Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Tire Rack vs SimpleTire

Saturday, November 2nd

2024 Tire Store Reviews

Tire Rack Review 5 Star Rating

Tire Rack

5 Star Rating
  • Selection: 26 brands
  • Price Range: $73.02 to $284.25/tire on 2021 Toyota Corolla; $350 to $511.98/tire on 2024 Tesla Cybertruck
  • Installation Fees: Around $110 for installation at Discount Tire or Tire Rack; independent installation options available
  • Extra Benefits: Free shipping, free 2-year tire road hazard protection and roadside assistance, replacement at the current price (up to $599) or repairs reimbursed up to $40
  • "A+” rated and accredited by the BBB
  • Over 10,000 5-star reviews
  • In business since 1979
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Tire Rack is our favorite place to shop for new tires - if anyone can make the process enjoyable, they do. From showing you their extensive testing on their very own test track to including big perks like two years of road hazard protection and roadside assistance at no extra cost, Tire Rack puts in the work to earn your trust and loyalty. They had a great selection of tires for both of the vehicles in our test case, and installation options in our area were abundant. Car owners come back to Tire Rack year after year because of the tire store's customer-centric approach to service, awarding the company more than 10,000 5-star reviews. We're glad to give Tire Rack a 5-star rating as well, as our #1 pick among tire stores.

SimpleTire Review 4.5 Star Rating

SimpleTire

4.5 Star Rating
  • Selection: Over 300 tire brands
  • Price Range: $49.96 to $251.40/tire on 2021 Toyota Corolla; $424.99 on 2024 Tesla Cybertruck
  • Installation Fees: Starting at $20/tire; options for both mobile and local shop install
  • Extra Benefits: 12 months of 24/7 roadside assistance included with installation, free shipping (to any address, installer, or FedEx location), best price guarantee, financing available through Affirm/Klarna/SimplePay, free tire replacement coverage, live customer support Monday-Saturday
  • "A+” rated and accredited by the BBB
  • In business over 15 years
  • Over 7 million customers served

SimpleTire takes the guesswork (and the stress) out of buying tires online. You'll have no trouble finding the right tires for your vehicle and setting up an installation appointment with a local shop or mobile installation service - and you'll have plenty of information on any of those providers to help you choose. Tire prices here are very competitive, and every purchase comes with 12 months of 24/7 roadside assistance. This is one of our favorite tire stores, and we give SimpleTire an almost perfect score.

Which Tire Store is the Best?

Buying tires can seem like a daunting task, but with the right approach, you can easily navigate the process and find the best tires for your vehicle. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you through it.

Start by assessing your driving habits and the conditions you frequently encounter. Do you drive mostly on highways, in the city, or off-road? Are you dealing with snow, rain, or extreme heat? The answers will help you decide whether you need all-season tires, summer tires, winter tires, or a specialized type like off-road or performance tires.

The Best Tire Stores Compare Tire Stores Compare Tire Store Reviews What are the best Tire Stores Best Tire Store Reviews

Tire Store FAQ

When buying tires, you'll need to know your vehicle's make and model, your typical driving conditions, and tire size. Most online retailers provide tools to help you find the right tires for your vehicle when you input those details, and some can even pull up your car's tire info based on your license plate or VIN.
Your vehicle's recommended tire size can usually be found in the owner's manual, on the tire itself, or on a sticker inside the driver's side door. It's important to match the tire size for proper fit and performance; stick with that unless you're going for some kind of customization and you know what you're doing.
Yes, buying tires online is perfectly safe when you purchase from reputable retailers. Many online tire stores offer secure payment options, customer reviews, and comprehensive return policies. Look for sites with positive feedback, a good rating from the Better Business Bureau, and a long history in the tire business.
Most online tire retailers partner with local installers. After purchasing, you can choose a certified installer near you where the tires will be shipped directly, and you can schedule an appointment for installation. Some offer mobile installation: the perfect choice if your vehicle can't currently be driven on the tires you have.
Usually, yes! Online tire prices are often more competitive due to lower overhead costs for the retailer. You might also find discounts, promotions, and bundle deals online that aren't available in physical stores. And, you've definitely got a better selection to choose from.
The best online tire retailers typically offer a fitment (yes, that's a funny-sounding word) guarantee, meaning if the tires don't fit your vehicle, they will exchange them or offer a refund. Be sure to review the return policy before purchasing.
Yes, tires purchased online usually come with the manufacturer's warranty, which is the same as buying from a physical store. Some online retailers also offer additional road hazard protection or extended warranties - either as a complimentary perk or at an added cost.
To feel confident that you're getting quality tires, look for customer reviews, check the tire's performance ratings (like traction and temperature), and buy from well-known brands and trusted online retailers. Make sure the tires meet your typical driving needs and conditions, from your usual usage (commuter on the highway or leisure driver on back roads) to climate.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Look at your current tires to gather important information. You'll find the tire size on the sidewall, which includes a series of numbers and letters (such as 225/65R17). This tells you the tire width, aspect ratio, construction type, and rim diameter. Make sure the new tires match these specifications unless you're making a deliberate change for a specific reason.

Use online resources to research tire brands, types, and models. Many websites offer tools where you can input your vehicle's make, model, and year to get tire recommendations. Read customer reviews and professional ratings to get a sense of how different tires perform in areas like traction, handling, comfort, and durability.

Feeling overwhelmed? We've got a shortcut for you: just shop for your tires online. Most of today's popular tire stores can walk you through all of those things we just mentioned. Enter your make, model, and year (or, for some online stores, just your license plate or VIN), and you're good to go. You'll usually be able to see the research those retailers have done and benefit from their expertise, along with reviews from other car owners, in order to make your choice.

Once you've chosen your tires, the next step is to arrange for installation. If you're an automotive pro and you want to install the tires yourself, you do you (just make sure the store allows for that; some tire shops require professional installation in order to make a purchase). But, if you'd rather let an actual pro do the dirty work, check the options on offer. Usually, the tires will be shipped directly to the installer you indicate, and you can schedule an appointment to have them mounted and balanced on your vehicle. Some online stores even offer mobile installation services where a technician comes to your location to install them.

Still not sure which tire store to use? No worries. Here are a few criteria that can narrow down the options:

  • Selection. Does the tire store carry options suitable for your vehicle? Most websites have options for the vast majority of vehicles, but if you have something higher end or unusual (hello, Tesla Cybertruck), your choices may be fewer.
  • Installation options. Do you plan on going the DIY route, or would you prefer a professional? Is mobile installation something you need?
  • Costs. The price of the tire isn't the only thing you should take note of. How much will the installation be? Are there any other fees that work their way into the process?
  • Benefits. Some tire stores sweeten the deal by offering free roadside assistance or maintenance over the life of the tire, like balancing, repairs, and pressure checks.
  • Reputation. What are people saying about the tire store? Does it get reviews from repeat customers who wouldn't even consider going somewhere else? What does the Better Business Bureau think of the company? Also look at customer feedback on specific tires as you browse the tire store's inventory.

Ready to get rid of those worn-down treads? The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked some of today's most popular tire stores. Use our information to find the perfect set of tires for your ride. Let the good times roll!

The Best Reviews of Tire Stores