Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Same Day Awards Review

Monday, April 15th

2024 Trophy Store Reviews

Same Day Awards Review 4.5 Star Rating

Same Day Awards

4.5 Star Rating
  • Trophy pricing starts at $4.49
  • Same-day delivery available
  • Free, unlimited engraving
  • Thousands of positive reviews
  • In business since 2013

With over two decades of experience in the brick-and-mortar awards industry, Paul Mazzaferro observed a growing trend among his clients: a tendency to wait until the last minute to order awards.

Ships to your door in 24 hours

Recognizing that his business had become the go-to destination for rush orders, he envisioned a solution. What if he could provide lightning-fast award delivery without compromising on attention to detail and quality? In 2013, Same Day Awards was founded to ship and deliver awards to your doorstep in as little as 24 hours. They pride themselves in the loyalty they've built by rescuing their customers from nearly impossible situations.

Confusing URLs

When we visited Same Day Awards' website, we were a bit puzzled by the absence of a catalog. Instead, we found an explanation of the ordering process and a breakdown of the shipping options. Luckily, we didn't have to fill out the contact form at the bottom of the page to gather more information; we utilized the live chat option and spoke to a representative who informed us that Same Day Awards is only a landing page, and their catalog is actually hosted on Order Fast Awards. We found it a little strange that this link wasn't provided on the landing page and that the two URLs aren't named in a way that clearly indicates they belong to the same business.

They've got your back in a hurry

Despite this odd layout decision (which seems like it would cost Same Day Awards some customers purely because they can't find where to order), they still have an excellent reputation and enjoy thousands of positive reviews. When you find yourself in need of high-quality awards in a hurry, don't hesitate to make the effort to reach Same Day Awards' online store. They truly excel at delivering orders promptly, especially for those last-minute scenarios - like when your school's science fair suddenly needs additional trophies because more students participated than expected, and the event is just a few days away. Or, picture this: your company lands a big client, and you need to order customized awards for an upcoming meeting on short notice. In situations where time is of the essence, Same Day Awards proves to be the reliable choice that can save the day.

Best Trophy Stores

How they do it

So, what makes Same Day Awards so unbeatable?

  • They stay up-to-date on the latest, fastest engraving technology
  • They employ people who care about helping customers out of a bind and executing your vision
  • They have access to drop shipping from 31 USA warehouses - so, in a real pinch, a trophy from the supplier closest to you can be sent to you ASAP, and the plate will be sent separately with instructions for attaching them

But don't take their word for it - over a thousand customer reviews describe prompt service and top-notch quality.

Last-minute success

In the realm of last-minute orders, Same Day Awards shines brightly. One customer shared their delight when a golf award trophy was needed urgently due to losing the original while traveling to the tournament. Placing the order on 7/21 and receiving it on 7/28, just in time for a tournament on 7/29, left the customer thoroughly impressed. Other reviews reported even faster order turnaround times.

Above and beyond expectations

When calling after hours on a weekend, most people wouldn't expect to reach the CEO. However, one customer was amazed when Paul Mazzaferro, the CEO of Same Day Awards, answered the call and took care of their needs. This unexpected level of dedication and service left a lasting impression on the customer, demonstrating that the company's commitment to customer satisfaction comes from the top down.

Equal attention paid to orders of all sizes

Even small orders receive significant attention and appreciation from Same Day Awards. One customer expressed their happiness with the company, highlighting how they were treated with the same level of care typically reserved for larger and repeat customers.

Best Trophy Stores

Exceptional speed and quality

When it comes to prompt service and top-notch quality, customers have raved about how swiftly they receive their orders and about the meticulous review process that includes email verification and proofs to make sure the awards are just right. Unlike some other online options, Same Day Awards goes the extra mile in both service and price, offering fantastic deals for exceptional quality. Whether it's your first or second time ordering from them, the experience consistently impresses customers, making them loyal clients for life.

Shipping cost depends on your location

Of course, expedited shipping typically comes with an additional cost - after all, overnight delivery isn't usually a complimentary service. However, Same Day Awards offers a slight advantage compared to its competitors by providing free shipping to the lower 48 states for orders totaling $95 or more. For smaller orders, there's a flat rate of $11.96. The exact cost of expedited shipping depends on your location and your desired delivery timeline, whether it's for same-day, next-day, or longer delivery. You can find detailed shipping information on the product pages of the trophies you're interested in.

Plenty of Same-Day options

Now that we've been convinced of Same Day Awards' exceptionality, especially when working with a quick turnaround, let's take a look at what they actually have on offer. From the top bar, their Same-Day options are:

  • Acrylics
  • Trophies
  • Art Glass
  • Clocks
  • Crystal
  • Cups
  • Eagles
  • Medals
  • Plaques, including Memorial Plaques

More designs available for 48-hour shipping

Their other offerings are available for browsing from the top bar drop-downs. These include all the same categories as the Same-Day options, plus a couple more, but there may be some designs available within these categories that aren't available for Same-Day. Most items will ship within 48 hours, so you won't need to opt for Same-Day unless you're really in a pickle. Once you've identified the category you're interested in - for example, Trophies - you can select a subcategory from the dropdown (like Cheerleading).

Best Trophy Stores

Competitive pricing

Same Day Awards' pricing is pretty darn reasonable. For example, most 6-7 inch trophies are priced at $5.39 and come with free, unlimited engraving personalization (no character limit). The more of each design you buy, the more you'll save - 5% on 11-35 trophies up to 25% on quantities of 501-799 trophies. You'll also be able to see the expected shipping time of each award on its product page.

Irrelevant product suggestions

We think the "Related Items" selection on the product pages could be a little better: if you're viewing an arm-wrestling trophy, chances are a trophy of a hunting dog is not going to have much relevance to you just because it's made of the same material.

Charges and fees apply to returns

Same Day Awards does accept returns, which is good to know just in case. Items are only eligible for return within 7 business days of receipt and if they've been approved for return by the company. You'll have to pay a 15% restocking charge, and an extra $2 for each engraved plate. You won't be refunded for shipping charges and you'll have to pay to ship your order back. Most awards retailers don't allow the return of anything that has been engraved, though, so that's still better than the competition. Engraved medals, acrylics, crystal, glass, plaques, and custom items can't be returned for credit - they're a done deal once you've got them. Also, if you cancel your order more than 24 hours after placing it, you'll need to pay a 15% cancellation fee.

Highly recommended

If you're someone who puts things off until the last minute, we aren't judging - and neither is Same Day Awards. With lightning fast processing and shipping that can get your awards to you in the nick of time, and at a great price, Same Day Awards earns an excellent rating in our review of Trophy stores.

Where Can You Find the Best Trophies and Awards?

Trophies are more than just shiny metals and polished woods. They represent important milestones, victories, and efforts. If you're in charge of picking one out, you want to be sure it shows that you appreciate this significance.

Having trouble locating a specialty trophy store locally? Don't worry - the majority of teams, organizations, and companies prefer to rely on reputable online trophy providers. It's easy to see why: online stores offer abundant options, boast competitive prices, and promise fast deliveries, matching the convenience of buying from a local physical store. Plus, any customizations you need can be handled without hassle, guaranteeing that your award will be ready in time for awards night.

The Best Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Store Reviews What are the best Trophy Stores Best Trophy Store Reviews

Trophy Store FAQ

You're only limited by your imagination. Trophies can be purchased pre-made and are a great choice for end-of-season awards ceremonies, sporting events, and much more. Metal or plastic? Crystal or acrylic? You'll find all of that and then some. And, for the truly special moments, consider a custom-designed trophy for the occasion.
Not necessarily. You can find options starting as low as $3!
That depends: are you buying a ready-made trophy that's in stock and just adding engraving, or are you designing a one-of-a-kind award? If you're going with something in stock, you can probably get your trophies in under a week.
Many trophy stores give you free delivery with your order! If you have a rush job, you might be able to pay extra for expedited shipping.
There are two basic types of personalization: the engraving that specifies the award recipient, award type, and so on, and the customization to include your group's logo or other images. Each trophy store has its own process for submitting the latter and it may take some time to work out the details. On the other hand, the engraving information is usually entered right on the website at the time you place your order.
Sometimes. Check the retailer's policy if you think you might need to return some of the trophies you're buying (like if you have fewer athletes than anticipated).
You won't find a better selection anywhere else! Plus, many trophy stores you'll find online have been in business for decades and have a loyal customer base: you can trust them to get your trophies done right. It's also an easy way to make sure that all of your engraving is accurate - with names spelled correctly and all of the other information exactly as you intended - because you can see it for yourself before you enter your order.
There are a lot of really great options out there, so it may be hard to choose! Pick one with a strong reputation - look for an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and/or plenty of positive customer reviews. After that, as long as the store you're considering has what you want in stock, at a price you like, and can get it to you on time for your event, you can trust that your trophy order is in good hands.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Lots of occasions warrant a commemorative trophy or plaque. Whether it's to acknowledge a student's academic excellence, celebrate an athlete's success, recognize a professional's achievement, or simply commemorate personal milestones, these awards can be meaningful keepsakes displayed by proud family members for many years to come.

When it comes to trophies, there are so many options to choose from, each suited for specific occasions and achievements. Cup trophies, for example, are commonly associated with sports like soccer and symbolize victory. Endurance athletes like marathon runners or swimming champions often receive medals to commemorate their achievements. In the corporate and academic world, crystal awards are used to celebrate professional milestones and academic excellence, recognizing the accomplishments of outstanding employees and scholars. Plaques, on the other hand, can be seen on the walls of dedicated educators or long-serving employees, telling stories of commitment and dedication in their respective fields. These trophies can be made from a variety of materials, including plastic, wood, metal, and glass.

So, how do you determine which trophy store is worthy of your patronage, especially considering your team or organization might be buying from them repeatedly in the future?

Here are some factors that might help you make up your mind when browsing trophy options:

  • Variety. Does the store offer a wide range of trophy styles? You'll want to avoid monotony in your awards ceremonies, especially in team sports where players return year after year. That's why it's recommended to choose a store that offers a robust inventory of trophies with various designs available.
  • Customer service. Is the purchasing process smooth and hassle-free? Are the customization processes easy to navigate or do they take a lot of time? And speaking of time, it's important to know if there's an option for fast delivery in case you need your trophies quickly.
  • Cost. Given the similarity in products among various trophy stores, how does the pricing of each store compare? Is it competitive, providing value for your money? Does expedited shipping cost an arm and a leg?
  • Credibility. What is the store's reputation in terms of customer satisfaction? Is there a policy that guarantees refunds or replacements for products that aren't to your liking? How is the company rated by the BBB?

Top Consumer Reviews has conducted an insightful evaluation and ranking of the leading trophy stores currently available. We hope this information helps you find the perfect trophies and awards for your upcoming end-of-season ceremony, celebratory banquet, or any recognition of excellence!

Compare Trophy Stores

Select any 2 Trophy Stores to compare them head to head

The Best Reviews of Trophy Stores