prefer a non-capsule format or you want a supplement with a concise ingredient list. While it may come at a slightly higher monthly cost, money-saving promotions and an unparalleled satisfaction guarantee make Thyroid Assist a compelling choice, providing peace of mind and a risk-free opportunity to experience its benefits. If you suffer from hypothyroidism and are looking for an effective, all-natural option for improving your health, put Thyroid Assist at the top of your list.
If you're dealing with the symptoms of hyperthyroidism, ThyroSoothe, offered by Native Remedies, now shares our top spot for thyroid support. Native Remedies is a trusted name in all-natural products, with an "A+” rating and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau (under the name of parent company Silver Star Brands).
3 ingredients to calm down your thyroid
This supplement is tailored to help you manage hyperactive thyroid issues using three 100% herbal ingredients:
Easy-to-use liquid format
ThyroSoothe comes in a lemon-flavored liquid form, with a recommended dosage of 0.5mL diluted in water or juice three times daily for users aged 12 and above. It's also safe for children aged 6-11, with a dosage of one drop per year of age, three times daily. At full strength, one bottle lasts about 40 days.
Plenty of opportunities to save money
While ThyroSoothe is priced slightly higher at $39.95 per bottle, there are almost always discounts or promotions on Native Remedies, so keep an eye out for pop-up offers. There was a sitewide promotion in place during our most recent visit to the online store, offering a 20% discount and free shipping with the given coupon code. Native Remedies also offers a perpetual Buy 2 Get 1 Free deal on most supplements, allowing you to mix and match or stock up on one favorite supplement (like ThyroSoothe). If you opt for their Auto Delivery Service, you'll save 15% and get free shipping on every order, so that you never run out.
Only for hyperthyroid issues
Since ThyroSoothe is designed for hyperthyroidism, it's important not to use it if you have an underactive thyroid. Native Remedies also advises against home therapy for Grave's disease or severe hyperthyroidism and cautions against combining ThyroSoothe with other thyroid medications without consulting your physician. However, you can safely combine this thyroid support formula with several other Native Remedies products, like PureCalm and Triple Complex Calm Tonic, for extra relief.
Get results or your money back
Consider trying ThyroSoothe for two compelling reasons. Users have reported improvements in sleep patterns, mood, hot flashes, and even blood test results. You can find those comments among the 35+ reviews on the Native Remedies website, or among the hundreds of reviews where ThyroSoothe is sold by third-party retailers. Second, Native Remedies stands by this supplement and all their products with an unmatched one-year satisfaction guarantee. Try ThyroSoothe for at least 30 days, and if you don't see results, you can get a full refund, even if you've used the entire bottle. This makes trying their products virtually risk-free.
Top supplement for hyperthyroidism
While ThyroSoothe may not be suitable for everyone with thyroid issues and may initially cost more than other products, it's an excellent choice for managing hyperthyroidism. Native Remedies offers multiple ways to save money on your purchase and provides a refund option if the supplement doesn't meet your expectations. For these reasons, ThyroSoothe earns an exceptional rating, along with its sister product from Native Remedies (Thyro Assist for hypothyroidism).
Thyroid Helper, offered by Wellness Resources, is a thyroid support supplement designed to enhance your thyroid health with its carefully selected ingredients: tyrosine, selenium, manganese, guggul, and ashwagandha. What sets this product apart is its commitment to thoroughly explaining how each component can positively impact your metabolism, energy levels, and mood.
Detailed info about each ingredient
For instance, the product page dives deep into the significance of selenium for proper thyroid function, highlighting its high concentration in the thyroid gland. Without adequate selenium, the activation of the thyroid hormone by selenoprotein D1 can decrease by up to 90%. If you're curious about the inner workings of your thyroid and how Thyroid Helper's ingredients can optimize its function, you'll find this to be an informative resource.
What's not included is important too
Moreover, Thyroid Helper goes the extra mile by clearly listing what it does not contain - no animal glandulars, herbal stimulants, or potassium iodide. These exclusions are based on well-founded reasons, all of which are thoroughly explained on the product page.
Flexible dosage could make this expensive
Dosage is straightforward. You can take 1-2 capsules of Thyroid Helper up to three times daily, ideally before or between meals. This translates to a monthly consumption ranging from 30 to 180 capsules, depending on your chosen dosage level. Pricing is reasonable, with a 90-capsule bottle priced at $25.99 and a 180-capsule bottle at $46.99. Either way, most customers will qualify for free shipping. The pricing makes this thyroid support supplement a little more spendy than some of the products we evaluated, especially if you wind up needing to take it at the maximum recommended dosage and frequency.
90-day refund policy
Wellness Resources, the company behind Thyroid Helper, offers a generous satisfaction guarantee, though that may vary depending on where you purchase this supplement. However, broadly speaking, if you're dissatisfied for any reason, you should be able to return your supplements within 90 days of purchase for a full refund. Keep in mind that the refund policy permits a refund on only one opened bottle per product per address.
Delivers results for the majority of users
Wellness Resources boasts a pristine "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and has been serving customers for almost four decades. About 75% of Thyroid Helper's customers have given the product a 4- or 5-star score, saying that it helped regulate their thyroid function where even prescription meds had failed. But, like any thyroid remedy, this isn't a works-for-everyone cure; some customers complained that they felt no difference at all or that Thyroid Helper gave them headaches.
Effective supplement for thyroid support
Thyroid Helper stands as a reliable choice for improving thyroid health. Its solid return and refund policy, coupled with the longevity of Wellness Resources as a company, instills confidence in the product. While we've dropped this supplement slightly in our rankings compared with a few products with more generous returns and a lower price point for a one-month supply, Thyroid Helper still earns our endorsement as an effective thyroid support supplement.
Thyroid Essentials, brought to you by Healthy Choice Naturals, is designed to provide comprehensive thyroid support through a blend of carefully chosen herbs, minerals, and vitamins. The company has been in business since 2003 and is one of the only providers of thyroid support supplements on our list that can proudly claim to be both "A+” rated and accredited by the Better Business Bureau.
Don't be put off by the outdated website
It's important to point that out early, because when you first visit the Healthy Choice Naturals website, you may wonder if they're still in business. The site copyright goes all the way back to 2013, the social media channels like Facebook have no new posts after 2014, and the site itself looks like it hasn't been updated in 10 years. But, never fear: the customer service phone number is fully functional and live, the coupons and promotions are up-to-date, and it's business as usual despite the outdated appearance.
Combination of vitamins, minerals, and herbal ingredients
So, let's move on to the supplement itself. Thyroid Essentials is composed of a range of ingredients, including Magnesium, Zinc, L-Tyrosine, Selenium, Manganese, Vitamin B-12, Iodine, Copper, Molybdenum, and more. The product information section offers some insights into how certain ingredients work, but it would benefit from more details, especially regarding less commonly known components like Bladderwrack and Schizandra, along with references to any clinical studies.
Extremely affordable
Thyroid Essentials comes in convenient capsule form, with a recommended daily dosage of two capsules to be taken with a meal. It's priced at $24.50 for one bottle (a 30-day supply), and you'll save money if you decide to buy 2 or more bottles at a time. While you'll have to get to the checkout to see what your shipping fees will be, Healthy Choice Naturals frequently offers discounts, such as 10% off and free shipping on orders of $75 or more. In fact, that was the promotion featured at the top of the site during our most recent visit to the Healthy Choice Naturals online store.
Get a refund within the first 90 days
One of the reasons that this thyroid product ranks higher than average on our list is the satisfaction guarantee. You have the flexibility to return your order for a refund within 90 days from your purchase date, and Healthy Choice Naturals did away with their previous requirement to purchase a minimum 2-month supply to qualify. It's important to note that you can return opened or used products, but refunds are limited to a maximum of a 90-day supply (so you might not want to buy more than three bottles with your first purchase).
Could use more feedback from customers
Besides the less-than-modern website, the only other downside to this thyroid supplement is the lack of customer feedback. Yes, there are a few testimonials on the website, but they're not dated or independently verified. We're not worried that this is a bad product; after all, the BBB gives the company its highest rating, and there were no complaints filed with the BBB in the last three years. But, to really stand out, Thyroid Essentials needs to pull back the curtain a bit and reveal more of what customers say, good or bad. It's that kind of feedback that makes it easier for people to know what to expect, such as side effects or possible interactions with medications they're already taking.
Worth a risk-free try
At the end of the day, we can overlook the outdated storefront and less-than-ample customer feedback and still give this Healthy Choice Naturals product a strong four-star rating. The combination of an accommodating return policy and a reputable company makes Thyroid Essentials a product well worth considering for your thyroid health needs.
If you're in search of a thyroid support product, Thyroid Synergy by Designs for Health is a worthwhile option to consider. Manufactured by a company with a strong reputation for quality since 1989 and boasting an "A+" rating with the Better Business Bureau, you can trust the integrity of this product.
Long list of ingredients
Now, let's delve into what Thyroid Synergy uses to promote your thyroid health. These capsules are packed with essential minerals, vitamins, and nutrients, including Vitamin A, Riboflavin, Iodine, Zinc, Selenium, Copper, Manganese, Chromium, N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, American Ginseng, and Forskolin Extract. Together, these ingredients work in harmony to maintain balanced cortisol, insulin, and blood glucose levels, facilitate the conversion of peripheral thyroid hormone, and support overall thyroid function.
One of the most affordable thyroid supplements on the market
The affordability of Thyroid Synergy is a big plus. Priced at $45.12 for a bottle of 120 capsules, you get a two-month supply at well under $25 per month. Additionally, most customers are likely to qualify for free shipping, making it a particularly cost-effective choice.
Plenty of five-star reviews
When it comes to product efficacy, Thyroid Synergy receives positive feedback from many customers. While we didn't come across the "thousands" of reviews mentioned by the company, there is a significant number of five-star ratings and an impressive average of 4.5 stars out of 5 across nearly 500 reviews. Users have reported substantial improvements in TSH levels, the ability to reduce reliance on traditional thyroid medications, and noticeable symptom alleviation, such as reduced hair loss and weight loss.
Returns and refunds aren't likely
However, the product's return policy leaves room for improvement. Designs for Health typically allows refund requests within 30 days of delivery, but only unopened products are eligible for return, and a 30% restocking fee applies. When purchased through third-party retailers, return policies may vary. Some customers found themselves being denied refunds even when their bottle of Thyroid Synergy arrived broken. You should only give this thyroid support supplement a try if you don't need the safety net of a satisfaction guarantee.
Better than average
Compared with other thyroid support products we evaluated, Thyroid Synergy stands as a thyroid supplement that has been effective for a considerable number of users. Manufactured by a long-standing, reputable company, we have no concerns about its quality. However, it falls mid-tier in our rankings due to its less-than-ideal refund policy. Nonetheless, Thyroid Synergy remains a dependable choice for thyroid support that has delivered positive outcomes for numerous satisfied customers.
Now Thyroid Energy is a nutritional supplement designed to support thyroid health, aiming to maintain a healthy thyroid gland and metabolism. This can be particularly beneficial for individuals concerned about their thyroid function, but it falls somewhere in the middle when compared to other products on the market. While it offers some beneficial ingredients, it has its drawbacks too.
Potent blend of herbal extracts, vitamins, and minerals
One notable aspect of Thyroid Energy is its combination of Iodine and Tyrosine, essential components for synthesizing thyroid secretions. Additionally, it includes minerals like Selenium, Zinc, and Copper, which serve as cofactors necessary for normal thyroid function. To complement these nutritional components, the supplement incorporates Ayurvedic herbal extracts from Guggul and Ashwagandha. The blend is non-GMO and kosher. The recommended dosage is 2 capsules per day, making it relatively easy to incorporate into your daily routine.
Some contraindications to be aware of
As with any supplement, it's crucial to exercise caution and consider potential side effects and interactions. Now Thyroid Energy is intended for adults only and is not recommended for pregnant or nursing women. If you are taking medications or have specific medical conditions, including known ulcers, consult with a physician before using this supplement. Some users may experience transient gastrointestinal upset, so discontinue use if these symptoms persist. Additionally, individuals with thyroid disorders or those taking medications such as warfarin, thyroid medications, L-dopa, SNRIs, MAO inhibitors, or other mood-altering drugs should seek medical advice before consuming this product.
Very budget-friendly
When it comes to pricing, Now Thyroid Energy offers a 90-day supply at $39.49, but prices may vary depending on the retailer. Most customers are likely to qualify for free shipping.
Limited but mostly positive reviews
Customer reviews of this thyroid support supplement provide a mixed picture. With an average rating of 4.5 stars out of 5 across just 110 reviews, it has some positive feedback. Some say they can feel a definite downshift in their energy levels as soon as they stop taking this Now product. However, there is limited feedback available overall, making it challenging to say with confidence that this is going to be your miracle product for thyroid issues.
You're not likely to get a refund
And, unfortunately, for some users, Thyroid Energy doesn't seem to do anything at all. Given that we found no satisfaction guarantee in conjunction with this product, unless your package arrives damaged, it appears that refunds are not likely to be offered. That makes Thyroid Energy less appealing as an option when compared with rival supplements that give you months (or even up to a year) to see if you get results.
Would be better with a satisfaction guarantee
Generally speaking, Now Thyroid Energy offers a commonly-used blend of ingredients aimed at supporting thyroid health and metabolism. While it has its merits, such as being non-GMO and kosher, it also has some limitations, including a less-than-generous return policy. With a rating average of 4.5 stars based on a relatively small number of reviews, it may be a risk worth taking for some, but there are other thyroid supplements on the market with more extensive customer feedback and more flexible return policies.
ThyrAid promises comprehensive thyroid care, adrenal and pituitary gland support, immune system enhancement, oxidative stress reduction, and hormonal balance. While it offers an array of benefits, it falls short in some crucial aspects, making it a middle-of-the-road choice in the realm of thyroid supplements.
Combines vitamins and minerals with herbal ingredients
ThyrAid contains a mix of minerals, vitamins, and herbal extracts, including Magnesium, Zinc, Manganese, Selenium, Copper, Iodine, Vitamin B12, Molybdenum, L-Tyrosine, Magnolia Vine, Ashwagandha Root, Bladderwrack, Kelp, Gotu Kola, Coleus Forskohlii, and Gugulipid. These ingredients collectively aim to support thyroid health, whether your issues stem from genetics, hormonal imbalances, or nutrient deficiencies.
What can it do for you
Let's break down what this thyroid support supplement claims to offer:
Expensive and doesn't have a satisfaction guarantee
The recommended dosage for ThyrAid is two capsules daily, to be taken with meals - one in the morning and one in the evening. Pricing for ThyrAid is set at $49.50 for a one-month supply. While this might be seen as a reasonable investment in your health, the lack of a return or refund policy is a downside worth mentioning.
Very mixed results among users
ThyrAid has earned decidedly mixed feedback from customers. It has an average rating of 3.9 stars out of 5 across 195 ratings, indicating some degree of user satisfaction. However, it's important to consider that 20% of customers have given it just 1 or 2 stars, so this is definitely not a thyroid support supplement that works for everyone. And remember, if you don't wind up being among the 50% of users who would give ThyrAid a five-star rating, you're out of luck if you want your money back.
Not a go-to choice for thyroid support
ThyrAid is a thyroid supplement that offers a comprehensive approach to thyroid health, but it has room for improvement. While it includes a range of ingredients aimed at supporting thyroid function, the lack of a returns or refunds policy is a notable drawback - especially at the almost $50/month price point. Moreover, the mixed customer feedback suggests that ThyrAid may not work equally well for everyone. If you're in search of a thyroid supplement, ThyrAid may be worth trying, but you should first check out the other options available on our list that offer a satisfaction guarantee and many more positive customer ratings.
If you're searching for a way to boost your energy, enhance focus, and support your thyroid hormone production, Vita Balance's Thyroid Support supplement might get your attention.
Ample details for each ingredient
It's always beneficial when thyroid support supplements provide information about the ingredients in their products, and Thyroid Support does an admirable job of that. Make sure to hover over the plus signs for each ingredient - Ashwagandha, Iodine, Vitamin B12, Selenium, Zinc, and L-Tyrosine - to learn more about how they contribute to improving your thyroid function. (Look for the image of the product bottle with a circle around it towards the middle of the page as you scroll.)
Low cost
You'll take two capsules per day with a meal. Each bottle provides a 30-day supply, and it's priced at $23.95 for a one-month purchase. If you decide to buy two or four bottles at once, you'll save a little ($42.96 and $64.44, respectively, would be your total cost).
Ingredients are endorsed, but not necessarily the product itself
As you continue to scroll, you'll also find quotes from reputable third-party sources like the American Thyroid Association and NCBI, which support the effectiveness of the ingredients in Thyroid Support. However, the site sets it up to make visitors feel like those organizations endorse this particular supplement, when in reality they're only backing the ingredients' efficacy. That doesn't sit well with us.
Company doesn't inspire confidence despite "A+” from BBB
Unfortunately, that's just the beginning of our hesitations with Thyroid Support. Despite having an "A+” rating from the BBB for parent company Vita Balance, and no complaints filed there, we're not convinced that this is a thriving business (or popular thyroid product for that matter). For one thing, the company's address tracks to a co-working space in Virginia: not exactly a large warehouse or corporate headquarters. Also, reviews for Thyroid Support are almost nonexistent beyond the five obviously-curated testimonials on the product site itself (and we're not confident that those are authentic, either).
Refunds are unlikely
Another concern is the confusing returns policy on the site. Instead of clearly stating whether there's a satisfaction guarantee or offering information about qualifying for a refund, it discusses what to do in case the "goods do not match those that you ordered" or if they have "faults when they are delivered." This leaves us in the dark about whether the policy covers situations where the thyroid supplement doesn't work for you or if you experience adverse reactions. Especially when it mentions that "goods must be returned in their original condition," we're left thinking that there's probably no way to try Thyroid Support and get your money back.
We don't recommend it
Taking these factors into account, Thyroid Support lands at the bottom of our list. Even if somehow this product is amazing, you're not likely to get the kind of support you need from the company itself if you have questions or concerns, and there's just not enough buzz from users to convince us that it's worth taking a chance here. Go with one of the higher-rated thyroid supplements on our list instead.
The thyroid is a small, butterfly-shaped gland located in your neck, just below your Adam's apple. Despite its modest size, the thyroid plays a crucial role in your body's overall health. It's like a conductor, orchestrating your metabolism and influencing various bodily functions.
The thyroid gland produces hormones called thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3). These hormones regulate your metabolism, affecting everything from energy levels to body temperature. When the thyroid doesn't produce enough hormones, it can lead to symptoms like fatigue, weight gain, sensitivity to cold, and sluggishness. In contrast, when the thyroid produces excessive hormones, symptoms may include weight loss, rapid heart rate, anxiety, and heat sensitivity.
When comparing these products, consider the following factors as you decide which one is right for your needs:
Top Consumer Reviews has conducted an extensive review and ranking of the best OTC thyroid support products available today. Your thyroid's health is integral to your overall well-being, and whether you're currently dealing with a thyroid issue or looking to maintain its optimal function, we trust that this information will aid you in finding the right supplement to maintain your health and vitality.
Select any 2 Thyroid Health Products to compare them head to head