Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Trophy Stores

Where Can You Find the Best Trophies and Awards?

Trophies are more than just shiny metals and polished woods. They represent important milestones, victories, and efforts. If you're in charge of picking one out, you want to be sure it shows that you appreciate this significance.

Having trouble locating a specialty trophy store locally? Don't worry - the majority of teams, organizations, and companies prefer to rely on reputable online trophy providers. It's easy to see why: online stores offer abundant options, boast competitive prices, and promise fast deliveries, matching the convenience of buying from a local physical store. Plus, any customizations you need can be handled without hassle, guaranteeing that your award will be ready in time for awards night.

Tuesday, March 5th

2024 Trophy Store Reviews

Mr. Trophy Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Mr. Trophy

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Mr. Trophy offers unique, customizable, retro-inspired trophies and awards with impeccable service. The user-friendly website provides a satisfying customization experience, allowing users to witness their designs coming to life. Standard orders are crafted and shipped within three days, and customers appreciate Mr. Trophy's commitment to product quality and customer happiness. Despite slightly longer wait times during peak seasons for larger or specialized orders, Mr. Trophy is our top choice for distinctive awards and trophies.

Same Day Awards Review 4.5 Star Rating

Same Day Awards

4.5 Star Rating

Same Day Awards is a company that specializes in delivering high-quality awards with lightning-fast processing and shipping. Founded in 2013, Same Day Awards caters to customers who need awards on short notice. They have built a reputation for rescuing customers from last-minute situations by providing same-day delivery and offering free, unlimited engraving. Despite a confusing website with a separate catalog URL, Same Day Awards has thousands of positive reviews and a loyal customer base. Their exceptional speed, quality, and attention to customer needs make them a reliable choice for those seeking prompt and top-notch awards.

Wilson Trophy Review 4.5 Star Rating

Wilson Trophy

4.5 Star Rating

Wilson Trophy has been in the industry for over 55 years, offering top-quality trophies, awards, plaques, and more. They specialize in providing a vast range of excellent trophies, medals, and awards, including custom designs based on unique ideas. As the official supplier for over 20 youth sports groups and a licensee of Little League Baseball, they enhance official league awards by adding logos and personal touches. Wilson Trophy's prices start at $7.25, and they offer customized awards for all occasions. They also provide free shipping for orders over $200. Despite a slightly higher price range compared to some of its competitors, Wilson Trophy is highly recommended for their impressive quality and customization choices.

Awardsco Review 4 Star Rating


4 Star Rating

Awardsco is a top player in the awards industry, bringing together over 60 years of experience through the fusion of Chicago Trophy and Awards International. They offer a wide range of high-quality recognition products for all celebrations and professional milestones. With features like free engraving for plaques and trophies, free shipping on orders over $100, and pricing starting at $4.33, Awardsco knows how to throw a party for your achievements. Their user-friendly website makes it easy to navigate and find the perfect award, with options for various sports and activities. While there are slightly longer shipping times and a shorter return window with restocking fees, Awardsco's exceptional customer service and commitment to quality make them a reliable choice for personalized and memorable awards.

Dinn Bros Review 4 Star Rating

Dinn Bros

4 Star Rating

Dinn Bros., also known as "The Trophy People," is a well-established trophy and awards company in America. With over 65 years of experience, they offer a wide range of recognition products, including trophies, plaques, medals, and more. Their reputation for delivering quality and value is backed by their immediate delivery and dedication to customer satisfaction. Dinn Bros. has a diverse selection of awards for every occasion, from sports to holidays, and their website makes it easy to navigate and find the perfect option. The one minor downside are the fees when you go over 40 characters (which adds up on bulk orders), but overall there's a lot to love about Dinn Bros. as a trophy store.

Decade Awards Review 4 Star Rating

Decade Awards

4 Star Rating

Decade Awards is a family-owned business that specializes in crafting high-quality trophies and awards. They believe that every achievement, no matter how big or small, deserves recognition. With their wide range of unique trophies and awards, they offer features like free engraving and free shipping on orders over $100. While their prices may be slightly higher compared to other competitors, their products are made of higher-quality materials. However, it's important to note that the details of their return policy are unclear. Overall, Decade Awards is a trusted and reliable choice for those seeking high-quality awards, but customers looking for quick shipping or lower prices may want to explore other options.

Crown Awards Review 3.5 Star Rating

Crown Awards

3.5 Star Rating

Crown Awards has been around for a while, offering everything from kids' sports trophies to fancy corporate awards, and you can shop from pretty much anywhere - their stores, catalog, or website. Although they have a sweet deal with things like a price match guarantee and super-fast (sometimes free) shipping, navigating through their online shop might test your patience a bit. While many people have given them thumbs up for swift service and quality products, a few have faced some bumps along the customer service road - which have in turn knocked Crown Awards down to an "F" rating from the BBB. But, considering the overwhelming number of positive reviews found elsewhere and their wallet-friendly prices, they might still be worth a peek when shopping for your next award purchase.

Trophy Central Review 3.5 Star Rating

Trophy Central

3.5 Star Rating

TrophyCentral, launched in 1999, aimed to simplify the trophy-buying process by migrating it to an online platform. Their online catalog offers the standard range of awards and related items, but it has a user interface that might make finding the perfect trophy a bit frustrating due to its lack of sorting or filtering options. Shoppers can appreciate the free engraving, rewards program, and free shipping on orders over $100, but should keep an eye on price changes that can occur post-purchase and be ready to navigate a return policy with a few caveats. Despite a few hitches, TrophyCentral's long presence in the market shows that it has performed steadily, if not amazingly compared to competitors, in the online trophy and awards industry.

Quick Trophy Review 3.5 Star Rating

Quick Trophy

3.5 Star Rating

QuickTrophy operates with a direct-to-customer business model, which means they handle everything from manufacturing to shipping without any middlemen. Located in Michigan's Upper Peninsula, they have plenty of stock on hand to quickly prepare and send out orders. Their website offers a wide variety of awards, including trophies, plaques, and engraved tags, with free engraving available. QuickTrophy has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and a stellar reputation for customer satisfaction. They also provide a shipping estimation tool that allows you to calculate projected arrival dates and costs. Although their website interface could be improved, QuickTrophy is a great choice if you're looking for high-quality trophies and awards from a smaller business.

Blue Ribbon Awards Review 2.5 Star Rating

Blue Ribbon Awards

2.5 Star Rating

Blue Ribbon Awards is a low-ranking option among online trophy award websites. We'd guess their operations rely heavily on their physical location, which has been in business since 1985, because their website comes across as outdated and impractical. The lack of customer reviews and the confusing similarity with other businesses with similar names and websites make it hard to confirm their credibility. While they offer a wide range of products, their pricing is not competitive, with higher prices compared to other trophy stores. Additionally, their website lacks filtering and sorting capabilities, making it difficult for customers to find the right product for their needs. Overall, Blue Ribbon Awards falls short in terms of user experience, pricing, and customer reviews, so we can't recommend them over their competitors.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Lots of occasions warrant a commemorative trophy or plaque. Whether it's to acknowledge a student's academic excellence, celebrate an athlete's success, recognize a professional's achievement, or simply commemorate personal milestones, these awards can be meaningful keepsakes displayed by proud family members for many years to come.

When it comes to trophies, there are so many options to choose from, each suited for specific occasions and achievements. Cup trophies, for example, are commonly associated with sports like soccer and symbolize victory. Endurance athletes like marathon runners or swimming champions often receive medals to commemorate their achievements. In the corporate and academic world, crystal awards are used to celebrate professional milestones and academic excellence, recognizing the accomplishments of outstanding employees and scholars. Plaques, on the other hand, can be seen on the walls of dedicated educators or long-serving employees, telling stories of commitment and dedication in their respective fields. These trophies can be made from a variety of materials, including plastic, wood, metal, and glass.

So, how do you determine which trophy store is worthy of your patronage, especially considering your team or organization might be buying from them repeatedly in the future?

Here are some factors that might help you make up your mind when browsing trophy options:

  • Variety. Does the store offer a wide range of trophy styles? You'll want to avoid monotony in your awards ceremonies, especially in team sports where players return year after year. That's why it's recommended to choose a store that offers a robust inventory of trophies with various designs available.
  • Customer service. Is the purchasing process smooth and hassle-free? Are the customization processes easy to navigate or do they take a lot of time? And speaking of time, it's important to know if there's an option for fast delivery in case you need your trophies quickly.
  • Cost. Given the similarity in products among various trophy stores, how does the pricing of each store compare? Is it competitive, providing value for your money? Does expedited shipping cost an arm and a leg?
  • Credibility. What is the store's reputation in terms of customer satisfaction? Is there a policy that guarantees refunds or replacements for products that aren't to your liking? How is the company rated by the BBB?

Top Consumer Reviews has conducted an insightful evaluation and ranking of the leading trophy stores currently available. We hope this information helps you find the perfect trophies and awards for your upcoming end-of-season ceremony, celebratory banquet, or any recognition of excellence!

The Best Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Store Reviews What are the best Trophy Stores Best Trophy Store Reviews

Trophy Store FAQ

You're only limited by your imagination. Trophies can be purchased pre-made and are a great choice for end-of-season awards ceremonies, sporting events, and much more. Metal or plastic? Crystal or acrylic? You'll find all of that and then some. And, for the truly special moments, consider a custom-designed trophy for the occasion.
Not necessarily. You can find options starting as low as $3!
That depends: are you buying a ready-made trophy that's in stock and just adding engraving, or are you designing a one-of-a-kind award? If you're going with something in stock, you can probably get your trophies in under a week.
Many trophy stores give you free delivery with your order! If you have a rush job, you might be able to pay extra for expedited shipping.
There are two basic types of personalization: the engraving that specifies the award recipient, award type, and so on, and the customization to include your group's logo or other images. Each trophy store has its own process for submitting the latter and it may take some time to work out the details. On the other hand, the engraving information is usually entered right on the website at the time you place your order.
Sometimes. Check the retailer's policy if you think you might need to return some of the trophies you're buying (like if you have fewer athletes than anticipated).
You won't find a better selection anywhere else! Plus, many trophy stores you'll find online have been in business for decades and have a loyal customer base: you can trust them to get your trophies done right. It's also an easy way to make sure that all of your engraving is accurate - with names spelled correctly and all of the other information exactly as you intended - because you can see it for yourself before you enter your order.
There are a lot of really great options out there, so it may be hard to choose! Pick one with a strong reputation - look for an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and/or plenty of positive customer reviews. After that, as long as the store you're considering has what you want in stock, at a price you like, and can get it to you on time for your event, you can trust that your trophy order is in good hands.

Compare Trophy Stores

Select any 2 Trophy Stores to compare them head to head

The Best Reviews of Trophy Stores